How Does 'Collapse: How Societies Choose To Fail Or Succeed' Explain Societal Collapses?

2025-06-15 14:11:22 227

3 answers

Grady
Grady
2025-06-16 14:59:38
I've read 'Collapse: How Societies Choose to Fail or Succeed' multiple times, and Jared Diamond’s approach hits hard. He doesn’t blame collapses on single events but shows how societies crumble under layered pressures—environmental mismanagement, climate shifts, hostile neighbors, and cultural rigidity. The Easter Island case stands out: they chopped down every last tree, triggering soil erosion and starvation. The Maya overpopulated, overfarmed, and ignored droughts until their cities became ruins. Diamond’s scary takeaway? Collapse isn’t sudden. It’s a slow-motion train wreck where societies ignore warning signs. Modern parallels leap out—deforestation, water shortages, political shortsightedness. The book’s brilliance lies in showing collapse as a choice, not fate. Societies that adapt (like Japan’s Tokugawa-era forest management) survive; those that don’t, vanish.
Xander
Xander
2025-06-16 21:21:16
Diamond’s 'Collapse' dissects societal failures like a forensic scientist. The Greenland Norse case fascinates me—they starved clinging to European farming in an Arctic climate, while Inuit thrived by adapting. Diamond argues collapses share five factors: environmental damage, climate change, hostile neighbors, loss of trade partners, and societal responses. The Anasazi’s water-management failures mirror today’s California droughts. What’s chilling is how elites often accelerate collapse by hoarding resources (Roman elites privatized land, worsening food shortages).

Modern relevance slaps you in the face. Diamond compares Montana’s environmental issues to past collapses—toxic mining, soil depletion, water disputes. But he isn’t all doom. Japan’s Edo period proves societies can pivot; they banned logging, switched to sustainable forestry, and survived. The book’s framework helps analyze current risks: are we repeating Maya mistakes with aquifer depletion? Diamond’s answer is clear—collapse isn’t inevitable if societies prioritize long-term thinking over short-term greed.
Liam
Liam
2025-06-19 21:59:22
Reading 'Collapse' feels like watching a disaster documentary where you scream at the characters to stop making bad choices. Diamond’s cases reveal how cultural myopia dooms societies. The Vikings in Greenland kept pretending they were still in Scandinavia, refusing to eat fish like the Inuit. The Rwandan genocide tied directly to land scarcity from population growth—a problem they ignored until violence erupted. Diamond’s key insight? Collapse happens when societies double down on failing systems instead of innovating.

I love how he contrasts failures with successes. New Guinea’s highlanders sustained agriculture for millennia by terracing hillsides, while the Maya’s monocrop farming wrecked their soil. The book’s modern warnings are uncomfortably precise: climate denial mirrors Easter Island’s deforestation denial. Diamond doesn’t just diagnose—he prescribes. Adaptive governance, like Iceland’s communal land management, can steer societies away from cliffs. His work’s a wake-up call: collapse isn’t about bad luck, but bad decisions repeated until it’s too late.
모든 답변 보기
QR 코드를 스캔하여 앱을 다운로드하세요

Related Books

대표님과의 위험한 결혼
대표님과의 위험한 결혼
강사랑과 심태경은 단지 거래를 위해 결혼했지만, 시간이 흐를수록 사랑은 점점 태경에게 마음이 기울었다. 그러나 태경의 마음은 처음부터 사랑에게 향한 적이 없었다. 그녀의 오랜 짝사랑은, 태경이 사랑을 차갑게 병원에 데려가 수술을 받게 한 그날로 완전히 끝이 났다. 사랑은 자존심을 버리고 뱃속의 아이만이라도 살려달라고 애원했지만, 태경은 냉정하게 말했다. “순진한 척 하지 말고, 수술실에 들어가.” 몇 년 후, 사랑은 다시 C시로 돌아왔다. 그런데 태경은 그녀를 어두운 구석으로 거칠게 끌고 가, 낮고 잠긴 목소리로 속삭였다. “사랑아, 제발 날 떠나지 마.”
10
100 Chapters
Once Rejected, Now Desired
Once Rejected, Now Desired
He was the love of her life. She had dreamt of being by his side, and prayed to the moon goddess that she would be his mate. When he asked her to be his Luna, Sophia's joy knew no bounds. But he tore her heart into pieces when he picked her foster sister over her, forcing her to work as a maid in the palace. Sophia was willing to bear anything, as long as it kept her close to him, but she is forced to flee after she finds out she is pregnant - and there is a looming threat on her life by the child's father himself. Years later, now a successful doctor, Sophia returns to the her pack on a mission - to heal the pack of the plague that threatens to wipe out the entire werewolf race, but she is met with the greatest shock of her life. Alpha King Asher - the man who broke her heart - is her mate! And this time, he does not intend to let her go.
9.9
411 Chapters
Fake Marriage: The Trillionire Tycoon's Fiesty Bride
Fake Marriage: The Trillionire Tycoon's Fiesty Bride
Evangline Carter was prepared to getmarried to the man she loved her entire life, but suddenly, she discovered that her fiance's heart was captured by another woman who was no other than her stepsister. She was humiliated, face slapped, destroyed for loving a man who despised her. She was willing to sacrifice her youth, time, energy, love and heart for that man, but all her good intentions lead to pain and mystery.Trying to drown her sorrow with alcohol after her ruined wedding with her fiance who hooked up with her stepsister. Evangeline unexpectedly had a one night stand with a stranger who turned out to be the rich and powerful Damien Cross.Damien Cross, the king of the Business world, was a man to be feared. A man who was known as the devil as just the sound of his name made people tremble, cold, ruthless, heart of ice, merciless but extremely enticingly handsome.  There was not a single person in this world that dared to offend him. He had avoided many women who tried so hard to gain his attention. That was until his path unexpectedly collided with Evangeline."I need a wife." Damien declared and they both got a marriage license.After so many years of being in pain and heartache, it was now Evanglines turn to witness and experience a love grander than anyone.The smarter, feistier, witter and cunning Evangline who knew how to survive the cruel, backstabbing and harsh upper class society smiled.Challenges will arise, chaos will commence, and a lot of drama will ensue. But then again, what is a love story without interruption? The story of love without any drama is simply just a crush and the story of Eva and Damien was way different than just an ordinary relationship.
9.1
743 Chapters
Wet Dreams (Erotica Collection)
Wet Dreams (Erotica Collection)
Warnings: This book may contain some violence, explicit and matured content and BDSM! I know what you're thinking this sounds like a dirty, filthy book filled with fantasy smut stories. Unveiling the Tapestry of Pleasure in this novel takes readers on an eclectic journey through the diverse sexual landscapes of various characters. Each chapter unfolds a unique narrative, exploring the intricacies of desire, intimacy, and self-discovery. From clandestine affairs to unconventional relationships, the novel weaves together a mosaic of human experiences, challenging preconceptions and celebrating the multifaceted nature of sexuality. As characters navigate their desires, the story invites readers to reflect on their own perspectives, fostering a nuanced exploration of the spectrum of human connection. This novel is hot and heavy full of insta-love and lust at its finest, with dominant alpha heros completely obsessed with claiming his/her untouched heroine. So if you’re searching for a hot, filthy, dirty ,wild sex fantasies novel then you’ve gotten one. For example maybe a story that entails: A hot professor, with his horny student! Or a romance between: A hot neighbor ready to be fucked by her long time neighbor crush! Or something fifty shades of grey alike: A Dominant his Submissive. This book is rated 18..... If you can handle the heat, well join the ride because things are going to get messy while reading.
9.2
552 Chapters
Alpha's Claimed Mate
Alpha's Claimed Mate
“ Know this. You have to do what I ask of you. And don’t ask any questions. ” His voice drops a few octaves. Instinctively, I place my hands over his chest, feeling his beating heart under my palm. “ Just do as I say and everything will be fine. ” His eyes lower to my lips. “ Or else…”  The lingering threat triggers the rebel side of mine. “ Or else? ” “ Or else…” He lifts his gaze to my eyes and shoots me a very promising smirk. “ I will make you. " ******** ******** A wild night out with her two best friends, away from her controlling boyfriend was all Natalie Whitman planned on the ocassion of her 20th birthday, but it didn't turn out quite right. Because now, she was marked and claimed by a man she doesn't even know and her boyfriend of two years is pounding the door. Hide the truth or pretend to be not marked—That's her only choice but it doesn't prove out to be easy when the Alpha who marked her comes barging in her life and it becomes impossible for her to ignore him.
9.5
217 Chapters
Loving my Rejected Luna
Loving my Rejected Luna
“I'm not asking you to love me back. As long as you let me love you, I'll love you till I die"_______________ Being rejected and thrown out of the pack by her mate and Lover was something Kiara never saw coming. She watched her life crumble before her eyes and decided that she was never going to forgive him no matter what. Two years later, after trying to put the past behind her and ignoring her ex lover and mate as much as she could, She bumped into him and the emotions and pain that had once been buried deep down surfaces to the top. But when a Powerful Alpha and a mafia Lord both have eyes on her, wanting her as their mate. Would she follow her heart which has longed for her mate? Or would she choose the man who would lay his world under her feet?
9.7
204 Chapters

Related Questions

What Historical Examples Are Analyzed In 'Collapse: How Societies Choose To Fail Or Succeed'?

3 answers2025-06-15 00:31:27
I recently finished 'Collapse' and was struck by how Jared Diamond examines societies through environmental lenses. The Norse in Greenland is a standout example—they clung to European farming methods despite the harsh Arctic climate, refusing to adapt like the Inuit. Their collapse shows how cultural rigidity can be fatal. Easter Island’s story is haunting; they deforested themselves into extinction, a clear warning about resource mismanagement. The Anasazi in the American Southwest faced similar issues with water scarcity and soil depletion. Diamond contrasts these with success stories like Tokugawa Japan, which regulated deforestation wisely. Each case underscores a theme: societies thrive or die by their response to ecological limits.

What Lessons Can Businesses Learn From 'Collapse: How Societies Choose To Fail Or Succeed'?

3 answers2025-06-15 10:36:11
Reading 'Collapse: How Societies Choose to Fail or Succeed' taught me that businesses must prioritize sustainability to avoid the same fate as fallen civilizations. Companies often ignore environmental limits, just like the Easter Islanders who deforested their land into oblivion. The book shows how short-term gains lead to long-term disasters—something businesses still do today by chasing quarterly profits at the expense of future stability. Diversification is another key lesson. Societies that relied on single resources, like the Greenland Norse with their cattle, collapsed when conditions changed. Modern businesses must avoid over-dependence on one product or market. The most resilient societies adapted to change, and companies need that flexibility too—whether it’s shifting supply chains or embracing new technologies before it’s too late.

Is 'Collapse: How Societies Choose To Fail Or Succeed' Relevant To Climate Change Today?

3 answers2025-06-15 17:49:57
Reading 'Collapse: How Societies Choose to Fail or Succeed' feels like staring into a mirror reflecting our current climate crisis. Jared Diamond meticulously dissects how past civilizations crumbled due to environmental mismanagement—deforestation, soil erosion, water scarcity. Today, we’re repeating those mistakes at a global scale. The book’s analysis of Easter Island’s ecological suicide parallels modern deforestation in the Amazon. Diamond’s warning about societal blind spots resonates deeply when I see policymakers ignore climate tipping points. His case studies aren’t just history lessons; they’re blueprints showing how resource depletion and climate denial lead to collapse. What makes it particularly chilling is how today’s interconnected global economy could amplify these failures exponentially.

Does 'Collapse: How Societies Choose To Fail Or Succeed' Offer Solutions To Modern Crises?

3 answers2025-06-15 07:34:16
I've read 'Collapse: How Societies Choose to Fail or Succeed' multiple times, and yes, it absolutely offers solutions—just not in a spoon-fed way. Diamond doesn't hand out quick fixes but forces you to think through historical patterns. He shows how societies like the Maya or Easter Island collapsed from environmental mismanagement, then contrasts them with success stories like Tokugawa Japan’s forest conservation. The takeaway? Modern crises need adaptive governance and long-term thinking. Climate change mirrors deforestation threats he analyzes, and his case studies on corporate responsibility (like Chevron’s sustainable practices in Papua New Guinea) prove solutions exist when profits align with survival. It’s a playbook for avoiding disaster if we pay attention.

Can Book In Business Help Startups Succeed?

3 answers2025-06-06 01:11:45
I’ve always believed that books can be game-changers, especially for startups. When I first started my own business, I devoured books like 'The Lean Startup' by Eric Ries and 'Zero to One' by Peter Thiel. These weren’t just theoretical guides—they gave me practical frameworks to test ideas quickly and focus on creating something unique. 'The Hard Thing About Hard Things' by Ben Horowitz also stood out because it didn’t sugarcoat the struggles of entrepreneurship. Founders often face loneliness and tough decisions, and that book felt like a mentor giving honest advice. Reading isn’t a magic bullet, but it equips you with tools to avoid common pitfalls and think critically. The right book can spark ideas you wouldn’t have considered otherwise, like how 'Atomic Habits' by James Clear helped me refine daily processes that scaled my team’s productivity. For startups, time is scarce, so choosing books with actionable insights is key.

Will The Marriage In 'BTTH I Married Xun'Er' Succeed?

5 answers2025-06-17 07:08:08
In 'BTTH I Married Xun'er', the marriage’s success hinges on the volatile dynamics between the protagonist and Xun'er. Their relationship is fraught with external pressures—clan politics, rival factions, and the weight of legacy. Xun'er’s loyalty is unwavering, but the protagonist’s growth from underdog to powerhouse creates imbalances. Power disparities often strain bonds, and here, his rapid ascension might outpace their emotional synchronization. Theirs isn’t just a love story; it’s a negotiation of mutual respect amid chaos. If they navigate betrayals and battles without sacrificing trust, the marriage could endure. However, the narrative’s tendency to prioritize conflict over resolution leaves room for tragedy. The success ultimately depends on whether their love can transcend the relentless demands of their world.

Why Did Serie Fail Frieren

3 answers2025-01-07 13:24:07
From a fan's perspective, 'Frieren: Beyond Journey's End' didn't quite land for me. It's not that it's inherently a bad series. There were some genuinely compelling elements, like the premise of an ancient elf living through her twilight years. But the execution feels lacking. The pacing often stumbles, with character development rushed and plot points that felt arbitrary. In general, the series seems to have trouble striking a balance between action and introspection. Not that a series can't successfully there but it takes a deft touch that 'Frieren' seems to lack.

Who Published Why The Nations Fail And When?

4 answers2025-05-22 06:34:04
As someone who loves diving deep into political and economic theories, I find 'Why Nations Fail' to be one of the most compelling reads on the subject. The book was published in 2012 by Crown Publishing Group, a division of Random House. The authors, Daron Acemoglu and James A. Robinson, present a groundbreaking analysis of why some nations prosper while others remain impoverished. They argue that inclusive institutions are the key to success, while extractive institutions lead to failure. The book blends history, economics, and political science to make its case, drawing on examples from ancient Rome to modern-day Botswana. It’s a must-read for anyone interested in understanding the roots of global inequality and the forces that shape nations. What makes 'Why Nations Fail' stand out is its accessibility despite its academic rigor. The authors avoid jargon, making complex ideas easy to grasp. The book has sparked debates among scholars and policymakers alike, and its relevance continues to grow as nations grapple with issues of governance and development. If you’re looking for a book that challenges conventional wisdom and offers a fresh perspective on global economics, this is it.
좋은 소설을 무료로 찾아 읽어보세요
GoodNovel 앱에서 수많은 인기 소설을 무료로 즐기세요! 마음에 드는 책을 다운로드하고, 언제 어디서나 편하게 읽을 수 있습니다
앱에서 책을 무료로 읽어보세요
앱에서 읽으려면 QR 코드를 스캔하세요.
DMCA.com Protection Status