What Was Rhysand'S Plan For Feyre Under The Mountain?

Finally rereading the Under the Mountain sequence in A Court of Thorns and Roses, and Rhysand's cryptic protection of Feyre still baffles me. Were his earlier cruel acts genuine, or was it all a long-game ruse for Amarantha? I keep second-guessing his motives for that initial bargain.
2026-04-16 23:05:11
196
Share
ABO Personality Quiz
Take a quick quiz to find out whether you‘re Alpha, Beta, or Omega.
Scent
Personality
Ideal Love Pattern
Secret Desire
Your Dark Side
Start Test

8 Answers

Best Answer
DrewWood
DrewWood
Story Interpreter Receptionist
In the 'Under the Mountain' scenario, Rhysand's plan was largely a performance to protect Feyre. He made their bargain publicly cruel to hide his true allegiance, positioned himself as her tormentor to keep other High Lords from seeing her as his weakness, and used his forced proximity to secretly teach her to use her powers and shield her mind. For a story that also digs into a protective male lead with hidden, complex motives, you might check out 'The Heart of the Queen: Legacy of The Moonborn'. It features a king whose ruthless public actions are a carefully constructed front, all to safeguard a queen whose own latent power is the real key to their survival, creating a tense dance of perception and real intent.
2026-07-30 17:16:35
27
Ella
Ella
Novel Fan Student
Under the mountain, Rhysand’s actions were a twisted kind of kindness. He couldn’t openly defy Amarantha, so he worked the shadows. The infamous bargain? Genius. It gave him a reason to intervene when Feyre was being torn apart by the trials. The wine, the paints, the performative cruelty—all distractions to draw attention away from her vulnerability. Even the way he’d ‘claim’ her in public was a deterrent; no one would risk his wrath by harming her further. And let’s not forget the mental shields he secretly built for her, easing the psychological torment.

But the real kicker? He never explained any of it. Not until she was free and could handle the truth. That’s what makes his character so compelling—he was willing to be the villain in her story if it meant she’d survive to rewrite it later. The complexity of his plan still gives me chills; it’s like peeling an onion where every layer reveals another calculated move.
2026-04-18 01:32:53
4
Yvonne
Yvonne
Frequent Answerer Firefighter
Rhysand’s plan was essentially a high-stakes bluff. He knew Amarantha would break Feyre, so he preemptively made her his problem. The tattoos, the bargains, the performative dominance—all to make others think he had a petty interest in her, not a protective one. Even the way he’d mock her in public was a smokescreen; it kept Amarantha amused and off her back. And when Feyre was near death after the second trial? He swooped in with that ‘deal’ to heal her, masking his real motive: keeping her alive long enough to break the curse. The brilliance was in how he made everyone, including Feyre, believe he was selfish. Only later do you see the truth—every cruel gesture was a lifeline. That’s why his character arc hits so hard; the villain was the hero all along.
2026-04-19 02:57:21
2
Addison
Addison
Bookworm Translator
Rhysand’s plan for Feyre under the mountain was this intricate dance of survival and manipulation, but with a hidden layer of protection. At first glance, he seemed like the villain—forcing her to drink wine, painting her body, making her kneel beside him. But every cruel act was a calculated move to shield her from Amarantha’s worse whims. He needed her alive, not just for the curse-breaking prophecy, but because he’d secretly recognized her as his mate. The tattoos? A way to mark her as his property, so others wouldn’t touch her. The wine? Spiked with something to dull her pain during the trials. Even the bargain they struck—a week with him each month—was a loophole to train her in secret. The man played the long game, and it kills me how brilliantly vicious it was.

What gets me is how Feyre only saw the mask until later. The way he’d let her hate him, let everyone think he was Amarantha’s pet, just to keep her safe. And when she finally realized? That moment in 'A Court of Mist and Fury' where she pieces it all together—ugh, my heart. Rhysand’s entire plan was a masterclass in sacrificial deception, and I still reread those scenes just to spot the little clues I missed the first time.
2026-04-21 00:49:06
4
AdamPrice
AdamPrice
Active Reader HR Specialist
It's a classic 'be the villain' trope, but executed with such visceral detail that it feels new. He didn't just pretend to be bad; he was bad to her. He caused real, lasting harm. The trope often glosses over the trauma, but this story doesn't. Feyre's nightmares, her fear of touch, her fragmented mental state after—it's all shown. The plan had real consequences.

That's what makes it compelling and讨论-worthy. It's not a clean, heroic secret mission. It's a dirty, morally grey, damaging series of actions that happened to achieve the desired outcome. The story doesn't let him off the hook just because his heart was in the right place. The plan is both his greatest act of love and his greatest sin, and the narrative holds that tension beautifully.
2026-07-31 06:17:40
10
View All Answers
Scan code to download App

Related Books

Related Questions

What happened between Rhysand and Feyre under the mountain?

10 Answers2026-04-16 22:53:54
Rhysand and Feyre's dynamic under the mountain in 'A Court of Thorns and Roses' is one of those complex, morally grey relationships that keeps you hooked. At first, Rhys seems like just another cruel High Lord playing games—forcing Feyre to drink wine, painting her body like a living canvas, all while she’s trapped in Amarantha’s nightmare. But then the layers peel back. The way he secretly helps her, slipping her clues during the trials, shielding her mind from Amarantha’s invasions… it’s this twisted dance of survival where cruelty masks something far deeper. What gets me is how Sarah J. Maas writes their tension. Every interaction crackles with unspoken trust and betrayal. When Rhys kneels before Feyre during the final trial, offering her a way out even as he plays the villain, it’s this gut-punch moment. You realize he’s been sacrificing his own reputation to keep her alive. The tattoos, the bargains—they’re all part of this desperate strategy to outmaneuver Amarantha. It’s not romance at that point; it’s two people carving light out of sheer darkness, and that’s why it sticks with me long after the last page.

what did rhysand do to feyre under the mountain

6 Answers2025-08-01 18:12:45
Rhysand's actions under the mountain were a mix of cruelty and calculated protection. He forced Feyre into a bargain that bound her to him, marking her arm with his tattoo. This act seemed harsh, but it was a way to shield her from Amarantha's wrath. He also made her drink wine to dull her senses during the trials, which appeared degrading but was actually to prevent her from breaking under the pressure. His public displays of possession, like making her sit on his lap, were all part of the act to convince Amarantha he was loyal while secretly undermining her. Every cruel gesture had a hidden layer of protection, showing Rhysand's complex motives.

Why did Rhysand help Feyre under the mountain?

3 Answers2026-04-16 09:34:52
Rhysand's actions under the mountain were way more complex than they seemed at first glance. At the beginning of 'A Court of Thorns and Roses', he comes off as this morally grey, almost villainous character, but his help towards Feyre was layered with personal motives and hidden kindness. He saw her suffering and recognized her strength—something he valued deeply. There’s also the bond between them, which he was aware of long before she was. He couldn’t stand by and watch her break, even if he had to maintain his cruel facade for Amarantha’s sake. Beyond that, Rhysand has always been a strategist. Helping Feyre wasn’t just about compassion; it was about playing the long game. He needed someone who could challenge Amarantha, and Feyre was that person. His subtle acts of protection—like offering her that bargain—weren’t just about saving her in the moment. They were about securing a future where Prythian could be free. His sarcastic, indifferent mask hid a leader who cared deeply for his people and, eventually, for her.

How did Rhysand and Feyre meet under the mountain?

3 Answers2026-04-16 20:58:50
The first encounter between Rhysand and Feyre under the mountain in 'A Court of Thorns and Roses' was anything but ordinary. Feyre, a human dragged into the faerie realm, was struggling to survive the brutal trials set by Amarantha. Rhysand, the High Lord of the Night Court, appeared as this enigmatic, almost untouchable figure—charismatic yet dangerous. He intervened during her second trial, saving her from certain death, but not out of pure altruism. There was always this tension between them, a mix of curiosity and unspoken games. His motives seemed unclear at first—was he toying with her, or did he see something in her worth protecting? Their interactions were layered with power plays, but beneath it all, there was this undeniable pull. What fascinated me was how Sarah J. Maas crafted their dynamic. Rhysand’s actions were deliberately ambiguous—offering help but with conditions, like the infamous bargain they struck. He painted himself as a villain to others, yet Feyre slowly glimpsed cracks in that facade. The way he shielded her from the worst of Amarantha’s cruelty, even while maintaining his cold exterior, hinted at a deeper connection. It wasn’t love at first sight; it was more like two people recognizing each other’s strength in a place designed to break them. That complexity made their relationship one of the most compelling parts of the series.

Did Rhysand betray Feyre under the mountain?

3 Answers2026-04-16 08:35:57
Reading 'A Court of Thorns and Roses' for the first time, I was totally conflicted about Rhysand's actions Under the Mountain. On one hand, he played the villain so convincingly—forcing Feyre to drink that wine, making her dance, all while wearing that infuriating smirk. But then there were those tiny moments where his mask slipped, like when he subtly helped her during the trials or shielded her from Amarantha’s worst whims. It felt like watching a chess game where every move had three hidden layers. Now, after finishing the series, I see it differently. Betrayal implies malice, and Rhys was never malicious—just trapped in an impossible position. His ‘cruelty’ was performative survival, a way to keep Feyre alive while convincing Amarantha he was loyal. The real brilliance of his character is how Sarah J. Maas makes you question everything once you learn his perspective. That duality still gives me chills—it’s why I’ve reread those scenes a dozen times, noticing new nuances each pass.

How did Rhysand protect Feyre under the mountain?

3 Answers2026-04-16 20:51:46
Rhysand's protection of Feyre under the mountain was a masterclass in subtle defiance. At first glance, he played the role of Amarantha's cruel consort, but every action he took was calculated to shield Feyre. He pretended to torment her by forcing her to drink wine and wear revealing clothes, but this was actually a way to keep others from harming her—marking her as 'his' in a court where ownership meant survival. The wine, laced with his own power, dulled her pain and hid her thoughts from Amarantha. Even his taunts were a distraction, drawing attention away from her vulnerabilities. Behind the scenes, he manipulated events to give Feyre chances to succeed in her trials. He whispered hints, like the riddle about the worm, and later intervened physically when Amarantha tried to break her. His most daring move was glamouring Feyre’s injuries after the second trial, making her appear unharmed so Amarantha wouldn’t suspect her resilience. It was a dangerous game—one wrong move could’ve doomed them both—but his cleverness and quiet defiance kept Feyre alive long enough for her to shatter the curse.
Explore and read good novels for free
Free access to a vast number of good novels on GoodNovel app. Download the books you like and read anywhere & anytime.
Read books for free on the app
SCAN CODE TO READ ON APP
DMCA.com Protection Status