Ugh, BookTok is obsessed with the same five quotes. You see "It is a truth universally acknowledged..." from 'Pride and Prejudice' or "It was the best of times, it was the worst of times" every other day. I get it, they're iconic, but it feels a bit like people are just grabbing the most famous first line without really getting into the book's mood. Like, 'A Tale of Two Cities' is so much more than that opening, you know? The real treasure is when someone digs up a less obvious line that actually captures a feeling.
I'm way more interested in the quotes that become popular because of a specific trend or feeling. Like, all the 'The Great Gatsby' lines about longing and green lights blew up because they fit that aesthetic of wanting something you can't have. Or from 'Frankenstein', the monster's speeches about loneliness get shared a lot in discussions about feeling like an outsider. Those resonate more because they're attached to a real emotion, not just a famous phrase.
Honestly, sometimes I wonder if the algorithm just latches onto what's easiest to put over a pretty montage. The deep cuts from 'Jane Eyre' or 'Wuthering Heights' that pop up feel more genuine, like they came from someone who actually read the book and found a line that punched them in the gut. That's what I look for.