Library

What Was Rhysand'S Plan For Feyre Under The Mountain?

Finally rereading the Under the Mountain sequence in A Court of Thorns and Roses, and Rhysand's cryptic protection of Feyre still baffles me. Were his earlier cruel acts genuine, or was it all a long-game ruse for Amarantha? I keep second-guessing his motives for that initial bargain.
2026-04-16 23:05:11
196
Share
ABO Personality Quiz
Take a quick quiz to find out whether you‘re Alpha, Beta, or Omega.
Scent
Personality
Ideal Love Pattern
Secret Desire
Your Dark Side
Start Test

9 Answers

Best Answer
Nora Adie
Nora Adie
As an example of a story with a protective male lead who has hidden, complex motives for his actions in order to keep Feyre safe in ‘Under the Mountain’, the first act of ‘The Heart of the Queen: Legacy of The Moonborn’ follows a similar vein. The King of Queensville’s cruel public actions are a carefully constructed facade to protect the Queen and the rest of the land from his true perceptions and in order to hide the fact that the Queen’s latent powers are the only thing that can save them in time. His tough exterior and harsh words hide a tense dance of perception and real intent as he attempts to teach the Queen to master her abilities before it is too late and those who would seek to destroy her get the better of him.
2026-07-30
Ella
Ella
Under the mountain of Velaris, Rhysand worked in the shadows of Amarantha the Mad Queen. The very famous (and feared) bargain he made? A plan of pure genius to intervene in the trials and save Feyre from being completely torn apart. The wine, the paints, the rituals of seemingly cruel play all served one very important end: distract from her weakness and vulnerability. The way he publicly ‘claimed’ her was another way to deter others from causing her harm. He created mental shields to protect her from the intense psychological torment of the tests as well.

What really impresses me is that he never revealed his plan to Feyre while she was still in the book. It was only after she had been freed and was able to deal with the truth of what he had done that he would reveal all. His complexity and the genius of his plan still sends shivers down my spine. It’s like an onion, every layer reveals another complexity, another stroke of sheer genius in his machinations.
2026-04-18
Yvonne
Yvonne
So Rhysand’s plan to save Feyre was a high-stakes bluff. He knew Amarantha would break Feyre, so he made her his problem. All the tattoos, the bargains he’d made, the performative, aggressive dominance that everyone knew to fear from him? It was all a ruse to make people believe he was only interested in saving Feyre because he wanted her. His public, and especially Amarantha’s, perception of him had to be that he was a selfish man, to keep her amused and distracted from more serious pursuits. And then, after the second trial when Feyre had nearly died, he’d proposed the ‘deal’ to heal her, which (obviously) she’d accepted. Later it would become clear that every cruel gesture he’d ever made to Feyre had been a lifeline for her. It’s brilliant, really, and it makes his character arc all the more powerful, because the villain of the story was actually the hero all along.
2026-04-19
Addison
Addison
I love how Rhysand manipulated Feyre under the mountain in order to keep her alive for the trials to break the curse. He made her drink wine, painted her body up, and had her kneel at his side as if she were his slave. But every cruel thing he did to her was to protect her from even worse things that Amarantha could do to her. Not only was he trying to save her life in order to complete the prophecy, but also he recognized her as his mate when no one else did. The tattoos on her face were to mark her as his property so that no one else would touch her. The wine he made her drink was spiked with something to keep her pain at bay during the trials. And the deal they made at the end was for her to spend one week with him every month and that was the only way he would agree to let her leave with Maas.

It’s interesting how we only got to see Rhysand’s mask for so long and how Feyre hated him until later when she finally realized what he had done for her. The way he allowed everyone to believe he was Amarantha’s pet and how he let Feyre hate him too. That was all a part of his plan to keep her safe. I re-read those scenes from A Court of Mist and Fury until I got all the little details and clues right that I had missed the first time around. It was a really good plan of sacrificial deception on the part of Rhysand.
2026-04-21
Educationals Sirec
Educationals Sirec
It’s a classic “be the villain” trope, done so viscerally that it feels new. He wasn’t just pretending to be evil to her, he actually did evil things to her, causing harm. This isn’t a story where the villainous plan of the hero is glossed over and he gets away scot-free. Instead, all of the terrible things he did are laid out before us – Feyre’s nightmares, her fear of being touched, her fragmented mental state after her time in Amarantha’s dungeon. The plan had consequences, for real.

This is what makes it so compelling to discuss and mull over. Instead of a neat, secret plan that the hero carries out, the writer depicted a “dirty” plan with far-reaching, damaging consequences that, in the end, worked. A plan that is both the greatest act of love and the greatest sin of the hero of the story. The narrative recognizes and beautifully conveys this complicated tension.
2026-07-31

Related Books

Related Questions

What happened between Rhysand and Feyre under the mountain?

10 Answers2026-04-16
There is a subtle musical motif present in this scene. Often when he commands music at a party it is a slow and very sensual and often dominating beat. Here the music is a means to an end – a way to humiliate Feiyana. And yet music is emotion, it is rhythm and connection. What Rhys is doing by forcing her to dance to his chosen music is creating a secret and physical connection with her. They move together as one. This is their entire dynamic down in the Under Mountain and it represents their struggle to survive together. Later in Velaris the music is something that brings them joy and celebrates their community together. Under the Mountain music is a means to an end – coercion that in some secret way creates a connection between two people. As with everything, the music has shifted to be something that is now chosen by them rather than forced upon them.

when does feyre go back to rhysand in a court of wings and ruin

10 Answers2025-08-01
This scene is after Tamlin’s huge meltdown in which he locks her in her bedroom. Then there’s a really good Lucien scene in which he helps her escape. The rest of the scene follows her as she travels through the forest, alone and scared, until she finally lets go and reaches for her bond with Rhys. We feel Rhys immediately feel her and he winnows to her. The rest of the scene is their wordless and frantic reunion, and then he takes her home to Velaris where she is greeted by her friends. This is the end of her undercover work, and the beginning of her work to get the rest of her band back together to fight. This takes place in the latter third of the book.

when does rhysand appear in acotar

8 Answers2025-08-01
What really matters about his appearance is the bargain he makes with Feyre. That deal serves as a kind of magical/legal tether to connect Feyre with Rhys throughout the rest of the book. He establishes a means by which he can come to her aid later in the story, when other characters are unable to do so. His appearance on the scene is an active, binding event, rather than simply a notable appearance. By making the bargain with Feyre, he binds his own fate with hers in that moment, which is so much more significant than simply having him show up and then never be seen again.

What powers does Feyre have in 'A Court of Mist and Fury'?

6 Answers2025-06-19
Waiting for someone to post a complete list of the Courts. I always have to look this up, and then I forget which one of the Winter Courts does ice/cold. Well, I remember that mind, water, and fire are three of them. If someone could just post a complete and clear list, I'd appreciate it. (I'm supposed to be working right now, but this is more fun than what I'm doing.)

How does the cold mountain novel end?

12 Answers2025-04-23
It's a "downer" of a story, well and magnificently written to be sure, but a "downer" nonetheless. And it demands a very specific emotional readiness to read. If you're in the mood for something to escape in, this is NOT the book for you. But if you're ready to have your heart torn out in the name of an exceptionally well-written story of human endurance and the relationships we have with others, then this is an ideal read for you. Just make sure you have something exceedingly light and fluffy in your reading queue for afterwards, because you're going to need it.

What is the ending of 'A Court of Mist and Fury'?

11 Answers2025-06-28
The ending of Mor is kinda unnoticed but her using her powers of truth on the High Lords to confirm Feyre’s story is the key to them indirectly helping her. Also her storyline tries to be wrapped up but fails, mainly her trying to reason with her dad and failing. It just really highlights the bad family relationships that Mor has with her dad and Tamlin and Feyre. The ending is set up really well for Mor, Azriel, and Elain, and the rest of the romantic storylines in the world of Feyre. The world is so much bigger than just Feyre’s point of view.

Where was 'Escape to Witch Mountain' filmed?

10 Answers2025-06-19
Movie magic is generally achieved by combining real and fake elements. I think the most realistic answer to this question is a combination of location shooting for immersing the audience in the scenes, using sound stages for scenes that are impossible to shoot on location and for the control that they provide, and then using matte paintings or miniatures for any of the remaining impossible shots. The mountain peak in the pictures may have been a painting. The scenes shot on the spaceship were shot on a set. But the scenes of running through the forest, with fear in the children's eyes, were probably shot in real trees in California, a quiet, damp, and ancient forest, with a crew of several people. That was real. And it was fantastic.

What did Celaena whisper to Chaol in Crown of Midnight?

10 Answers2025-10-17
One of the most powerful scenes in the novel is a quiet moment in a corridor where the most dangerous person in the castle is reduced to a whisper. This humanizes Celaena in a really powerful way, especially given how her actions play out afterwards. We see the cost of her strength to develop her even further as a character in that moment with Chaol. It’s a great lesson in pacing and character development in the midst of a high fantasy plot.

Why was 'Brokeback Mountain' considered controversial?

6 Answers2025-06-16
The soundtrack to this movie is beautiful, as always. I’ve been staring at the wall trying to come up with things to write about and this haunting guitar theme from Gustavo Santaolalla keeps popping up. It’s a beautiful and lonely tune and I wonder if it evokes as much sadness as the rest of the film in order to touch bases with the audience that the dialogue doesn’t. You can’t really argue with feelings and maybe that’s why some people are having such a hard time finding the ‘agenda’ of this film because instead of presenting them with a politicized argument the film presents them with a heartbreak and they don’t know how to stay angry with two fictional people and their failed relationship.

What are the differences between the books in 'A Court of Thorns and Roses'?

1 Answers2025-06-19
I can literally recite chapters from A Court of Thorns and Roses. The series grows SO MUCH from book to book. The first book is this really dark, really atmospheric retelling of Beauty and the Beast set in this fae world, and it’s really focused on Feyre’s survival and her journey and her growth as a person. It’s a really personal story, and the stakes aren’t world-ending at all. It’s really focused on Feyre and her growth as a person, and her learning to look past the human prejudices that she had before. And it’s just a really great story about sacrifice. This is followed by 'A Court of Mist and Fury'. After the initial intimacy of 'A Court of Thorns and Roses' the story explodes into a very fast paced, highly emotional and epic read. Rhysand is no longer just a mysterious figure for Feyre but a deeply complex character, morally ambiguous in places but at the centre of a found family for her. The Night Court, hidden from the rest of the world, is brought to life in full colour with all the dangers and politics that this entails. Feyre learns to deal with her own and others' trauma in this highly intense but extremely positive read. She learns to be autonomous and also deals with the weight of her newfound power. The story of the various High Lords and how they use their magic is also brought to life in great detail. Now in full-on war mode, ‘A Court of Wings and Ruin’ was a totally different read from the intimacy of the first books. First of all, it was a massive novel. While all of Maas’ novels are long, ACOWAR had to be the longest, covering so many characters, storylines and realms. But the intimacy that we first saw with Feyre and Tamlin was still there, however it had to be woven into the larger story of the war and the ways in which Feyre and her friends managed to fight Hybern. It also focused on all of the different alliances between the different courts, as well as introducing new, very old and powerful magical objects. Some of the most interesting and dark plot points dealt with the brutality of Hybern and how it affected all of the characters in the novel. There is also quite a bit of Feyre’s growth from a hunter to strategist in this novel as well. The supporting cast was also very fully developed. We saw a lot more of Cassian, and his extreme loyalty to both Feyre and Azriel. We found out more about Mor, and his secrets. We even saw Lucien’s storyline take a drastic turn as he tries to work out his allegiances. ‘A Court of Frost and Starlight’ and ‘A Court of Silver Flames’ are also very different reads to the rest of the series. Instead of continuing to follow Feyre on her journey, these novels explore the aftermath of the war and the personal struggles of each of the characters. Feyre is not the focus of these novels. Nesta’s journey to recovery from her physical and emotional trauma is raw and unflinching, often bordering on the uncomfortably grittier side of things. The training of the Valkyries, the House of Wind and their sentient magic, and the struggles that the main characters face with addiction in ‘A Court of Silver Flames’ make it feel like a completely new spin-off series rather than continuing the ACOTAR novels. It’s clear that Maas has no intention of allowing her characters or the world that she has created to stagnate. Each novel is a complete reinvention, and a fresh read every time.
Explore and read good novels for free
Free access to a vast number of good novels on GoodNovel app. Download the books you like and read anywhere & anytime.
Read books for free on the app
SCAN CODE TO READ ON APP
DMCA.com Protection Status