Who Is Conrad And Jeremiah In The Summer I Turned Pretty?

If you’ve ever had a summer crush that felt like it could last forever, you’ll get why Conrad and Jeremiah Fisher are such big deals in 'The Summer I Turned Pretty.' These two aren’t just love interests; they’re symbols of first loves, family drama, and growing up. Conrad’s the guy who writes poetry but won’t admit it, the one who shows love through actions (like fixing Belly’s broken porch swing) but can’t say the words. Jeremiah’s the opposite—he’ll declare his feelings with a grand gesture, like serenading Belly at a bonfire, but his fear of being second-best simmers underneath.

What’s fascinating is how the story uses their differences to explore themes of grief (their mom’s illness looms large) and identity. Conrad retreats into himself; Jeremiah overcompensates with humor. And Belly? She’s stuck in the middle, torn between the safety of Jeremiah’s adoration and the electric unpredictability of Conrad. The books dive even deeper into their messy bond, especially Jeremiah’s resentment toward Conrad for always being the 'golden boy.' It’s not just a love triangle—it’s a family saga wrapped in saltwater and nostalgia.

Conrad and Jeremiah are like two sides of the same coin in 'The Summer I Turned Pretty.' Conrad’s all dark jeans and smoldering looks, the kind of guy who reads philosophy books on the dock. Jeremiah’s the one in flip-flops, cracking jokes and organizing midnight swims. But here’s the kicker: their rivalry isn’t just about Belly. It’s about losing their mom, their dad’s failures, and the pressure of inheriting a beach house full of memories.

Conrad’s arc hits harder in season 2, when his walls finally start crumbling. There’s a scene where he breaks down in the car that wrecked me. Jeremiah, meanwhile, gets more layered—his cheerful facade cracks when he realizes love isn’t always fair. The show nails the messy, aching beauty of first loves, especially when they’re tied to a place and a family. Every time I hear 'This Love' by Taylor Swift (their theme song, fight me), I think of Conrad’s clenched jaw and Jeremiah’s hopeful grin. God, what a show.

Conrad and Jeremiah Fisher are the heartthrob brothers at the center of 'The Summer I Turned Pretty,' and honestly, their dynamic is what hooked me from the first episode. Conrad’s the older brother—brooding, intense, and carrying this quiet weight of responsibility that makes you want to peel back his layers. He’s the kind of guy who’s always holding something back, and that tension drives so much of the story. Jeremiah, on the other hand, is sunshine personified: playful, open-hearted, and the life of every beach party. But don’t let that fool you—there’s depth there, especially when it comes to his loyalty to his family and his unspoken rivalry with Conrad.

The show (and the book series it’s based on) does this incredible job of making you flip-flop between Team Conrad and Team Jeremiah because they’re both flawed and real in their own ways. Conrad’s struggles with grief and expectations hit hard, especially in season 2, while Jeremiah’s charm hides his own insecurities about never being 'the chosen one.' It’s messy, it’s emotional, and it’s exactly why fans can’t stop debating which brother Belly should end up with. Personally, I’ve rewatched the Cousins Beach scenes too many times to admit—their chemistry with Belly is just that addictive.