Why Is 'Extremely Loud & Incredibly Close' Controversial?

2025-06-20 01:22:27 264

3 Answers

Theo
Theo
2025-06-23 08:18:01
What makes 'Extremely Loud & Incredibly Close' controversial isn’t just the content—it’s the timing. Published in 2005 when 9/11 wounds were still raw, many felt it was too soon for a metaphorical treatment. Oskar’s quest to find the lock matching his father’s key was seen by some as trivializing actual victims’ families’ pain. The inclusion of falling-body imagery, though artistically bold, struck others as gratuitous.

Yet the novel’s emotional core is undeniable. The grandfather’s letters from Dresden create a powerful analogy between historical and contemporary trauma, but this parallel also drew flak for equating different scales of tragedy. Some Jewish readers took issue with using Hiroshima/Dresden narratives alongside 9/11, feeling it diluted unique horrors.

Foer’s decision to blend humor with devastation also polarized audiences. Scenes like Oskar yelling 'I’m incompetent!' during a panic attack walked a fine line between dark comedy and tonal whiplash. Ultimately, the book’s willingness to risk alienating readers made it unforgettable—you either embraced its messy humanity or rejected it as pretentious trauma porn.
Omar
Omar
2025-06-25 03:02:40
'Extremely Loud & Incredibly Close' fascinates me because its controversies stem from bold artistic choices. The fragmented structure, mixing Oskar’s first-person narrative with his grandparents’ typewritten letters and blank pages, deliberately mirrors the chaos of grief. Critics argued this style made the 9/11 themes feel disjointed, while defenders praised it for capturing how trauma disrupts memory.

Another hot topic was the characterization. Oskar’s hyper-verbal, neurodivergent-coded personality divided readers—some found his voice unrealistic for a nine-year-old, even if grieving. His mother’s passive portrayal sparked debates about parental neglect versus silent strength. The grandparents’ subplot, involving wartime trauma and selective muteness, was either a poignant parallel or an overcrowded distraction from the central tragedy.

The book’s visual elements, like pages with single sentences or red pen edits, pushed literary boundaries but alienated readers preferring conventional prose. Jonathan Safran Foer’s maximalist approach was hailed as innovative by some, dismissed as gimmicky by others. What’s undeniable is how it forced conversations about who ‘owns’ collective grief and how far artistic license should stretch with real-world catastrophes.
Parker
Parker
2025-06-26 11:21:30
I read 'Extremely Loud & Incredibly Close' years ago, and its controversy stuck with me. The novel’s portrayal of 9/11 trauma through a child’s perspective rubbed some readers the wrong way—they felt it exploited real tragedy for literary effect. The protagonist Oskar’s quirks, like his tambourine and invented inventions, made him polarizing; some saw him as endearing, others as annoyingly precocious. The nonlinear storytelling with interspersed letters and photos confused traditional readers expecting a straightforward narrative. Certain scenes, like Oskar’s imagined conversation with his dead father in a voicemail, were criticized as emotionally manipulative rather than authentic. What fascinated me was how the book’s experimental style became its biggest strength and weakness simultaneously—it either deeply moved people or left them cold.
View All Answers
Scan code to download App

Related Books

Why Mr CEO, Why Me
Why Mr CEO, Why Me
She came to Australia from India to achieve her dreams, but an innocent visit to the notorious kings street in Sydney changed her life. From an international exchange student/intern (in a small local company) to Madam of Chen's family, one of the most powerful families in the world, her life took a 180-degree turn. She couldn’t believe how her fate got twisted this way with the most dangerous and noble man, who until now was resistant to the women. The key thing was that she was not very keen to the change her life like this. Even when she was rotten spoiled by him, she was still not ready to accept her identity as the wife of this ridiculously man.
9.7
62 Chapters
BEHIND CLOSE DOORS
BEHIND CLOSE DOORS
"You slept here?" George asked. "Yes, I…um,” Irene gulped, licking her lips and making a quick calculation in her mind on what to say, “I um…I was feeling hot when reading, so I decided to take a shower and might have fallen asleep after it. You just woke me up, have-have you been standing here? Um what's up, are you ready for work?” She asked while getting up to put on her nightwear. George watched her then sighed, “Irene, can I ask you something?” His eyes was burning red, and he was bitterly angry which was showing on his face “Why did you do this to me, what have I done to deserve the betrayal from you, What haven’t I done for you, what else do you need from a man i’ve not given to, why didn’t you tell me you want to be a model, why do you chose to let me know this way, do you want a divorce?” Irene and George had met in school and fallen in love, then their relationship had led into a beautiful marriage where she had been most happy until she had miscarried two pregnancies. Down and broken, George had decided to make her better by hiring a cook who would bring all her online delicacies to their dining table for her. But who would have expected that her one night of mistake would not only change her but would fill her beautiful marriage with lies? How is she to avoid her sins despite knowing it was wrong and still craving for it? How would she face her darling husband and tell him her darkest secret? But even though the sin was addictive, she had no idea what other secrets lies between, waiting to shatter her heart.
10
27 Chapters
Got Too Close
Got Too Close
"You're a dangerous woman, Elena," He reached, turning on the shower beside her head. "I think your demons are making you see things wrong, Mr. Rossi," she murmured through the water spilling down her head. He laughed, "They are right; you're my trigger," his nose buried into the crook of her neck, he muttered, sending shivers down her spine. "And too bad a lot of people cross you..." ***** Her life came crashing down when she signed a contract marriage with the calm President Nikolai Rossi, who only had eyes on one woman who wasn't her. To make matters worse, she couldn't help but fall in love with him and his son, knowing he'd never reciprocate. After a terrible divorce, three years later, Elena Vero is a mother of one. She now has to return to Italy for business, unfortunately falling into the waiting palms of her ex-husband, who surprisingly wants her back. But being his wife has never been a bed of roses and never will it be, especially when she finds out he isn't all that he seems.
9.9
132 Chapters
Why Me?
Why Me?
Why Me? Have you ever questioned this yourself? Bullying -> Love -> Hatred -> Romance -> Friendship -> Harassment -> Revenge -> Forgiving -> ... The story is about a girl who is oversized or fat. She rarely has any friends. She goes through lots of hardships in her life, be in her family or school or high school or her love life. The story starts from her school life and it goes on. But with all those hardships, will she give up? Or will she be able to survive and make herself stronger? Will she be able to make friends? Will she get love? <<…So, I was swayed for a moment." His words were like bullets piercing my heart. I still could not believe what he was saying, I grabbed his shirt and asked with tears in my eyes, "What about the time... the time we spent together? What about everything we did together? What about…" He interrupted me as he made his shirt free from my hand looked at the side she was and said, "It was a time pass for me. Just look at her and look at yourself in the mirror. I love her. I missed her. I did not feel anything for you. I just played with you. Do you think a fatty like you deserves me? Ha-ha, did you really think I loved a hippo like you? ">> P.S.> The cover's original does not belong to me.
10
107 Chapters
WHY ME
WHY ME
Eighteen-year-old Ayesha dreams of pursuing her education and building a life on her own terms. But when her traditional family arranges her marriage to Arman, the eldest son of a wealthy and influential family, her world is turned upside down. Stripped of her independence and into a household where she is treated as an outsider, Ayesha quickly learns that her worth is seen only in terms of what she can provide—not who she is. Arman, cold and distant, seems to care little for her struggles, and his family spares no opportunity to remind Ayesha of her "place." Despite their cruelty, she refuses to be crushed. With courage and determination, Ayesha begins to carve out her own identity, even in the face of hostility. As tensions rise and secrets within the household come to light, Ayesha is faced with a choice: remain trapped in a marriage that diminishes her, or fight for the freedom and self-respect she deserves. Along the way, she discovers that strength can be found in the most unexpected places—and that love, even in its most fragile form, can transform and heal. Why Me is a heart-wrenching story of resilience, self-discovery, and the power of standing up for oneself, set against the backdrop of tradition and societal expectations. is a poignant and powerful exploration of resilience, identity, and the battle for autonomy. Set against the backdrop of tradition and societal expectations, it is a moving story of finding hope, strength, and love in the darkest of times.But at the end she will find LOVE.
Not enough ratings
160 Chapters
A Love Too Close
A Love Too Close
Blurb A secret baby. A billionaire ex. A Love she swore she would never touch again. Annie's life was already in ruins—shattered by betrayal, rebuilt by pain, held together by sheer will. But just when she finally starts breathing again, the past she buried began to rise. Because someone dangerously close… someone she should have walked away from… is about to step right back into her path. And this time, the storm he brings might be the one she can't survive.
Not enough ratings
8 Chapters

Related Questions

What Is The Meaning Of 'Everytime I Close My Eyes' By Babyface?

4 Answers2025-09-13 12:15:08
Music has this incredible power to tap into our emotions, and 'Everytime I Close My Eyes' by Babyface is a perfect example of that. The song explores the themes of love and longing, emphasizing how the connection with someone special can profoundly impact our lives. For me, it feels like a deep dive into the vulnerability of love; when I hear those lyrics, I'm transported to moments of yearning—like the weekends I spent reminiscing about my first crush. Every lyric radiates a sense of nostalgia, painting a vivid picture of heartbeats and stolen glances. Babyface’s silky voice delivers a heartfelt message, as if he's laying bare his own emotions for us to feel. The way he expresses the beauty of dreaming about loved ones when you close your eyes resonates with anyone who's ever experienced that intense desire for intimacy. It’s like he captures the essence of those quiet, introspective moments where love mingles with a touch of solitude. Listening to this song, I can’t help but think about all the times I’ve found myself lost in someone’s memory. It’s magical and earthy at the same time, reminding us that love lingers even when we’re apart. And let’s not forget the production! The blend of smooth R&B and heartfelt lyrics creates a vibe that’s perfect for those late-night moments you just want to get lost in the music. The melody stays in your head, yet the deeper meaning captures the heart, making it a timeless piece that resonates across generations. Whenever I put it on, it’s like an old friend who understands where I’m coming from, reminding me of the beautiful mess that is love.

What Does The Music Video For 'Everytime I Close My Eyes' Depict?

4 Answers2025-09-13 15:02:44
The music video for 'Everytime I Close My Eyes' is a beautifully crafted journey through emotions, blending elements of nostalgia, love, and self-reflection. It opens with soft lighting and serene visuals that instantly draw you in. The scenes often transition between a dreamy landscape and intimate moments shared by characters, likely representing the artist's thoughts or memories. Each frame feels like a brushstroke on a canvas, painting a story of longing, desire, and the bittersweet nature of human connections. As the music unfolds, I found myself captivated by the powerful imagery that accompanies the lyrics. There are moments of solitude, pairing the artist with shots of nature, evoking a sense of peace that contrasts beautifully with the inner turmoil suggested by the lyrics. The video explores themes of escapism, where closing one's eyes becomes a metaphor for finding solace amid chaos, and the visual narrative complements this perfectly. Whether it's the soft glimmer of the sun setting or the gentle touch of a hand, every detail serves to pull at the heartstrings. It's like witnessing a delicate memory play out in real time, which left me both reflective and hopeful. In a world full of noise, I think this video encourages us to seek those quiet moments of introspection, where we can find clarity and peace before the storm resumes.

What Are The Most Memorable Lines From 'Everytime I Close My Eyes'?

5 Answers2025-09-13 13:36:17
From the moment I heard 'Everytime I Close My Eyes', I was completely taken in by the atmosphere it creates. The line 'You are the dream that makes my heart beat' has always resonated with me deeply. It encapsulates that euphoric feeling when you see someone special, and it feels like time stands still. It’s those rare moments you want to freeze forever, right? Quite moving, isn’t it? The way it speaks about love intertwining with dreams feels so enchanting. Another line that I find unforgettable is 'In your presence, I dance with hope.' It just evokes imagery of whimsical joy and endless possibilities. You know, there’s something incredibly powerful about expressing hope through dance. It makes me think of those carefree days where nothing else mattered—just being alive and feeling the rhythm of life with someone you care about. It’s the type of line that stays with you long after the song ends, reminding you to cherish those moments. The way this piece captures that feeling of anticipation really hits home. It’s like a beautiful snapshot of love, and it reminds me that even simple lines can evoke such strong emotions.

What Time Period Does 'At Day'S Close: Night In Times Past' Cover?

3 Answers2025-06-12 20:14:30
I've been fascinated by 'At Day's Close: Night in Times Past' ever since I picked it up. This book dives deep into the nocturnal world from the late Middle Ages right through to the Industrial Revolution. It's incredible how much changed during these centuries—how people viewed darkness, how night influenced culture, and even how crime flourished under cover of darkness. The author doesn't just stick to Europe either; there's plenty about colonial America and how settlers adapted to the night. If you\'re into history with a twist, this one's a must-read. The way it contrasts pre-electricity nights with today's 24/7 illuminated world is mind-blowing.

What Techniques Does A Camera Man Use For Dramatic Close-Ups?

4 Answers2025-10-17 03:28:37
Close-ups are a secret handshake between the lens and the actor that can say more than pages of dialogue. I get obsessed with three basic levers: lens choice, light, and the camera's motion. A longer focal length (85mm, 100mm, or even a 135mm) compresses features and flatters faces, making an actor’s eyes pop; a wider lens close in will distort and can feel raw or uncomfortable — useful when you want the audience to squirm. Opening the aperture for a super shallow depth of field isolates the eye or mouth with creamy bokeh; it’s one of the fastest ways to make a close-up feel intimate. Lighting determines mood: low-key, rim light, or a single soft source can carve musculature of the face and reveal memory lines the actor barely uses. Think of 'Raging Bull' or 'The Godfather' where chiaroscuro tells half the story. Beyond the optics, micro-techniques matter: a slow push-in (dolly or zoom used tastefully) increases pressure, while a sudden cut to an ECU (extreme close-up) creates shock. Rack focus can shift attention from a trembling hand to the actor’s eyes mid-scene. Catchlights are tiny but crucial — without them the eyes read dead. For truthfulness I love to work with naturalistic blocking, letting the actor breathe within the frame so facial beats happen organically. Even sound and editing choices support close-ups: cut on breath, hold a fraction longer for a silent reveal. It’s those small choices that turn a face into a whole world, and when it lands properly it gives me goosebumps every time.

Is Close As Neighbors Based On A True Story?

4 Answers2025-10-17 00:41:05
here's how I see it: the simple truth is, it depends on which 'Close as Neighbors' you're talking about. There are a few indie films and novels with similar names, and creators often use phrasing like "based on a true story" loosely. In my experience, when a piece of media wears that label, it usually means the core idea or a handful of events were inspired by real life, but the characters, dialogue, and many plot beats are dramatized for narrative impact. If you're trying to figure out whether the specific 'Close as Neighbors' you watched is grounded in reality, check the opening or closing credits for a "based on" line, look up interviews with the director or author, and peek at the production notes or the publisher's blurb. I once dug through an indie film's festival press kit and found the modest true incident that birthed the story — tiny in reality but huge on screen. Ultimately, whether it's strictly factual or a dramatized riff, the emotional truth can still hit hard, and that's what stuck with me.

How Do Authors Use Keep Your Friends Close In Book Plots?

5 Answers2025-10-17 00:43:10
Nothing spices a plot like an apparent ally who might be a dagger in disguise; I love how authors use the idea of 'keep your friends close' to turn comfort into suspense. In novels it shows up in dialogue, of course — a character repeats a proverb and we feel the chill — but more powerful is when it's woven into the architecture of relationships. An author will place a sympathetic friend next to the protagonist for years, then pull a hidden motive into view at the exact moment the reader trusts them most. Beyond betrayal, writers use the motif to explore moral complexity. Sometimes ‘keeping friends close’ becomes a survival strategy: protagonists maintain intimacy to protect secrets, to gather information, or to manipulate politics without becoming monsters. I adore stories where loyalty is porous, where companionship is transactional yet emotionally real, like the way 'The Godfather' frames loyalty and power, or how political maneuvering in 'Game of Thrones' makes every hug a negotiation. It’s one of those narrative moves that can be tender and terrifying at once, and I always find myself re-reading scenes afterward, hunting for the micro-signals the author left — a glance, a hesitation, a line of dialogue that suddenly bursts into meaning. It leaves me buzzing with both disappointment and appreciation, which is exactly the fun I crave.

Which Apps Offer Books Read Out Loud For Free?

3 Answers2025-09-03 06:55:28
Wow, if you love having books read to you, there's a nice bunch of genuinely free options out there — I get excited thinking about evening walks with someone narrating 'Pride and Prejudice' in my ear. LibriVox is my first shout: volunteers record public-domain books and the app (or website) streams downloads for free. The quality varies — some recordings are theatrical, some are more like a friendly reading — but classics like 'Moby-Dick' and 'Dracula' are easy to find. Loyal Books (used to be BooksShouldBeFree) pulls from the same public-domain pool with a cleaner app interface, so it’s great for quick browsing. For modern titles, your local library apps are pure gold. Libby (by OverDrive) and Hoopla let you borrow audiobooks for free with a library card; Libby has a beautiful interface for holds and downloads, while Hoopla often has simultaneous-access titles so you don’t wait. OverDrive’s older app still works, but Libby feels fresher. Project Gutenberg doesn’t always have professional audio, but they do host recordings and text files you can pair with any text-to-speech engine — so if you want a book read aloud and it’s public domain, you can make it happen. On the tech side: Google Play Books and the Kindle app can use your phone’s text-to-speech (TTS) to read many ebooks aloud, and iOS has Speak Screen while Android has Select-to-Speak/TTS options. If you want a dedicated TTS reader, Voice Aloud Reader (Android) and NaturalReader (has a free tier) are solid. Also peek at Spotify or YouTube for public-domain audiobooks people upload — not always complete or legal, but sometimes you find gems. Honestly, try a couple: classics on LibriVox, current-ish titles via Libby or Hoopla, and TTS for PDFs and obscure formats. It’s like building your own audiobook buffet, and I love swapping between volunteer reads and crisp TTS voices depending on my mood.
Explore and read good novels for free
Free access to a vast number of good novels on GoodNovel app. Download the books you like and read anywhere & anytime.
Read books for free on the app
SCAN CODE TO READ ON APP
DMCA.com Protection Status