Why Is 'Civilization And Its Discontents' Considered Controversial?

2025-06-17 17:15:03 30

4 answers

Ursula
Ursula
2025-06-20 15:35:11
Freud's 'Civilization and Its Discontents' sparks debate because it challenges the very fabric of societal harmony. He argues that civilization demands repression—our instincts for aggression and sexual freedom clash with communal order, creating chronic dissatisfaction. Critics slam this as overly pessimistic, reducing human progress to a mere battle against primal urges. The book’s bold claim that religion is an 'illusion' to cope with existential terror also ruffled feathers, especially among theologians. Freud’s dark lens on human nature feels reductive to some, ignoring altruism and cultural creativity.

Yet, others praise its raw honesty. By framing society as a necessary but stifling force, Freud articulates a tension we all feel but rarely voice. His ideas on the superego policing desires resonate in modern discussions about mental health. The controversy lies in its uncomfortable truths: civilization isn’t just a triumph; it’s a negotiated surrender.
Addison
Addison
2025-06-19 23:14:53
This book’s a lightning rod because Freud dismantles rosy ideals about progress. He posits that our ‘civilized’ rules—monogamy, laws, even art—are just Band-Aids over innate savagery. It’s provocative to suggest that Michelangelo’s sculptures or Beethoven’s symphonies stem from sublimated aggression. The backlash? Many argue he undervalues human empathy. His take on religion as collective neurosis especially irked scholars, calling it reductive. But fans counter that Freud nails the paradox: society protects us yet cages our wildest selves. It’s divisive because it forces us to question if our ‘advancements’ are truly liberating or just elaborate constraints.
Paige
Paige
2025-06-22 22:11:53
'Civilization and Its Discontents' is controversial for its unflinching take on human suffering. Freud insists that societal norms create inner conflict—our need for love wars with selfish impulses, and guilt becomes the price of belonging. The book’s dismissal of religion as a childish crutch shocked readers. Yet, its exploration of the death drive (our subconscious pull toward chaos) feels eerily relevant today, from political unrest to environmental destruction. Critics say Freud ignores joy; supporters call it a necessary mirror.
Violet
Violet
2025-06-18 10:26:59
Freud’s book rattled cages by framing civilization as a double-edged sword. It suppresses our darkest desires but leaves us restless. His blunt take—that even science and art are born from frustration—angers optimists. The religious critique feels dated now, but the core idea still stings: we’re never truly free, just better at hiding our chains. It’s short, dense, and deliberately provocative, designed to unsettle.
모든 답변 보기
QR 코드를 스캔하여 앱을 다운로드하세요

Related Books

Auctioned to my Brother's Bestfriend
Auctioned to my Brother's Bestfriend
"50 million dollars"The words hang in the air and Angelica Smith was auctioned to Damien Victor.Kidnapped and sold, the first shock came to her when she learned that her bidder was none other than her brother's best friend.Little did she know that it was only the first of many dark secrets that were yet to be revealed because he was no longer the same man whom she used to admire in her teenage years.The one who can never see a scratch on her skin wanted to leave such deep marks that she remembers her whole life and she wasn't even sure why he was taking revenge on her.What would happen when she learned about his hidden intentions?Will she ever be able to come out of his cage or will she remain his plaything?✿✿✿✿✿✿✿'No one can hurt, touch, see, or feel you except me. You are mine, Tesoro. I will break you until you don't accept it' ~ Damien Victor 'You can have my body, not my soul. I will never submit to you, even if you kill me' ~ Angelica Smith ××××××××Features highly mature content 🔞
9.5
125 Chapters
LunaLola-The Moon Wolf
LunaLola-The Moon Wolf
"You're the moon wolf, Lola. You're the wolf with the power of the Moon goddess", Serena said and collective gasps were heard in the room. After being rejected by her mate in Moonlit pack, Lola escaped on a full moon only to enter the territory of the next Alpha King who also happened to be her second chance mate. Adrian is the next Alpha King but he hasn't been able to assume his role because he needed a Luna by his side. A rogue that trespassed on his territory, whom he ordered be killed turned out to be his mate leaving him in a dilemma. Will Adrian reject Lola because she came into his territory as a rogue? Will he overcome what happened to him in the past and give Lola a chance or reject her and go ahead with Fay as his chosen Luna? What will happen when everyone finds out just how much power Lola wields and how she's supposed to protect her kind in an oncoming war? Find out in Lola - The Moon Wolf!
8.9
183 Chapters
The Billionaire's Runaway Lover
The Billionaire's Runaway Lover
27-year-old Lilith Hill has never been with a man. When her friend pushes her to get into a secret relationship with the sexiest man alive, billionaire Kai Rivera, she jumps at the opportunity. But powerful men come from powerful families and she is just a little author who has no one backing her. What will she do when an unexpected pregnancy rocks the world. Will Kai forgive her for her deception? [Warning: Mature Content]
9.5
94 Chapters
THE BETA IS MINE
THE BETA IS MINE
What would you do if you've been saving yourself for your mate? Only for him to choose another Alpha Female right in your face? Reciprocate the act. Avenge. An eye for an eye. A tooth for a tooth. Easier said than done. Because whenever he was around me, my body betrayed me. "Alia, do you trust me? Even just for tonight?" His voice came out low and rough that it sent shivers of pleasure direct to my core. I know I should not trust him. But my mouth and body have a mind of their own. "I trust you, Gavin..." I whispered as I pressed my back to his naked chest. He took a deep breath and dipped his head into the crook of my neck, slowly brushing his lips against my burning skin. I angled my head, giving him more access while a sultry moan escaped my throat when he started nibbling and sucking the soft spot where his mark should be. This was all wrong, but I don't want to be right this time. Just for tonight. ¨¨¨¨¨¨Book 2 of the Black Shadow Pack Series - The novel is stand-alone, however, to understand the characters deeper and the concept of The Claiming, I highly recommend that you read the first book HE'S MY ALPHA (completed). Also available on this app. Black Shadow Pack Series: Book 1 - HE'S MY ALPHA (Completed) Book 2 - THE BETA IS MINE (Completed) Book 3 - LOVING THE GAMMA (Completed) Spin-Off Book 1 - IN THE ARMS OF MY ALPHA (Completed) Spin-Off Book 2 - THROUGH THE EYES OF MY ALPHA (Ongoing)
9.9
80 Chapters
The CEO's Addiction To Love
The CEO's Addiction To Love
Charlotte Simmons was not just betrayed by her fiancé, who cheated on her with a mistress. Her family business was also taken from her, and she was tricked into sleeping with a stranger on her wedding night. She eventually gave birth to a stranger's child! Her fiancé used her adultery as an excuse to dump her in public, making her the laughing stock of the city. That night, Charlotte Simmons drank herself to oblivion and vowed to seek revenge. However, when she woke up, she found herself lying in Zachary Connor’s bed! She was even more surprised when Zachary asked her to marry him! "Marry me and I’ll make you shine." Who was Zachary Connor? He was known as the emperor of darkness and he also happened to be filthy rich! There were rumors that he was gay. Well, who cared? He was a douchebag anyway, so she decided to go along just so she could punish him for his behavior! They signed and made their marriage official. From then on, Charlotte Simmons got ready and started her plan to torment Zachary Connor. After tormenting him, she knocked on his door that night and said, "Mr. Connor, I want a divorce." However, the next day, Charlotte Simmons walked out of the room with a pale face. "How dare you try to leave when you’re already mine?"
8.7
1425 Chapters
Violets and Ash
Violets and Ash
At ten years old, Violet stumbled into the Cedar Grove Pack covered in wounds and malnourished from walking for four days. With her memory shattered, she’s taken in and raised by the pack doctor. Nine years later fate takes Violet across the country, to the wealthiest pack in the world. Soon the walls she constructed around herself, and that harrowing night will be threatened. A face from her past set’s things in motion, his smoky eyes risk sending her to her knees. Flashbacks, blackouts, and secrets steeped in lies, prove to Violet that the past always comes back to haunt you.
10
206 Chapters

Related Questions

How Long Is Freud'S 'Civilization And Its Discontents'?

4 answers2025-06-17 01:43:05
Freud's 'Civilization and Its Discontents' is a dense but relatively short work, clocking in at around 80-100 pages depending on the edition. It's not the length that matters, though—it's how Freud packs so much into such a compact space. The book explores the tension between individual desires and societal constraints, delving into concepts like the death drive and the superego. What makes it fascinating is how Freud connects psychology to broader cultural critiques. He argues that civilization demands repression, creating inevitable discontent. The prose is sharp, almost clinical, but the ideas simmer long after you finish. It’s the kind of book you reread just to catch what you missed the first time.

What Is The Main Argument In 'Civilization And Its Discontents'?

4 answers2025-06-17 23:01:33
Freud's 'Civilization and Its Discontents' digs into the tension between human instincts and societal rules. He argues civilization demands repression—our aggressive and sexual drives clash with laws, morals, and order. This creates perpetual guilt and unhappiness. The book explores how societies curb primal desires to maintain stability, yet this very restraint breeds discontent. Freud ties it to the superego’s harsh judgments, making us feel guilty even for thoughts, not just actions. Religion, art, and love are temporary escapes, but they can’t fully reconcile our wild instincts with civilized life. What’s fascinating is his take on technology. Even progress can’t erase this fundamental conflict; it just masks it. Freud’s pessimism shines—civilization may protect us, but it also stifles our true nature. The book’s a grim mirror, showing how our greatest achievements come at a psychological cost.

Does 'Civilization And Its Discontents' Relate To Psychology Today?

4 answers2025-06-17 13:45:55
Freud's 'Civilization and Its Discontents' remains eerily relevant to modern psychology, especially in how it dissects the tension between individual desires and societal constraints. Today, therapists often grapple with patients who feel crushed by the demands of productivity, social media perfection, or rigid norms—echoing Freud’s idea that civilization imposes suffering by repressing our primal instincts. The book’s exploration of guilt, aggression, and the 'death drive' resonates in studies on anxiety disorders and the psychological toll of urban isolation. Contemporary research on collective trauma, like pandemics or climate anxiety, mirrors Freud’s warnings about civilization’s fragility. His concept of the 'superego' aligns with cognitive-behavioral therapy’s focus on internalized criticism. Yet, modern psychology expands beyond Freud’s pessimism, integrating neurobiology and cultural diversity. While some theories feel dated, the core question—how to balance human nature with societal survival—still sparks debates in mental health circles.

Is 'Civilization And Its Discontents' Based On Freud'S Theories?

4 answers2025-06-17 07:51:21
Absolutely! 'Civilization and Its Discontents' is Freud’s own work, diving deep into his psychoanalytic theories. He explores the tension between individual desires and societal constraints, framing it through concepts like the pleasure principle and the superego. Freud argues that civilization demands repression of primal instincts, leading to inherent discontent. His signature ideas—the Oedipus complex, aggression as a innate drive, and the death instinct—are woven throughout. It’s less about clinical case studies and more about applying psychoanalysis to culture, making it a philosophical extension of his earlier theories. What’s fascinating is how Freud connects personal psychology to collective struggles. He sees societal norms as a mirror of the superego’s moral policing, and war as an outburst of repressed Thanatos (the death drive). The book doesn’t just repeat his theories; it stretches them to explain why human societies, despite progress, can’t escape conflict. It’s Freud at his most ambitious, blending psychology, anthropology, and social critique.

How Does 'Civilization And Its Discontents' Critique Modern Society?

4 answers2025-06-17 08:49:56
Freud's 'Civilization and Its Discontents' digs into the tension between individual desires and societal constraints. He argues modern society forces us to repress primal instincts—aggression, sexual drives—for collective harmony, creating inner turmoil. The book paints civilization as a double-edged sword: it protects us from chaos but inflicts psychological suffering by stifling our true nature. Freud sees guilt as society’s enforcer, a byproduct of suppressed urges that leaves us perpetually discontent. Technology and progress don’t bring happiness, just more layers of repression. The book questions if the trade-off—security for freedom—is worth it, hinting that our discontent might be the price of order. Freud’s critique remains eerily relevant, especially in today’s hyper-regulated world where anxiety and alienation feel like universal currencies.

How Does 'Grendel' Criticize Human Civilization?

3 answers2025-06-20 09:27:18
John Gardner's 'Grendel' rips into human civilization by showing us through the monster's eyes how hollow our grand narratives really are. The humans in the story build their societies on myths of heroism and order, but Grendel sees the truth - it's all just violence and chaos dressed up in fancy words. Their mead halls and kingdoms are fragile constructs that crumble under his attacks, revealing how easily their so-called civilization falls apart. The poet character especially gets under Grendel's skin, spinning pretty lies about their culture while ignoring the bloodshed that actually holds it together. What makes this critique so brutal is that Grendel isn't some mindless beast; he's smarter than most humans and sees right through their hypocrisy. Their wars aren't about justice, their laws aren't about fairness - it's all just power plays and survival instincts pretending to be something nobler.

What Lost Civilization Does 'Fingerprints Of The Gods' Describe?

4 answers2025-06-20 08:37:14
'Fingerprints of the Gods' dives into the mysteries of ancient civilizations, particularly focusing on Atlantis and other advanced societies that supposedly predate recorded history. Graham Hancock argues that these civilizations possessed technology and knowledge far beyond what we traditionally attribute to them. He points to architectural marvels like the pyramids of Egypt and the ruins of Tiwanaku as evidence of their sophistication. The book suggests a global cataclysm wiped them out, leaving only fragments of their existence. The narrative weaves together myths, geological data, and archaeological anomalies to challenge mainstream history. Hancock’s theory hinges on the idea that these civilizations shared a common origin or were interconnected in ways we’re only beginning to understand. The book doesn’t just describe a single lost civilization but paints a picture of a forgotten epoch where humanity achieved greatness before collapsing under natural disasters.

How Does 'A History Of The World In 6 Glasses' Link Beer To Civilization?

4 answers2025-06-14 01:56:19
In 'A History of the World in 6 Glasses', beer isn't just a drink—it's a cornerstone of civilization. The book argues that beer's fermentation process likely began with the storage of grain, which early agricultural societies like the Mesopotamians and Egyptians relied on. This wasn't just about sustenance; beer became currency, a social lubricant, and even part of religious rituals. Workers building the pyramids were paid in beer, and it featured in hymns to goddesses like Ninkasi. The drink also spurred technological advances. Brewing required pottery for storage, which led to the development of ceramics. Beer's role in communal feasting helped solidify social hierarchies, as elites controlled its distribution. The book paints beer as a catalyst for stability—wherever grain was grown, beer followed, binding communities together long before bread became a staple. It's a fascinating lens to view how something so simple shaped trade, culture, and even the earliest economies.
좋은 소설을 무료로 찾아 읽어보세요
GoodNovel 앱에서 수많은 인기 소설을 무료로 즐기세요! 마음에 드는 책을 다운로드하고, 언제 어디서나 편하게 읽을 수 있습니다
앱에서 책을 무료로 읽어보세요
앱에서 읽으려면 QR 코드를 스캔하세요.
DMCA.com Protection Status