Home / Romance / Shortcake / If You Stay You'll Never get Out

Share

If You Stay You'll Never get Out

Author: Sis Shepherd
last update publish date: 2026-05-17 10:11:26

"Maybe I'll be a hermit," Gemma said flatly.

Mandy's eyes glittered. "Well, Tony's not going to wait around forever. Somebody ought to keep him company while you're off writing poems." She tipped her cup toward Gemma like a toast. "Who knows? Maybe by Christmas I'll have a ring on my finger."

The cousins laughed. It was a small, sharp laugh, and it found its mark. The room narrowed to a pinhole. All Gemma could see was Mandy's face and the bright, satisfied shine in her eyes.

"Say that again," Gemma heard herself say.

Mandy gave her a slow, pitying look. "Tony deserves someone who's actually here. Someone who knows what she wants."

Gemma's fist moved before she decided to move it. It landed with a wet crunch. Mandy stumbled back, one hand clapped to her face, the other grabbing for the counter. Somebody gasped. Even the music seemed to fall away.

Gemma's knuckles throbbed. She had bitten down hard on the inside of her cheek, and she could taste copper. She barely noticed. Everyone was staring at her, waiting to see what she'd do next.

Kyle got to her first. His grip on her arm was iron. "Enough, Gem," he said through his teeth, and steered her toward the hall before anyone else could decide to get involved.

Behind them, Mandy's friends closed around her, a chorus of oh my God and is it broken. Gemma didn't look back. The noise of the party dimmed behind her with every step.

"What the hell was that?" Kyle hissed. "You promised Mom you'd

keep it together tonight."

Gemma wiped her hand on her jeans. The skin over her knuckles was split and already swelling. "It was nothing."

"You probably broke her nose."

"I doubt it," Gemma said, but she couldn't keep the satisfaction out of her voice.

Kyle sighed and let go of her at the end of the hall. "Just try not to start any more fights before midnight. Okay?"

She nodded without really hearing him. She slipped into her bedroom, locked the door and pressed her forehead against the cool drywall.

Breathe. In. Out.

It didn't help. The room tilted. The air was too thick, too close, and through the wall the party kept getting louder, the laughter meaner, the bass heavier. Her hands had started to shake. She knew the signs by now: the heat crawling under her skin, the sweat at her temples, her heartbeat pounding in her ears. The cafeteria all over again.

Not now. Not in front of everyone.

She crossed to the window and shoved it open. The night air poured in, cooler, full of crickets and the electric buzz of the streetlights. Below, the backyard sat empty. The burgers had run out an hour ago, and everyone had crowded inside around the kegs. Only the pool was still awake, glowing blue under the patio lights.

She needed out. She grabbed the blanket off her bed and her vape off the nightstand, swung one leg over the sill, and dropped into the grass. She kept to the side of the house, quick and quiet, until she reached the lawn chairs in the shadow of the garage.

The sky was clear, the stars sharp as broken glass. She wrapped herself in the blanket, sank into a chair and let out a long breath. For the first time all night, she let her face go slack.

If she closed her eyes, the party could be happening to someone else. She let herself picture it: standing up, walking to the highway, following it out of town and never looking back. It was the same thing she'd be doing in the morning. Somehow it felt completely different.

She took a long pull off the vape and held it. The air tasted like chlorine and cut grass and, faintly, the burnt-sugar smell of the Labor Day fireworks, still hanging around a week later.

She heard Tony before she saw him, his boots scuffing the concrete. He stopped at the edge of the pool, a silhouette against the porch light, and looked at her for a long moment. Then he came over and sat on the foot of her chair. He didn't say anything.

Gemma kept her eyes on the sky and tracked a satellite as it slid between the stars. Part of her hoped he'd just get up and leave.

"You okay?" he asked.

She laughed, a dry rasp. "Not really."

"I saw what happened."

"Everybody saw."

"She had it coming." His voice was even. "You might want to ice that hand, though."

Gemma flexed her fingers. The knuckles had puffed up red, but the ache felt far away, an echo of something bigger. "Maybe later."

They sat in the quiet, watching the light move across the water. Inside, somebody started chanting her name, and it bounced off the walls and spilled out into the yard. Gemma winced.

"Was she serious?" she asked. "About you and her?"

Tony didn't answer right away. He picked at a loose thread on the blanket, winding it around his finger until the tip went white.

"You have to go," he said finally. "To Colorado. You know that, right?"

It wasn't an answer. She noticed that he hadn't given her one.

She bit the inside of her cheek, right where it was already raw. "I know."

"If you stay, you'll never get out." He said it to the pool, not to her. "I'd know."

Gemma looked down at the vape, rolling it between her palms. "I tried, Tony. I really did." Her voice came out small. "She got in my head anyway. What if I go out there and everything changes? What if I come home and you're gone?"

He didn't answer that either.

She took a long, slow pull, strawberry vapor curling in her lungs. Without thinking, she turned and blew the cloud right in his face. It was an old trick, one she'd pulled a hundred times just to get a rise out of him.

Usually he'd wave it off and grumble that she was going to rot her lungs, or worse, that brain of hers, with all that THC. Tonight he only smiled, eyes locked on hers. Instead of pulling back, he leaned in and caught the cloud in one slow, deliberate breath, like a dare, until there was almost no space left between them.

Continue to read this book for free
Scan code to download App

Latest chapter

  • Shortcake   Chase was a Friend-A Good One

    The next Thursday, at their table under the sagging window, Chase turned his phone around to show her his calendar. Every Thursday from seven to ten was blocked off in blue for the rest of the semester. One letter: G."I cleared these," he said. "Thursdays are ours. I need you to protect them too, okay? This only works if we both take it seriously.""Of course," she said. "Yeah. Of course."Freddy had mentioned a movie night on the second floor next Thursday. Gemma had already said maybe. She'd text her later.Chase smiled and slid her newest draft across the table. Green ink covered the first page. In the margin beside her ending, he'd written: Almost. You're so close to being great.She bent over the pages, already reaching for her pen, already wanting to close the gap.It didn't feel like losing anything. It felt like being chosen.***October came in cold, and the nights got long.Thursdays stopped ending at ten. They closed down the library reading room, and when the librarian fl

  • Shortcake   Not Your Closet

    The night of that very first dinner at Juniper, she'd called Tony from the window seat, still a little warm from the wine. The bar noise came through the phone, and the jukebox, and Kyle yelling at somebody in the background about a tab."Guess what I had for dinner," she said."Let me guess. Sonic.""Duck." She pulled one leg under herself. "With cherry sauce. And this cheese thing called burrata, it's like mozzarella but it's got cream inside, you'd hate it. And wine. One glass. At a place with tablecloths."There was a pause on the line. Then Tony laughed, warm and low. "Duck? Like from the pond? You used to cry when your daddy went out after the mallards.""It's different. It's French.""Uh-huh. Who took you to the French duck place?""Just a friend from the program." She didn't know why she said it that way. A friend. She didn't say Chase. She didn't say he. "A bunch of us went.""Well." She could hear him smiling. "Next time you're home, I'll take you out to the pond and get you

  • Shortcake   She Couldn't Remember.

    The fourth favor was dinner."You've been here a month," Chase said at the end of their Thursday session, packing up his tablet. "Where have you eaten?"Gemma counted on her fingers. "The dining hall. The pizza place. The Sonic out on the highway. That burger place across from the bookstore." She thought. "Oh, and the Taco Bell. Twice."Chase stared at her like she'd confessed to a crime. "That's it?""What's wrong with Sonic? Sonic has tots.""Nothing's wrong with Sonic." He was trying not to laugh. "Sonic is fine. Sonic is a national treasure. But Gemma." He leaned across the table. "There's a whole world out there that isn't fried and served in a paper bag. Saturday. I'm taking you to dinner. A real one."He took her to a place called Juniper, on a side street downtown, in an old brick building that had once been a bank. The windows were tall and dark, and the tables were small and close together, with white tablecloths and little candles in glass jars, and every single person in t

  • Shortcake   The Flu Sweater

    The third favor was the sweater.It was the last week of September, and the mornings had started to turn cold in a way Oklahoma mornings never did, the air thin and bright and smelling like pine. Gemma had dug out the sweater her mother had knit her the Christmas she was sixteen. It was a big, soft, mustard-yellow cable-knit, with a slightly lopsided collar where Dee had dropped a stitch and decided she liked it. Gemma had worn it to every football game her junior and senior years. It smelled like her mother's cedar chest. She wore it to the library for their Thursday session.Chase looked up when she sat down. He looked at her for a moment longer than usual. Then he set his stylus down."Can I say something," he said, "and you won't throw your coffee at me?"She laughed. "Depends on what it is.""That color." He tilted his head, studying her the way he studied a paragraph. "It's doing you no favors."Gemma looked down at herself. "My mom made this.""I can tell. It's beautiful. The

  • Shortcake   Friends in Low Places

    On Thursday, at their table under the sagging window, Chase pulled up an email on his tablet and turned it around to show her."Friday night," he said. "Dr. Hale's reading from her new collection at the library. Seven o'clock, in the reading room. Very small, invite-only, mostly faculty and the journal staff. She asked me to bring you specifically." His eyes were bright. "Gem, you're going to love it. She's reading the one about her mother's hands. It's the best thing she's ever written."Gemma looked at the email. Then she looked up."I can't," she said. "I'm going to the bonfire with Freddy."Chase laughed, like she'd made a joke. "The football thing?""The football thing.""Gemma." He said it patiently, the way you'd talk to a kid who wanted cake for dinner. "It's a bunch of drunk freshmen standing around a fire. You can do that any night of the week. This is Hale. This is a room full of people who could change your whole life.""I know." She made herself keep looking at him. "But

  • Shortcake   He's Just Thoughtful

    She'd come out of Forms of Creative Nonfiction at two in the afternoon, dragging, and there he'd be on the bench outside Hawthorne Hall with a second cup, iced this time, because it had been a warm day. She'd stay up until one rewriting a paragraph for workshop and walk into the library the next morning gray-faced and squinting, and before she'd even set her bag down, the cup would be sliding across the table toward her. On the first truly cold morning, when frost furred the grass on the quad and Gemma came out of the guesthouse in a hoodie because she hadn't unpacked her coat yet, he was waiting on the steps with a hot chocolate. Three pumps of caramel. Extra whipped cream. A crosshatch on top."Too cold for espresso," he said, handing it over. "Even for you."She never once saw him buy them. She never saw him stand in line at Marco's cart. They were just there, warm in her hands, whenever she needed one. Sometimes before she knew she needed one.She didn't think it was weird. Not rea

  • Shortcake   Freddy

    Tony stood at the bar, filling a mug of beer. He topped it off and sent it sliding down the counter, then leaned back, his eyes fixed on the door. Matt came up behind him, his voice low. "She’s not coming through that door anytime soon.""Who?""Whatever, dude. You know exactly who I’m talking abou

  • Shortcake   All Moved In

    The following morning, as they gathered their belongings, Dee’s voice cut through the sound of the alarm. “Gemma, if you’re planning to shower before we hit the road, you’d better get to it now.”“No thanks. I’m avoiding the shower as long as possible,” Gemma replied, tugging Tony’s sweatshirt back

  • Shortcake   Hotel

    When they pulled over for fuel and snacks, the reality of Dee's planning set in; they wouldn't be eating any real food until they reached the hotel. "You know we can't mess with Mom's schedule," Kyle remarked as he climbed back into the U-Haul, tossing a bag of chips to his sister.Gemma held the b

  • Shortcake   Goodbyes

    The house was full of music, and more than half the town. Gemma Havley’s family had gone all out for her going-away party. She was leaving small-town Florence, Oklahoma, for college in Bronson, Colorado. It was already going to be a big change for her, and she hated change. But her English teacher,

More Chapters
Explore and read good novels for free
Free access to a vast number of good novels on GoodNovel app. Download the books you like and read anywhere & anytime.
Read books for free on the app
SCAN CODE TO READ ON APP
DMCA.com Protection Status