Why Is 'Conclave' By Robert Harris Controversial?

2025-06-19 18:55:05 314

4 답변

Jack
Jack
2025-06-20 04:55:18
'Conclave' stirred the pot by humanizing the papal election process. Harris paints cardinals as flawed, relatable figures—greedy, compassionate, or insecure—which upset those who prefer clergy portrayed as purely virtuous. The novel’s fictional reforms, like transparency in voting, felt uncomfortably plausible to traditionalists. Its brisk, cinematic style also drew criticism for prioritizing entertainment over reverence, though that very approach hooked history buffs and thriller enthusiasts alike.
Neil
Neil
2025-06-20 21:10:03
Robert Harris's 'conclave' sparked debate for its audacious peek into the Vatican's secretive papal election. Critics argued it blurred fiction and reality too aggressively, with its detailed procedural accuracy making some readers uncomfortable—almost as if exposing sacred behind-the-scenes rituals. The novel’s protagonist, a liberal cardinal, clashes with traditionalists, mirroring real-world tensions in the Church, which ruffled feathers among conservative Catholics.

Others took issue with the twist ending involving a groundbreaking papal choice, calling it melodramatic or implausible. Yet fans praised its gripping tension and meticulous research, proving controversy often stems from daring storytelling that challenges expectations.
Nathan
Nathan
2025-06-22 04:26:38
Harris’s 'Conclave' rankled purists by treating the papacy like a high-stakes game. The book’s insider details—how votes are cast, alliances forged—felt too revealing to some. Its dramatic liberties, especially the surprise finale, polarized readers. Yet its mix of fact and fiction sparked conversations about power and spirituality, proving even divisive art can illuminate hidden corners of our world.
Kayla
Kayla
2025-06-22 16:15:53
The controversy around 'Conclave' hinges on its unflinching portrayal of Vatican politics. Harris crafts a narrative where ambition and faith collide, with cardinals scheming like secular politicians—a depiction some found irreverent. The book’s speculative climax, where a non-cardinal is elected pope, divided readers; some called it visionary, others sacrilegious. Its blend of thriller pacing with ecclesiastical drama made it a lightning rod for discussions about art’s role in critiquing religious institutions.
모든 답변 보기
QR 코드를 스캔하여 앱을 다운로드하세요

관련 작품

Alpha Harris A Betrayed Bond
Alpha Harris A Betrayed Bond
Atticus has been on the run almost his whole life, forced to leave his home so young and thrown into a world of the unknown, never allowed to let anyone see his other half. He hides that side of him, the beast that wants to come out and stretch his limbs. Everyone he knows is gone, dead. Life has been hard, the world has hardened his heart. That is until one day he runs into a small pack with no home and no Alpha, desperate for someone to lead them. This little pack quickly finds their way into his heart, melting that cold heart, and giving him a reason to live again. Atticus hopes one day he will be able to find a place for this little pack to call home, and not have to be on the run any longer. .... Alpha Harris, after 5 years of his pack being merged with another, waiting for Harris to become of age and graduate Alpha training, Alpha Harris finally returns home to claim his title and move his pack home. Alpha Harris falls into his role as Alpha, and in no time has his pack up and running again. The thought of finding his Luna doesn't cross his mind as he dives into the busy life of the Alpha of a bustling pack. Finding a luna is the furthest thing from his mind as he works on rebuilding his father's pack. Which is why he was surprised when he finally finds him, and is shocked by his rank. Unable to deny his mate, Alpha Harris quickly falls deep in love with his mate and everything seems perfect, until it's not. A mate would never betray their mate, would they? They would never betray the bond, a blessing from the Moon Goddess, would they?
10
135 챕터
A NIGHT WITH DOCTOR ROBERT CROWN
A NIGHT WITH DOCTOR ROBERT CROWN
Blurb Sally is a 23-year-old woman juggling schooling, three part-time jobs, and caring for her sole living relative, her younger sister. Her already difficult life takes a turn for the worse when her sister is diagnosed with cancer and requires rapid treatment. Desperate to save her sister, she signs a contract with Mrs Crown, a wealthy woman who offers her a deal in which she will pay for her young sister's treatment in exchange for Sally spending the night with her son, the famed Multi-Millionaire Doctor, Robert Crown.
6
155 챕터
The Billionaire's Assistant
The Billionaire's Assistant
When Executive Director, Lucio Delevonte, walks in on his employee, Lisa using supernatural powers he wasn't in Knowledge of, He proposes an offer. "I'll protect you from the crazy scientists with my power and money, In turn, you have to protect me from my preying competitors" But when business gets mixed with pleasure one night, neither knows what will happen next. This is a truly hot office romance between a billionaire and his assistant that's worth reading.
9.5
123 챕터
Finding Home In Him
Finding Home In Him
After being kicked out of his family home because of his sexuality, Jackson Stroud is left with nothing but his pride. Desperate for a place to stay, he posts a tweet offering his body in exchange for shelter. Charles Thorne, a ruthless billionaire CEO, offers Jackson a temporary place in his luxurious mansion, under one condition: Jackson must be his bedmate. The arrangement quickly spirals into something neither expected. Will Jackson be able to resist falling for Charles, or will their toxic bond become too powerful to break?
평가가 충분하지 않습니다.
19 챕터
HEARTBEAT
HEARTBEAT
Aella is a 20-year-old girl burdened by the death of her mother. She gets abducted and unwittingly ventures into a world filled with twisted truths and sinister intentions. She falls in love with Ace the only man ready to die for her. From the moment she watches her father die, Aella realises that her life is now shrouded in darkness and secrets. It may seem that an ordinary girl has now become a prey hunted by crime Lords.
10
91 챕터
The Deceitful Heart of a Billionaire
The Deceitful Heart of a Billionaire
There came a time in the world of glamour and money. There was a young and wealthy man named James Brookes. James was the only son of Mr and Mrs Williams Brookes. He was an epitome of wealth and success. His family always got what they wanted through deceit and cunning ways. James met a young girl at a business event named Laurie who he became physically attracted to due to her beauty, intelligence and determination. Laurie didn't agree at first but James got her forcefully and deceitfully. They later got married. Meanwhile, James' parents were responsible for the death of Laurie's parents and the downfall of her family. Laurie was unaware of this because she was only 10 when her parent died. She later found out about this after she got married to James. How will Laurie react to this ? Will Laurie be able to get through this ? What will her marriage to James be like after she had heard about all this ?
평가가 충분하지 않습니다.
8 챕터

연관 질문

What Does "Conclave" Mean?

2 답변2025-08-01 00:13:52
A “conclave” is basically a private or secret meeting, often involving a group of people who need to make an important decision. You’ll usually hear it in serious or formal contexts—like when high-ranking officials, leaders, or even cardinals in the Catholic Church get together to discuss something behind closed doors. For example, when the cardinals gather to elect a new pope, that meeting is literally called a conclave. But it can also be used more loosely. If a bunch of executives or political advisors are having a hush-hush strategy session, someone might say they’re in a conclave. The key idea is that it’s exclusive, and others aren’t allowed in. There’s a sense of privacy and importance around it. So, while you probably wouldn’t use it to describe your weekend hangout with friends, if your team at work is called into a behind-the-scenes meeting to make a big decision, “conclave” wouldn’t be out of place.

Is The Movie Conclave On Netflix?

3 답변2025-08-08 09:02:45
Not yet! I double-checked, and the movie 'Conclave' isn’t currently available on Netflix. It’s based on the novel by Robert Harris, which dives deep into the political intrigue of a papal election. If you’re into slower-paced, thought-provoking political dramas, it’s the kind of story you’d enjoy. While it’s not streaming on Netflix now, it’s always worth keeping an eye out since Netflix often updates its library. Meanwhile, the book is a great read if you’re curious about the plot. Or, if you're looking for political dramas on Netflix, give 'The Two Popes' a shot—it has a similar vibe and is extremely well-made.

Is The Conclave Movie Worth Watching?

2 답변2025-08-01 07:50:19
Yeah, Conclave is definitely worth checking out—if you’re into slow-burning political thrillers with a heavy dose of secrecy and tension. It’s not your typical action-packed blockbuster, but it pulls you in with atmosphere, suspense, and some seriously good performances. Ralph Fiennes, as always, is excellent—subtle, intense, and really commanding on screen. And the whole concept of cardinals locking themselves away to elect the next pope? Kind of fascinating, especially with the film digging into the behind-the-scenes maneuvering. The pacing is deliberate—some might call it slow—but if you like intelligent drama with a bit of mystery and moral complexity, this one will hook you. That said, if you prefer fast-paced stories or heavy emotional arcs, this might not be your cup of tea. It’s more about quiet power plays than big dramatic explosions. But honestly? It’s a smart, well-crafted film that sticks with you.

Is Conclave Based On A True Story?

2 답변2025-08-01 05:35:09
Nope, Conclave isn’t based on a true story—but it definitely feels like it could be. The movie is adapted from a novel by Robert Harris, and while the setting and general concept (the election of a new pope behind locked doors) are real and rooted in actual Vatican tradition, the characters and plot are fictional. Think of it more like a “what if?” scenario set in a very real and fascinating environment. The film creates a super realistic atmosphere—like, you could easily believe that kind of drama could unfold behind closed doors in the Vatican—but there’s no evidence anything like the events in the movie actually happened. It’s more about exploring themes like secrecy, power, and moral dilemmas in a super prestigious, closed-off setting. So, not a true story, but definitely inspired by real processes and rituals.

How Does 'Conclave' By Robert Harris End?

4 답변2025-06-19 04:04:08
The ending of 'Conclave' by Robert Harris is a masterstroke of political and spiritual intrigue. Cardinal Lomeli, the protagonist, uncovers a shocking secret about Cardinal Tremblay—he was born female and underwent gender reassignment, disqualifying him from the priesthood. The revelation comes during the final vote, throwing the conclave into chaos. Yet, Lomeli, torn between duty and compassion, keeps the secret to protect the Church’s integrity. The novel closes with Lomeli resigning, hinting at his disillusionment with the institution’s corruption. What makes the ending unforgettable is its moral ambiguity. Harris doesn’t offer easy answers. Lomeli’s silence preserves the Church’s image but perpetuates its hypocrisy. The final scene, where he watches the new pope—a compromise candidate—bless the crowd, underscores the tension between faith and power. It’s a quiet, devastating critique of how institutions often prioritize survival over truth.

Does 'Conclave' By Robert Harris Have A Movie Adaptation?

4 답변2025-06-19 00:52:45
I’ve been a fan of Robert Harris’s 'Conclave' since it came out, and I’ve dug deep into whether it got a movie adaptation. The answer’s no—not yet, anyway. The novel’s intense Vatican politics and cloak-and-dagger intrigue would make for a gripping film, but so far, it’s untouched by Hollywood. Harris’s other works like 'The Ghost Writer' and 'Enigma' got screen time, which makes it surprising this one hasn’t. The book’s rich visuals—smoke-filled conclaves, whispered betrayals—feel tailor-made for cinema. Maybe the logistics of Vatican access or the niche subject delayed it. Still, fingers crossed for a future adaptation. What’s cool is how the book’s structure almost mimics a screenplay, with tight timelines and high stakes. If it ever gets greenlit, I’d cast someone like Mark Strong as Cardinal Lomeli—his gravitas fits the role perfectly. The lack of an adaptation might actually be a blessing; it keeps the book’s suspense pure, unspoiled by casting debates or rushed scripts. For now, readers get to imagine their own ideal version, which is half the fun.

Who Dies First In 'Conclave' By Robert Harris?

4 답변2025-06-19 15:30:11
In 'Conclave' by Robert Harris, Cardinal Lomeli doesn’t just witness death—he unravels it. The first to fall is Cardinal Santini, a powerhouse in the Vatican’s political machinations. His death isn’t a quiet passing; it’s a thunderclap that disrupts the papal election. Santini collapses mid-conclave, his demise shrouded in secrecy, forcing Lomeli to navigate a labyrinth of suspicion. The novel twists his death into a catalyst, exposing hidden alliances and betrayals among the cardinals. Harris paints Santini’s end with gripping ambiguity. Was it natural, or something darker? The lack of obvious foul play only deepens the intrigue. Lomeli’s investigation peels back layers of Vatican intrigue, where ambition and faith collide. Santini’s death isn’t just a plot point—it’s the spark that ignites a fiery exploration of power, morality, and the cost of truth in a world built on shadows.

What Is The Main Conflict In 'Conclave' By Robert Harris?

4 답변2025-06-19 18:20:31
The main conflict in 'Conclave' by Robert Harris revolves around the intense political and personal battles within the Vatican during the election of a new Pope. Cardinals from across the globe gather, each harboring secrets, ambitions, and rivalries. The protagonist, Cardinal Lomeli, faces the moral dilemma of uncovering these hidden truths while maintaining the sanctity of the conclave. External pressures, like media scrutiny and geopolitical interference, add layers of tension. The clash between tradition and modernity, loyalty and betrayal, creates a gripping narrative that questions the very soul of the Church. The stakes couldn’t higher—power, faith, and legacy hang in the balance. Some cardinals push for radical reform, others cling to dogma, and a few are outright corrupt. Lomeli’s struggle to navigate this minefield while upholding his integrity forms the emotional core. Harris masterfully blends thriller elements with deep theological debates, making the conflict feel both urgent and timeless. It’s not just about who becomes Pope; it’s about what the Church will stand for in a changing world.
좋은 소설을 무료로 찾아 읽어보세요
GoodNovel 앱에서 수많은 인기 소설을 무료로 즐기세요! 마음에 드는 책을 다운로드하고, 언제 어디서나 편하게 읽을 수 있습니다
앱에서 책을 무료로 읽어보세요
앱에서 읽으려면 QR 코드를 스캔하세요.
DMCA.com Protection Status