LOGINLibrary
Search
What Method Does Plato The Republic Propose For Choosing Rulers?
2025-08-27 18:13:21
62
4 Answers
Blake
2025-08-28 08:39:45
I like to boil Plato’s proposal down to a phrase: pick rulers by proven love of knowledge, shown through rigorous training. In 'The Republic' he imagines starting with guardians chosen for temperament, then putting them through staged education—music/physical training, then math and sciences, then dialectic—so only those who genuinely understand the Good govern
It’s a meritocratic ideal but with heavy state control: communal upbringing, arranged breeding for the best traits, and the infamous 'noble lie' to keep people in their places. To me, the attractive part is the emphasis on wisdom over popularity; the worrying part is how easily power could be abused under such a system. I often wonder how you’d keep that balance in practice.
It’s a meritocratic ideal but with heavy state control: communal upbringing, arranged breeding for the best traits, and the infamous 'noble lie' to keep people in their places. To me, the attractive part is the emphasis on wisdom over popularity; the worrying part is how easily power could be abused under such a system. I often wonder how you’d keep that balance in practice.
Henry
2025-08-29 18:51:58
Flipping through 'The Republic' late at night once, I kept pausing at Plato's plan for picking rulers because it's both striking and strangely practical in his own idealized way.
He wants leaders who aren't chosen by birth or popularity but by a long, state-directed selection and education process: children with the right temperaments become guardians, undergo shared upbringing, and are weeded through trials of music, gymnastics, mathematics, and finally dialectic. Those who demonstrate the rare capacity to grasp the Form of the Good—after decades of training and testing—become the rulers. Plato even proposes a communal life for guardians to avoid family loyalties skewing judgment, plus a 'noble lie' to keep social harmony, and controlled marriages to try to produce the best offspring.
Reading it felt like watching a very old blueprint for a meritocracy that’s also authoritarian: merit in knowledge and character, but enforced by the state. I find it compelling in theory—having rulers who love wisdom—but it raises big ethical flags for me when applied to real people. Still, the image of a philosopher steering the polis sticks with me, and I often wonder how a modern version could avoid the darker bits.
He wants leaders who aren't chosen by birth or popularity but by a long, state-directed selection and education process: children with the right temperaments become guardians, undergo shared upbringing, and are weeded through trials of music, gymnastics, mathematics, and finally dialectic. Those who demonstrate the rare capacity to grasp the Form of the Good—after decades of training and testing—become the rulers. Plato even proposes a communal life for guardians to avoid family loyalties skewing judgment, plus a 'noble lie' to keep social harmony, and controlled marriages to try to produce the best offspring.
Reading it felt like watching a very old blueprint for a meritocracy that’s also authoritarian: merit in knowledge and character, but enforced by the state. I find it compelling in theory—having rulers who love wisdom—but it raises big ethical flags for me when applied to real people. Still, the image of a philosopher steering the polis sticks with me, and I often wonder how a modern version could avoid the darker bits.
Kevin
2025-08-31 12:22:13
I often explain Plato's scheme by mapping its stages, because that helps me remember the logic behind the famous philosopher-rulers in 'The Republic'. First stage: selection by nature and early education—kids who show the right mix of spirit and reason are chosen for further training. Second stage: formative curriculum—music and gymnastics shape character, then mathematics and geometry broaden the mind. Third stage: intensive intellectual training—advanced studies in astronomy, harmonics, and especially dialectic prepare the soul for seeing forms. Fourth stage: trials of leadership—those who reach the highest insight, particularly the Form of the Good, then take on rulership after real-world experience.
Plato also couples this with social engineering: communal living for guardians, regulated procreation to breed talent, and the 'noble lie' to keep classes stable. I find this method fascinating because it’s thorough: philosophical education is front and center rather than merely decorative. Yet it’s easy to criticize—centralized control over families and reproduction seems invasive, and the assumption that knowledge of the Good prevents abuse is optimistic. Still, the core—selecting rulers for intellectual and moral excellence—feels like an idea worth wrestling with, even today.
Plato also couples this with social engineering: communal living for guardians, regulated procreation to breed talent, and the 'noble lie' to keep classes stable. I find this method fascinating because it’s thorough: philosophical education is front and center rather than merely decorative. Yet it’s easy to criticize—centralized control over families and reproduction seems invasive, and the assumption that knowledge of the Good prevents abuse is optimistic. Still, the core—selecting rulers for intellectual and moral excellence—feels like an idea worth wrestling with, even today.
Benjamin
2025-09-01 18:52:52
When I think about Plato's method in 'The Republic', I picture a multi-stage sieve rather than a single election. First, youngsters are observed for natural aptitude—courage, temperance, intelligence—and those who fit are funneled into the guardian class. Then there’s a prescribed curriculum: early roles emphasize music and physical training to shape soul and body, later shifting to arithmetic, geometry, astronomy, and harmonics to build abstract thought. Finally, dialectic training aims to make some of those students capable of grasping the Good, which is the key quality for ruling.
It’s very meritocratic in intent, but the state-run nature—communal child-rearing, arranged pairings, and the use of a 'noble lie' to cement roles—feels intrusive to me. Still, I appreciate Plato’s core idea: leaders should be selected for wisdom and moral knowledge, not wealth or popularity. The challenge, of course, is how to design fair tests and avoid concentrated power corrupting the whole system.
It’s very meritocratic in intent, but the state-run nature—communal child-rearing, arranged pairings, and the use of a 'noble lie' to cement roles—feels intrusive to me. Still, I appreciate Plato’s core idea: leaders should be selected for wisdom and moral knowledge, not wealth or popularity. The challenge, of course, is how to design fair tests and avoid concentrated power corrupting the whole system.
View All Answers
Scan code to download App
Related Books
What does the major want?
Lara is a prisoner, she will meet Mark in a hard situation, what will happen?? Both of them are completely devoted to each other...
18 Chapters
Choosing paths
As a Catholic girl I was just trying to make it through college. I wasn't looking for a lot in life. Just good grades, getting married before twenty two, having a few kids and God's blessings.
People say that in life, you don't always get what you want and life has a way of roaming from the trail you planned to follow. I never realised how true the saying was.
Religion was my everything, so what happens when I end up falling for the same gender? It couldn't get worse, right?
But as life always feels the need to show you, it could... And it would.
23 Chapters
Choosing Fate
“You’re disgusting. Get out of my room,” I demand as I press up to my feet. He doesn’t protest and stands up, slicking his bright pink hair back.
“Whatever ya say, Bunny. Get some sleep. You have an early day tomorrow,” he winks at me and makes his way out the door.
- - - -
Sapphire Stone is the third daughter of the late Alpha Bronson Stone. Despite losing both her parents to the Fated Plague when she was just a child, and being separated from her sisters, Saph maintained an optimistic attitude. She was always the sister who could look on the bright side. That is until she lost her chosen mate when he sacrificed his life for another. Once bright-eyed and caring Saph is now using any means to numb herself from the pain of her broken heart. Her reckless behavior has ultimately landed her in serious trouble with Alpha Asher of Red Mountain Pack. Coping with her loss and grief is hard enough. Now, Saph must face the man who cost her chosen mate his life, along with helping find a cure for what could be another plague.
Alpha Asher is the light-hearted, and alternative, leader of the Red Mountain Pack. After uprooting his pack from Australia, Asher has vowed to always keep his pack members safe and free from worry. The full moon run reveals a bond that Asher cannot fight, but also cannot act on. With secrets from his past resurfacing, Asher will do anything to protect his new-found mate, even if it’s from herself. A former betrayal looms in the shadows, threatening to decimate what’s left of Asher’s pack. It will require him to trust his mate, and new allies, to help him save what matters most to him.
70 Chapters
Choosing You
I've crushed on Ethan McKay since the moment I laid eyes on him. After a year and a half of going to the same college, he still has no clue I exist. Aside from my best friend, I'm practically invisible since I've spent the last seven years of my life purposefully living in the shadows, just waiting for my life to begin. Not that it matters. He's got his own life to live anyway. Parties to attend. Girls to see. And a father to impress so he can regain his trust, and earn back his rightful place in the family business. So, how is it that one night, one party, changes everything for the both of us?
112 Chapters
Choosing the billionaire
Underpaid.
Overworked.
Cheated on.
Pregnant from a one night stand.
And about to lose the only family she ever had.
Life seriously couldn’t get any lower for Izzy. Until her billionaire baby daddy waltzes back into her life to offer her a contract marriage. Coincidence or nah? It wouldn’t matter anyway. Left with no choice at the lowest of lows, Izzy agrees to marry Roshan Armento.
Roshan tries to stay distant from his contract wife but when the threat of his psychopathic step brother looms over their lives and marriage, he has to abandon all restrictions and get closer to her.
However, the one thing they did not expect was to fall in love with each other.
Secrets upon secrets begin to unravel. And why have enemies when you have family? Will their fake marriage survive the blaze? And will their love come out unscathed?
9 Chapters
Choosing Someone Better
During a family gathering, my mother produces a few photos of different men. She asks me which one I want to get into an arranged marriage with.
I don't choose Bradley Garvin again in this lifetime. Instead, I pull out a photo of my own and give it to my mother. It's of Terrence Garvin, the Garvin family's true leader.
My mother is surprised. I've pursued Bradley for many years, after all.
What she doesn't know is that I married him in my past life. However, he rarely came home. I always thought it was because he was too busy. Whenever anyone asked me about it, I took all the blame.
I only discovered the truth on our 20th wedding anniversary after accidentally breaking a box he kept locked in his closet.
It turned out my sister was the one he'd always loved. He never returned home because he didn't want to see me.
Unexpectedly, Bradley loses his mind when I'm about to put a diamond ring on Terrence's finger on our wedding day.
9 Chapters
Related Questions
How Does Plato The Republic Describe The Tripartite Soul?
4 Answers2025-08-29 23:01:04
When I first dug into Plato's 'Republic' as a restless undergrad, what gripped me wasn’t just the big city metaphors but how he slices the inner life into three distinct voices. He calls them roughly reason, spirit, and appetite. Reason (the rational part) is the thinking, calculating part that loves truth and should rule; spirit (thumos) is the part that craves honor and supports reason, especially in resisting shame or fear; appetite (the many desires) chases bodily needs, pleasures, money, and all the messy cravings.
Plato links this to his ideal city so tightly that it clicked for me: rulers = reason, auxiliaries = spirit, producers = appetites. Justice, for him, is harmony — each part doing its proper work under reason’s guidance. He ties virtues to these parts too: wisdom with rulers, courage with spirit, temperance with appetite, and justice when all three fit together. Reading it now I still like picturing the soul as a small city where the rational mayor keeps things from descending into chaos — it’s a tidy moral map that actually helps when my own impulses argue for pizza at 2 a.m.
How To Get To Onyx Dominican Republic From Nearby Cities?
3 Answers2025-10-11 22:05:20
Getting to Onyx in the Dominican Republic is a breeze if you're coming from nearby cities. For example, if you’re starting your journey from Santo Domingo, you have a couple of options at your disposal. The easiest and most common way is to hop on a bus. You can catch one from several terminals in downtown Santo Domingo that head towards Punta Cana, which is relatively close to Onyx. The bus ride typically lasts about two to three hours, depending on traffic, and is a comfortable way to enjoy the scenic views of the countryside.
Alternatively, if you prefer a more personalized experience or are traveling with a group, you could look into renting a car or scheduling a private shuttle service. This allows for flexibility in stopping at small towns along the way and soaking up the local culture. Just make sure to navigate the roads carefully—driving in the Dominican Republic can be an adventure in itself! Keep an eye out for shared van services, known as ‘carros públicos’ as well, which are popular among locals and can be an economical option.
For those steeped in a vacation mindset, catch an early morning flight directly to Punta Cana International Airport, which is only about 30 minutes away from Onyx. With all these options, you’re all set for a fantastic escape to this vibrant destination! I'm always excited to share the journey with friends, imagining the fun adventures we’ll have upon arrival. It's all part of the thrill!
How Does Plato The Republic Book 10 Critique Poetry?
3 Answers2025-07-06 18:42:02
I’ve always been fascinated by how Plato’s 'The Republic' tackles the role of art in society, especially in Book 10. His critique of poetry is brutal but thought-provoking. Plato argues that poetry is a mere imitation of reality, making it twice removed from the truth. He compares poets to painters who create copies of physical objects, which are themselves copies of the ideal Forms. This makes poetry deceptive, as it distracts people from seeking genuine knowledge.
Plato also attacks poetry’s emotional appeal, claiming it stirs up irrational passions that weaken the soul. He fears tragic poetry, for example, encourages audiences to indulge in grief or anger instead of cultivating reason. For him, a just society must prioritize philosophy over poetry because only philosophy leads to true understanding. While I adore poetry’s beauty, I can’t ignore Plato’s point about its potential to mislead. His ideas make me question whether art should serve truth or just entertain.
Who Are The Main Antagonists In 'Starwars The Terran Republic'?
1 Answers2025-06-10 05:45:40
I’ve been obsessed with 'Starwars The Terran Republic' since it dropped, especially its villains—they’re not your typical mustache-twirling bad guys. The antagonists here are layered, almost making you root for them before remembering they’re the ones causing chaos. Take Admiral Kael Voss, for instance. This guy isn’t just a military mastermind; he’s a fallen hero who genuinely believes the Republic’s corruption justifies his brutal crusade. His charisma makes his scenes electric, especially when he debates the protagonist about ‘necessary evil.’ Then there’s the Shadow Cabal, a group of ex-senators and corporate elites pulling strings from behind the scenes. Their power plays—sabotaging economies, framing allies—are terrifying because they feel ripped from real-world politics.
The wildcard is Drek’ath, a rogue Sith disillusioned with both Jedi and Sith doctrines. He doesn’t want power; he wants to burn the entire system down. His unpredictability steals every scene—one minute he’s helping rebels, the next he’s detonating a starport to ‘erase hypocrisy.’ What makes these antagonists work is how their goals clash with each other, not just the heroes. Voss wants control, the Cabal wants profit, Drek’ath wants annihilation—and watching them collide is half the fun. The series even humanizes them with fleeting moments: Voss mourning lost comrades, the Cabal’s youngest member questioning their cruelty. It’s that balance of menace and vulnerability that lifts them above generic villains.
Who Wrote The Republic Book And Is It Still Relevant Today?
3 Answers2025-07-11 16:59:21
I've been diving into philosophy lately, and 'The Republic' by Plato is one of those timeless works that keeps popping up in discussions. Written around 380 BCE, it’s a cornerstone of Western philosophy, exploring justice, governance, and the ideal society. Even today, its ideas about democracy, education, and the 'philosopher king' spark debates. Modern political theorists still reference it when discussing ethics or authoritarianism. The allegory of the cave, for instance, is endlessly relevant in discussions about misinformation and perception. While some concepts feel outdated, like its rigid class system, the core questions it raises about morality and power remain shockingly fresh.
Who Wrote The Republic Book And What Inspired It?
3 Answers2025-07-11 06:30:48
I've always been fascinated by ancient philosophy, and 'The Republic' is one of those timeless works that sticks with you. Plato wrote it, and it’s basically his masterpiece. The guy was a student of Socrates, and you can see how much that influenced him. The whole book is a deep dive into justice, morality, and the ideal society. It’s inspired by the political chaos in Athens back then—Plato saw how messed up things were and imagined a world where philosophers ruled instead of corrupt politicians. The allegory of the cave is my favorite part; it makes you question reality in such a mind-blowing way.
Who Wrote The Republic Book And Where Can I Read It?
3 Answers2025-07-11 12:19:39
I've been digging into philosophy lately, and one of the most talked-about works is 'The Republic' by Plato. It's this ancient Greek masterpiece that dives deep into justice, governance, and the ideal society. You can find it in pretty much any major bookstore or library, but if you're looking for something more accessible, Project Gutenberg has a free digital version. I also recommend checking out local university libraries since they often have annotated editions that make the dense text easier to understand. Personally, I prefer physical copies for stuff like this because flipping back and forth helps me connect the ideas better.
Who Wrote The Republic Book And Is There A Movie Adaptation?
3 Answers2025-07-11 00:24:10
I’ve always been fascinated by ancient philosophy, and 'The Republic' is one of those timeless works that still sparks debates today. The book was written by Plato, the legendary Greek philosopher, around 380 BCE. It’s a deep dive into justice, governance, and the ideal society, with Socrates as the main character—though it’s really Plato’s ideas shining through. As for a movie adaptation, there isn’t a direct Hollywood blockbuster, but you’ll find plenty of documentaries and educational films that break down its themes. Some indie filmmakers have tried capturing its essence, but nothing beats the original text for sheer intellectual thrill. If you’re into philosophy, this is a must-read, though brace yourself for some heavy thinking!
Popular Question
Popular Searches More
The Works Of Geber
Drag Me Down By One Direction
Forgotten
Butt Naked Bear:
Waterford Whispers News 2021
Walkable City: How Downtown Can Save America, One Step At A Time
Encyclopaedia Britannica
The Fireborne Blade
Women Who Love Too Much: When You Keep Wishing And Hoping He'll Change
Marvel Peter In Multiverse Mashup
Mykelti Williamson Movies
Kiss Me More
The Secret Of The Cottingley Fairies: Hidden For 100 Years: The New Evidence
Tatanka-Iyotanka: A Biography Of Sitting Bull
Rental Ebooks
Perfect Bastard
A Rip Through Time
Unwieldy Creatures
Seeking Shelter
Speak
Flowers From The Storm
Gary Stu
Drought Artinya
Conversations With Nostradamus: His Prophecies Explained, Vol. 2
Protest Art
A Cuckold Marriage
Penguin Random House Python Crash Course
A Month Of Roses: Thirty-One Meditations On The Rosary
Reads By The River
Longing For Synonym
Explore and read good novels for free
Free access to a vast number of good novels on GoodNovel app. Download the books you like and read anywhere & anytime.
Read books for free on the app
SCAN CODE TO READ ON APP
