Did Sirius Acknowledge Regulus Black Harry Potter Before The War?

2025-08-28 00:34:14 286

3 回答

Yosef
Yosef
2025-08-30 12:07:12
Honestly, if you ask whether Sirius knew Regulus existed and who he was before the war, the short reality is: absolutely. They were brothers — part of the same Black family tapestry that Sirius eventually tore off the wall — so Sirius was well aware of Regulus as a person and a choice-maker long before anything with Voldemort ramped up.

Reading 'Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix' and later 'Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows' made the family tensions really clear to me. Sirius and Regulus had opposite reactions to their upbringing: Sirius cut himself off and fled the family’s pure-blood fanaticism, while Regulus leaned in, joined the Death Eaters, and became someone Sirius was openly contemptuous of. That contempt is obvious in how little Sirius spoke of him and how bitter he sounded about the family’s values. Crucially, though, Sirius never learned Regulus’s secret redemption — that Regulus tried to undo Voldemort by targeting the locket Horcrux — because that detail only comes out through Kreacher much later. Sirius died believing Regulus was a turncoat toward darkness, not the complicated, regretful figure we learn about afterward, and that tragic ignorance colors a lot of how I feel about both of them.
Nora
Nora
2025-08-31 18:03:12
When I first dug into the timeline of the Black family during a late-night reread, the dynamics between the brothers jumped out. Sirius wasn’t shy about recognizing Regulus as his sibling before and during the early stages of the war: they grew up in the same house, went to the same family gatherings, and were both on the Black tapestry. Sirius’s acknowledgment, though, was laced with derision — he viewed Regulus’s decisions (joining Voldemort’s followers) as choices that showed poor judgment and an acceptance of the family’s cruel values.

If you’re thinking in terms of concrete knowledge, Sirius knew Regulus had become a Death Eater, but he did not know about Regulus’s late change of heart or his attempt to sabotage Voldemort by targeting the locket. That bit only becomes clear in 'Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows' through Kreacher’s testimony. So yes, Sirius acknowledged Regulus as a person and as a member of the Death Eaters, but he never acknowledged — because he didn’t know — Regulus’s private act of conscience that would later reframe Regulus’s story for us readers.
Isaac
Isaac
2025-08-31 22:16:40
I used to be annoyed by how little the movies touched on Regulus, because the books make his relationship with Sirius quietly painful. To your question: Sirius definitely knew and acknowledged Regulus before and during the earlier part of the war — they were family, after all — but his acknowledgment was mostly scornful. He saw Regulus as someone who stayed in the family fold and bought into its twisted beliefs.

What makes the whole thing heartbreaking is that Sirius never learned the full story. Regulus’s attempt to turn against Voldemort and retrieve the locket is revealed only later via Kreacher in 'Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows', after Sirius has already died. So Sirius acknowledged Regulus only in the narrow, resentful way he viewed the Black household and its choices; he never got to reconcile or recognize Regulus’s final, redeeming action, which feels like one of those small, tragic threads J.K. Rowling weaves through the saga.
すべての回答を見る
コードをスキャンしてアプリをダウンロード

関連書籍

Sirius
Sirius
The world is in the middle of catastrophe for ten years, a Sewer in the Village of Mecchichuzan was the only refuge of the remaining humans to protect themselves against the Psychopaths who are roaming around. There are chosen people who were blessed to be born with the talent of learning Magic, which they use for resistance and for the expansion of their territory. Their magic consists of Weapon creation, enhancements, producing ailments and many more. The story revolves to a 22-year-old Teenager named "Jin Rudina", who has no talent in casting magic but will do his best to achieve a world where freedom exists. But why does the Psychopaths are powerful than the human magic casters?
10
5 チャプター
Black Wings
Black Wings
On his birthday, Ravi Lazy Arsenio asked for an original plea while blowing out candles on a birthday cake to bring down an angel in his life. When Ravi headed to his room the same day he was startled by a strange man being in his room wearing only leather trousers. The man named Raymond said that his life belonged to Ravi whose purpose of his arrival was to take care of Ravi as well as help him in all of Ravi's lazy daily life, evidenced by a large tattoo bearing Ravi's name on his chest. Ravi wants to report it to the police but undoes his intentions when he finds out there's a big secret they have to cover up about Raymond that comes out of nowhere. Plus Raymond's behavior like children under five years old who cry easily, there is something that surprises Ravi is that he has big wings, black and soft, coming out of his back. Not only that, Raymond always shoots scents that almost make Ravi lose control of himself. Raymond's arrival also makes Ravi's life more complicated than before which leads him into a big problem that Ravi never imagined. Who exactly is Raymond? What is the real purpose? What dark past did Raymond and his family try to hide from Ravi all along?
評価が足りません
50 チャプター
Acknowledge fear is an illusion
Acknowledge fear is an illusion
The story follows a group of six terrified passengers trapped on a speeding train driven by a greedy Shinigami who make an offer in exchange for their lives. He gave us six different rings that represent their irrational fears as they faced their painful confrontation of the past. If they can succeed to overcome it, the Shinigami will set them free but if their fears swallow them up he will collect each of the souls and deliver it to hell. The passengers are headed by Senior Team Captain of Men’s Volleyball; William followed by a geek guy named Travis, Stefanie a fragile genius student, newly-hired fashion stylist Belinda, Brendan a college professor, and Paris an ambitious and perfectionist Architect. Without any choice, they are forced to make a deal with the Shinigami and wore those rings for the rest of their journey. Driven by monstrous intention, the Shinigami took advantage of their fears to control each one of them to fight their own battle as they experienced hallucinations through going back to their memories. Each memory and close encounter gave them a near-death experience that cost much of their lives. As their journey twisted in different events, it gave them a shocking revelation of finding oneself and turning back to God to repent for their sins.
評価が足りません
12 チャプター
I Left My Heart On Sirius
I Left My Heart On Sirius
When Evie Crichton comes to Sirius she has no idea how the placement on the planet will change her life. On her first assignment in her new base she meets Ethan Nacher, the chief of a military team stationed near the base. From the very first moment dark handsome Sirian is a mystery that keeps her awake at night. But his behavior is just confusing-one minute it seems he wants to keep his distance and the next he is everywhere she goes. For Ethan Evie Crichton is like an unattainable dream. He loses his head for her the first minute he sees her. But he is just a Sirian soldier put in charge of protecting the Earthian base and he is convinced a beautiful Earthian girl would not ever care to look at him. Unexpected attack on the base forces Ethan to make on the spot decision. He saves Evie from the bombarded base and takes her on a journey through the jungle to his home city. He promises that when they get there he'll help Evie contact another base and return to her people. But will she want to return? On the journey despite her better judgement Evie falls for the handsome soldier more and more every day. However Ethan seems to treat her just as a burden for his team. Was the chemistry that seemed to have been building between them before just in Evie's head? As they face dangers on their way they will both have to face their feelings as well and decide whether they are stronger than reason.
10
11 チャプター
Black Luna
Black Luna
Pain was all she knew. And if happiness was what she was seeking, she has to uncover her hidden past and her dark secrets to achieve her goal. Will she succeed?
5.1
31 チャプター
Black Card
Black Card
Steal the CEO's Black Card or his cold heart? "Please... Please sir I'm begging you, I didn't steal the card. Please believe me" Belle hopelessly begged, tears welling her already messy face. "You deserve to be in prison...fraud!" the store manager exclaimed in pure disdain, glaring as he snickered. Belle was an orphan from a young age, struggling for her dream. A dream of becoming a great doctor. A dream she weaved together with her late parents. For several years, a tiny room in a dilapidated building served her humble home, living at the mercy of others. Most of the time she has empty pockets and an empty stomach. She endured the ridicule from wearing worn-out clothes and torn shoes for medical school. Life is a struggle for her but never did she think of stealing, especially the BLACK CARD of the famous and cold CEO, Ethan DelValle.
9.8
93 チャプター

関連質問

How Does Regulus Black Harry Potter Die In The Books?

3 回答2025-08-28 01:47:22
Oddly, one of the bits of 'Harry Potter' lore that still gives me chills is how quietly tragic Regulus Arcturus Black's end is. He shows up in the story as R.A.B. — a mysterious figure who stole the locket Horcrux — and we only fully learn his fate piecemeal across 'Half-Blood Prince' and 'Deathly Hallows'. He'd been a Death Eater but had a crisis of conscience after realizing what Voldemort had become; he conspired with his house-elf Kreacher to swap the real locket with a fake and smuggle the real one out of the cave where Voldemort hid it. What actually kills him is the protection around the Horcrux. There’s a potion in the basin guarding the locket that makes anyone who drinks it violently ill and mentally tormented, and Inferi — the reanimated corpses — patrol the lake. Regulus had Kreacher row him to the island, had Kreacher dive to fetch the locket, then ordered Kreacher to take the locket back to the house and destroy it because Regulus himself had become too weak after drinking the potion. He scrawled R.A.B. as his sign and told Kreacher to run home. Kreacher escaped with the locket and returned without him. So in the books it’s clear he dies in that cave: the potion left him incapacitated and the Inferi (or the lake itself) finished the job. It’s a small, quiet kind of heroism — not in battle with fanfare, but a private, desperate act of redemption that only shows up later as a crucial piece of the puzzle. Sometimes I think about how that moment reframes the Black family tragedy, and how a single act by Regulus ripples through the whole series.

What Motivated Regulus Black Harry Potter To Defy Voldemort?

3 回答2025-08-28 11:26:10
Late one rainy evening I reread the scene in 'Harry Potter' where Kreacher tells Harry about Regulus, and something about that small, tragic rebellion stuck with me. Regulus wasn't a heroic leader charging into battle; he was a young man who woke up to how monstrous Voldemort really was. From what we get in the books, he joined the Death Eaters partly out of family pressure and elitist loyalties, but then discovered that Voldemort’s cruelty had no boundaries — including making Horcruxes and ordering vile tasks of those he considered beneath him. That discovery seems to have cracked something in Regulus's conscience. What really sells it for me is the role of Kreacher. The fact that Regulus trusted a house-elf enough to involve him, and then tried to instruct Kreacher to destroy the Horcrux, feels like genuine remorse mixed with urgency. He didn't try to topple Voldemort in public; he schemed in secret and paid with his life. To me, that suggests his motive was more personal integrity than ambition — a desire to undo a wicked part of what he'd enabled. It's a quiet, desperate atonement, and when I picture Regulus writing those instructions for Kreacher, it stays with me as an act of private bravery rather than a dramatic, glory-seeking move.

Are There Deleted Chapters About Regulus Black Harry Potter In Canon?

3 回答2025-08-28 23:55:38
This is one of those tiny fandom mysteries that I end up chewing on during late-night rereads. Short take: there aren’t any officially published deleted chapters from the seven main 'Harry Potter' books that focus solely on Regulus Black as a standalone scene. What we get in the canon is mostly woven into existing chapters — the biggest reveal about Regulus and the locket comes through Kreacher’s memories in 'Deathly Hallows' (the chapter often called 'Kreacher’s Tale'), and that’s the canonical moment where his sacrifice is fully explained. That said, J.K. Rowling expanded Regulus’s background outside the novels. She wrote extra pieces on the website that used to be Pottermore (now WizardingWorld), giving short biographies and bits of context about side characters like Regulus Arcturus Black. Many fans treat those posts and Rowling’s subsequent interviews and tweets as part of the wider canon, since they’re the author’s own supplemental notes. So if you’re chasing more Regulus content, check out those Pottermore/WizardingWorld entries and a few of Rowling’s Q&A remarks — they flesh him out more than the book text alone. Finally, be aware of fanfiction and rumor: there are plenty of imagined deleted chapters floating around forums and AO3 where writers create entire scenes of Regulus sneaking into Grimmauld Place or writing the famous note. Those are fun, but they’re not official. If you want the official feel, read Kreacher’s memories in 'Deathly Hallows' and the Pottermore piece; they’re short but they hit hard, emotionally.

What Items Link To Regulus Black Harry Potter In Fan Theories?

3 回答2025-08-28 16:21:01
Man, Regulus is one of those characters who makes me want to dig through every dusty prop in the 'Harry Potter' universe. For me, the big items that fan theories orbit are the locket itself (the Horcrux), the note signed R.A.B., Kreacher as a living heirloom, 12 Grimmauld Place, and the Black family tapestry. Canon gives us the locket-and-note combo: Regulus pulled the Horcrux out of Voldemort’s cave, swapped it for a fake, and left a letter. Fans have run with that—some say the note was more than a signature, that it contained hidden cipher clues pointing to where he stashed other items or the method he used. I used to re-read the cave scene and think about smells and coppery potion residue; it’s easy to imagine he carried a tiny tool kit or a protective amulet when he went. Kreacher is treated like an object in a lot of theories—people trace memories and house-elf obedience as a kind of living evidence chain. Fans imagine hidden compartments inside family heirlooms at 12 Grimmauld Place where Regulus might have concealed other things: a signet ring, a locket box, or even a potion vial from the cave. The tapestry is another favorite; some theorists claim the way the genealogy is stitched could hide coordinates or altered names (like an embroidered clue to R.A.B.’s real motives). Then there are the wilder ones: that Regulus might have had interaction with other artifacts—maybe he saw traces of the ring in some memory or briefly handled something later identified as a Horcrux. I like these theories because they treat objects as storytelling breadcrumbs. When I picture tracing Regulus’s steps, I think of unpolished brass, ink-stained notes, and a house-elf holding onto secrets—and that mood is what keeps me poking through fan maps and headcanons late into the night.

What Is Regulus Black Harry Potter'S Full Backstory In Canon?

3 回答2025-08-28 23:20:53
I fell down a Regulus spiral the first time I read about him in 'Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows'—there's something quietly heroic and tragic about his whole arc. Regulus Arcturus Black was the younger brother in the Black family, born into that old, proud pure-blood tradition that valued blood status above everything. He went to Hogwarts and was sorted into Slytherin, and at some point in his youth he joined the Death Eaters, convinced by family loyalty and the heady power of belonging to Voldemort's inner circle. The turning point, canonically, is when Regulus discovered that Voldemort had made a Horcrux out of Slytherin's locket. Horrified at what Voldemort had become and how he was being used, Regulus used Kreacher—the house-elf he treated badly and later showed a surprising streak of compassion toward—to help him stealthily retrieve the locket from the cave where Voldemort hid it. He forced Kreacher to help him because Kreacher could obey orders Voldemort's protections would ignore. Regulus drank the basin potion that protected the Horcrux and was weakened; he ordered Kreacher to take the locket back to their family home. Before Kreacher fled, Regulus managed to swap the real locket with a fake and scrawled the initials 'R.A.B.' in it, intending for someone to know what he had done. Sadly, Regulus never made it out alive. The cave was defended by Inferi, and when Regulus commanded Kreacher to go, he was left behind and died there, probably pulled under by the Inferi. His bravery only came to light years later through Kreacher's memories and the discoveries in 'Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince' and 'Deathly Hallows', which set Harry and co. on the path to finding the Horcruxes. To me, Regulus is one of the quietest redemption stories in the series: he started on the wrong side, but when it mattered he acted—and paid the ultimate price. It always leaves me a little bittersweet when I think about him in Grimmauld Place, and how small acts of conscience can ripple into something huge.

Where Is Regulus Black Harry Potter'S Grave Located Canonically?

3 回答2025-08-28 18:52:22
I've sat up late re-reading bits of 'Harry Potter' more times than I can count, and one thing that always nags me is how many small, important details J.K. Rowling leaves unexplained — Regulus's burial is one of those. Canonically, there is no explicit statement in the novels or in Rowling's extra writings about where Regulus Arcturus Black was buried. The books tell us the crucial parts: he joined the Death Eaters, turned against Voldemort, and died trying to destroy the Horcrux in the cave. Kreacher relates the story of Regulus's orders and his death in 'Deathly Hallows', but there’s no line that pins down a gravesite or a marked headstone. Because the canon is silent, fans naturally fill the gaps. Common theories place him in the Black family vault or a family plot somewhere near 12 Grimmauld Place or the ancestral Black estate — that feels right thematically, since the family prized lineage and tombs — but those are extrapolations, not sourced facts. Others speculate he might have been quietly buried without honor because he betrayed the family’s Death Eater ideals, or even cremated with minimal notice. Personally, I imagine a small, private grave on the old Black lands, maybe unmarked, because that fits the melancholy of his story: brave, guilty, and erased a little by family politics. If you're chasing a canonical citation, though, the honest truth is there isn't one; the books simply don't say, and Rowling hasn't supplied a follow-up detail that pins it down for us.

What Happened To Regulus Black

4 回答2025-01-08 09:46:27
Regulus Arcturus Black, a character from J.K. Rowling's Harry Potter series, met a tragic fate. Raised in a pure-blood family, he joined Voldemort's Death Eaters when he was fairly young. But with time, he saw the true nature of Voldemort and decided to betray him, a dangerous act. Regulus planned meticulously to destroy one of Voldemort’s Horcruxes, a locket held by an Inferius-guarded cave. He enlisted his house-elf Kreacher to help. He drank a cursed potion protecting the locket, replaced it with a false one, and ordered Kreacher to leave him behind. The Inferi dragged Regulus into the lake, where he met his end. It shows his bravery and intelligence, choosing to die for the cause he believed in.

When Did Regulus Black Die

5 回答2025-02-01 20:53:44
As an avid 'Harry Potter' enthusiast, I can tell you that Regulus Arcturus Black, the unsung hero, met his tragic end in 1979. Ironically, a house-elf was the only witness to his death, which occurred at the hands of Inferi in a cave while attempting to retrieve a piece of Voldemort's soul in a locket.
無料で面白い小説を探して読んでみましょう
GoodNovel アプリで人気小説に無料で!お好きな本をダウンロードして、いつでもどこでも読みましょう!
アプリで無料で本を読む
コードをスキャンしてアプリで読む
DMCA.com Protection Status