Who Obliviated Hermione Granger In Fanfiction Scenes?

2026-02-01 23:09:07
128
Share
ABO Personality Quiz
Take a quick quiz to find out whether you‘re Alpha, Beta, or Omega.
Scent
Personality
Ideal Love Pattern
Secret Desire
Your Dark Side
Start Test

4 Answers

Yasmine
Yasmine
Story Finder Student
Late at night, scrolling through fic rec lists, I started cataloguing who gets used as the memory-eraser in different genres. High-tragedy melodramas love Bellatrix or Lucius for theatrical, cruel obliviations—the kind that make readers gasp and clutch their hearts. Political or conspiracy fics often pick Ministry hands or shadowy operatives, which fits a story about cover-ups and hidden agendas. Conversely, angst-heavy domestic AUs or dark!romance pieces sometimes cast a close companion—Harry, Ron, or even a reimagined Dumbledore—to do the erasing out of twisted love or misguided protection; those are the ones that make me squirm because they ask whether protecting someone can ever justify stealing their memories.

There are also clever subversions: Hermione herself choosing oblivion to forget unbearable knowledge, or a character doing a partial wipe that leaves emotional echoes rather than full erasure. Writers use the choice of obliviator to signal theme—villainy, bureaucracy, protection, or self-sacrifice—and I admire the fics that follow up on the ethical weight instead of treating it like a reset button. My favorite scenes are the ones that deal honestly with recovery and the reclaiming of identity.
2026-02-02 10:05:59
9
Kiera
Kiera
Responder Firefighter
I get sucked into threads about this all the time, and honestly the variety is wild. In FanFiction set in the 'Harry Potter' universe, 'obliviating' Hermione pops up as a device used by lots of different characters depending on the mood the writer wants. Villainous types like Bellatrix or Lucius are often chosen when the scene needs cruelty and control; their obliviation scenes are brutal and meant to shock, erasing personal history to assert dominance. On the flip side, Ministry agents—sometimes generic ones, sometimes named figures like Dolores—show up in conspiratorial plots where secrecy is the priority and the bureaucracy does the wiping.

Then there are the emotionally messy choices: Severus shows up a lot in morally gray fics because his Occlumency knowledge and cold methodology make him believable as someone who could perform precise memory charms. Likewise, a protective-suffering trope will have someone close—Harry or Ron in darker or AU stories—take the awful step to wipe parts of Hermione's memory to shield her from trauma or to preserve a secret, and that lands as deeply controversial in fandom discussions. I tend to prefer versions where Hermione regains herself or there's meaningful fallout; it keeps the stakes human rather than just a plot trick.
2026-02-02 22:43:12
4
Oliver
Oliver
Sharp Observer Analyst
On my late-night fic binges I keep noticing two patterns: either the obliviator is clearly a villain (Bellatrix, Death Eater types, or a cold Ministry operative) or it's someone doing something morally grey to ‘protect’ Hermione (a desperate ally or rival). Writers pick the perpetrator to set tone—if they want to shock and villainize, they go with an antagonist; if they want dread and regret, they choose a close character who believes wiping is mercy. There are also comedic or AU takes where someone like gilderoy lockhart is used ironically for memory shenanigans, but canonically his attempts are laughable and he ends up erasing himself.

It’s important to notice fanfic tags: searching for "memory charm", "obliviation", or "amnesia" usually surfaces whether the eraser is malicious or protective. Fans react strongly when it's a beloved character doing the wiping—those fics spark the fiercest debates about consent and characterization. Personally I gravitate to stories that treat memory loss with care and give Hermione agency in the long run.
2026-02-04 03:34:00
1
Julia
Julia
Reviewer Veterinarian
I find that fanfiction rarely pins this down to a single canonical perpetrator—authors pick whoever serves the emotional aim. For pure menace you’ll see Death Eaters or cruel Ministry officials; for secret-protection plots it’s often unnamed Ministry agents or a trusted ally who makes the terrible call. Some writers go for a morally messy route with Severus or a conflicted Harry, using the act to explore guilt and consequences.

What fascinates me most is why writers choose one over the other: the obliviator becomes a tool to define the story’s moral compass. I’m drawn to takes where the harm isn’t swept under the rug and Hermione’s recovery or agency is honored, because that’s the part that feels honest and satisfying to me.
2026-02-06 08:52:00
10
View All Answers
Scan code to download App

Related Books

Related Questions

How does someone get obliviated in Harry Potter canon?

4 Answers2026-02-01 13:15:18
Memory magic in 'Harry Potter' is mainly about the Memory Charm, most famously cast with the word 'Obliviate'. I like to think of it as surgical happy-sad editing: a skilled witch or wizard pinpoints a memory (or cluster of memories), concentrates hard, waves their wand and either erases or alters that slice of a person's past. In canon we see this in action in a few different ways — Hermione deliberately uses it on her parents in 'Deathly Hallows' to give them new identities and send them away, while Gilderoy Lockhart’s backfired spell in 'Chamber of Secrets' shows how horribly wrong it can go when done clumsily. Ministry Obliviators are professionals who perform these charms on Muggles after magical incidents, and they have whole procedures to cover evidence and reconfigure recollection. It isn’t a simple zap; intent and skill matter. You can target specifics, disguise or replace memories, or (if done badly) wipe someone’s whole sense of self. There are also differences between charm types — Legilimency extracts or reads memories, while the Memory Charm modifies or removes them — and the law treats unauthorized alteration severely. I get chills thinking about the ethics behind it every time I reread those scenes, because it’s both wistful and creepy in equal measure.

Which fanfiction explores Draco Malfoy and Hermione Granger kiss scenes?

4 Answers2026-07-16 14:13:26
So you're after Dramione kissing scenes specifically? Those are scattered across the fandom like gems, really depends on the flavor you want. There's the classic 'Isolation' by bex-chan – that slow-burn enemy-to-lovers tension finally breaks in a moment that feels earned and devastating, all pent-up anger turning into something else. 'The Disappearances of Draco Malfoy' by speechwriter builds to a wartime kiss under immense pressure that's more about desperate connection than romance. For something lighter with fantastic banter leading to the inevitable, 'Draco Malfoy and the Mortifying Ordeal of Being in Love' has a particular scene on a balcony that had me grinning like an idiot. Honestly, sometimes I just search the pairing tag on Archive of Our Own and filter by 'kissing' in the additional tags. You'll find a ton of one-shots dedicated to that exact moment – from stolen kisses in broom cupboards to post-war public reconciliations. The mood ranges from sweet to downright steamy.

How does Hermione Granger survive the torture scene?

3 Answers2026-04-24 12:30:39
Hermione's survival during that brutal torture scene in 'Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows' isn't just about luck—it's a testament to her sheer resilience and the way Rowling subtly layers her character. Bellatrix uses the Cruciatus Curse, which inflicts unbearable pain, but Hermione’s mental fortitude shines through. Unlike physical wounds, the curse attacks the mind, and Hermione’s ability to compartmentalize pain, honed from years of rigorous study and crisis management (remember the troll incident in first year?), likely helped her endure. She also isn’t alone; Harry and Ron’s presence, though restrained, gives her something to anchor to. The scene’s aftermath is equally telling—she’s shaken but immediately functional, proving her emotional stamina. It’s one of those moments where the 'brightest witch of her age' title isn’t just about books—it’s about survival. What’s often overlooked is how Rowling uses this moment to contrast Hermione with other victims of the Cruciatus, like Neville’s parents. Hermione’s temporary suffering underscores the horror of long-term damage, making her endurance a narrative device to highlight the curse’s brutality. Plus, her refusal to break under interrogation—even when threatened with death—mirrors real-world resistance tactics. She focuses on protecting Harry’s mission, a priority that might’ve distracted her from the pain. It’s raw, human, and utterly believable for someone who’s faced down Umbridge and a mountain troll before breakfast.

Who performs the torture scene on Hermione Granger?

3 Answers2026-04-24 04:36:21
That scene in 'Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows' where Hermione endures that horrific torture still gives me chills. Bellatrix Lestrange, played by Helena Bonham Carter, is the one who carves 'Mudblood' into Hermione's arm. The way Carter embodies Bellatrix's madness—her gleeful cruelty mixed with aristocratic disdain—makes it one of the most visceral moments in the series. I remember discussing it with friends; some couldn’t even watch the scene, while others argued it was necessary to show the true horror of the Death Eaters. Personally, I think it’s a testament to how far the films were willing to go to depict the stakes of war. What’s interesting is how the book and movie handle it differently. In the book, the torture happens off-page, leaving more to the imagination, but the film forces you to confront it head-on. It’s brutal, but it also highlights Hermione’s resilience. Even in pain, she lies to protect Harry, which says so much about her character. Bellatrix’s obsession with purity and her twisted admiration for Hermione’s defiance make the dynamic even more compelling.

Which fanfics feature a book accurate hermione as protagonist?

5 Answers2025-11-24 14:38:43
I get a little giddy thinking about a Hermione who actually reads, studies, and solves problems the way she does in the books — sensible, driven, and annoyingly lovable. If you want fics where Hermione stays true to the spirit of 'Harry Potter', focus on stories labeled 'canon-compliant', 'book-Hermione', or 'character-preservation'. Those tags are gold because they tell you the author is attempting to keep her motivations, intelligence, and moral compass intact. I usually skim the first few chapters looking for small tells: Hermione using research and library skills before magic tricks, correcting other characters with humility rather than smugness, and making choices that reflect her values (justice, fairness, and a soft spot for the underdog). I also pay attention to POV and voice. A protagonist-written-from-Hermione-POV fic that keeps her insecurity about fitting in, her impatience with sloppiness, and her loyalty to friends is a big win. On sites like Archive of Our Own and FanFiction.net, filter for completeness and reviews; long, well-reviewed fics often have readers calling out when Hermione is OOC. For community recommendations, check subreddit threads and curated bookmarks — readers often debate whether a fic preserves book-canon Hermione, and those debates are where you’ll find trustworthy pointers. Personally, I treasure stories that make Hermione the protagonist without turning her into a flawless superhero; the little compromises and internal debates are what make her feel real to me.

Is Hermione Granger's torture scene in the movies?

3 Answers2026-04-24 03:06:00
Hermione's torture scene in 'Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows' is one of those moments that sticks with you long after the credits roll. The film adaptation captures the raw horror of Bellatrix Lestrange's cruelty, but it's interesting how the tone differs from the book. In the movie, Helena Bonham Carter's performance amplifies the chaotic, almost gleeful malice, while the book lingers more on Hermione's silent suffering and Ron's anguish. The filmmakers made a choice to focus on the visceral impact—the screams, the flickering light of the wand—but I wish they'd included more of Hermione's internal resilience, like her refusal to give up Harry's name despite the pain. That scene also makes me think about how 'Deathly Hallows' handled darker themes overall. The movies had to balance staying true to the books while keeping a PG-13 rating, so some edges were softened. Still, Emma Watson's acting here is phenomenal—you can see the moment Hermione's fear turns into defiance. It’s a shame we didn’t get more of her inner monologue, though. The books let you into her head, and that’s where her strength really shines.

Which fanfiction Hermione pairings are most popular among readers?

3 Answers2026-07-05 16:02:37
Romione's definitely got the numbers, no question there. If you're looking at sheer volume of fics and dedicated archives, Hermione with Ron is still the dominant force, especially in longer, canon-compliant fcs. But I think the more interesting signal lately is the way Dramione has completely taken over the zeitgeist. It dominates the trending tags on AO3, and the quality of the writing in that niche has gotten so sophisticated, with all those dark academia and marriage law tropes. That being said, the pairing that genuinely surprised me with its staying power is Hermione/Snape. It's a much smaller, more insular fandom compared to the big two, but the authors there are absolutely devoted. They're doing these intricate character studies that peel back layers from both of them in a way the main ships sometimes don't bother with.
Explore and read good novels for free
Free access to a vast number of good novels on GoodNovel app. Download the books you like and read anywhere & anytime.
Read books for free on the app
SCAN CODE TO READ ON APP
DMCA.com Protection Status