LOGINGemma sat with her legs under her on her bed, waiting for Freddy to get out of the shower, absently scrolling through her phone while the bathroom fan hummed in the background.
Her screen lit up with a text from Tony. Good morning, Shortcake. Your brother owes me fifty bucks. I won the bet.
A small smile tugged at her lips before she could stop it. Bet? she typed back. What bet?
Kyle bet me they’d have to turn around and come get you before they even made it home.
“That asshole,” Gemma announced to the room.
Freddy stepped out of the bathroom, towel wrapped around her, steam curling behind her. “Um… who are we mad at?” she asked, rifling through her drawer for clothes. She yanked the towel off her head and started aggressively drying her hair.
“My brother,” Gemma said, glaring at her phone. “Apparently he bet Tony fifty bucks that they’d have to turn around and come get me before they even made it home.”
Freddy snorted. “Okay, that’s actually kind of funny.”
“It is not,” Gemma argued, though she was already fighting a smile. “He didn’t even think I could survive twenty-four hours on my own.”
Freddy pointed the towel at her. “To be fair, didn’t you say you spent the entire drive out here talking about how you didn’t want to leave literally everyone and everything you’ve ever known?”
Gemma flopped backward onto the bed dramatically. “I was going through something.”
“You still are,” Freddy informed her.
Gemma groaned into Tony’s sweatshirt. “Yeah, well, apparently my emotional breakdown was profitable.”
Freddy laughed as she pulled on her shirt. “Text him back and tell him not to worry. I’ll take good care of you while you’re here.”
Gemma raised an eyebrow. “That sounds vaguely threatening.”
“It should,” Freddy replied proudly. “It’ll probably involve chaos and at least three terrible decisions.”
Tony text: And for the record, I never took the bet because I thought you’d fail I knew you wouldn't
Gemma stared at that one a little longer than she meant to, warmth blooming in her chest despite herself.
Gemma headed toward the bathroom, still looking down at her phone. Freddy watched her go, shaking her head with a little smirk.
“Yeah,” Freddy called after her, “just his best friend’s kid sister.”
“Rude!” Gemma called out laughing as she shut the bathroom door behind her.
A few minutes later, Gemma came out of the bathroom dressed in the jeans and shirt Freddy had tossed her earlier. She carefully folded Tony’s sweatshirt and placed it at the end of her bed.
Freddy watched her, eyebrows raised. “Why are you taking such care with an old sweatshirt?”
Gemma blushed. “It’s Tony’s.”
Freddy let out a laugh that echoed through the dorm room. “Tony, huh? The Tony who treats you like a kid sister. You just looked at your phone like you were in love with it that last text you got.”
Gemma nearly choked. “Oh my God, I did not.”
“You absolutely did,” Freddy shot back. “That was a full-on romance movie smile. ”Gemma stood looking at her. “Nothing to say? mmhmm I thought so."
“Freddy, I’ve known you less than twenty-four hours and you think you know me already?” Gemma laughed.
“I know enough to know you don’t think of this Tony as a big brother figure,” Freddy shot back. “That was not a sibling look—or at least, nothing I ever gave my brothers.” She pointed to the shirt Gemma had just folded. "And I sure as heck would never treat one of their sweatshirts like they were made of gold. Theirs are mostly stains and sweat."
"I..." Gemma started to say something then looked at the shirt. She laughed, "I suppose there was something there on my end but he doesn't think of me that way."
Freddy shook her head at her and said, "Lets go get an early dinner and hit the town and cause as much chaos as we can."
“Let’s go have an early dinner and then go out and cause some chaos,” Freddy declared. She hooked her arm through Gemmas and they walked out of their dorm room together.
They made thier way across campus to the little diner Gemma’s parents had taken her to. After they ordered, Freddy leaned back in the booth and grinned. “So, tell me about this Tony.”
“Tony’s just… Tony,” Gemma said, shrugging.
Freddy stared her down, waiting her out in silence.
Gemma sighed, giving in. “Okay. Tony and my brother Kyle grew up together—they were always causing trouble in our little town. He was at our house all the time. Out of all Kyle’s friends, Tony was always just… Tony. He looked out for me the way Kyle did, and then I think he started seeing me differently, but he never wanted to say anything. Now I’m here and he’s there. He’ll end up with someone else as soon as he forgets about me.”
“Tony’s just… Tony,” Gemma said, shrugging.
Freddy stared her down, waiting her out in silence.
Gemma sighed, giving in. “Okay. Tony and my brother Kyle grew up together—they were always causing trouble in our little town. He was at our house all the time. Out of all Kyle’s friends, Tony was always just… Tony. He looked out for me the way Kyle did, and then I think he started seeing me differently, but he never wanted to say anything. Now I’m here and he’s there. He’ll end up with someone else as soon as he forgets about me.”
Freddy turned serious. “So what about vacations, or other times you want to go home? He’ll still be there, right?”
“Yeah,” Gemma said quietly. “He’s part owner of KT Spirits with Kyle. But that doesn’t keep him from moving on.” She stared out the window, her thoughts drifting far away.
I’m sorry,” she blurted as she took her phone.“Pretty sure it was my fault—I was looking back and ran right into you.” He grinned, extending a hand before noticing her arms were full. “Chase.”She juggled her things, giving him a quick, apologetic smile. “Gemma. But I really have to go—I have, like, ten minutes and no idea where I’m going.”“Ah, a freshman,” he teased gently. “Good luck, Gemma.”She laughed, a little breathless. “Thanks. I’ll need it.”“Thanks, Chase—gonna need it!” she called over her shoulder as she hurried off, heart pounding, already late.The first week was like any first week—chaos. Lost rooms, unfindable classrooms that only seemed to appear after she finally broke down and asked for directions. Snack machine doughnuts, cafeteria food that was sometimes edible, and lots of shared laughter with Freddy.She spotted Chase only once more in passing midweek. He nodded at her with that dazzling smile, and she found herself smiling back before hurrying on to her next
Instead of going back to sleep after Freddy left, Gemma called her mom. Dee picked up on the second ring. “Hey, honey, is everything good?”“Just seeing if you guys made it home.” Gemma didn’t want to admit she just needed to hear her mom’s voice.“We just pulled into Florence a few minutes ago,” Deb replied. “Your dad and Kyle took turns driving on the way back—and I think they did a lot more than the speed limit when they caught me napping.”“Sounds like them. Try riding on the back of a motorcycle with Kyle sometime,” Gemma replied, rolling her eyes fondly.Dee laughed. “No thank you. That’s all you, sweetheart. Hang on, let me put you on speaker so you can say hey to your dad and brother.”“Hey, Bug,” her dad called.“Hey, Dad. Better slow down before you get a ticket,” she teased.Then came Kyle’s voice. “Thanks a lot, Gemma. Now I have to give Tony fifty bucks.”“Serves you right,” she shot back, grinning. She could practically see him close his eyes, pretending to be aggravated
By the time the bars started shutting down, Freddy told Gemma, “Well, that’s half of the ones I know. We’ll get to the next half next weekend.” They were linked arm in arm, giggling their way down the sidewalk.“I am starving,” Freddy declared.Gemma nodded, her stomach growling in agreement. “Same.”They headed toward the golden arches, only to find the lobby closed and the drive-thru the only option.Gemma stopped at the curb, eyeing the line of cars. “What are we supposed to do now?”Freddy grinned. “Follow my lead.”They joined a small crowd of other late-night bar goers—the only difference were they were in cars—slipping into the drive-thru lane on foot and advancing with the line as if they belonged there.Gemma lowered her voice. “Um, will they actually let us do this?”Freddy just winked. “We’re about to find out.”They walked up and stood at the glowing order speaker. Freddy leaned in, all confidence. “We’d like an order of fries and two chocolate shakes, please.”A crackling
The first bar they hit was loud and sticky, the air buzzing with music and laughter. Freddy hustled them into a game of darts with two frat boys—Chase and Ethan, both cocky in their backward caps and college hoodies.Freddy squinted at the board and let her dart fly. It bounced off the edge and landed in someone’s abandoned nachos.Ethan howled with laughter. “A bold strategy, Freddy!”“Guess I’ll try to keep it on the board.”Gemma tried not to laugh. She stepped up, feeling the familiar weight of the dart in her hand, the memory of a hundred slow nights at KT Spirits sharpening her aim. She threw—bullseye.Ethan whistled. “Beginner’s luck?”Gemma shrugged, a sly smile tugging at her lips. “Wanna bet?”Three throws later, the boys were groaning and Freddy was laughing. “Damn, girl,” Freddy said, slinging an arm around Gemma’s shoulders. “You are full of surprises.”Gemma just grinned, a blush warming her cheeks. She’d never been the center of attention like this before—at home, she’d
Gemma sat with her legs under her on her bed, waiting for Freddy to get out of the shower, absently scrolling through her phone while the bathroom fan hummed in the background.Her screen lit up with a text from Tony. Good morning, Shortcake. Your brother owes me fifty bucks. I won the bet.A small smile tugged at her lips before she could stop it. Bet? she typed back. What bet?Kyle bet me they’d have to turn around and come get you before they even made it home.“That asshole,” Gemma announced to the room.Freddy stepped out of the bathroom, towel wrapped around her, steam curling behind her. “Um… who are we mad at?” she asked, rifling through her drawer for clothes. She yanked the towel off her head and started aggressively drying her hair.“My brother,” Gemma said, glaring at her phone. “Apparently he bet Tony fifty bucks that they’d have to turn around and come get me before they even made it home.”Freddy snorted. “Okay, that’s actually kind of funny.”“It is not,” Gemma argued,
Tony stood at the bar, filling a mug of beer. He topped it off and sent it sliding down the counter, then leaned back, his eyes fixed on the door. Matt came up behind him, his voice low. "She’s not coming through that door anytime soon.""Who?""Whatever, dude. You know exactly who I’m talking about." Tony tried to move around him, but Matt wouldn’t budge. "Dude, don’t act like you don’t know.""Gemma? She’s just Kyle’s kid sister. That is it," Tony replied."You are so full of it," Matt said, throwing a bar rag over his shoulder. "Tell me this: if she went to school closer, where would you be? At Kyle’s—and not because of Kyle."Tony remained silent, shifting his gaze back to the rows of bottles behind the bar. He didn't know what to say to Matt because it was no secret how he felt; everyone could see it plainly. Admitting it out loud, however, was a hurdle he wasn't ready to clear, even to himself."Would you knock it off? There’s nothing between me and Gemma." Tony’s phone buzzed w







