LOGINIt started out soft, like his had. Then it wasn't. Something that had been held back all night, all summer, maybe for years, came loose all at once. Her hands went into his hair. His went to her waist, and then to the small of her back under the hem of his own navy sweatshirt, warm against her skin, and she heard herself make a sound she didn't recognize. The cushions shifted under them. The blanket slid off onto the floor. Somewhere behind them the movie kept playing, screams and music, and neither of them heard a word of it.
She pulled him closer. He pressed her back into the arm of the couch. Her heart was pounding so hard she could feel it in her fingertips, in her throat, everywhere. Her hand found the top button of his flannel shirt, and her fingers were shaking, and she started to work it loose.
Tony's hand closed over hers.
Not pushing it away. Just holding it, very still, against his chest, where she could feel his heart going just as hard as hers.
He pulled back an inch. His breath was ragged. His eyes were dark and wild and full of something that looked almost like pain.
"Gem," he said hoarsely. "Wait."
She froze. For one awful second, she thought she'd done something wrong. That he didn't want her. That she'd read it all wrong, the bleachers and the porch and the sweatshirt and everything.
Then she saw his face, and knew it wasn't that. It was the opposite of that.
"I want to," he said. His voice cracked straight down the middle. "God. You don't know how bad I want to. I've wanted to for so long it scares me." He pressed his forehead against hers and closed his eyes. "But not like this."
"Like what?" she whispered.
"Like this. Tonight. With you leaving in the morning and your brother coming back at eight and your mom thinking you're dead in a ditch." He swallowed. "With you running from that party, and me just—catching you. I don't want this to be something that happened because you were scared and I was here."
She stared up at him. Her lips still felt swollen. Her whole body was humming.
And the thing was, he was right.
She could feel it, now that he'd said it out loud. Underneath the wanting, and there was so much wanting, there was something else. Something frantic. Like she was trying to grab hold of one last thing before the ground fell out from under her. Like if she could just make this happen tonight, she wouldn't have to get in that car tomorrow and drive away from everything.
She didn't want that. Not for this. Not for him.
"I don't want it to be like that either," she said quietly.
"Yeah?"
"Yeah." She let out a long, shaky breath. Her hand was still on his chest, under his, over his heart. "I want it to be when we're not saying goodbye."
Something in his face went soft and wrecked all at once. "Okay," he whispered. "Then that's what we'll wait for."
"Is that dumb?"
"No, Shortcake." He laughed, low and unsteady, and kissed her forehead. Then her nose. Then, very gently, the corner of her mouth, and pulled away before it could turn into anything. "It's the least dumb thing either of us has done all night."
She laughed too, and it broke something open. Some of the tension went out of both of them at once, and they lay there for a while just breathing, foreheads together, grinning at each other like idiots in the blue light of the TV.
Then he reached down and retrieved the blanket from the floor.
He stretched out along the couch and drew her down with him, her back against his chest, his arm over her waist, their fingers laced against her stomach. The couch was too narrow and too short. Neither of them moved to fix it.
Across the room, a chainsaw roared to life and a woman screamed. Gemma tensed, her fingers tightening on his.
"Hey," he murmured against her ear.
She let out a breath, and the tension drained from her shoulders.
The screams kept coming, the chainsaw revving and sputtering, until the noise stopped being a movie and became the texture of the night. Tony pressed his face into the curve of her neck and felt her heartbeat under his palm.
"Sleep," he whispered. "I'll be right here."
She answered with a soft hum, already half gone, her body going loose and heavy against him. On the screen, someone else was running. Someone else was dying. Tony closed his eyes and let the chainsaw lull him under too, Gemma warm and real in his arms, the horror playing on behind them, unwatched.
Voices jolted Tony awake. Raised ones, out in the stairwell. For one groggy second he told himself it was the movie. Then he registered the gray light at the blinds and the dead black of the TV screen, which had shut itself off hours ago, and a key rasped in the lock.
The door swung open. Kyle came in first, shoulders slumped like the air itself was pressing down on him. Don Havley came in behind him and stopped dead when he saw Tony and Gemma tangled together on the couch.
"Mr. Bennet." Don's voice was low and controlled, but every line of his body said danger. "Would you care to explain why my daughter is on your couch while my wife is pacing our kitchen, scared out of her mind?"
Tony's chest locked up. He eased himself upright, careful not to jostle Gemma. "I found her on the road. Out past the strip mall. I couldn't just leave her there." His voice wobbled.
"You could've used your phone," Don said.
"I did. I texted Kyle. He came by to check on her. I thought he'd tell you." Tony swallowed hard. "I should've called you myself. I'm sorry."
"Sorry doesn't cut it, Tony." Don's jaw worked. "I'm grateful you picked her up. I am. Anything could've happened out there. But you knew you should've called me." His eyes cut to Kyle. "And you'd better hope there's a door at home your mother can't get through."
Then he turned to Gemma. "Shoes."
She bent and shoved her feet into her sneakers without tying them. Just before she stood, she pressed a quick kiss to Tony's cheek, fear and gratitude and something harder to name all crowding her eyes at once. Tony braced himself for Don to haul him off the couch by his hair.
Instead, Don closed his eyes, like a man who'd been bracing for this a long time too. "Be there when she pulls out at noon."
"If that's okay—" Tony started.
"Don't ask permission." Don sounded tired now. "Dee might pitch a fit, but Gemma clearly wants you there." He paused at the door. "We love you like one of our own, Tony. Just give Dee an hour to cool off first."
"Yes, sir."
The next Thursday, at their table under the sagging window, Chase turned his phone around to show her his calendar. Every Thursday from seven to ten was blocked off in blue for the rest of the semester. One letter: G."I cleared these," he said. "Thursdays are ours. I need you to protect them too, okay? This only works if we both take it seriously.""Of course," she said. "Yeah. Of course."Freddy had mentioned a movie night on the second floor next Thursday. Gemma had already said maybe. She'd text her later.Chase smiled and slid her newest draft across the table. Green ink covered the first page. In the margin beside her ending, he'd written: Almost. You're so close to being great.She bent over the pages, already reaching for her pen, already wanting to close the gap.It didn't feel like losing anything. It felt like being chosen.***October came in cold, and the nights got long.Thursdays stopped ending at ten. They closed down the library reading room, and when the librarian fl
The night of that very first dinner at Juniper, she'd called Tony from the window seat, still a little warm from the wine. The bar noise came through the phone, and the jukebox, and Kyle yelling at somebody in the background about a tab."Guess what I had for dinner," she said."Let me guess. Sonic.""Duck." She pulled one leg under herself. "With cherry sauce. And this cheese thing called burrata, it's like mozzarella but it's got cream inside, you'd hate it. And wine. One glass. At a place with tablecloths."There was a pause on the line. Then Tony laughed, warm and low. "Duck? Like from the pond? You used to cry when your daddy went out after the mallards.""It's different. It's French.""Uh-huh. Who took you to the French duck place?""Just a friend from the program." She didn't know why she said it that way. A friend. She didn't say Chase. She didn't say he. "A bunch of us went.""Well." She could hear him smiling. "Next time you're home, I'll take you out to the pond and get you
The fourth favor was dinner."You've been here a month," Chase said at the end of their Thursday session, packing up his tablet. "Where have you eaten?"Gemma counted on her fingers. "The dining hall. The pizza place. The Sonic out on the highway. That burger place across from the bookstore." She thought. "Oh, and the Taco Bell. Twice."Chase stared at her like she'd confessed to a crime. "That's it?""What's wrong with Sonic? Sonic has tots.""Nothing's wrong with Sonic." He was trying not to laugh. "Sonic is fine. Sonic is a national treasure. But Gemma." He leaned across the table. "There's a whole world out there that isn't fried and served in a paper bag. Saturday. I'm taking you to dinner. A real one."He took her to a place called Juniper, on a side street downtown, in an old brick building that had once been a bank. The windows were tall and dark, and the tables were small and close together, with white tablecloths and little candles in glass jars, and every single person in t
The third favor was the sweater.It was the last week of September, and the mornings had started to turn cold in a way Oklahoma mornings never did, the air thin and bright and smelling like pine. Gemma had dug out the sweater her mother had knit her the Christmas she was sixteen. It was a big, soft, mustard-yellow cable-knit, with a slightly lopsided collar where Dee had dropped a stitch and decided she liked it. Gemma had worn it to every football game her junior and senior years. It smelled like her mother's cedar chest. She wore it to the library for their Thursday session.Chase looked up when she sat down. He looked at her for a moment longer than usual. Then he set his stylus down."Can I say something," he said, "and you won't throw your coffee at me?"She laughed. "Depends on what it is.""That color." He tilted his head, studying her the way he studied a paragraph. "It's doing you no favors."Gemma looked down at herself. "My mom made this.""I can tell. It's beautiful. The
On Thursday, at their table under the sagging window, Chase pulled up an email on his tablet and turned it around to show her."Friday night," he said. "Dr. Hale's reading from her new collection at the library. Seven o'clock, in the reading room. Very small, invite-only, mostly faculty and the journal staff. She asked me to bring you specifically." His eyes were bright. "Gem, you're going to love it. She's reading the one about her mother's hands. It's the best thing she's ever written."Gemma looked at the email. Then she looked up."I can't," she said. "I'm going to the bonfire with Freddy."Chase laughed, like she'd made a joke. "The football thing?""The football thing.""Gemma." He said it patiently, the way you'd talk to a kid who wanted cake for dinner. "It's a bunch of drunk freshmen standing around a fire. You can do that any night of the week. This is Hale. This is a room full of people who could change your whole life.""I know." She made herself keep looking at him. "But
She'd come out of Forms of Creative Nonfiction at two in the afternoon, dragging, and there he'd be on the bench outside Hawthorne Hall with a second cup, iced this time, because it had been a warm day. She'd stay up until one rewriting a paragraph for workshop and walk into the library the next morning gray-faced and squinting, and before she'd even set her bag down, the cup would be sliding across the table toward her. On the first truly cold morning, when frost furred the grass on the quad and Gemma came out of the guesthouse in a hoodie because she hadn't unpacked her coat yet, he was waiting on the steps with a hot chocolate. Three pumps of caramel. Extra whipped cream. A crosshatch on top."Too cold for espresso," he said, handing it over. "Even for you."She never once saw him buy them. She never saw him stand in line at Marco's cart. They were just there, warm in her hands, whenever she needed one. Sometimes before she knew she needed one.She didn't think it was weird. Not rea
“Love you guys, too.” Gemma hung up. Why did that call just pull all the happiness from last night right out of her spirit? It was supposed to be simple and cheerful, but now all she could think about was what she was missing. By five tonight—even though they had just gotten home—she knew her mom an
By the time the bars started shutting down, Freddy told Gemma, “Well, that’s half of the ones I know. We’ll get to the next half next weekend.” They were linked arm in arm, giggling their way down the sidewalk.“I am starving,” Freddy declared.Gemma nodded, her stomach growling in agreement. “Same.
Gemma sat with her legs under her on her bed, waiting for Freddy to get out of the shower, absently scrolling through her phone while the bathroom fan hummed in the background.Her screen lit up with a text from Tony. Good morning, Shortcake. Your brother owes me fifty bucks. I won the bet.A small
Tony stood at the bar, filling a mug of beer. He topped it off and sent it sliding down the counter, then leaned back, his eyes fixed on the door. Matt came up behind him, his voice low. "She’s not coming through that door anytime soon.""Who?""Whatever, dude. You know exactly who I’m talking abou







