Why Was Boromir Tempted By The Ring In 'The Fellowship Of The Ring'?

2025-06-30 11:30:52 19

3 answers

Zane
Zane
2025-07-01 00:52:46
Boromir's temptation by the Ring in 'The Fellowship of the Ring' stems from his deep love for Gondor and desperation to save his people. He sees the Ring as a weapon, the only hope against Sauron's overwhelming forces. His father Denethor's constant pressure to prove himself as a leader amplifies this desire. Unlike Aragorn, who understands the Ring's corruption, Boromir believes he could wield it for good. The Ring preys on this noble intention, twisting it into obsession. His final attempt to take the Ring from Frodo isn't pure malice—it's the tragic outcome of a warrior prioritizing military victory over wisdom, blinded by the Ring's promise of power to protect what he loves most.
Violet
Violet
2025-07-02 23:20:14
As someone who's analyzed Boromir's arc extensively, his fall is one of Tolkien's most human tragedies. The Ring doesn't tempt him with personal glory—it exploits his patriotism and fear. Gondor has been fighting Mordor alone for generations, and Boromir witnesses his homeland's gradual destruction firsthand. The Council of Elrond reveals his frustration; he can't comprehend destroying the Ring when it could be Gondor's salvation.

The Ring magnifies his warrior mindset. Boromir operates in absolutes—victory or annihilation—which makes him vulnerable. He dismisses the 'folly' of walking into Mordor because his entire life has been about holding the line through strength. His contempt for Isildur's weakness ironically mirrors his own later failure.

What's fascinating is how his relationship with Aragorn factors in. Boromir initially respects Aragorn's claim to Gondor's throne, but the Ring sows doubt. It whispers that a true son of Gondor shouldn't surrender power to a ranger. This culminates at Amon Hen, where his internal conflict becomes physical—he genuinely believes taking the Ring is saving Middle-earth, not betrayal. His redemption comes too late, making his death hit harder.
Braxton
Braxton
2025-07-04 00:53:03
Boromir's downfall hits differently when you consider his role as the 'normal guy' among the Fellowship. Everyone else has some resistance—elves, wizards, dwarves, even hobbits with their simplicity. But Boromir? Just a man with all mortal flaws. The Ring targets his very human fears: inadequacy and failure.

His temptation isn't instant. It builds through small moments—watching Gandalf fall in Moria, seeing the impossibility of their quest. The Ring offers certainty in chaos. His famous line 'Give me the Ring!' isn't greed; it's a soldier's last stand mentality.

Key detail: Boromir never wants the Ring for himself. He frames it as 'Gondor's gift'—a twisted self-sacrifice. This makes his arc more tragic than villains like Saruman. Even corrupted, his core desire remains noble. That's why his death defending Merry and Pippin lands so powerfully—it proves the real Boromir was always there, just buried under the Ring's influence.
View All Answers
Scan code to download App

Related Books

Ring
Ring
We all have that one unforgettable ex, the one that showed you an intense and extremely potent love, the one you thought that you were going to spend forever with, until the inevitable split. For Elliott Frost, it was Kain Griffin. After splitting up with him 12 years ago, she considered him a part of her turbulent past, never to be revisited again, she was finally getting her life back again, trying to get her explosive temper under control, but she hadn't been able to get over her immense sexual attraction to him, until he showed up again on the day of her wedding, determined and hell bent on getting her back, and as she knows Kain Griffin never takes no for an answer.
10
36 Chapters
The Auction Ring
The Auction Ring
“Now, you will do anything I ask for?” asked Michelangelo. “Anything, Master!” “Then strip! Show me your naked body,” commanded Michelangelo. “Wha… t?” she was taken aback. “Oh, I didn’t tell you the main role of Odal? It’s to service your master, be their sex slave. Every night you will wait for me in this room without any clothes. No crying, no tears, only your naked body, is that clear?” ordered Michelangelo. ***** Sweet, gullible Renata Zyanya’s life turns upside down after she has a one-night stand with the handsome Michelangelo Venturi. She thinks she met her knight but who she met was a mafia heir. After meeting with him she gets threatened, assaulted, kidnapped, and auctioned off to the highest bidder. Tikhon Kuznetsova, the supreme Boss is looking for an heir who can take over Siago Mafia Syndicate (SMS). The best candidate is Michelangelo Venturi. But he dislikes the mafia life, yet it keeps pulling him towards itself. The only solution to get out of it – break one of the rules: fall in love. He thinks Renata could be the one. But circumstances force him to make her his slave. Struggling between his calling and love, he must figure out what he wants more, to become the Supreme Boss of SMS or Renata. The shift from a loving relationship to a master-slave relationship to enemies is sure to take a toll on their love story.
10
195 Chapters
The enchanted ring
The enchanted ring
Looking into the eyes of the brilliant Gregory Green, the world around her disappeared. The grin on his face grew wider as he watched a star struck Willow, gaze deeply into his eyes. Picking up her hand in front of all in the room he shouts ," she is mine! The room was silent and Willow snapped out of her hypnotic trance,looking at the ring on her finger, she tried to tug it off. To her surprise it felt as if it was getting tighter. Gregory watched her struggle,his laugh echoed in the room as he slowly leaned in. Willow stepped back,assuming he was diving in for a kiss. Pulling her into him,his hot breath tickled her ears as he whispered," this is no ordinary ring,babygirl. you are mine forever!" She shook her head , a clear indication of her saying no but the guests at the diner started to applaud. No one dared go against Gregory Green,the richest man in the city. No one dared! Until he forcefully wedded Willow Winter, a waitress in a little diner! A mischievous Willow sets alight to his life,until he claims her heart!
Not enough ratings
12 Chapters
RING OF FATE
RING OF FATE
Angelo Marcus the prince of a warewolf pack become rebellious and decides to make a human girl as his mate instead of a warewolf. That leads to war between the two respected parks.
10
106 Chapters
That Problematic Ring
That Problematic Ring
Freya Daniella Howard, 24 years old, first heir of Howard Constructions is in ‎love with her boyfriend ‎Benjamin, but scared to tell that to her parents ‎because she knows Benjamin will not meet with ‎their expectations. When her ‎mother asks who she is dating, she without much thought says her best ‎friend's ‎name - Rafael. ‎ Rafael, 28 years old, sole heir of Eastmond Builders, secretly dating a model ‎because he ‎knows his high and mighty parents have high plans for him. ‎Though he's not much bothered because he only wants to savor his love-life for now and focus on his dream; to be eligible enough to be the CEO of his ‎family's business. ‎ However, Freya's lie which was intended to be unharmed ruins all his plans ‎and he becomes her ‎betrothal out of nowhere. Their families celebrate the ‎moment and tie them into Wedlock -- too swift for ‎them to comprehend what in the world has happened to them.‎ Is it fate or Freya's heedless mistake that confined them into marriage?.....hard ‎to answer. ‎
8
81 Chapters
The Broken Signet Ring
The Broken Signet Ring
On the night of the Benedetto family's Harvest Festival, my Mafia husband, Salvatore, told me to bring our son, Giuseppe, to the family gathering. He said his madre had finally accepted us into the Benedetto bloodline. I was trembling with excitement in our little cottage as I dressed Giuseppe in his finest little suit. He had carved a single wooden rose by hand, a project he'd saved for over five years. He said he would present it to his grandmother at the celebration, a plea for her to accept our place in the family. But the moment we stepped into the stone manor, I saw Carmela. Salvatore had her pinned against an oak barrel in a deep, searing kiss. In the moonlight, her hand was undoing his tie. In front of everyone, Salvatore smiled and gently pushed her away. He walked toward the family members gathered in a semicircle and raised a crystal glass. "Tonight, in addition to celebrating the harvest, I have an important announcement." "I would like to introduce you all to the woman I have married in the eyes of God and the Church." "Miss Carmela Torrino." Before I could even process his words, Giuseppe tore his hand from mine and rushed forward. "Papa, what are you saying?" "Isn't my mother your wife?"
9 Chapters

Related Questions

How Does 'The Fellowship Of The Ring' End?

3 answers2025-06-30 00:23:41
The ending of 'The Fellowship of the Ring' is both heartbreaking and thrilling. After the intense battle in Moria where Gandalf falls into the abyss fighting the Balrog, the group is shattered. They reach Lothlórien, where Galadriel gives them gifts and foresight. The fellowship then travels down the Anduin River, but tensions rise as Frodo realizes the Ring’s corruption is tearing them apart. At Amon Hen, Boromir tries to take the Ring from Frodo, leading to a dramatic confrontation. Frodo decides to continue the quest alone, but Sam refuses to leave his side, and they sneak off to Mordor. The book ends with the fellowship broken—Boromir dead, Merry and Pippin captured by orcs, and Aragorn, Legolas, and Gimli vowing to rescue them. It’s a cliffhanger that makes you desperate to pick up 'The Two Towers' immediately.

Who Dies In 'The Fellowship Of The Ring'?

3 answers2025-06-30 09:42:24
The big death in 'The Fellowship of the Ring' is Gandalf, and it hits hard. He falls fighting the Balrog in Moria, sacrificing himself so the rest of the Fellowship can escape. It’s one of those moments where you’re like, 'No way did that just happen.' The way Tolkien writes it makes you feel the weight—the darkness of the chasm, the sheer hopelessness. But here’s the thing: Gandalf’s death isn’t just about loss. It forces the others, especially Frodo and Aragorn, to step up. The Fellowship fractures after this, and you see how each character deals with grief and responsibility. Boromir also dies later, but that’s more about redemption after his obsession with the Ring nearly destroys everything.

What Is The Significance Of The One Ring In 'The Fellowship Of The Ring'?

3 answers2025-06-30 13:10:09
The One Ring in 'The Fellowship of the Ring' isn't just a piece of jewelry—it's the ultimate weapon of corruption. Crafted by Sauron to dominate all other rings of power, it embodies his will and malice. Anyone who wears it becomes invisible to mortal eyes but visible to the Nazgûl and Sauron himself. The Ring whispers promises of power, twisting minds until even the noblest beings like Boromir fall to its temptation. Its significance lies in its dual nature: a tool for absolute control and a test of character. Destroying it is the only way to break Sauron's hold, making Frodo's journey a desperate race against time and the Ring's corrosive influence.

How Does Frodo Change In 'The Fellowship Of The Ring'?

3 answers2025-06-30 19:49:16
Frodo's transformation in 'The Fellowship of the Ring' is subtle but profound. At first, he's just a naive Hobbit who loves his quiet life in the Shire. After inheriting the Ring, he slowly realizes the weight of his responsibility. The journey forces him to grow tougher mentally—he starts making hard decisions, like leaving the Fellowship to protect them. His physical endurance also improves, surviving wounds that would kill others. But the Ring's corruption is always there, eating at his kindness. By the end, he's not the cheerful Hobbit he once was; he's a weary traveler who understands the cost of heroism. The way he resists the Ring's pull shows his inner strength, even as it hollows him out.

Where Does 'The Fellowship Of The Ring' Take Place?

3 answers2025-06-30 22:27:23
The world of 'The Fellowship of the Ring' is Middle-earth, a sprawling fantasy realm packed with diverse landscapes. The story kicks off in the peaceful Shire, home to hobbits with its rolling green hills and cozy hobbit holes. From there, the fellowship travels through locations like the eerie Old Forest, the ancient ruins of Weathertop, and the majestic elven city of Rivendell hidden in a valley. They cross the treacherous Misty Mountains, venture into the dark depths of Moria, and finally reach the golden woods of Lothlórien. Each place has its own unique vibe, from the homely comfort of the Shire to the ominous shadows of Mordor looming in the distance.

What Is The Setting Of 'Fellowship Point'?

4 answers2025-07-01 19:06:32
'Fellowship Point' unfolds in a lush, coastal peninsula in Maine, where the wild beauty of nature contrasts sharply with the quiet tensions of human relationships. The setting is almost a character itself—windswept cliffs, dense forests, and the ever-present Atlantic Ocean shape the lives of the protagonists. The story spans generations, weaving between the 1950s and present day, showing how the land remains constant while the people change. The peninsula is privately owned, a sanctuary for the wealthy, yet it harbors secrets and conflicts about legacy, conservation, and ownership. The old family cottages, weathered by salt and time, hold memories of summers filled with laughter and whispered arguments. The nearby town, with its quaint shops and wary locals, adds a layer of small-town politics. The setting mirrors the novel’s themes: the clash between preservation and progress, the weight of history, and the solace found in untouched landscapes. It’s a place where characters confront their pasts and decide what to carry forward.

Where Can I Buy 'Fellowship Point'?

4 answers2025-07-01 03:36:38
Finding 'Fellowship Point' is easier than you think. Major online retailers like Amazon, Barnes & Noble, and Book Depository stock it in both paperback and hardcover. If you prefer audiobooks, check Audible or Libro.fm—they often have narrations that bring the story to life. Local bookstores usually carry it too, especially if they curate literary fiction. For international buyers, Bookshop.org supports indie stores while shipping globally. Libraries are another great option if you want to borrow it first. Don’t overlook secondhand shops like AbeBooks or ThriftBooks; they sometimes have signed copies or rare editions. The novel’s popularity means it’s rarely out of stock, but prices fluctuate, so compare options. E-readers can grab the Kindle or ePub version instantly. If you love author events, check Alice Elliott Dark’s website—she occasionally sells signed copies directly.

What Powers Does The Ring Have In 'Reincarnated As The Hero Ring'?

5 answers2025-06-13 07:58:31
In 'Reincarnated as the Hero Ring', the ring isn't just a piece of jewelry—it's a game-changer. It amplifies the wearer's physical abilities, turning an ordinary fighter into a superhuman warrior with enhanced strength, speed, and reflexes. The ring also acts as a mana battery, storing vast reserves of energy that the hero can tap into during battles, allowing for prolonged use of magic without exhaustion. Beyond raw power, the ring has a sentient aspect, offering tactical advice and even predicting enemy moves. It can analyze opponents' weaknesses and relay that information to the wearer in real time. Some versions of the ring might even grant elemental resistances or temporary invulnerability, making the hero nearly unstoppable. The ring’s true strength lies in its adaptability, evolving alongside the hero to unlock new abilities as the story progresses. It’s not just a tool; it’s a partner in the hero’s journey.
Explore and read good novels for free
Free access to a vast number of good novels on GoodNovel app. Download the books you like and read anywhere & anytime.
Read books for free on the app
SCAN CODE TO READ ON APP
DMCA.com Protection Status