Why Is 'Batman: The Killing Joke' Controversial Among Fans?

2025-06-18 07:22:58 219

3 answers

Ruby
Ruby
2025-06-21 05:32:14
As someone who's read 'Batman: The Killing Joke' multiple times, the controversy boils down to Barbara Gordon's treatment. The story reduces her to a plot device, getting shot and paralyzed just to motivate Batman and her father. It feels cheap, especially for such a pivotal character. The Joker's backstory is brilliant, but Barbara's arc is shock value without depth. Many fans expected better from Alan Moore, known for complex narratives. The artwork is stunning, but the story's misstep with Barbara overshadows its brilliance. It's a divisive read—love it or hate it, but you can't ignore its impact.
Hannah
Hannah
2025-06-24 13:47:23
The controversy surrounding 'Batman: The Killing Joke' is multilayered, and here's why it sparks heated debates. The graphic novel's exploration of the Joker's origin is undeniably masterful, painting him as a tragic figure who 'had one bad day.' This psychological depth contrasts sharply with how Barbara Gordon is handled. Her assault and paralysis are framed as collateral damage, a means to push Jim Gordon to his limits. Many argue this diminishes her agency, reducing her from a hero to a victim.

Another issue is the tonal shift. The story's bleakness, particularly the sexualized violence, feels gratuitous to some readers. While it aims to show the Joker's chaos, it crosses into exploitation for others. The animated adaptation doubled down on this, adding unnecessary subplots that diluted the core narrative. Yet, fans of the book praise its raw, unfiltered take on madness and morality. The art by Brian Bolland is iconic, with every panel dripping with tension. It's a polarizing work—either you appreciate its bold strokes or recoil at its choices.
Jack
Jack
2025-06-21 12:20:32
Let's cut to the chase: 'Batman: The Killing Joke' is controversial because it's a double-edged sword. On one side, you have the Joker's origin—a haunting, almost poetic look at how tragedy can break a man. It's compelling stuff, making him more than just a clown. On the flip side, Barbara Gordon's storyline feels like a betrayal. She's Batgirl, a symbol of resilience, yet here she's sidelined brutally. The narrative doesn't explore her trauma; it uses it.

The book's legacy is messy. Some hail it as a dark masterpiece, while others see it as a missed opportunity. The animated movie tried to 'fix' things by adding Barbara's pre-Joker arc, but it only highlighted the original's flaws. What stings most is how the story could've balanced both characters better. The Joker's philosophy clashes with Batman's ideals beautifully, but Barbara's role leaves a bitter taste. It's a must-read for the debate alone, but prepare to wrestle with its choices.
Lihat Semua Jawaban
Pindai kode untuk mengunduh Aplikasi

Related Books

FANS
FANS
[Romance Comedy] Hidup sebagai Niki yang cantik dan kaya raya membuat kehidupan Nara berubah 360 derajat. Nara tak tahu apa yang terjadi, namun keadaan memaksanya untuk hidup bersama Jason seorang penyanyi dan aktor terkenal yang banyak diidolakan banyak wanita dari remaja hingga orang tua. Mulanya Nara merasa canggung menjalani perannya sebagai Niki. Kejadian-kejadian lucu pun sering kali terjadi karena ketidaktahuannya tentang kehidupan Niki. Lewat perannya, Nara jadi tahu banyak fakta tentang kehidupan Jason yang ingin sekali ia ungkapkan pada Dita adiknya yang begitu mengidolakan Jason, atau bahkan pada semua FANSnya.
Belum ada penilaian
28 Chapters
Gadis Cacat Pilihan CEO
Gadis Cacat Pilihan CEO
Maya Angelita adalah top model terkenal, ia merasa hidupnya hancur setelah mengalami kecelakaan yang membuat kedua kakinya lumpuh. Saat dia membutuhkan dukungan dari orang yang dia cintai, calon suaminya justru membatalkan pernikahan mereka. Seorang perawat yang dipekerjakan oleh mamanya Maya membuat gadis itu kembali bersemangat untuk menjalani hidup. Namanya Ananda Kusuma. Sebuah salah paham yang awalnya membuat Maya kesal, dia ingin perawat perempuan bukan laki-laki yang membuatnya jengah. Sayangnya Ananda Kusuma ini berjenis kelamin laki-laki. Apa jadinya bila sebenarnya si perawat itu adalah seorang CEO yang pernah menjadi fans Maya tanpa ia ketahui? Akankah cinta Ananda membuat Maya sembuh dari lumpuhnya? Andaikan Maya menjadi cacat seumur hidup, maukah sang CEO menerima wanita yang tak sempurna itu untuk menjadi pendamping hidupnya?
10
111 Chapters
Skandal Cinta Dokter Annastacia
Skandal Cinta Dokter Annastacia
Dokter Annastacia Brighton adalah seorang dokter bedah cantik berusia 30 tahun, dia populer di antara sesama dokter di almamaternya, tapi dia terlalu berdedikasi dengan profesinya sehingga tidak tertarik berpacaran. Hingga suatu malam dia dalam keadaan mabuk mengalami one night stand bersama seorang popstar sekaligus model pria terkenal yang memiliki banyak fans fanatik, Jason Channing atau biasa disebut JC. Sementara ayah Dokter Annastacia mengatur perjodohan untuk puterinya itu dengan putera koleganya yaitu Dokter John Baldere. Klan Bardere adalah pemilik dari Wyndham Hospital International, tempat Dokter Annastacia dan keluarganya bekerja saat ini. Dokter cantik ini pun bingung, siapa yang harus dia pilih si tampan yang menggoda atau sang penguasa tempat dia bekerja? Baik John maupun JC tak ingin mundur, mereka keras kepala dan ingin cinta Annastacia sekalipun harus menimbulkan skandal.
10
91 Chapters
MENGEJAR CINTA IDOLA
MENGEJAR CINTA IDOLA
Velope Pranaja adalah artis populer masa kini. Ia mempunyai banyak fans di kalangan remaja dan pria kelas atas. Salah satu penggemar fanatiknya adalah Leonardo Atmaja, seorang penerus dari perusahaan perhiasan terkenal di ibu kota. Leonardo sangat menyukai Velope sampai ingin menjalanin hubungan cinta dengannya. Namun, cinta mereka di tentang oleh Tuan Besar Atmaja. Terlebih, Leonardo telah dijodohkan dengan anak dari teman sesama pengusaha. Apakah Leon akan menyerah begitu saja karena cintanya tidak direstui keluarga? Lalu pada akhirnya apakah Leon dan Velope akan bisa bersama, walau cinta mereka terhalang restu dan status?
9.9
118 Chapters
Mr. Airlangga
Mr. Airlangga
Daaaarrr ! Lagi-lagi suara petir, biarpun aku nggak terlonjak seperti tadi tapi cukup bikin hati lumayan ngenes. Dengan kecepatan siput seperti ini jam berapa aku akan sampai Jakarta. Aku mendesah sedih, desahan yang sia-sia karena cuman aku sendiri yang tahu. Bruukkk ! Aku kaget lima kepalang. Aku menabrak sesuatu? Buru-buru aku melankah ke depan mobil, ingin melihat apa yang tadi sepertinya aku tabrak. Noooooo…..orang? Ada orang…eh laki-laki jatuh tertunduk di depan mobilku. “Tempat apa ini?” akhirnya dia berbicara. Pheeeww…aku menarik nafas lega, minimal dia bisa berbicara, coba kalau dia ternyata tidak bisa berbicara dan aku tidak tahu menahu bahasa isyarat bagaimana kita akan berkomunikasi coba? “Bandung….” Jawabku ragu-ragu, aku tidak yakin apa maksud pertanyaan dia dengan “tempat apa ini”, apa maksudnya kita di mana? Aku yakin sih aku belum meninggalkan bandung. “Bandung? Apa itu nama desa?” Hah…dia tidak tau Bandung? Mati gue, jangan-jangan tabrakan tandi membuat dia gegar otak. Sekarang dia mengalami amnesia dan tidak tahu siapa dirinya, tidak tahu apapun! Terus apa yang harus aku lakukan? Tiba-tiba aku ingat film Jason Bourne, dimana dia mengalami amnesia setelah tertembak dan jatuh ke laut. Tetapi lelaki ini bukan Jason Bourne, tapi dari postur badan dan wajahnya bisa saja lho dia menjadi the next Jason Bourne. Aarrrgghhh gue ngelantur lagi. “Mas ingat namanya siapa?” ok, pertanyaan basic untuk memastikan apakah dia amnesia atau bukan. “Gajah Mada” jawabnya singkat. Aku dengan refleks menyunggingkan senyum kecil, pasti emak bapak si emas ini adalah fans berat patih maha tersohor dari Majapahit tersebut. “Kenapa kamu tersenyum?” tanyanya membuyarkan lamunanku.
10
46 Chapters
Forgotten You
Forgotten You
"Sepertinya kita langsung mulai aja, Naz, gue udah enggak tahan." Karisma memegang celana pendeknya untuk segera diturunkan. Gadis itu terbelalak. Wajahnya terlihat panik kala menangkap sinyal aneh dari Karisma yang nampaknya serius akan melakukan hal keji tersebut padanya. Nazmi Alisya, seorang model terkenal yang memiliki tubuh ideal impian semua wanita di dunia. Paras menawan dengan bibir mungil merona membuat semua pria selalu terpikat dengan senyuman sensualnya. Tak terkecuali dengan Karisma dan Geri, dua lelaki yang masih kukuh saling merebut gadis cantik nan polos tersebut. Belum lagi Fahmi, seorang fans berat Nazmi yang selalu meneror hubungan gadis itu dengan siapa pun dia dekat. Karisma bukan hanya piawai bermain musik, tapi juga pandai dalam merebut hati Nazmi untuk selalu menuruti apa mau lelaki itu. Bahkan saat Nazmi akan menikah dengan Geri sekalipun, tetap saja Karisma dengan keras kepalanya melakukan segala cara untuk mendapatkan Nazmi kembali. Termasuk memiliki tubuh gadis cantik itu. Sebuah ide gila yang sempat terlintas beberapa bulan lalu. Menghamili Nazmi. Akankah Karisma berhasil merebut Nazmi dari Geri? Siapa yang akan dipilih Nazmi untuk menjadi suaminya? Lalu bagaimana dengan nasib percintaan mereka karena tentu Fahmi juga akan menghalalkan segala cara untuk terus mencuri perhatian sang idol cantik tersebut.
10
183 Chapters

Related Questions

Who Wrote And Illustrated 'Batman: The Killing Joke'?

3 answers2025-06-18 04:17:03
The legendary 'Batman: The Killing Joke' was crafted by Alan Moore, one of the most influential writers in comic history, with stunning artwork by Brian Bolland. Moore's writing digs deep into the Joker's twisted psychology, making this one of the most chilling Batman stories ever told. Bolland's illustrations are just as iconic, with every panel dripping with tension and that unforgettable final scene that still sparks debates decades later. Their collaboration created a masterpiece that redefined how dark superhero stories could go, blending philosophy with brutal violence in a way that few comics had dared before.

Does 'Batman: The Killing Joke' Have An Animated Adaptation?

3 answers2025-06-18 02:21:27
Yeah, 'Batman: The Killing Joke' got the animated treatment back in 2016. It’s a pretty faithful adaptation of Alan Moore’s iconic graphic novel, with Kevin Conroy and Mark Hamill reprising their roles as Batman and Joker—which is a huge win for fans. The animation style stays close to the original’s gritty aesthetic, and the voice acting elevates the psychological tension. The added prologue focusing on Batgirl’s perspective sparked debate, but it fleshes out her character more than the comic did. The R-rated approach lets them keep the dark themes intact, especially Joker’s brutal assault on Barbara. If you’re into noir-ish, psychological thrillers, this one’s worth watching.

Is 'Batman: The Killing Joke' Canon In The DC Universe?

3 answers2025-06-18 05:47:00
As someone who's followed DC comics for years, 'Batman: The Killing Joke' occupies a weird space in canon. The original graphic novel was initially a standalone story, but its impact was so massive that elements became ingrained in the Batman mythos. Barbara Gordon's paralysis and her transformation into Oracle got folded into main continuity. The Joker's backstory here is often referenced but remains ambiguous - even within the story itself. DC's multiverse approach means it's simultaneously canon and not, depending on which version of Batman we're talking about. The animated adaptation took liberties that further muddy the waters, blending it with other timelines.

How Does 'Batman: The Killing Joke' Redefine Joker'S Origin?

3 answers2025-06-18 23:53:54
The graphic novel 'Batman: The Killing Joke' gives the Joker a tragic yet ambiguous backstory that makes him more complex than just a madman. This version suggests he was once a failed comedian who turned to crime out of desperation, only for one bad day to break him completely. The story plays with the idea that anyone could become the Joker under enough pressure, blurring the line between sanity and madness. His origin isn't presented as factual but as one possible story, adding layers to his unpredictability. The artwork and writing combine to show how pain can twist someone into a monster, making him eerily relatable yet terrifying.

What Happens To Barbara Gordon In 'Batman: The Killing Joke'?

3 answers2025-06-18 20:35:57
Barbara Gordon's story in 'Batman: The Killing Joke' is one of the most brutal moments in comic history. The Joker shoots her through the spine, paralyzing her from the waist down. This isn't just physical trauma—he strips her naked and photographs her broken body to torment her father, Commissioner Gordon. The attack is vile, but what's remarkable is how Barbara rebuilds herself. She doesn't stay a victim. Later stories show her becoming Oracle, a tech genius who coordinates the entire superhero community from her wheelchair. Her intelligence and resilience turn personal horror into something impactful. The comic doesn't shy away from showing how dark the Joker can get, but Barbara's legacy proves that even the worst moments can be overcome.

What Batman X Joker Fanfics Mirror The Emotional Intensity Of ‘The Killing Joke’?

2 answers2025-05-20 21:29:36
As someone who's spent countless nights diving into the twisted dynamics of Batman and Joker fanfics, I can confidently say there are gems that rival 'The Killing Joke' in emotional depth. One standout is 'A Beautiful Madness,' where the Joker's descent into chaos is painted with heartbreaking vulnerability, mirroring the tragic backstory from the comic. The fic explores his fractured psyche through surreal, almost poetic monologues, while Batman grapples with his own moral compass, torn between justice and pity. Another haunting piece is 'Laughing in the Dark,' which reimagines their relationship as a toxic codependency, with Joker teetering between obsession and self-destruction. The writer uses Gotham's gothic atmosphere to amplify the tension, making every confrontation feel like a dance on the edge of sanity. Then there's 'Crimson Smile,' a fic that flips the script by giving Joker moments of eerie clarity, where he questions his own existence. Batman's internal struggle is laid bare here, as he wrestles with the idea that maybe, just maybe, he’s as broken as the man he’s trying to stop. The emotional intensity peaks in scenes where Joker’s laughter turns into sobs, and Batman’s fists unclench for a fleeting second. These stories don’t just mimic 'The Killing Joke'—they expand on its themes, weaving in fresh layers of psychological torment and existential dread. For fans craving that raw, unfiltered emotion, these fics are a must-read.

What Is The Answer To The Candice Joke

3 answers2025-03-26 06:11:04
The Candice joke is a play on words that's kind of hilarious. It's usually about someone asking, 'Hey, have you heard of Candice?' and then someone falls for it, leading to the punchline, which plays on their name sounding like 'Can this' as in 'Can this joke get any better?' It's all in good fun and relies on the delivery, catching people off guard and making them chuckle at how silly it is!

What Do You Put In A Toaster Joke

3 answers2025-03-14 17:29:20
I like to say, 'What do you call a toaster that likes to tell jokes? A toasted comedian!' It's silly but it always brings a giggle. Sometimes, a pun is the best way to slice through the morning routine, right? When I'm not busy, it brings me such joy to share jokes with friends over breakfast!
Jelajahi dan baca novel bagus secara gratis
Akses gratis ke berbagai novel bagus di aplikasi GoodNovel. Unduh buku yang kamu suka dan baca di mana saja & kapan saja.
Baca buku gratis di Aplikasi
Pindai kode untuk membaca di Aplikasi
DMCA.com Protection Status