What Mental Illness Does Bartleby Have In 'Bartleby The Scrivener'?

2025-06-18 10:45:22 148

4 answers

Rowan
Rowan
2025-06-19 08:46:15
Bartleby’s condition in 'Bartleby the Scrivener' is a masterclass in ambiguity, but many interpret it as severe depression or catatonic schizophrenia. He exhibits classic signs: withdrawal from social interaction, repetitive speech ('I would prefer not to'), and a gradual refusal to perform even basic survival tasks like eating. His detachment isn’t just laziness—it’s a profound disconnection from reality’s demands.

The story hints at existential despair, too. Bartleby’s former job at the Dead Letter Office could symbolize futility, crushing his spirit. Unlike typical mental illness portrayals, he isn’t violent or erratic; his silence is his rebellion. Some argue it’s autism spectrum disorder, given his rigid routines and literal thinking. Melville leaves it open, making Bartleby a mirror for societal neglect. The tragedy isn’t his diagnosis but how the world abandons those it doesn’t understand.
Felicity
Felicity
2025-06-24 02:40:26
Bartleby’s behavior screams burnout mixed with extreme apathy. Imagine working a soul-crushing job until your mind just… stops. He’s not hostile, just empty, repeating his polite refusal like a broken record. Modern psychology might call it dysthymia or selective mutism. His isolation in the office corner feels symbolic—mental illness shoved aside but never addressed.

What’s chilling is how his coworkers oscillate between pity and irritation, a stark reminder of how people treat the mentally unwell. The lawyer’s 'charity' is just guilt dressed up as kindness. Bartleby’s eventual starvation isn’t a plot twist; it’s the inevitable end for someone society refuses to see as human.
Cassidy
Cassidy
2025-06-22 23:42:22
I’d bet Bartleby has schizoid personality disorder. He’s indifferent to relationships, emotionally cold, and obsessed with his 'prefer not to' mantra. It’s not depression—he doesn’t seem sad, just utterly detached. The scrivener work fits his need for repetitive, solitary tasks.

Melville’s genius is making us debate his illness while exposing how workplaces exploit fragile minds. Bartleby isn’t ill because he refuses work; work makes him ill. His passive resistance feels almost heroic, a quiet protest against capitalist grind.
Ulysses
Ulysses
2025-06-23 04:16:32
Bartleby’s like a ghost in a suit—no rage, no tears, just hollow obedience until even that fades. Clinically, it mirrors negative schizophrenia symptoms: flat affect, avolition. But literature majors love calling it 'Melville’s critique of alienation.' Truth? Both fit.

His decline isn’t dramatic; it’s in tiny refusals, each a brick in his mental prison. The office’s sterile environment amplifies his spiral. No therapy, no intervention—just a man erased by apathy.
View All Answers
Scan code to download App

Related Books

YOU ARE MENTAL
YOU ARE MENTAL
You are mental,no am not am saying the truth vampire are real. Am Alex people don't believe me but I know vampire are real I saw one,now no one believes me,am in a mental institution now am scared someone save me because his coming
10
92 Chapters
The Elemental Wolves
The Elemental Wolves
Four wolves, four different characters, four different powers, four different elements. The Elemental Wolves are a blessing from The Moon Goddess to the werewolf kingdom. But what happens when one of the Elementals was kidnapped before they could even shift. Will the Moon Goddess's words come to pass or the enemies will win? Reading THE ELEMENTAL WOLVES will make you find that out.
9.7
28 Chapters
Experimental Desires
Experimental Desires
When Jasmine Martin walked into the school’s building she had no idea how her life was going to change. Meeting Josh Tillman was life changing for many reasons. Including learning a bit about a professor desires...
7.3
71 Chapters
The Elemental Sisters
The Elemental Sisters
Five sisters with the power to control the elements reach out to their allies for help, as they prepare to fight an evil scourge intent on destroying everything. After losing their parents in an attack, and watching their home burn. The oldest sister, Akasha, is left to take over her parents' role and protect her sisters as they struggle to cope with the loss of everyone and everything they know. A prince in a struggle of his own is sent on an impossible mission to spy on the enemies and find out who they are after, only to discover the sisters and become emotionally attached as he aids them in their quest, and helps them prove to his father their worth. Battles ensue as they fight to protect themselves, fall in love, and learn how to use their powers as they fight to stop the scourge.
10
40 Chapters
SOLD to the KING of ALPHA'S
SOLD to the KING of ALPHA'S
Stella Sullivan is your normal seventeen-nearly eighteen-year-old girl. She likes shopping, taking selfies on her phone and hanging out with her friends until she had to move as her mother has just died and her father couldn't cope. He got into a lot of debt with his boss, and the only payment his boss would take was his daughter. So, as a cover for selling her, her father told her he got a promotion and that they had to move to a quiet country town as part of that promotion. What Stella didn't know was that she was about to be introduced to a new kind of not only living but an entirely different species. Axel Echethier has just turned five hundred years old. He is cruel, ruthless, violent, strict, savage, brutal, and a lot would call him bloodthirsty and barbaric, but that is only to others outside his pack because outsiders cause trouble and then pack members get killed. He is the King of Alphas and nothing gets done with a soft hand. Axel learnt that the hard way when he lost his chosen Queen. He has given up on finding his true mate, but this doesn't faze him as a true mate would just be a distraction and a weakness he doesn't want... **** WARNING **** The first part of this story contains mature scenes, implied rape, and some violence. In the extension "SOLD TO THE ENEMY ALPHA KING" Please read at your own discretion, as this part contains some violence, including physical, mental, and sexual abuse, including some rape, which may trigger some readers. Again, please read at your own discretion.
8.7
126 Chapters
Skeletons Of The Marital Closet
Skeletons Of The Marital Closet
"Gale Warm, what the Warm family owes me is for you to pay!" Shawn Wood threw Gale Warm into a mental hospital, tortured and humiliated. Two years later, he married her. "Don't be delusional, you are just here to atone for your family sins." He hated her, and only wanted to bully her.Gale Warm endured it while searching for the truth, and proved her family's innocence. Later, Gale Warm threw the evidence on Shawn Wood's face. "I never owed you." Later, Shawn  Wood turned pale overnight. He whispered in her ear day and night. "Gale, don't leave me. Otherwise, I won’t be able to live..." "Shawn Wood, how dare you threaten me!" "How dare I? You wouldn’t want our children to have no father, would you?"
9
2049 Chapters

Related Questions

Who Is The Narrator In 'Bartleby The Scrivener'?

4 answers2025-06-18 06:10:43
The narrator in 'Bartleby the Scrivener' is an elderly, methodical lawyer who runs a modest Wall Street firm. His voice is measured and reflective, tinged with a mix of bewilderment and paternalistic concern as he recounts Bartleby’s baffling defiance. He prides himself on rationality and order, yet Bartleby’s passive resistance unravels his composure, exposing his own moral contradictions. His tone shifts from amused detachment to uneasy introspection, revealing a man who clings to societal norms but is haunted by empathy he can’t fully act upon. The lawyer’s narration is layered—part character study, part self-critique. He frames Bartleby as an enigma, yet his own actions (or inactions) speak louder: hiring the scrivener out of pity, tolerating his refusals, then abandoning him when the situation grows inconvenient. His language oscillates between legal precision and poetic melancholy, especially in describing Bartleby’s 'dead-wall reveries.' Through him, Melville critiques the limits of capitalist compassion, wrapping existential dread in deceptively dry prose.

Why Does Bartleby Say 'I Would Prefer Not To' In 'Bartleby The Scrivener'?

3 answers2025-06-18 12:45:39
Bartleby's famous line 'I would prefer not to' in 'Bartleby the Scrivener' is his quiet rebellion against the soul-crushing monotony of his job. As a scrivener, he spends his days copying legal documents without any real purpose or creative input. His refusal isn’t just about laziness—it’s a protest against the dehumanizing nature of modern work. The phrase becomes his shield, a way to assert control in a system that treats him as a machine. What’s chilling is how calm he remains, never angry or defiant, just persistently unwilling to comply. This makes him even more unsettling to his boss, who can’t understand why someone would reject the basic expectations of society without explanation. Bartleby’s preference for 'not' is his only form of agency in a world that offers him none.

What Is The Significance Of The Ending In 'Bartleby The Scrivener'?

4 answers2025-06-18 12:26:36
The ending of 'Bartleby the Scrivener' is a haunting meditation on isolation and societal indifference. Bartleby's passive resistance—'I would prefer not to'—escalates into his literal starvation, a stark critique of how institutions discard the nonconforming. The narrator, despite his guilt, abandons Bartleby to die in the Tombs, revealing the limits of paternalistic compassion in a capitalist system. Melville’s genius lies in ambiguity. Is Bartleby a Christ-like martyr or a symbol of existential futility? The scrivener’s final whisper, 'Ah, humanity,' implicates us all. It’s not just about one man’s tragedy but our collective failure to see souls behind labor. The ending lingers like an unanswered question, forcing readers to confront their own complicity in systems that erase individuality.

How Does 'Bartleby The Scrivener' Critique Capitalism?

4 answers2025-06-18 07:26:23
In 'Bartleby the Scrivener,' Melville crafts a subtle yet scathing critique of capitalism through the lens of alienation and dehumanization. The narrator, a Wall Street lawyer, represents the system's indifference—his office is a microcosm of capitalist efficiency, where workers are reduced to mechanical functions. Bartleby’s passive resistance, his repeated 'I would prefer not to,' disrupts this machinery, exposing its fragility. His refusal isn’t just defiance; it’s a silent indictment of a world that values productivity over humanity. The scrivener’s eventual demise, ignored even in death, underscores capitalism’s cruel neglect of those it discards. The story mirrors Marx’s theory of alienation—workers become estranged from their labor, their essence stripped away. Bartleby’s withdrawal isn’t laziness; it’s a protest against soulless repetition. The lawyer’s failed attempts to 'help' reveal the system’s hollow charity—capitalism offers pity, not change. Melville’s genius lies in showing how even kindness within this framework is transactional, leaving no room for genuine connection.

Is 'Bartleby The Scrivener' Based On A True Story?

3 answers2025-06-18 00:17:24
I've dug into 'Bartleby the Scrivener' a few times, and while it feels eerily real, it's not based on a true story. Melville crafted this masterpiece as a commentary on workplace alienation and human resistance. The setting—a 19th-century Wall Street law office—mirrors Melville's own struggles with the corporate grind, but Bartleby himself is pure fiction. His passive defiance resonates because it taps into universal frustrations about autonomy. The story’s power lies in its ambiguity; we never learn Bartleby’s backstory, which makes his 'I would prefer not to' even more haunting. If you want something similarly thought-provoking, try 'The Metamorphosis'—Kafka nails existential dread too.
Explore and read good novels for free
Free access to a vast number of good novels on GoodNovel app. Download the books you like and read anywhere & anytime.
Read books for free on the app
SCAN CODE TO READ ON APP
DMCA.com Protection Status