Why Is Sirius Black Innocent In 'Harry Potter And The Prisoner Of Azkaban'?
I just reread the twist—my friends still think he betrayed the Potters. How did we all miss Pettigrew's reveal the first time? The evidence is so obvious now.
2025-06-20 18:21:27
704
Follow63
Share
Vincy Mathews
ABO Personality Quiz
Take a quick quiz to find out whether you‘re Alpha, Beta, or Omega.
Scent
Personality
Ideal Love Pattern
Secret Desire
Your Dark Side
Start Test
13 Answers
Best Answer
Marco Antonio Melgarejo Payano
There’s been a lot of confusion as to whether Sirius was the Potters’ Secret-Keeper or not. He wasn’t – it was his friend Peter Pettigrew. He betrayed the Potters to Voldemort, then faked his own death and framed Sirius for the murder. You get to learn all about the Marauders in this story, which is really fun. Misunderstood people on the run is always a good story. This one is sort of like ‘His Innocent Sera’. A woman wrongfully accused of a heinous crime has to survive in a dark and ruthless empire while at the same time trying to protect a young heir to a throne. Her desperate struggle to survive, and the long slow reveal of the real conspiracy, made for a very compelling read.
2026-07-31
Vincent
Sirius wasn’t the one who betrayed the Potters- it was Peter Pettigrew. Yes, the proof is in the details. Sirius never killed anyone. He pretended to have been killed by Pettigrew and when he found out he had been falsely accused he escaped from Azkaban to catch the real traitor- not to harm Harry. The map which led Harry to Sirius had a message attached to it that read “Pettigrew alive”. Case closed.
2025-06-21
Otto
I never suspected J.K. Rowling to have Sirius Black in Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban as an innocent man. Throughout most of the book he is portrayed by readers as the man who betrayed Harry Potter’s parents to their deaths. What readers have finally learned is that Sirius Black was never the Secret-Keeper for Harry Potter’s parents. He was framed by Peter Pettigrew who had faked his own death as a rat and had been hiding in plain sight as Ron Weasley’s pet Scabbers.
All of the proof of Sirius’s innocence is locked in the characters’ memories and magic. We can read Sirius’s name on the Marauder’s Map, but we can’t be sure what it means until Hermione produces her Time-Turner and the Harry of the past is brought back to life. That man is worthless. He looks a mess, behaves wildly, as if he doesn’t care about anything. But he cares deeply about Harry. This man has been unfairly imprisoned for years. He is innocent. And in this book, the greatest villainy of all is the way of the wizarding world to convict so quickly and with so little proof of guilt. Even good men like Dumbledore are capable of regretting their trust in others.
2025-06-24
Piper
The big revelation of Sirius’s innocence was another classic example of the misdirection that is a hallmark of great storytelling by J.K. Rowling. After being convinced of Sirius’s guilt throughout much of the book, we finally learn that he was Harry’s other parent, left behind to watch over Harry. (Pettigrew, on the other hand, is the real rat – literally.) Sirius’s animagus form, a large black dog, is therefore a guardian – as his human form is. All of the events that seemed to make Sirius crazy were simply part of his obsessed searching for black rats for months. The big scene where all is revealed takes place in the Shrieking Shack and here Harry at last learns the truth from Lupin and Sirius. The look of shock on the face of the true traitor, Pettigrew, is a great moment too. Justice is finally served – even if rather late in the day.
2025-06-25
Russell
Sirius Black is innocent in that he was never given a trial. For twelve long years the wizarding world believed him to be guilty of his cousin’s murder, because they heard him laughing after the event. Little did they know that he was in a state of near mad bliss, being so shocked by the event. In reality he had been framed by Peter who had cut off his own finger and transformed into a rat. This rat, calling itself Scabbers, was living long past his natural life, with a missing toe. It was Sirius’ greatest courage that he risked life and limb to expose Peter to Harry, in the hopes that he would be spared. Instead the Ministry of Magic’s greatest failing was allowing an innocent man to rot in Azkaban.
2025-06-25
View All Answers
Scan code to download App
Related Books
Enchanting the Prince
Cooper
9.8
89.4K
Lily Forte has known her mate since she was born. The Fae Prince, Aolis, realized she was his mate while she was in utero. He has waited patiently for Lily to grow up and reach her 18th birthday so she and her wolf will recognize him as her mate.
However, when Lily turns 18, even though she feels the mate bond, she doesn't respond to it, asking Aolis for time. He has always been like a brother, like the other sons of the Guardians. Now, she's supposed to feel differently for Aolis because her wolf says he's her mate?
Not only that, but she has never dated another man. She has no idea what it is like to be kissed by someone. Most she-wolves have at least some experience before they meet their mates, but everyone has stayed away from her, knowing her mate had already identified her as his.
On a fateful night, she is kissed by another wolf, and realizes that Aolis felt her betrayal. He gives her one week to decide if she wants him. If not, he will find another mate and take over as King.
Lily, not realizing the severity of Aolis's ultimatum, doesn't arrive in Araphrya, Aolis's home, until after his deadline. When she does, she realizes he has already left to find his mate. Lily rushes to find him and interrupts his wedding.
Lily begs him for another chance but the slight toward the fae causes a rift and war begins. Lorelai wants Aolis and if she can't have him, no one can.
Can Lily convince Aolis to choose her as the Queen of his land and his heart, to stand beside him against the dark fae or will Aolis choose a mate and leave Lily alone with her regrets?
Avani is the last earth dragon in the world. Not only that, but he is also the last male dragon. The other three remaining elemental dragons, air, water and fire, are all females. Unless he mates with one of the other three dragons, the race of pure dragons will die out.
Since he snubs the idea of finding a mate, refusing to allow anyone to claim him and therefore control him, he has taken over as protector of the forest. The hunters are always searching for supernaturals to force into their Arenas, a modern-day gladiator fighting ring. And now, they are capturing supernaturals to experiment on, creating a new race of hybrid creatures. Because Avani can shift his emerald-green scales into the black of onyx, those he saves have started to call him The Dark Protector.
Merethyl is an elven princess. She and her brother, Yhendorn, are captured by hunters when her family is attacked, her parents slaughtered in front of her. She and Yhendorn are held captive, experimented on, until one day they find a way to escape. As they flee, Yhendorn is re-captured sacrificing himself to make sure Merethyl gets away.
As she runs, the hunters chase her, trying to run her down. Avani hears her and flies to her rescue, killing the hunters that are after her. When he realizes that she smells better than anyone he’s ever smelled before, he knows he must get away from her. He cannot allow her to have the total control over him that claiming him would give her. But Merethyl has nowhere else to go and she needs Avani’s help to rescue her brother.
Will Avani be able to resist the charms of the elven princess, or will he fall to her, claimed, making her his dragonrider?
I was the second princess of the Phoenix Court.
And I fell in love with a lowly black serpent.
In my past life, just to be with him, I purposely picked that black serpent during the Sacred Bonding ceremony when we each chose our companion beasts.
After that, we spent every night together.
I didn't care what the whole clan thought. I was determined to marry him.
But on our wedding day, that same serpent I'd given my heart to drove an arrow straight through me, killing me while I was three months pregnant.
As I lay dying, I heard him hiss bitterly in my ear, "If it weren't for you, I'd have been with Seraphine by now. You should've died a long time ago."
That's when I finally got it. All he cared about was power. And he'd been in love with my older sister all along—the sister who was next in line for the Phoenix throne.
When I opened my eyes again, we were back at that same moment—the Sacred Bonding ceremony.
Before everyone, he dropped to his knees and confessed he loved my sister. He begged not to be bound to me.
The whole clan looked at me with pity.
But I only smiled and pointed to a small white serpent resting quietly off to the side.
That black serpent thought clinging to my sister would make him powerful. What he didn't realize was that only the one I chose would become the true heir to the Phoenix Court.
[COMPLETED]
Fates... How much do you believe in Fates?
Centuries ago, a prophecy was told. In time, bits of pieces were lost. The remaining was preserved but it left many questions:
"Every period of time comes forth the Archnemesis.
The night will fall like the snow in winter season
and the day will come like a flower that blooms in springtime.
War shall cause the lives of many and the weak shall suffer.
But lo, and behold, in a family of winter shall come the Blood Star of every generation.
Strength and might that shall spill the blood of its Adversary by the death with its soul."
Chloe Liu just wanted to become a fully pledged Kryst, a soldier of the Kingdom of Demetrius.
Lucian Liu and the members of the Seven Geniuses just wanted to protect his sister.
Prince Ciaran, the Særi ust Trūx (Future King), just wanted to protect the Kingdom of Demetrius along with his friends.
What if the Fates wanted more?
Ambition, love, manipulation, and power. The 27th Blood Star Bellatrix has to get through to the end. But will Bellatrix be able to turn the water to blood?
For three hundreds under vampire rule, the Blood Prince has drawn a new bride from his realms every fifty years.
In my previous life, Seraphina was chosen,Lucian’s childhood sweetheart.
The night before our bonding ceremony, she burst into our chamber, tears streaming.
“Lucian, I’ve been chosen as the Blood Prince’s seventh bride!” she sobbed.
“They say he loses control on his wedding night, drains every drop of blood from his bride. None of the first six lived to see dawn.
I don’t want to die—please, claim me as your mate!”
But Lucian had already claimed me.
And by wolf law, an Alpha may bind only one mate at a time.
So I step forward, and refused her.
The next day, at the altar, Seraphina slit her throat with a silver dagger.
Lucian didn’t flinch.
He ordered the blood scrubbed from the stones—and proceeded with our ceremony as nothing had happened.
However,on our honeymoon, he pushed me into starving wolves.
His eyes burned crimson as he snarled, “If you hadn’t tricked me into marking you earlier, Seraphina would be alive.
You killed her.”
Over a dozen of wolves with gleaming eyes swarmed me in,
tore me limb from limb.
Then I woke, back on the day the mate-hunger hex seized Lucian.
This time, I dragged Seraph-the girl Lucian cherished as most precious jewel,from her house myself,
and shoved her into Lucian’s chamber.
“Be his cure, and I’ll take your place as the Blood Prince’s bride instead.
Five years ago, Ciara Laurent went to prison for a crime she didn’t commit. She endured inhumane cruelty, lost her identity as the pack heiress and her mate, Alpha Thomas publicly rejected her.
Now she’s bailed out only to find out Alpha Thomas is marrying her stepsister, Alicent Laurent. The woman who Ciara took the fall for.
Before Ciara can even recover from the betrayal, her family sends her to the royal palace as Alicent’s personal maid.
“You are expected to carry Prince Thomas’s child in Alicent’s place. Only an heir born from his true fated mate can inherit the throne.”
“Never!” Ciara scoffs. “Your plan may sound perfect, but Thomas rejected me. Don’t you remember?”
She refuses to become a vessel for the royal heir.
Until something inside her suddenly awakens. A sharp, inexplicable pull drags Ciara toward the palace window. Alpha Thomas has just arrived.
The moment their eyes meet, her wolf awakens with a cry she hasn’t heard in five years.
Only to realize the mate bond between her and Thomas….never died!
I maintain a private list of novel recs I see posted in threads like this one, for reference later. The list has grown to become quite long. The hardest part is deciding which novel to start reading next. Is it going to be the 400k word epic political novel, or the tight 50k word study of man? So hard to choose!