How Does 'Bartleby The Scrivener' Critique Capitalism?

2025-06-18 07:26:23 170

4 answers

Juliana
Juliana
2025-06-21 19:47:44
In 'Bartleby the Scrivener,' Melville crafts a subtle yet scathing critique of capitalism through the lens of alienation and dehumanization. The narrator, a Wall Street lawyer, represents the system's indifference—his office is a microcosm of capitalist efficiency, where workers are reduced to mechanical functions. Bartleby’s passive resistance, his repeated 'I would prefer not to,' disrupts this machinery, exposing its fragility. His refusal isn’t just defiance; it’s a silent indictment of a world that values productivity over humanity.

The scrivener’s eventual demise, ignored even in death, underscores capitalism’s cruel neglect of those it discards. The story mirrors Marx’s theory of alienation—workers become estranged from their labor, their essence stripped away. Bartleby’s withdrawal isn’t laziness; it’s a protest against soulless repetition. The lawyer’s failed attempts to 'help' reveal the system’s hollow charity—capitalism offers pity, not change. Melville’s genius lies in showing how even kindness within this framework is transactional, leaving no room for genuine connection.
Flynn
Flynn
2025-06-20 02:20:04
Melville’s story dissects capitalism’s soul-crushing monotony. Bartleby isn’t just a quirky employee; he’s capitalism’s ghost, haunting its corridors with his existential refusal. The office—sterile, hierarchical—mirrors modern workplaces where individuality is erased. The lawyer, though sympathetic, perpetuates the system, treating Bartleby as a problem to manage, not a person to understand. Capitalism here isn’t just exploitative; it’s isolating, turning human bonds into cold contracts. Bartleby’s resistance isn’t active rebellion but a quiet unraveling of the system’s logic, revealing its absurdity when faced with unconditional 'no.'
Oscar
Oscar
2025-06-22 22:50:56
The critique in 'Bartleby' is stark: capitalism reduces people to cogs. Bartleby’s refusal to comply isn’t laziness—it’s a rejection of meaningless labor. The lawyer’s office, with its rigid roles, shows how work under capitalism drains purpose. Even charity, like the lawyer’s offers, is performative, maintaining the status quo. Bartleby’s fate—dying alone in a prison—highlights the system’s brutality toward those who won’t conform. Melville doesn’t offer solutions; he forces us to confront the inhumanity we’ve normalized.
Abigail
Abigail
2025-06-24 01:07:33
Bartleby’s story is capitalism’s nightmare. His passive resistance exposes how the system can’t handle non-participation. The lawyer’s frustration isn’t about lost work but disrupted control. Capitalism demands endless productivity; Bartleby’s 'prefer not to' breaks that spell. His death isn’t tragic—it’s inevitable in a world that discards what it can’t use. Melville’s genius is making a ghost out of a clerk, showing how capitalism turns people into shadows.
모든 답변 보기
QR 코드를 스캔하여 앱을 다운로드하세요

Related Books

Resent, Reject, Regret
Resent, Reject, Regret
Even the coldest heart would soon grow warm if she kept holding on to it. That was what she believed. That was why she became his unloved placeholder of a wife. Unfortunately, all her devotion only led to a heartless divorce. “She’s awake now,” he told her. “Step down and step away, you miserable knock-off.”Then, he left. When he came back, it was because he needed her to do something only an impostor could do: go to jail for his dream girl’s crime. Deirdre McKinnon was condemned to perdition. She lost her baby before it was born. She lost her face to violence. She lost the ability to see. It was two months of a hell-like nightmare. At last, something died inside her heart. Two years later, she found herself another man, but when Brendan Brighthall met her by pure happenstance, a new feeling was born in his heart: jealousy. There were no means too terrible, no scheme too underhanded—not if it meant he’d possess Deirdre’s heart again. And yet, she simply refused to love him anymore.“What do you want me to do, Deirdre McKinnon?! What must I do to go back to the good old days?” His eyes turned red. “I’ll give you everything I have!”“You gave me a copper trinket two years ago. It was a sorry excuse for a wedding ring, and yet I cared for it as though it was the most precious jewel in the world…“But now? Nothing you can give would be even remotely worthwhile. Not even you.”
7.7
1573 Chapters
Punished by His Love
Punished by His Love
She was a destitute woman whose life was dependent on others. She was forced to be a scapegoat and traded herself, which resulted in her pregnancy. He considered that she was the ultimate embodiment of evil as she was greed and deceitful. She tried all her efforts to win his heart but failed. Her departure made him so furious that he searched through the ends of the world and managed to recapture her. The whole city knew that she would be shredded into a million pieces. She asked him in desperation, “I left our marriage with nothing, so why won’t you let me go?”In a domineering tone, he answered, “You’ve stolen my heart and given birth to my child, and you wish to escape from me?”
9
2823 Chapters
Married at First Sight
Married at First Sight
Since the day Serenity got hitched to a stranger on their blind date, she had assumed married life would be ordinary but respectful and mundane. It never crossed her mind that her new husband would be clingy like a piece of gum stuck to the bottom of a shoe. To her utmost surprise, he could make her troubles disappear whenever she was in a fix. Despite her questioning, her husband would always pass it off as luck. Until one day, she watched an interview with a local billionaire known for fussing over his wife. That was when she noticed the uncanny resemblance of the billionaire to her husband. The wife whom he was showering attention on turned out to be her!
9.3
4400 Chapters
A Complicated Romance
A Complicated Romance
She poured her heart out, yet he did not do the same. As infidelity befell her marriage, she was forced to divorce her husband with nothing left in her name. Overnight, she changed from the enviable position of Madam Larson to a pitiful, penniless wretch. She thought that she would not meet him again, yet fate played with her and they crossed paths once more. “Let me go, I beg you.”“Do you think I’ll do that again?”
8.8
699 Chapters
The Unloved Luna Queen
The Unloved Luna Queen
Darcy a 17-year-old Alpha Female wants nothing more than to be loved. Being always ignored by her parents and looked down upon, the only love she ever knew was from her elder twin brother, Dylan and her best friend Lavender. She believes all her miseries will come to an end when she finds her mate. Colton is the next in line Alpha King who wants nothing more than to take his childhood sweetheart Patrina as his chosen Queen. He doesn't want anything to do with his true mate and wishes to spend his life with the woman he loved, but everything changes when he finds his true mate on the day of his coronation ceremony and is forced to accept her as his Queen and Mate. Stephen is the next in line Beta of the royal pack or so he thought. He has always been in love with Darcy but decided to stay away when he realised she wanted to find her true mate. Everyone's worlds come crashing down when Darcy is accused of a murder conspiracy. While proving Darcy innocent a lot from the past is revealed leaving everyone shocked. Will Darcy be able to find the love she always craved and deserved? Will Colton realise his mistake before it is too late? Will Stephen be able to move on with his life without Darcy? Follow on their journey to find out. THE UNWANTED LUNA SERIES BOOK 1 - THE UNLOVED LUNA QUEEN BOOK 2 - THE VENGEFUL LUNA QUEEN All rights reserved! © Midnight Shines Books, 2020.
9.5
100 Chapters
Addicted to Loving You: The Paranoid and Domineering Boss's Convicted Wife
Addicted to Loving You: The Paranoid and Domineering Boss's Convicted Wife
Ling Yiran had been sentenced to three years in prison due to the car accident that killed the fiancée of Yi Jinli, the richest man in Shen City. When released from prison, she somehow ended up catching the attention of Yi Jinli. She kneeled on the ground and begged him, "Yi Jinli, can you let me go?" But he only smiled and said, "Sister, I will never let you go." It was said that Yi Jinli was completely indifferent to anyone and everyone, but for some reason, he did everything he could to please a sanitation worker girl who had been in prison for the past three years. However, the truth of the car accident that year had robbed her of all her love for him, and she ran away. Many years later, he begged her while on the ground, "Yiran, as long as you return by my side, I will do anything for you." But she only stared at him coldly and said, "Then, go die."
9.2
2890 Chapters

Related Questions

Who Is The Narrator In 'Bartleby The Scrivener'?

4 answers2025-06-18 06:10:43
The narrator in 'Bartleby the Scrivener' is an elderly, methodical lawyer who runs a modest Wall Street firm. His voice is measured and reflective, tinged with a mix of bewilderment and paternalistic concern as he recounts Bartleby’s baffling defiance. He prides himself on rationality and order, yet Bartleby’s passive resistance unravels his composure, exposing his own moral contradictions. His tone shifts from amused detachment to uneasy introspection, revealing a man who clings to societal norms but is haunted by empathy he can’t fully act upon. The lawyer’s narration is layered—part character study, part self-critique. He frames Bartleby as an enigma, yet his own actions (or inactions) speak louder: hiring the scrivener out of pity, tolerating his refusals, then abandoning him when the situation grows inconvenient. His language oscillates between legal precision and poetic melancholy, especially in describing Bartleby’s 'dead-wall reveries.' Through him, Melville critiques the limits of capitalist compassion, wrapping existential dread in deceptively dry prose.

What Mental Illness Does Bartleby Have In 'Bartleby The Scrivener'?

4 answers2025-06-18 10:45:22
Bartleby’s condition in 'Bartleby the Scrivener' is a masterclass in ambiguity, but many interpret it as severe depression or catatonic schizophrenia. He exhibits classic signs: withdrawal from social interaction, repetitive speech ('I would prefer not to'), and a gradual refusal to perform even basic survival tasks like eating. His detachment isn’t just laziness—it’s a profound disconnection from reality’s demands. The story hints at existential despair, too. Bartleby’s former job at the Dead Letter Office could symbolize futility, crushing his spirit. Unlike typical mental illness portrayals, he isn’t violent or erratic; his silence is his rebellion. Some argue it’s autism spectrum disorder, given his rigid routines and literal thinking. Melville leaves it open, making Bartleby a mirror for societal neglect. The tragedy isn’t his diagnosis but how the world abandons those it doesn’t understand.

Why Does Bartleby Say 'I Would Prefer Not To' In 'Bartleby The Scrivener'?

3 answers2025-06-18 12:45:39
Bartleby's famous line 'I would prefer not to' in 'Bartleby the Scrivener' is his quiet rebellion against the soul-crushing monotony of his job. As a scrivener, he spends his days copying legal documents without any real purpose or creative input. His refusal isn’t just about laziness—it’s a protest against the dehumanizing nature of modern work. The phrase becomes his shield, a way to assert control in a system that treats him as a machine. What’s chilling is how calm he remains, never angry or defiant, just persistently unwilling to comply. This makes him even more unsettling to his boss, who can’t understand why someone would reject the basic expectations of society without explanation. Bartleby’s preference for 'not' is his only form of agency in a world that offers him none.

What Is The Significance Of The Ending In 'Bartleby The Scrivener'?

4 answers2025-06-18 12:26:36
The ending of 'Bartleby the Scrivener' is a haunting meditation on isolation and societal indifference. Bartleby's passive resistance—'I would prefer not to'—escalates into his literal starvation, a stark critique of how institutions discard the nonconforming. The narrator, despite his guilt, abandons Bartleby to die in the Tombs, revealing the limits of paternalistic compassion in a capitalist system. Melville’s genius lies in ambiguity. Is Bartleby a Christ-like martyr or a symbol of existential futility? The scrivener’s final whisper, 'Ah, humanity,' implicates us all. It’s not just about one man’s tragedy but our collective failure to see souls behind labor. The ending lingers like an unanswered question, forcing readers to confront their own complicity in systems that erase individuality.

Is 'Bartleby The Scrivener' Based On A True Story?

3 answers2025-06-18 00:17:24
I've dug into 'Bartleby the Scrivener' a few times, and while it feels eerily real, it's not based on a true story. Melville crafted this masterpiece as a commentary on workplace alienation and human resistance. The setting—a 19th-century Wall Street law office—mirrors Melville's own struggles with the corporate grind, but Bartleby himself is pure fiction. His passive defiance resonates because it taps into universal frustrations about autonomy. The story’s power lies in its ambiguity; we never learn Bartleby’s backstory, which makes his 'I would prefer not to' even more haunting. If you want something similarly thought-provoking, try 'The Metamorphosis'—Kafka nails existential dread too.
좋은 소설을 무료로 찾아 읽어보세요
GoodNovel 앱에서 수많은 인기 소설을 무료로 즐기세요! 마음에 드는 책을 다운로드하고, 언제 어디서나 편하게 읽을 수 있습니다
앱에서 책을 무료로 읽어보세요
앱에서 읽으려면 QR 코드를 스캔하세요.
DMCA.com Protection Status