CHAPTER 2 Evelyn Becomes a Suspect

By the time the council meeting lets out, folks are already whispering Evelyn Blackwood’s name.

In Raven Hollow, suspicion has always traveled faster than truth, and Evelyn has spent her entire life learning what that means.

She’s thirty-two now, one of the last Blackwoods left in Raven Hollow. The family’s been here longer than the oldest trees, and that history clings to her whether she wants it or not. You can see it in the way she moves quietly, careful, always aware of eyes that linger a little too long.

Something about her unsettles the sense of time. She’s tall, quiet, never one to draw attention, but somehow you notice her anyway. Her hair is chestnut, usually pulled back in a loose braid for work, though a few strands always slip free. If the light catches just right, you might spot a glint of silver easy to miss, never spoken of.

Her eyes are what most people remember.

They’re a deep green, flecked with gold, and seem to change if you look too long. Some folks say there’s warmth in them. Others say there’s something older. Most just look away, uneasy, like she knows more than she lets on.

She doesn’t ask for attention. Her clothes are simple: soft shirts, old sweaters, boots made for muddy trails and long hours. Still, people notice her. There’s always a hint of lavender and rosemary about her, mixed with rain and earth, like the woods themselves follow her home.

But her hands tell the truest story.

Faint scars mark her hands: old cuts from years of tending plants, glass, and things best left unnamed. Her hands are steady, careful, made for healing more than harm, though most folks in town seem to forget that part.

Long before the town became a place of stone buildings and tidy streets, the Blackwoods were healers, herbalists, and keepers of old knowledge. Evelyn grew up on those stories, passed down like an inheritance.

One, in particular, has never left her.

On storm-heavy evenings, her grandmother would speak of Mabel Blackwood who, during a fever that swept the valley, brewed remedies from yarrow and foxglove and stayed awake for three nights tending to sick children. Mabel slept in a rocking chair at their bedside, her skirts stained with poultices, never asking for thanks.

The fever broke. And still, the whispers came. They said she must have bargained with the moon.

It is always the same, Evelyn has learned.

The Blackwoods gathered moonwort beneath silver skies, tended sacred groves, and helped shape the wards that still protect Raven Hollow from things most people will never see.

But history does not stay intact.

It bends.

It frays.

Service turns to suspicion. Care turns to caution. In the end, all that’s left is a single word, spoken soft but certain.

Witch.

In Raven Hollow, that’s always been enough.

Evelyn grew up at the edge of town, in a weathered old house tangled with ivy and wild roses. It belonged to her grandmother, and her grandmother before that. Every room still holds pieces of their handwritten journals on the shelves, herbs drying from the rafters, faded portraits watching from the corners.

Her childhood was always a contradiction. She was a Blackwood, so she belonged here. She was a witch, so she never really did.

She went to the same school as everyone else, sat in the same classrooms, walked the same roads home. Still, there was always a line she couldn’t cross. Parents told their kids not to stray near the Blackwood place. Birthday invitations never showed up. If a cow got sick or a storm ruined the corn, folks started whispering about curses before the rain even stopped.

Children absorbed their parents’ fears.

By twelve, she was used to hearing words like hex and bad luck behind her back. She learned to keep her chin up and her tears to herself.

The loneliness only grew after her parents died, just months apart, when she was nineteen. Some said it was illness. Others whispered about magic gone wrong. The truth was quieter, sadder, but rumors always outlast the facts.

Left alone, Evelyn got the house and all the old suspicion that came with it.

Most people expected her to leave. Instead, she stayed.

She turned the old shop by the square into Blackwood Botanicals. It always smells of lavender, cedar, and chamomile drying overhead. Folks come for help with sleepless nights, sore knees, grief that lingers. Evelyn’s spent years tending to neighbors who’d never admit how much they rely on her.

She brewed teas for fevers, mixed salves for burns, brought medicine to sick kids in the middle of snowstorms. She sat with the dying when no one else would. Still, most folks looked at her with the same old fear. That contradiction was just part of her life now.

People trusted her cures, but not her hands. Some would thank her in private, but look away in the street.

Now, walking through the market square under a gray sky, she feels every stare prick at her skin. Conversations hush when she passes.

Mrs. Pratt gathers her grandkids close. Mr. Dalrymple, who’s come to her for his knees more times than she can count, stares at the ground and mutters about curses. Two boys behind a cart snicker, waving their hands in mock spells as she walks by.

She tells herself the cruelty shouldn’t sting, but it does. She knows these people, their losses, their recoveries, the funerals she’s sat through beside them. Today, none of it matters. Rumor is louder than memory. Still, not everyone turns away.

Inside, tucked beneath the threshold, Evelyn nearly steps on a folded piece of paper. As she bends to pick it up, a voice calls out from across the street. "Morning, Miss Blackwood!" It is Nora Finch, the baker's apprentice, red-cheeked and nervous, clutching an empty basket. Nora hesitates at the curb before forcing herself closer, eyes darting to see if anyone notices. "My gran says folks are foolish, and I reckon she's right. She sent these." Nora slides a small bag toward Evelyn, the scent of warm rolls drifting out. "I saw what they wrote on your door. Don't let it get to you." She gives a quick, shy smile and disappears into the morning crowd before Evelyn can reply.

Evelyn turns back to the doorstep and reads the note. ‘We know you didn’t do this.’ The handwriting is shaky but, this time, she thinks she recognizes the flourish of the 'w.' Another note arrives before noon. ‘Stay strong.’

Inside, tucked beneath the threshold, she finds a folded piece of paper. ‘We know you didn’t do this.’ The handwriting is shaky and unsigned. Another note arrives before noon. ‘Stay strong.’

These small kindnesses matter more than folks realize. In a place this scared, even bread left on a doorstep feels like courage. But kindness is rare here. Suspicion always finds its way back. The old feud stirs up again, just like it always does.

For centuries, the Blackwoods and the founding werewolf clan, the Ashfords, have shared a complicated history. The truth is buried beneath generations of half-remembered stories and deliberate omissions. Still, most versions agree on one point: a conflict occurred long ago over the relics used to maintain Raven Hollow’s protective seal. Some elders whisper of the Midnight Bargain, a ritual pact between the clans meant to tie the valley’s safety to both families, binding the power of Blackwood witchcraft with Ashford blood. Others still remember what they call the Lantern Night, when an entire Ashford hunting party was found asleep in the frozen woods, lanterns smashed like someone tried to erase the light itself, and strange sigils drawn in the snow, as if some agreement had twisted into betrayal. There are rumors that the relic known as the Moonlock, a silver amulet said to anchor the wards and respond only to moonlight and blood, was stolen that night, spirited away just as the magic began to unravel, and that in the confusion, a Blackwood child vanished and was never found. Whether the Blackwoods retaliated or forgave, only the oldest family journals would know. But that act, whatever its shape, left scars on both lineages, and a thread of mistrust that has never fully healed.

Some claim the Blackwoods wanted sole control of the magic.

Others insist the werewolves betrayed an agreement.

The actual details have long been lost.

What remains is resentment.

Now, with the relics gone and the seal growing weaker, folks are quick to grab the easiest answer they can find.

A witch took them, they say. Who else but Evelyn Blackwood? The rumor spreads fast. By nightfall, the council calls for an inquiry. They call it an investigation, but Evelyn knows what that means.

Scrutiny.

Interrogation.

Judgment.

She sits alone in the shop after closing, shelves of herbs and candlelight for company. Rain taps at the windows. Tonight, the room that’s always felt safe feels distant.

For the first time, doubt creeps in where confidence used to live. Not doubt in herself, but in the town. She wonders if truth matters once folks have picked their villain. Her eyes find the old photograph behind the counter, her grandmother, standing in this shop years ago, looking calm and unyielding.

She understands that look now. The Blackwoods have weathered blame and suspicion for generations. Maybe she’s just the next to carry it.

But as the wind rattles the windows and shadows gather outside, something else settles in her chest. The accusations feel off—too neat, too easy. Someone wants the town looking her way. Someone gains from the fear.

And if the relics truly are missing, if the seal is genuinely failing, then the danger facing Raven Hollow is far greater than a frightened mob searching for a scapegoat. If the seal breaks completely, there could be more than whispers in the night; strange lights and sudden sickness might only be the beginning. Old enemies could creep in from the woods or slip through the mist: the Hollowborn, shade-wolves with eyes like burning coals, hungry for warmth after decades wandering the wild marshes, or the silent gatherers who lure wanderers with the sound of bells at dusk, stealing their voices before sunrise. Worse yet, something ancient and hungry, long kept at bay, might finally walk free. The Grinning Man from the river, whose smile withered the orchard in the tales her grandmother told, leaves muddy footprints on the doorstep and petals that turn black beneath his shadow. The Night-Root itself, sleeping below the valley, waits for the wards to weaken, eager to send its tangled roots upward into the world, and chaos could sweep through the hollow in ways no one dares to imagine.

Evelyn folds the anonymous note and slips it into her pocket.

Then she extinguishes the lamps one by one.

Whatever waits beneath the surface of this mystery, she intends to find it before the town tears itself apart. Tomorrow at dawn, she will start at the site where the relics vanished, retracing steps no one else dares to follow. If any answers linger in forgotten footprints or in the disturbed circle of ash where the old wards once glowed, she means to find them. Part of her aches to prove her innocence, but deeper still is the hope that by uncovering the truth she can finally mend what has always been broken between herself and Raven Hollow. Even now, when suspicion wounds her most, Evelyn remembers autumn fairs and winter lanterns, the distant laughter of children chasing foxfire in the fields beyond her garden. She recalls early mornings when her remedies coaxed color back into the faces of the sick, the silent gratitude in a mother's gaze as her child slept. These memories are stubborn roots, keeping her anchored to a place that has never fully claimed her. If she can protect the town even when it does not trust her, perhaps she can also prove that the Blackwood legacy means more than old fears.

Because if history has taught her anything, it is this:

Monsters don’t usually look like the ones folks are already scared of.