Share

Chapter 3

Author: Ardern
Satisfaction curved Ryan's mouth.

"Good. You could never wear a dress like that again. Making it would only waste money."

He reached for my shoulder.

I stepped aside without comment, changed clothes, and walked Rachel to the elevator myself.

Before the doors closed, Ryan pushed a straw into a carton of oat milk and handed it to Sophie.

"You can't handle dairy. Drink this instead."

I was lactose intolerant too.

It was the first time he'd ever bought oat milk, and he'd bought it for someone else.

"Hannah, is that girl your friend?

"I don't mean to interfere, but Ryan brought Sophie to my store two days ago and bought more than thirty outfits. Some were casual, some formal. He said it didn't matter that she couldn't wear most of them to graduation.

"So why'd he call your reception dress a waste? Once you remove the wedding label, it's just a red evening dress."

Rachel held the dress with open disbelief.

I remembered the graduation robe Sophie had worn beside Ryan in her posts.

She'd been required to wear that robe, yet Ryan had still been happy to buy thirty other outfits for later.

I said nothing and transferred payment to Rachel.

"No. You canceled the order. I can't take your money."

"Your time still cost something. Besides, I need you to help me with one thing."

I didn't go back upstairs. I went straight to work.

When I returned that evening, Sophie was gone and Ryan was showering.

I packed my belongings in the bedroom. As I rolled the suitcase into the study, Ryan appeared in the doorway, rubbing a towel over his hair.

"I've barely slept these past few days. I spent today helping Sophie find a new apartment.

"I'm going to bed. You should turn in early too."

He entered the main bedroom, then looked back in surprise.

"Han, did you wash the wedding quilt and linens?"

I nodded.

His brows drew together in disapproval.

"You're not planning to put that old red wedding set on the bed, are you?"

"It looks dated. I'm not sleeping in it."

He backed out, yawned, and headed into the guest room.

"Sleep in it yourself if you like it. I'll stay in here until you change everything back."

The door closed.

The guest room was red too.

It was simply the warm tomato red Sophie liked.

For the last six months, Ryan had brought her home constantly while helping with her graduate thesis.

He'd personally taken her shopping and chosen the bedding she preferred.

Tacky or attractive. Comfortable or impossible to sleep in.

He didn't have a fixed standard for any of it.

He merely had one standard for Sophie and another for me.

I packed through the entire night.

At dawn, the quilt and linens were dry. I folded them carefully and placed them in my suitcase.

Then I went into the living room and took an old photograph from the drawer.

It showed my mother standing beside Ryan's.

They'd been close friends and coworkers before they died in the Harrow Mill fire.

Before my mother died, she told me she'd sewn the quilt by hand as a wedding gift.

Ryan's mother had left him a brooch and asked him to give it to his future wife.

Ryan and I had met at their joint memorial service.

Whenever we spoke of our mothers afterward, grief had always brought us closer.

He once promised to pin that brooch onto my dress at our wedding.

Now the wedding was canceled, and the brooch belonged to someone else.

The guest-room door suddenly opened. Ryan stepped out rubbing his eyes, his voice flat.

"Why didn't you wake me? I'm helping Sophie move today."

A crushing weight settled over my chest.

I hadn't intended to ask, but I couldn't stop myself.

"Why did you give Sophie the brooch?"

His fingers paused, and he frowned.

"Why shouldn't she wear it? She needed something for her graduation photos, and it looked good on her."

"Your mother left that for-"

"Hannah, when did you become so superstitious and old-fashioned?"

His scolding tone pinned me in place.

"It's one brooch. It would only collect dust in a box, so I gave it to someone who could use it.

"And can't you stop turning everything into a ceremony? Life moves forward. Isn't it exhausting to keep clinging to objects and old promises?"
Continue to read this book for free
Scan code to download App

Latest chapter

  • The Things He Withheld   Chapter 10

    "Ryan, you don't need to change. You did those things for Sophie because you wanted to. With me, they felt like work. You were exhausted, and so was I."He stood among the crowd while everyone else watched the sky. His eyes never left me."I didn't come to argue. I came to tell you I truly understand how wrong I was.""You understand because I left. Had I stayed, you'd still call me dramatic and dismiss everything I loved as empty pageantry."He stepped closer and pulled something from his pocket, trying to press it into my palm."Han, I got the brooch back. My mother meant it for you."I withdrew my hand, and the brooch fell onto the grass."No, Ryan. She meant it for your wife, and I'm not her."He bent quickly, picked it up, and closed his fingers around it."I'm sorry.""You've said that many times. You should save one apology for your mother."If she could have heard what you said about the last gift she left, it would have broken her heart."Instructions sounded throu

  • The Things He Withheld   Chapter 9

    I only smiled and said nothing.One afternoon, I came across a viral video online.It was the same clip Sophie had posted after graduation.Ryan stood in a suit, thanking everyone for looking after her.The comments overflowed with excitement."Where do I find a mentor like this?""He's more romantic for her graduation than my boyfriend is for my birthday. He complains about buying one cake, and this man ordered three tiers.""Are you two together yet? He obviously loves you. It'd be criminal not to date him."My finger paused, then I scrolled past.A few days later, Sophie called me for the first time.Her voice was hoarse when I answered."Hannah, Ryan won't speak to me. He says the video damaged his life and forced me to delete my account, but it was real footage. I didn't generate it."Now he's angry and refuses to help me. He promised to find me a job, but I've heard nothing."Please help me."I continued editing a work document."Help you with what?"Her energy re

  • The Things He Withheld   Chapter 8

    Rachel frowned at him."Ryan, Hannah's gone.""That's impossible. She wouldn't leave without saying anything.""She did say goodbye. She celebrated her twenty-eighth birthday with us, then left."Ryan stopped breathing.His mouth opened slowly."Her birthday... when was it?""Yesterday."Rachel rolled her eyes. "You didn't know?"The room seemed to tilt around him.Yesterday, he'd told Hannah she embarrassed him and made his life exhausting.Then he'd picked up Sophie's parents, spent the evening drinking with them, and stayed at the hotel until morning.He'd become accustomed to Hannah being understanding and undemanding.No cake for her birthday. No anniversary dinner. Everything could be kept simple.So he'd forgotten the date entirely."Did... did you celebrate with her?""Obviously. Who else was going to do it?"Rachel tapped her phone and showed him a video.Hannah sat at the center of a round table with a modest cake in front of her.When she closed her eyes t

  • The Things He Withheld   Chapter 7

    "Hannah used to keep all kinds of things here. There was always a single flower in a tiny vase, and she changed the picture in that frame every few days."She also had a desk calendar. The first thing she did every morning was turn the page because she said it made time feel real."And she kept a stack of notes about good restaurants. Whenever someone in the office had a birthday, Hannah was the one who booked the table."Then, little by little, all of it disappeared."The employee sighed, clearly saddened by the memory.Ryan stood speechless.He remembered the small vases Hannah used to place around their old rental, changing the water every day and replacing each flower when it wilted.One week she bought sunflowers. The next, pale lisianthus.Ryan had called the habit fussy and inconvenient until she put the vases away.He never saw them again.She'd also researched a different restaurant for almost every date.Some were suited to birthdays, some to anniversaries, and som

  • The Things He Withheld   Chapter 6

    The moment he pushed her away, Sophie lunged forward and wrapped both arms around his waist."Why do you refuse to understand what I'm saying?"Hannah didn't come, but I did. I brought my driver's license, my birth certificate, everything we'd need. I even wore the veil. You could marry me instead."People entering and leaving the courthouse turned to stare.Ryan went rigid.He threw both hands into the air, his arms locked because he had no idea where else to put them.Yet Sophie's words unsettled him far more than her embrace.As her grip tightened, he forced himself to shove her away."What are you talking about? I can't marry you. I was your graduate mentor.""So what? There's no rule against it. You don't love Hannah anyway. You even waited until my graduation ceremony ended before you went to your own engagement dinner."Ryan's temple began to pound.Was that why Hannah was angry enough to miss the ceremony?Why hadn't she simply asked? He could have explained.Sophi

  • The Things He Withheld   Chapter 5

    After drinking too much, Ryan woke in the hotel with a splitting headache.He forced himself through breakfast with Sophie's parents, then helped Sophie walk Milo.As his mind slowly cleared, he remembered that today was his courthouse appointment.His head rang.The civil ceremony had been scheduled for ten. It was already eleven.He shoved the leash into Sophie's hand and drove straight to the Alder County Courthouse.At a red light, he sent Hannah a message."Traffic's terrible. I'll be a little late."By the time he ran inside, she still hadn't replied.Ryan hissed under his breath, rubbing his temple with one hand while typing with the other."I'm here. Where are you? Are you late too?""Send me your location. I'll come get you if I have to.""Hannah, why aren't you answering?""Is this because of what I said yesterday? Fine, I admit I was harsh. But you know I've hated ceremonies since I was a kid. I've never given a formal toast in my life. Your father put me on the

More Chapters
Explore and read good novels for free
Free access to a vast number of good novels on GoodNovel app. Download the books you like and read anywhere & anytime.
Read books for free on the app
SCAN CODE TO READ ON APP
DMCA.com Protection Status