I find anthology contributions tricky. She has stories in things like 'I'll Be Home for Christmas' and 'Kiss Me at Midnight.' A complete 'complete list' would include those, which is why author websites or fan-maintained databases are better than retailer pages that might only show full-length novels.
Mhairi McFarlane's books in order of publication are: 'You Had Me at Hello' (2012), 'Here's Looking at You' (2013), 'It's Not Me, It's You' (2014), 'Who's That Girl?' (2016), 'Don't You Forget About Me' (2018), 'If I Never Met You' (2020), 'Just Last Night' (2021), 'Mad About You' (2022), and 'Between Us' (2023). Her debut kicked off a really solid run of British rom-coms that just kept getting better, in my opinion. The gap between 2016 and 2018 felt long at the time, but the wait was worth it for 'Don't You Forget About Me'. She's been pretty consistent with a book every year or two since then, which is great for fans who love her specific blend of humor and heart.
It's fun to see how her style has evolved from the earlier, more straightforward rom-coms to books like 'Between Us' that weave in more complex, almost suspenseful relationship dynamics.
I think people get hung up on 'order' with authors like her because once you find one you love, you want to consume everything correctly. But with McFarlane, the correct way is any way that gets you reading. The library hold for 'If I Never Met You' might come in before 'You Had Me at Hello'. Read it! The used bookstore might only have 'It's Not Me, It's You'. Grab it! There's no test at the end. The only wrong order is not reading them at all. They're that good.
I’ve read them all, and my ranking changes every time I think about it. That’s a sign of a great author—no single book is objectively the ‘best.’ They all have different strengths. So just dive in. The water’s lovely. You’ll probably end up reading them all anyway, so the starting point is just where the journey begins.
So, to summarize the entire internet's consensus on this: Nope. No order. Now, please, go enjoy yourself. You have a stack of brilliant books waiting for you, in whatever sequence you damn well please. Happy reading!
The beauty of the standalone model is that if you don't like one, you can try another without feeling you've wasted time on 'setup' for a series you now don't want to finish. Maybe you didn't connect with the characters in 'You Had Me at Hello'. Fine! Try 'Mad About You'—completely different people, different problems.
It gives the author and the reader freedom. So experiment. DNF one if it's not clicking and jump to another without guilt. There's no overarching plot you're abandoning.