Is 'Cities Of Salt' Banned In Any Countries And Why?

2025-06-17 21:57:54 258

4 answers

Samuel
Samuel
2025-06-19 11:57:28
I dug into this because 'Cities of Salt' is one of those books that sparks debates wherever it's mentioned. The novel, written by Abdelrahman Munif, faced bans in several Gulf countries, particularly Saudi Arabia and the UAE. The reasons aren't officially spelled out, but it's widely believed the book's unflinching portrayal of oil-driven societal upheaval and political corruption hit too close to home. The story critiques the rapid modernization and foreign influence in the region, which likely unsettled authorities.

Munif's depiction of a fictionalized Arab monarchy's collusion with Western oil companies was seen as subversive. The book doesn't pull punches—it shows how greed dismantles tradition, leaving ordinary people displaced and angry. Censorship often targets works that challenge power structures, and 'Cities of Salt' does exactly that. Its ban reflects a fear of narratives that question authority or expose uncomfortable truths about economic exploitation.
Claire
Claire
2025-06-21 05:37:37
As someone who follows literary censorship, I can confirm 'Cities of Salt' was banned in Saudi Arabia shortly after its 1984 release. The government never issued a detailed statement, but scholars point to its allegorical critique of petro-monarchies. The novel's premise—a small fishing village destroyed by oil discovery—mirrors real Gulf history, making it politically radioactive. Authorities probably feared it would fuel dissent by highlighting how oil wealth reshaped society unevenly, leaving many behind. The ban wasn't just about content; Munif's Saudi citizenship amplified the perceived betrayal.
Zane
Zane
2025-06-21 14:17:35
Here's the scoop: 'Cities of Salt' got blacklisted in some Gulf states for its raw take on oil colonialism. It fictionalizes how oil discoveries turned Bedouin societies upside down—foreigners reap profits while locals lose their land. The ban seems driven by its portrayal of rulers as puppets to Western interests. Munif's background as an oil economist added credibility, making his critique harder to dismiss. Censors likely saw it as a blueprint for rebellion, though it's really a lament for lost ways of life.
Violet
Violet
2025-06-21 23:44:45
Banned in Saudi Arabia, 'Cities of Salt' ruffled feathers with its oil-politics allegory. The book's doom-laden vision of modernization clashed with the state's glossy narrative. No explicit reason was given, but its unflattering depiction of monarchy-Western corporate ties explains the backlash. Munif's exile suggests the regime took it personally. Unlike outright propaganda, its literary subtlety made it dangerous—readers might draw real-world parallels.
Lihat Semua Jawaban
Pindai kode untuk mengunduh Aplikasi

Related Books

Why
Why
Sebuah tanya selalu menghampiri seorang wanita bernama Aina Anindya, semenjak sadar dari koma. Ia terlihat mulai berubah, bukan soal ia meninggalkan kewajibannya sebagai seorang istri. Tapi, sebuah tanya dalam hati yang tidak menemukan sebuah titik terang dan jawaban. Mengingat ia kehilangan sebagian memori ingatannya beberapa bulan belakangan. Ya, semenjak ia mengalami kecelakaan ia kehilangan separuh ingatannya beberapa bulan belakang, dan juga lumpuh. Tapi, hatinya seolah jujur. Ia mengingat setiap perlakuan orang-orang yang menyakitinya, dengan cara ia merasakan semua perlakuan orang terdekatnya. Hingga tanpa sadar terkadang ia tiba-tiba marah, lalu menangis dalam diam. Aina adalah sosok wanita ceria, dan selalu berpikiran positif. Namun, semua berubah ia akan bersikap dingin, tapi dengan caranya sendiri, hingga tidak satu pun orang tahu atau menyadari jika hatinya tidak mudah di setuh lagi, oleh orang-orang yang bersikap munafik padanya. Hingga Aina lebih sering tersenyum palsu, dan ia begitu pintar menyembunyikan rasa sakit dalam hatinya. Sekalipun dengan keterbatasannya ketika ia memakai kursi roda, ia terus berusaha mengingat semua. Sebenarnya ada rahasia besar apa, yang membuatnya tiba-tiba menangis dalam diam. Kenapa ia begitu terluka ketika menatap orang-orang yang selalu bersikap baik padanya. Ketika di rumah, Aina merasa senang sekaligus bersyukur ketika orang yang begitu ia cintai sepenuh hati, dan sayangi begitu memperhatikan keadaannya. Tapi, tetap saja. Hatinya terlalu jujur, dan tidak menerima kebaikan orang-orang terdekatnya. Mampukah Aina mengingat semua kejadian beberapa bulan yang lalu, hingga hatinya menaruh benci pada orang yang ia cintai, dan kasihi. Mampukah ia bertahan dengan keadaannya, dan rasa sakit yang tidak ia mengerti.
10
46 Chapters
WHY ?
WHY ?
Anya Alovra Welaxzander, remaja yang terlahir dari keluarga mapan dan bermartabat. Benar kata sebagian orang, bahagia itu tidak selalu diukur dari seberapa banyak harta yang dimiliki. Anya membuktikannya sendiri. Bagaimana ia menjalani kehidupan kejam yang penuh akan sandiwara. Dibenci oleh seluruh anggota keluarganya, bahkan ibunya sendiri amat membencinya. Hanya ada Oma Stefi yang selalu melindunginya dari perlakuan buruk Opa Bram dan kedua kakak kembarnya. Ayahnya tidak pernah menemaninya di rumah, dia sibuk sendiri di luar kota. Musuh teraneh Anya, ialah Devan Adhrama. Lelaki tampan yang mempunyai kekurangan dengan fungsi pendengarannya, Anya biasa memanggilnya, 'Si Tampan Tuli'. Sebuah fakta besar membuat Anya semakin membenci Devan. Anya rasa, lelaki itu mempunyai otak yang tidak beres, sudah tahu jika mereka saling membenci, Devan malah mengungkapkan perasaannya kepada Anya. Sinting memang, sudah jelas jika Anya tidak pernah menyukainya, masih saja nekat. Ingat! Perasaan tidak akan ada yang pernah tahu, bahkan Anya sekalipun. Raungi terus kehidupan Anya yang tak sempurna. Akan kutunjukkan kepadamu, siapa kawan sebenarnya dan mana lawan sesungguhnya. Kalian juga akan mengetahui fakta besar tersembunyi yang tersimpan rapi di sini.
10
8 Chapters
Why Not?
Why Not?
Rheyner Aditya Effendi dan Nadira Almira adalah sepasang sahabat yang tumbuh bersama sejak balita. Di akhir masa putih abu-abu Rheyner menyadari kalau ternyata dirinya memiliki rasa sayang sebagai seorang pria pada Nadira. Rheyner menahan diri untuk mengungkapkan perasaannya. Namun, ia sudah mulai merancang masa depan untuk dilalui bersama Nadira. Rheyner akan menjadikan Nadira ratu dalam kehidupannya kelak. Sayangnya, tidak semua hal berjalan sesuai jalan pikiran Rheyner. Apalagi sejak dirinya mendapatkan beasiswa ke Jepang. Kesalahpahaman kerap menghampiri. “Nggak usah peduli sama aku lagi. Jangan jadi sahabatku lagi. Jangan lagi urusin kehidupanku. Kamu urusin aja hidup kamu. Kita sampai di sini aja. Kalau perlu kita nggak usah saling kenal lagi. Kamu bebas sekarang." Air mata Nadira sudah membanjiri wajah. Ia hempaskan tangan Rheyner. Ego Rheyner tersentil. Amarah menguasai diri. “OKE, GUE NGGAK AKAN PEDULI SAMA LO LAGI! GUE NGGAK MAU JADI SAHABAT LO LAGI!” Nadira segera berlalu dari hadapan Rheyner. Napas Rheyner terengah. Matanya memerah. Kedua tangannya masih terkepal. Pelan tapi pasti cairan bening keluar dari sudut matanya. Apakah semua benar-benar akan berakhir sampai di sini? Apakah pernikahan yang dibayangkan oleh Rheyner tidak akan pernah menjadi nyata?
10
29 Chapters
Why Him?
Why Him?
"Oh, jadi sekarang kau seorang gay?" "Ya, dan aku begini itu semua karena dirimu, Bri!" **** Berawal dari sebuah nominal uang sejumlah satu juta dollar, Brianna Caroline tidak pernah menyangka bahwa tantangan mendekati pria yang diklaim kebal terhadap rayuan wanita; berhasil menuntunnya untuk bertemu kembali dengan Ellecio William. Sosok pria dari masa lalu yang sangat ingin Brianna hindari. Entah bagaimana semesta bekerja, dari tujuh milyar jumlah penduduk bumi dan dari sekian juta orang yang mengalami kelainan orientasi seksual. Kenapa harus Ellecio yang menjadi target Brianna? Kenapa dia? Dia yang memandang Brianna sebagai penghancur kehidupannya. Dia yang setengah mati membenci sosok wanita itu. Bagaimanakah nasib Brianna ke depannya? Akankah Ellecio tetap membencinya ketika ada masa di mana satu persatu rahasia masa lalu berhasil terungkap?
10
7 Chapters
The Reason Why
The Reason Why
Athena adalah seorang Podcaster, yang tidak sengaja harus berhadapan dengan Ares, si lelaki penuh rencana licik dan kejam. Niat awal Athena adalah membuat prank untuk konten Youtube sahabatnya, tetapi malah dia yang merasa dikerjai oleh Ares hanya karena lelaki itu tak ingin wajahnya terekspos ke publik. Merasa tak adil karena Athena kabur begitu saja, Ares dengan sengaja pindah ke sekolah Athena dan memulai semua rencana untuk membuat gadis itu jera. Ternyata Ares mengerjai gadis itu bukan karena wajahnya terekspos ke publik saja, tapi juga ada sebab lain yang disembunyikannya. Ares butuh Athena untuk disalahkan atas kematian seseorang yang berharga baginya.
10
93 Chapters
Sahabat Jadi Cinta, Why Not?
Sahabat Jadi Cinta, Why Not?
Hanya sepenggal kisah sepasang sahabat berbeda jenis yang berakhir cinta. “Gue ngerasa sinting dengan apa yang gue rasain saat ini. Gue bingung. Gue enggak tahu sejak kapan, tapi yang jelas gue sayang banget sama dia. Setiap melihatnya gue merasa ... lengkap? Enggak ngertilah gue. Pokoknya sesuatu seperti itu. Kayak ketika lo lagi nyusun puzzle, terus kepingan terakhir lo hilang. Saat lo sudah menyerah, tiba-tiba lo bisa nemuin kepingan terakhir itu. Lo ngerasa bahagia karena akhirnya puzzle lo bisa lengkap.”
10
32 Chapters

Related Questions

Who Wrote 'Cities Of Salt' And Why Is It Controversial?

4 answers2025-06-17 06:57:00
The novel 'Cities of Salt' was penned by the Saudi Arabian writer Abdelrahman Munif, a master of political storytelling. Its controversy stems from its unflinching portrayal of oil's disruptive force in the Arab world, blending myth and reality to critique Western imperialism and local corruption. Munif's vivid prose exposes how oil wealth erodes traditions, turning Bedouin communities into displaced shadows of themselves. The book was banned in several Gulf states for its perceived anti-monarchical stance, yet it remains a landmark for its poetic defiance and historical resonance. What makes it electrifying is its refusal to romanticize progress. Munif depicts pipelines as veins draining cultural identity, and foreign engineers as modern colonizers. The controversy isn’t just political—it’s emotional, capturing the grief of a people severed from their land. Critics call it incendiary; admirers hail it as a necessary mirror. Either way, its raw honesty ensures it lingers in the mind long after the last page.

What Is The Plot Summary Of 'Cities Of Salt'?

4 answers2025-06-17 14:10:36
'Cities of Salt' is a sprawling epic that captures the seismic shifts in a fictional Gulf kingdom when oil is discovered. The novel begins with the quiet, traditional life of a coastal village, where the rhythms of existence are dictated by the sea and the land. Suddenly, American oilmen arrive, and their presence disrupts everything. The villagers are bewildered by the foreigners' technology and arrogance, and their way of life is obliterated. The story follows multiple characters—locals, oil workers, and the emerging elite—as they navigate the chaos of modernization. The narrative exposes the exploitation and cultural erosion that accompany the oil boom. The villagers are displaced, their land stolen, and their identities fractured. The ruling class, seduced by wealth, becomes complicit in the destruction. The novel’s title reflects the ephemeral nature of the new wealth—like cities built on salt, it’s destined to dissolve. The prose is rich with allegory, painting a haunting portrait of greed, displacement, and the loss of innocence. It’s a tragic, unforgettable exploration of how progress can erase history.

How Does 'Cities Of Salt' Critique Oil And Colonialism?

4 answers2025-06-17 05:54:59
'Cities of Salt' is a scathing critique of oil-driven colonialism, painting a visceral picture of how foreign exploitation ravages both land and culture. The novel traces the arrival of American oil companies in a fictional Gulf kingdom, stripping the desert of its resources while erasing Bedouin traditions. The locals are reduced to laborers or displaced entirely, their ancestral knowledge rendered obsolete overnight. Modernity is forced upon them like a curse—roads and pipelines cut through sacred grounds, and the air reeks of burning oil instead of campfires. The real tragedy lies in the psychological colonization. The protagonist, Miteb, embodies this clash; his horsemanship and survival skills mean nothing in the new world. Even the novel's fragmented structure mirrors the disintegration of a society—once cohesive, now splintered by greed. Munif doesn’t just blame outsiders; he shows how local elites collaborate, trading sovereignty for wealth. The title itself is ironic: salt, once a symbol of purity and preservation, becomes a metaphor for the bitterness left behind.

What Are The Main Themes Explored In 'Cities Of Salt'?

5 answers2025-06-17 00:29:05
In 'Cities of Salt', the novel dives deep into the clash between tradition and modernization, particularly in an unnamed Gulf country. The arrival of American oil companies disrupts the lives of Bedouins, stripping them of their land and way of life. The story captures the erosion of cultural identity, as people are forced to adapt or resist the rapid industrialization. The book also explores greed and exploitation, showing how foreign powers manipulate local rulers for profit, leaving the native population powerless. Themes of displacement and loss permeate the narrative—families torn apart, villages erased. Yet, there’s a quiet resistance, a refusal to completely surrender to the new order. The novel’s strength lies in its unflinching portrayal of how progress isn’t always benevolent, often leaving scars deeper than the benefits it brings.

How Does 'Cities Of Salt' Portray Arab Society And Change?

5 answers2025-06-17 05:55:33
'Cities of Salt' dives deep into the upheaval Arab society faces when oil is discovered, stripping away romanticized notions of tradition. Munif’s novel shows how modernization isn’t just progress—it’s a violent rupture. Bedouins lose their lands to foreign oil companies, their identities eroded as anonymous workers in corporate towns. The book’s fragmented structure mirrors this disintegration: families splinter, elders lose authority, and the desert itself becomes a wasteland of pipelines. The irony is crushing. Wealth from oil doesn’t uplift communities; it creates hollow cities where locals are either servants or rebels. The novel’s silence around the ruling elite speaks volumes—change is orchestrated by invisible forces, leaving ordinary Arabs scrambling. Some characters adapt, becoming complicit in their own cultural erasure, while others resist futilely. Munif doesn’t offer solutions; he documents the slow, irreversible death of a way of life.

What Is The Setting Of 'Below The Salt'?

3 answers2025-06-18 03:48:34
The setting of 'Below the Salt' is a medieval-inspired world where society is sharply divided by an invisible barrier called the Salt Line. Above it, the nobility live in opulent castles with magical luxuries, while below, commoners endure backbreaking labor in salt mines and fields. The geography reflects this divide—lush, golden landscapes above, bleak and salted earth below. Time moves differently too; a day above might be a week below, creating weird gaps in aging. The story primarily unfolds in the border town of Marrow, where the salt trade thrives, and rebellion simmers. The author cleverly uses this setup to explore class struggle through literal magic separation.

Who Is The Protagonist In 'Below The Salt'?

3 answers2025-06-18 00:11:07
The protagonist in 'Below the Salt' is John Gower, a medieval poet who gets caught up in a time-traveling adventure that shakes his understanding of history and his own place in it. What makes Gower fascinating is how ordinary he starts—just a man chronicling the past—until he's thrust into a conspiracy spanning centuries. His journey from observer to active participant mirrors the book's themes of agency and legacy. Gower's voice carries the weight of someone who's seen too much yet remains curiously hopeful. The way he balances his scholarly detachment with growing emotional investment in the people he meets across time creates a compelling internal conflict. His relationships with historical figures feel authentic because we see them through his evolving perspective.

What Are The Major Conflicts In 'Below The Salt'?

3 answers2025-06-18 20:35:49
The conflicts in 'Below the Salt' hit hard because they mirror real-life struggles. The main tension revolves around class warfare—peasants versus nobility in medieval England, where the poor are literally starving while aristocrats feast. There's also the personal conflict of John, our protagonist, who's torn between loyalty to his family and his growing revolutionary ideals. The book doesn't shy away from showing how religion gets weaponized too, with corrupt clergy using fear to control people. What makes it gripping is how these big conflicts trickle down to everyday choices, like whether to share bread with a neighbor or hoard it for your kids. The writing makes you feel the weight of each decision.
Jelajahi dan baca novel bagus secara gratis
Akses gratis ke berbagai novel bagus di aplikasi GoodNovel. Unduh buku yang kamu suka dan baca di mana saja & kapan saja.
Baca buku gratis di Aplikasi
Pindai kode untuk membaca di Aplikasi
DMCA.com Protection Status