Library

How Did Milton Friedman Respond To Keynesian Economics?

2025-08-31 03:04:37 120

4 Answers

Noah

2025-09-01 04:32:36

I like to imagine Friedman as the scrappy empiricist pushing back on Keynesian confidence in fiscal fine-tuning. He respected Keynes's focus on aggregate demand in downturns but insisted that inflation, money supply, and expectations were the missing pieces. His 1957 ideas on consumption — later called the 'permanent income hypothesis' — argued people smooth consumption over time, so temporary tax cuts or spending spikes might not boost demand as much as Keynesians expected.

Friedman also reframed the Phillips curve debate. Instead of a stable trade-off you could exploit, he said workers and firms would adapt their expectations, so trying to keep unemployment low with excessive inflation only backfires in the long run. That insight pushed central banks to prioritize stable money growth and anti-inflation credibility. I find that tension still alive today when economists argue over stimulus versus monetary policy; Friedman's fingerprints are everywhere, even in modern debates about rules versus discretion.

Holden

2025-09-03 13:36:21

When I first dug into the history of macro debates, Friedman's response to Keynes felt like watching a calm but relentless counterargument unfold. He didn't throw out Keynes's observations entirely — he acknowledged short-run demand effects — but he reframed the mechanism. Friedman put the spotlight on money: the quantity theory, stable velocity assumptions (with caveats), and the idea that changes in the money supply play a decisive role in nominal income and inflation. His empirical work with Anna Schwartz in 'A Monetary History of the United States, 1867–1960' was his hammer, showing correlations between money growth and economic fluctuations that, to him, Keynesian fiscal prescriptions overlooked.

Beyond empirical claims, Friedman attacked the theoretical underpinnings. He introduced the 'permanent income' view of consumption to challenge the Keynesian consumption function, and he developed the natural rate hypothesis: monetary policy can only change unemployment in the short run because people form expectations. That led to his critique of the Phillips curve — inflation and unemployment trade-offs vanish once expectations adjust. Practically, he favored monetary rules (think the k-percent rule) and limited discretionary fiscal activism. Reading his debates gives me chills — it's the kind of intellectual sparring that reshaped policy for decades, and it still colors how I read every central bank statement.

Nolan

2025-09-03 19:42:30

I sometimes tell friends that Friedman was the contrarian who made Keynesianism re-examine its blind spots. He didn't deny recessions or demand slumps, but he argued that ignoring money and expectations leads to bad policy. Two of his moves stuck with me: first, the permanent income idea showing consumption responds more to lifetime income than to temporary fiscal tinkering; second, the expectations-augmented Phillips curve which says any inflation-unemployment trade-off dissolves as people anticipate inflation.

His policy prescription was simple-sounding: steady, predictable monetary growth and skepticism about activist fiscal management. That practical nudge—less discretionary spending sprees and more monetary discipline—still shapes how I read economic commentary, especially when inflation fears rear up.

Yvette

2025-09-06 15:11:32

On a late-night bus ride back from a seminar I once sketched Friedman's critique across the margin of my notebook. He wasn't simply arguing against Keynes with slogans; he built an alternate toolkit. Chronologically, his early methodological pieces set the stage, but by the 1950s and 1960s he had concrete alternatives: the permanent income hypothesis attacked the Keynesian consumption function by modeling forward-looking behavior; his collaboration on 'A Monetary History of the United States, 1867–1960' provided empirical ammunition; and his 1968 presidential address to economists crystallized the policy thrust — emphasize monetary stability and expectational dynamics.

Conceptually, Friedman's key moves were to reassert the quantity theory in modern terms and to introduce expectations into macro relationships. That produced the natural rate idea: policy can affect real variables only temporarily. He also recommended rules like a steady money growth rate to avoid discretionary errors and political cycles of inflationary policy. To me, the most interesting part is how this changed practice: central banks increasingly focus on inflation control and credibility, and debates about fiscal multipliers still echo Friedman's doubts about short-lived stimulus. It's a deep pivot from demand-first thinking to a framework where money, expectations, and microfoundations matter.

View All Answers

Related Books

Adored Stardom: Away from Mr. Hamilton

Wyneth Walford had loved Hayden Hamilton with all her heart for a decade, dedicating three years of her life to caring for him after he was left in a vegetative state by an accident. However, her time and devotion were poured down the drain. Hayden's heart remained stone cold.After their divorce, Wyneth entered the showbiz world, starring in movies alongside charming silver foxes and appearing on variety shows with young hunks. Her doting brothers were prominent figures, including an award-winning actor, a brilliant composer, and a founder of a major brand. Haute couture and jewelry were second nature to her, and even the nation's heartthrob was pursuing her. She had become the most coveted woman in the industry.

9.8

655 Chapters

Her Destined Alpha

Born from darkness, Delsanra Silver grew up knowing nothing but pain and suffering, even her own kind treated her as an outcast. Running from the coven who so madly craves her power, she finds herself accidentally crashing straight into the arms of none other than Rayhan Rossi, the future Alpha of the Black Storm Pack. Never would have expected that her saviour, would come in the form of one of the very races she’s tried so desperately to evade. What will happen when the dangerous young Alpha claims she is his destined mate? Will their love have a chance to blossom… Or will their differences tear them apart. ----- He pushed my hair behind my ear as he moved closer, his warm breath fanning my face. “You're beautiful, Delsanra. I've never seen anyone more ravishing in my life and the best part is you were made for me. You’re mine to claim, and I won't rest until I do.” I couldn't respond, this contact was making my body react weirdly, the urge to yield consuming me. His nose brushed my neck and a small whimper left my lips. All I could think of was his seductive scent, the way his touch felt… “Oh, and one more thing…” His voice was husky and the heat between my legs was growing. I gasped when his hand cupped my knee, only making that ache throb harder. “You smell divine.” ----- Book 3 of The Alpha Series Book 1 – Her Forbidden Alpha Book 2 – Her Cold-Heated Alpha Book 3 – Her Destined Alpha Book 4 – Caged Between The Beta & Alpha

97 Chapters

Dear Ex-Wife, You Are MINE!

After losing her self-respect for three years, Victoria finally let go of the man who never loved her and the family that never accepted her. She had previously sacrificed her true self in the name of love, but now she aims to reclaim it again, not for someone else’s love, but solely for her own. Unexpectedly, the man who had been distant towards Victoria suddenly became passionate with her. Nevertheless, Victoria had already made a firm decision, or so she believed. On the way to her new journey, Victoria faced several challenges that she never expected. Past dug around and hidden truths unravelled along with endless drama and schemes of enemies. Could she put everything together and find her way alone in this journey, or would she get back the love she has waited for three long years? **** “Alessandro...” I called out to him, eager to express the words that were difficult for me to say: I am pregnant! Not a lie anymore but a fucking truth... I want to say it to him. He stopped and looked back. “Now, don’t waste time. Apologise...” In a split second, I was caught off guard by his words, causing me to respond with something unexpected and completely out of character. “Let’s get a divorce,” I did not even let him finish his words… (Book 1: Completed ch1-ch156) ************ Book 2: Greetings, Mr. Husband (Ongoing, started immediately after Book 1)

9.1

184 Chapters

One Night Mistake with Cohen Hamilton

Catherine Santocristo's almost perfect life started to get messy after she had a one-night stand with the future heir of the Hamilton Corporation because he got her pregnant. After a month, Catherine will be in search of him. After days of searching, Catherine found Cohen, but it was too late. On the day she learned it was him, it was also the day of Cohen's lavish wedding to his long-time fiancee, Sandria. Distressed, she walked away and thought about herself. She told about it to her parents. It was not easy for Catherine as they pressured her to get married as soon as possible or else abort the unborn child. She couldn't tell them she became pregnant because of a one-night stand and not because of her boyfriend. In some turn of events, Catherine finds herself marrying her ex-boyfriend to save her family from the humiliation of society. Little did she know it was the starting point of her life in hell. Cohen and Catherine's paths will cross again after five years, which will further complicate their situation.

Not enough ratings

12 Chapters

One Weekend with the Billionaire

“When done properly, this position can be most satisfying for a woman because it allows deep penetration." I open my mouth to respond, but all that comes out is a staggered breath and a small sigh. He chuckles, a low, rough rumble and then leans down and kisses the middle of my back. I feel the tip of him again at my entryway. He pushes in slightly, and my body comes to life again. My muscles react to his presence, contracting and loosening, as if my body is trying to suck him deep inside. He's my husband's boss, so this is supposed to be wrong. So why does it feel so right? *** Braxton Merriweather always gets what he wants. Now, he wants her--Julia Thompson, the wife of one of his workers. From the moment he first laid eyes on her, he knew he had to possess her in every way. When Jeff Thompson takes him up on the bargain he proposes, Braxton is shocked. He's even more surprised when Mrs. Thompson agrees. But now that he's had a taste of her, he wants more. How can he possess a woman who's already married to someone else? Julia feels trapped by her marriage to her high school sweetheart. In the two years since they've been married, he's changed, and not for the better. When billionaire Braxton Merriweather shows interest in her, she's flattered. And intrigued. Is it possible that one of the richest men in the world could really want her? And if so... what does she do about her husband? One Weekend with the Billionaire is a sexy story for mature readers. Previously published on some platforms as the award winning novel The Billionaire CEO's Bargain.

9.6

94 Chapters

Serving the Alpha at His Whim

Jessica-Lyn Kilian has a new Alpha and one would think it's sad that her Alpha is dead. He was her brother. After years of abuse and isolation, she has hope. Only it's dashed by this intimidating man. He tars her with the same brush as her brother. Blaming her for not alerting the authorities of their plight. He demands to take control as his right. Jessie's brother had attacked his pack and died. Alrick Johannsen of the Silver Ridge Pack has just returned from battle to save the Ruling Council(NARC). His pack is under attack by a fool and he dies. Alrick doesn't get the satisfaction of putting his miserable hide down. The law forces him to deal with the ruins of this pack. Victor of Iron Hill Pack has a sister. She claims not to know his illegal activities. Since she didn't inform anyone of those activities. Alrick is holding her responsible. He decides suddenly to punish her. She will serve him until he decides what to do with her. Jessie has three choices. Place herself at the mercy of NARC, accept his punishment, or leave. Leaving is death, her brother's actions saw to that. As a rogue, NARC or Alrick will kill her legally. Alrick told her there was no place for her in his pack or any other. What will she do? How will Alrick respond? Will their bond bloom into a soulbond? Or will the discovery of her brother alive destroy it? After all, Alrick must by law hunt and kill Victor. (This is a standalone novel from the world of A Black River Pack Series. It all starts in His Brother's Mate.)

8.5

109 Chapters

Related Questions

Which Books Did Milton Friedman Write About Capitalism?

4 Answers2025-08-31 13:10:49

I got hooked on Friedman during a long flight when someone across the aisle was reading 'Capitalism and Freedom' and the cover caught my eye. That book is the centerpiece — short, punchy, and full of arguments tying economic freedom to political liberty. It’s where Friedman lays out his case for limited government, school vouchers, and a volunteer military, and it’s the best place to start if you want his big-picture take on capitalism. After that I dove into 'Free to Choose' (written with Rose Friedman), which feels more conversational and was made alongside the TV series of the same name. It expands on the everyday implications of market choices and public policy in accessible language. For readers who like collections, 'There's No Such Thing as a Free Lunch' gathers columns and essays that show Friedman reacting to contemporary issues, often with sharp, memorable lines. If you want deeper, more technical work connected to capitalism’s underpinnings, there's 'A Monetary History of the United States, 1867–1960' (with Anna J. Schwartz) and essay collections like 'The Optimum Quantity of Money and Other Essays'. For a critique of policy inertia look to 'Tyranny of the Status Quo' (also coauthored with Rose). I keep returning to different ones depending on whether I’m looking for philosophy, rhetoric, or historical evidence — each has its own flavor and value.

Has Any Milton Friedman Book Been Adapted Into A Documentary?

4 Answers2025-07-28 00:47:26

As a longtime follower of economic thought and media adaptations, I can confirm that Milton Friedman's influential book 'Capitalism and Freedom' served as the foundation for the documentary series 'Free to Choose,' which he co-created with his wife, Rose Friedman. This multi-part series, first aired in 1980, explores the principles of free-market economics and individual liberty, topics central to Friedman's work. The series was groundbreaking, blending academic rigor with accessible storytelling, making complex economic ideas understandable to a broad audience. 'Free to Choose' not only adapted Friedman's written arguments into a visual format but also expanded on them with real-world examples and debates. The series remains a seminal piece for anyone interested in economics, and its impact is still felt today. Friedman's charismatic presence and clear explanations helped cement his reputation as one of the most effective communicators of free-market ideas. The documentary is a must-watch for fans of his work or anyone curious about the intersection of economics and public policy.

Why Did Milton Friedman Support School Vouchers?

4 Answers2025-08-31 02:37:32

When I first dug into Milton Friedman's ideas, what struck me was how neatly the school voucher proposal fit his broader faith in markets. In 'The Role of Government in Education' and later in 'Capitalism and Freedom' he argued that public schooling, run as a near-monopoly, suffered from dulling bureaucracy and weak incentives. His basic move was simple and elegant: let the public funding follow the student, so parents — not school administrators — would be the consumers choosing where that money goes. That choice, in his view, would create competition between schools, forcing them to be more responsive and innovative. He also believed vouchers could help poorer families access better schools, because market mechanisms don't inherently favor incumbents if designed correctly. Of course, Friedman assumed relatively good information for parents and minimal coercive regulation — assumptions critics later challenged. Still, I find the logic compelling: if you trust parents and want to break up a monopoly, vouchers are a natural policy lever. It’s not a panacea, but it’s a principled attempt to realign incentives toward quality and choice, and that idea keeps nudging public debate in interesting ways.

What Is The Most Controversial Argument In Milton Friedman Books?

4 Answers2025-07-28 03:57:18

Milton Friedman's works are packed with provocative ideas, but the most controversial argument has to be his staunch defense of free-market capitalism in 'Capitalism and Freedom.' He argues that government intervention, even with good intentions, often does more harm than good. This includes social welfare programs, which he believes create dependency rather than empowerment. His views on deregulation, especially in industries like healthcare and education, have sparked heated debates for decades. Another polarizing stance is his support for school vouchers, suggesting parents should choose schools rather than relying on public education. Critics argue this would deepen inequality, while supporters see it as a path to competition and improvement. Friedman's belief that corporations should focus solely on profit ('The Social Responsibility of Business is to Increase Its Profits') also draws ire, as many feel businesses must consider societal impact. His ideas remain lightning rods in economic discourse.

What Did Milton Friedman Propose About Monetary Policy?

4 Answers2025-08-31 01:41:09

I've been chewing on Friedman's ideas for years, partly because I first bumped into them while leafing through 'A Monetary History of the United States' on a rainy commute. He basically flipped the script on the old Keynesian idea that fiscal policy and managing demand could reliably steer unemployment and inflation. What he proposed, in plain terms, was that the central bank should focus on controlling the money supply rather than trying to fine-tune the economy with discretionary moves. His well-known prescription was the k-percent rule: let the money supply grow at a steady, predictable rate roughly equal to real GDP growth, and avoid big, surprise interventions. Friedman also argued that inflation is fundamentally a monetary phenomenon — that is, sustained inflation arises when the money supply expands faster than the economy can absorb. He emphasized long and variable lags in monetary policy, which made activist tinkering dangerous and often destabilizing. Practically, this pushed for central bank rules and transparency, and it underpinned critiques of the Phillips curve trade-off between inflation and unemployment. Reading his work made me think differently about central banking: stability and predictability beat frantic adjustments any day.

When Did Milton Friedman Win The Nobel Prize In Economics?

4 Answers2025-08-31 09:25:24

1976 — that’s when Milton Friedman received the Nobel Memorial Prize in Economic Sciences. I still get a little thrill whenever I look up that citation: it was awarded "for his achievements in the fields of consumption analysis, monetary history and theory, and for his demonstration of the complexity of stabilization policy." That line always feels like a snapshot of an intense career, crammed into a single sentence. I’ve spent lazy afternoons rereading passages from 'Capitalism and Freedom' and skimming 'A Monetary History of the United States, 1867–1960' (his monumental collaboration with Anna Schwartz) while sipping bad coffee. Seeing the prize year next to his name connects the dots between his academic work in the 1950s and 1960s and the political debates of the 1970s. It’s interesting how a date — 1976 — becomes a little anchor for conversations about monetarism, the decline of Keynesian dominance, and the broader cultural shifts toward market-oriented policies. If you’re curious about the why as well as the when, that Nobel citation is a neat doorway: consumption theory, monetary history, and stabilization policy — three lenses through which he reshaped modern macroeconomic thought. I tend to flip to specific chapters that irritate my friends and make them think twice, which is always fun.

Which Policies Did Milton Friedman Recommend For Inflation Control?

4 Answers2025-08-31 06:40:28

I get a little giddy whenever someone brings up inflation because Milton Friedman’s take is so clean and provocative. He boiled it down to a simple principle: inflation is 'always and everywhere a monetary phenomenon.' Practically, that meant he wanted central banks to stop letting the money supply grow too fast. His big prescription was a steady rule for money growth—often called the k-percent rule—where the central bank increases the money supply at a constant, predictable rate tied to the economy’s long-run output growth. Beyond that technical bit, Friedman pushed for central bank discipline: limit discretionary meddling, aim for price stability, and avoid short-term political objectives that let governments run big deficits. He also opposed wage and price controls as false fixes and argued that sometimes you need a tighter monetary policy even if it causes short-term pain like higher unemployment, because letting inflation expectations become entrenched makes things worse later. I think his ideas still spark debate today: some prefer flexible rules like nominal GDP targeting, but Friedman's insistence on predictable money growth and fiscal prudence really reshaped how we think about taming inflation—and it’s why I keep a copy of 'The Monetarist View' in my mental bookshelf whenever someone claims inflation can be solved by one-off controls.

Where Can I Read Milton Friedman Books For Free Online?

4 Answers2025-07-28 16:06:00

As someone who's spent countless hours digging through online libraries and academic resources, I can tell you that finding Milton Friedman's works for free isn't always easy, but it's possible with some patience. Project Gutenberg is a fantastic starting point – they offer a selection of classic economic texts, though Friedman's more modern works might not be there. The Internet Archive is another goldmine; I've stumbled upon some of his lectures and older books like 'Capitalism and Freedom' there. University repositories often host free economic materials, so checking places like the Online Library of Liberty or the Fraser Institute's website could yield results. Google Books sometimes provides substantial previews, enough to get the core ideas. Just remember that while free resources are great, supporting authors and publishers when possible helps keep these works accessible for future readers.

How Did Milton Friedman Respond To Keynesian Economics?

4 Answers

Related Books

Related Questions

Which Books Did Milton Friedman Write About Capitalism?

Has Any Milton Friedman Book Been Adapted Into A Documentary?

Why Did Milton Friedman Support School Vouchers?

What Is The Most Controversial Argument In Milton Friedman Books?

What Did Milton Friedman Propose About Monetary Policy?

When Did Milton Friedman Win The Nobel Prize In Economics?

Which Policies Did Milton Friedman Recommend For Inflation Control?

Where Can I Read Milton Friedman Books For Free Online?

Popular Question

Which Deku X Bakugou Fanfics Explore Their Emotional Bond During Intense Battles?

Who Is The Strongest Character In Invincible

Which Authors Specialize In Detective Mystery Novels?

How Do I Enforce Please Don'T Spoil Me In Group Chats?

Are Headfirst Books Good For Beginners?

Who Are The Main Characters In 'Genshin Impact Transmigrated As Furina'S Second Personality'?

Who Dies In 'Nyxia' And How Does It Impact The Story?

Does 'Epoch Of The Forsaken' Have A Romance Subplot?

Are Laurie King Novels Adapted Into Movies Or TV Series?

How Does Hank Morgan Change Camelot In 'A Connecticut Yankee In King Arthur'S Court'?

Popular Searches More