Why Does Emily Grierson Kill Homer Barron In 'A Rose For Emily'?

2025-06-25 07:00:19 286

3 answers

Dylan
Dylan
2025-07-01 14:32:56
Emily Grierson's murder of Homer Barron in 'A Rose for Emily' is a desperate act of control in a life where she's had little. The story paints her as a relic of the Old South, trapped by her father's strict rules and societal expectations. When Homer, a Northern laborer, shows interest but won't commit, Emily sees her chance at love slipping away. Killing him isn't just about possession—it's her twisted way of preserving the one relationship that made her feel alive. Faulkner hints at this with the bridal chamber setup, showing Emily's delusion that death could freeze their connection in time. The townspeople's gossip about her mental state suggests she wasn't fully rational, making the act both chilling and tragically inevitable given her isolation.
Nina
Nina
2025-06-27 01:13:20
The killing in 'A Rose for Emily' is a layered psychological study wrapped in Southern Gothic trappings. Emily's entire existence was defined by denial—denial of her father's death, denial of changing times, and ultimately, denial of Homer's rejection. Faulkner drops clues that Homer was gay or at least uninterested in marriage, which would've been catastrophic for Emily's pride in that era. Her poisoning him with arsenic isn't just crime; it's perverted domesticity. She keeps his corpse like a macabre houseguest, dressing it in nightclothes and leaving love letters nearby.

What fascinates me is how Faulkner uses this to critique the South's decay. Emily's home, like her mind, becomes a tomb for outdated values. The townspeople enable her delusions because she represents their nostalgic fantasies. The final reveal of Homer's corpse isn't just shock value—it shows how far someone will go to maintain illusions when reality offers nothing. If you like this, check out 'The Fall of the House of Usher' for another masterpiece about crumbling aristocracy and twisted love.
Zoe
Zoe
2025-07-01 15:29:47
Emily's murder of Homer stems from a toxic mix of loneliness and Southern aristocratic entitlement. Having been sheltered by her domineering father, she never learned healthy relationships. When Homer arrives, he's both exciting (as a Yankee outsider) and terrifying (as someone who could abandon her). The story's nonlinear structure hides this, but pay attention to the timeline—Emily buys poison right after Homer's coworkers leave town, implying he was preparing to leave too.

Her actions mirror how the Old South clung to traditions despite inevitable change. The gray hair found on Homer's corpse proves she'd been lying beside him for years, a grotesque parody of marriage. For readers who enjoy complex female characters, 'We Have Always Lived in the Castle' by Shirley Jackson offers a similarly unsettling exploration of isolation and violence.
View All Answers
Scan code to download App

Related Books

Emily Warner
Emily Warner
Emily Warner, the crazy and happy go lucky side-chick in all of the stories. She is happy that all of her friends met the man of their dreams but she hasn’t. She has never met a man who even remotely loved her. As a kid, she always hoped for a crazy life story like beauty and the beast or toy story or finding nemo. But she worked at a nine to five job, at the age of twenty nine, she was single, while all of her friends were either getting married or pregnant. And there she was sitting in front of the television, eating chips out of her hair. At this point in her life, she was heartbroken, depressed and done pretending to be happy when she was clearly not. She just wanted to escape, run away and have a crazy adventure. Little did she know that she would regret making that wish.
10
52 Chapters
Little Emily
Little Emily
Emily Addison has been abused and neglected by a man she thought was her father. What happens when she gets saved by her brothers? Who has been searching for her for years now. What will Emily do and how will she react to all these new secrets? And find a new love life together.
8.8
146 Chapters
HAUNTING EMILY
HAUNTING EMILY
Emily took a case she should’ve never accepted. The man she was supposed to bring down? Matteo Romenetti, known as California's most wanted criminal. He was her first love, the boy who once made her believe in forever. But the night she tried to let go, he showed up at her door. **** “Tell me,” he whispered, stepping closer, “if I mean nothing to you… why does your heart still race when I’m this close?”
10
29 Chapters
Emily, Mr. Billionaire.
Emily, Mr. Billionaire.
“Is this a…contract?” “It has everything you would need if you want to go on dates with me for the next couple of weeks. From the times you can call me to the days I would not be available to pick up calls or even respond to text messages no matter how urgent they are. There’s also a number of locations we can have our dates and another number of places I would never set foot in. Things you can talk about and things you should stay out of. There’s a detailed list of questions you can ask me there and an even more detailed list of things you should never mention. It’s not too much. All you need to do is go through it, sign the contract and we’re good to go. I’ll text you the dates and locations of our dates and have my driver come pick you up.” Emily was bewildered. “You’ve got to be joking.” ——- Emily Stark was given a choice- to either get married to a billionaire she had never met her entire life in place of her sister who had ran away in fear of getting married or somehow find a way to pay her parents’ debt of thirty million dollars in a day. She is immediately stuck at a crossroad but knows she has no choice but to succumb and get married. After all, it was just marriage? How much complicated could it be? Well, unless your husband to be is a cold ruthless billionaire who only cares about his work and has absolutely no interest in you. And to make it worse, thinks marriage is nothing but another business deal. A contract to be signed and simply gotten over with with time.
8
100 Chapters
Emily and The Wolves
Emily and The Wolves
Think werewolves are just fairy tales? But no! They do exist. And Emily, having lived a calm and unremarkable life, suddenly finds herself in the very epicenter of the war that flared up between the Wolves and the Hunters! And it is she, Amy, who is the cause of this very war. Why? Let's get together and find out.
Not enough ratings
55 Chapters
The Two Sides of Emily Chavez
The Two Sides of Emily Chavez
Emily Chavez is a simple university student wishing to be a nurse someday. What will she do when she wakes up one day being a totally different person from who she really is? Is it part of her dream or is it real? How can she get out from this mystery when she herself cannot explain what is happening?
Not enough ratings
11 Chapters

Related Questions

What Does The Rose Symbolize In 'A Rose For Emily'?

3 answers2025-06-25 13:10:17
In 'A Rose for Emily,' the rose isn’t just a flower—it’s a complex symbol of love, decay, and the passage of time. Miss Emily herself is like a preserved rose, frozen in her old Southern ways while the world changes around her. The title suggests a tribute, but it’s ironic; her life was anything but romantic. The rose also represents secrecy—her hidden corpse of Homer Barron is like the thorns hidden beneath petals. Faulkner uses it to show how clinging to the past (like Emily clinging to her father’s corpse) leads to grotesque outcomes. It’s not a beautiful symbol; it’s a warning about what happens when tradition festers instead of adapts.

Who Is The Narrator In 'A Rose For Emily'?

3 answers2025-06-25 06:58:24
The narrator in 'A Rose for Emily' isn't just one person—it's the collective voice of the townspeople, gossiping about Emily Grierson like they’ve been watching her for decades. This 'we' perspective makes the story feel like a local legend, something passed down over coffee or at the general store. The tone shifts between pity and judgment, especially when describing Emily’s reclusive life and her scandalous relationship with Homer Barron. What’s chilling is how the narrator casually drops hints about the ending—like the smell around her house—while pretending not to know the full truth. It’s Southern Gothic at its finest, where the town itself becomes a character, complicit in Emily’s tragedy.

What Is The Significance Of Emily'S House In 'A Rose For Emily'?

3 answers2025-06-25 00:44:05
Emily's house in 'A Rose for Emily' isn't just a setting—it's a decaying monument to the Old South's stubborn refusal to change. The towering, once-grand home mirrors Emily herself: proud, isolated, and crumbling under the weight of time. Its closed doors hide secrets (like Homer's corpse), just as Emily's defiance hides her mental decay. The house becomes a physical barrier between her and the town's judgment, a fortress where she clings to dead traditions. Faulkner uses it brilliantly to show how clinging to the past literally rots you from the inside out. Every dust-covered room screams 'ghost of what once was,' making it the perfect Gothic symbol of Southern Gothic literature's obsession with decay.

How Does 'A Rose For Emily' Explore Southern Gothic Themes?

3 answers2025-06-25 03:55:46
The Southern Gothic vibe in 'A Rose for Emily' hits hard with its decaying setting and twisted traditions. Faulkner paints Emily's home as a crumbling relic of the Old South, filled with dust and shadows, mirroring her own mental decline. The story drips with grotesque elements—Emily's necrophilia isn't just shocking; it's a metaphor for the South clinging to dead traditions. The town's gossipy narrators embody the oppressive social scrutiny that suffocates individuality, especially for women. Emily's isolation speaks to the Gothic theme of entrapment, showing how the past haunts the present. The grotesque twist ending reveals how deeply corruption runs, blending horror with pity for a woman destroyed by her environment.

How Does Faulkner Use Time Shifts In 'A Rose For Emily'?

3 answers2025-06-25 11:16:18
Faulkner's use of time shifts in 'A Rose for Emily' isn’t just a stylistic choice—it’s the backbone of the story’s eerie atmosphere. The narrative jumps between past and present without warning, mirroring how memory works in real life. We see Emily’s decaying mansion in the present, then suddenly we’re decades back watching her father chase suitors away. This non-linear structure keeps readers disoriented, making the final reveal about Homer’s corpse hit harder. The time shifts also emphasize how Emily is stuck in the past, refusing to accept change even as the town modernizes around her. Faulkner makes us piece together her tragic story like detectives sifting through clues scattered across different eras.

Why Did Emily Write 'We Were Never Here'?

3 answers2025-06-24 20:23:50
Emily wrote 'We Were Never Here' to explore the dark side of female friendships and the psychological toll of keeping dangerous secrets. The novel digs into how trust can warp into something toxic when pushed to extremes. It's not just about the thrill of a murder cover-up; it's about how shared guilt binds people in ways they can't escape. The book mirrors real-life situations where friendships become co-dependent and destructive, showing how easily loyalty can turn into a prison. Emily's sharp writing makes you feel the characters' paranoia and desperation, like you're right there with them, questioning every decision.

How Did Henry Emily Die

3 answers2025-02-01 14:02:10
Actually, there seems to be some confusion here. Emily Henry is a best-selling author of numerous beloved books such as 'Beach Read'. There's no public record of any event that suggests she has passed away, thankfully.

Does Emily Prentiss Die

3 answers2025-01-17 09:15:00
As someone who regularly watches 'Criminal Minds', I can confirm that Emily Prentiss, played by Paget Brewster, does not die in the series. While she does experience some brutal moments, particularly in season 6 when she is believed to be dead, she manages to survive. Her character even eventually becomes the unit chief, leading the BAU team. 'Criminal Minds' is theme-heavy - full of thrills and suspense, always keeping you at the edge of your seat!
Explore and read good novels for free
Free access to a vast number of good novels on GoodNovel app. Download the books you like and read anywhere & anytime.
Read books for free on the app
SCAN CODE TO READ ON APP
DMCA.com Protection Status