Why Did Critics Originally React Harshly To The Sun Also Rises?

2025-10-22 23:05:05 143

8 Answers

Reid
Reid
2025-10-23 07:37:06
Reading 'The Sun Also Rises' in a campus lit class, I was struck by how many reviewers back in 1926 felt betrayed by Hemingway's voice. They wanted plot, explanation, and moral closure; instead they got an elliptical, fragmentary narrative that trusts the reader to feel more than to be told. That minimalist technique—the iceberg theory—felt dismissive to critics who equated lyrical description with literary value. On top of that, the book's setting among expatriates, heavy drinking, broken veterans, and social flouting rubbed a lot of reviewers the wrong way: it didn't celebrate American ideals, it showcased defeat and drift.

Cultural context really matters here. After World War I, the public craved either uplifting recovery stories or clear denunciations of decadence. Hemingway offered neither. Add to this a dose of resentment toward his macho persona and the themes of emasculation and sexual politics, and you get a chorus of harsh takes. For me, those initial barbs tell us less about the novel's worth and more about the fragile sensibilities of its early audience; I enjoy how it keeps pushing readers today.
Mia
Mia
2025-10-24 01:50:31
Debates about 'The Sun Also Rises' used to flare up whenever I brought it into conversation back in grad school, and I still get a kick out of why critics originally tore into it. On one level they were shocked by its content: unvarnished talk of divorce, infidelity, alcoholism, and a casual, sometimes cruel, depiction of human relationships. That frankness clashed with the more genteel social novels critics were used to, and a lot of gatekeepers saw the book as immoral or tawdry, not worthy of serious literature.

Beyond the morals police, many reviewers hated Hemingway’s style. His lean, pared-down sentences felt like an insult to readers expecting lush, Victorian prose or flashy modernist tricks. To those critics the language looked unfinished or simplistic — they mistook restraint for incompetence. Add to that the portrayal of postwar expatriates as aimless and decentered; critics who wanted clear moral arcs found the characters’ drifting lives infuriating. Some also read the book autobiographically and attacked Hemingway’s persona, which amplified the backlash.

Cultural context mattered too: this was a novel that wore its disillusionment openly, labeling a generation adrift. Combined with candid references to sexuality (including implications around male-male desire) and aggressive masculinity displayed and dismantled through bullfighting and booze, the book hit nerves. Today I love how those very elements make 'The Sun Also Rises' feel honest and modern, but I can see why it first sparked fury rather than applause.
Charlie
Charlie
2025-10-25 03:49:44
In grad seminars I liked to point out that early hostility to 'The Sun Also Rises' often came from critics who misunderstood modernist experimentation. Hemingway stripped ornamentation to focus on gesture and dialogue; where reviewers wanted moral commentary they found ironic distance and understatement. People also reacted to subject matter: aimlessness after the war, casual sex, drinking, and a protagonist who isn't conventionally heroic—that made journalists and literary gatekeepers uneasy.

Put simply, critics read the novel through older moral and stylistic lenses and missed the craft beneath the surface. Personally, I think that discomfort reveals more about the era than the text, and that stubborn clarity still hooks me.
Micah
Micah
2025-10-25 18:31:28
I've always been curious about the initial storm of hate that greeted 'The Sun Also Rises.' When I dug into the contemporary reviews, a few blunt reasons kept showing up: Hemingway's pared-down prose felt like sloppiness to critics used to ornate Victorian flourishes, and the book's aimless gang of expatriates smashed the moral maps readers expected. People were uncomfortable with how unromantic and blunt everything was—sex, drinking, heartbreak—without any tidy moralizing. That starkness looked like emptiness to many reviewers.

Beyond style, social norms were being pushed. The novel's frankness about sexuality, its casual depiction of adultery, and the hinted homosexuality around some characters offended the conservative sensibilities of the 1920s. Critics also judged the characters as shallow or immoral—Brett's sexual freedom and Jake's impotence (both physical and existential) were read as moral failures rather than honest portrayals of a postwar generation. I find it wild that what read as realism then now reads as brave economy; it just goes to show how taste and cultural comfort zones shift over time, and I still appreciate the raw honesty even when it unsettles me.
Helena
Helena
2025-10-26 12:35:44
I keep thinking about how readers' morals shape early criticism of 'The Sun Also Rises.' Back when it appeared, people expected novels to guide behavior or comfort readers; instead Hemingway presented characters mired in postwar numbness, often making ugly choices without narrative punishment. Critics called that nihilistic and shallow. Stylistically, his spare sentences and conversational dialogue were interpreted as undercraft rather than technique, and that misunderstanding fueled a lot of hostility.

There was also fear: Brett's agency and the book's candid sexuality shook up conventional gender norms, and implied queerness made some reviewers squeamish. Over time the book's modernist innovations and psychological depth became clearer, and I appreciate how the initial backlash highlights the clash between new art and old expectations—it's part of what keeps the book alive for me.
Riley
Riley
2025-10-26 18:04:01
When I think back on the initial critical storm around 'The Sun Also Rises' I see three big triggers: content, style, and context. The content was raw—infidelity, drinking, emasculation—so puritan or conventional reviewers pounced. Stylistically, Hemingway’s minimalism ran counter to the florid modernists and old-school narrators, so many mistook deliberate understatement for simple-mindedness. Contextually, the novel’s portrayal of disillusioned expatriates and its hinting at sexual complexity made it a lightning rod in a conservative postwar climate.

Critics were also wrestling with what literature should do after the Great War; Hemingway offered bleak clarity rather than comforting resolution. Over time, readers learned to read the gaps and silences as technique, not failure. Personally, I find that early outrage tells you as much about the era as it does about the book — which is part of why I keep returning to it with curiosity.
Titus
Titus
2025-10-26 18:33:07
Brightly colored covers and café chatter pulled me into arguing for 'The Sun Also Rises' with friends, and the reasons critics originally reacted so harshly still feel obvious. To many reviewers in the 1920s the book seemed like an affront: its characters are messy, often cruel, and sometimes unlikable; for a culture that wanted moral clarity, that ambiguity was scandalous. Also, the sexual undercurrents and open discussion of divorce and affairs made it easy fodder for accusations of immorality and even book bans in some places.

Then there’s the voice — Hemingway’s short, clipped sentences felt revolutionary and, to some, simply wrong. Critics trained on ornate prose accused him of being careless or juvenile. Instead of seeing the craft behind the restraint, they judged surface simplicity. Another angle was the book’s cultural discomfort: it unmasks postwar disillusionment and a kind of lost masculinity that many preferred left unsaid. Add Hemingway’s rising fame and macho persona, and critics sometimes turned personal, attacking the writer through the work. I still enjoy debating how a novel once dismissed as immoral and unsophisticated climbed into the canon; it proves how taste and context shape reputations.
Violette
Violette
2025-10-28 13:19:23
One rainy afternoon in a café I argued with a friend that the scandal around 'The Sun Also Rises' was cultural noise as much as critique. Critics slammed Hemingway for what they called a lack of plot, but that was really a reaction to a new aesthetic: fragments, implication, and silence. They were also scandalized by how openly the book handled sex and how it portrayed broken veterans and disillusioned youth—the so-called 'Lost Generation.' Many reviewers equated the absence of moralizing with amorality, and they disliked Brett's sexual autonomy and the book's refusal to condemn her neatly.

Some critiques were also personal: Hemingway's public persona—flinty, macho, uncompromising—didn't help win friends among the literary establishment. I enjoy how the controversy highlights the gap between changing art forms and public expectation, and it makes the novel's endurance feel earned.
View All Answers
Scan code to download App

Related Books

Why did she " Divorce Me "
Why did she " Divorce Me "
Two unknown people tide in an unwanted bond .. marriage bond . It's an arrange marriage , both got married .. Amoli the female lead .. she took vows of marriage with her heart that she will be loyal and always give her everything to make this marriage work although she was against this relationship . On the other hands Varun the male lead ... He vowed that he will go any extent to make this marriage broken .. After the marriage Varun struggle to take divorce from his wife while Amoli never give any ears to her husband's divorce demand , At last Varun kissed the victory by getting divorce papers in his hands but there is a confusion in his head that what made his wife to change her hard skull mind not to give divorce to give divorce ... With this one question arise in his head ' why did she " Divorce Me " .. ' .
9.1
55 Chapters
The Rich also cry
The Rich also cry
Selena the daughter of a wealthy aristocrat fell in love with a poor migrant boy Chris. However, it would be over her father's dead body would he allow such a relationship to go on. Selena falls pregnant and her father did not hesitate to do what he thought was best for his daughter, unfortunately, he lost more than he bargained for. Caleb Thompson was given up for adoption because his grandfather wouldn't accept a mixed-race grandchild into his family. He grew up not knowing who his mother was, and spent his entire life at the home of his adoptive parents who barely had enough but gave up the little they had for him. Caleb enters into an arranged marriage with Sophie Fernandez the granddaughter of a wealthy family at a time he was accused of a crime he did not commit, they both needed each other help. Caleb's sudden inheritance gives him leverage but not after he was thrown into a world of revenge, romance, passion, love-triangle and restoration.
9.2
49 Chapters
Why Mr CEO, Why Me
Why Mr CEO, Why Me
She came to Australia from India to achieve her dreams, but an innocent visit to the notorious kings street in Sydney changed her life. From an international exchange student/intern (in a small local company) to Madam of Chen's family, one of the most powerful families in the world, her life took a 180-degree turn. She couldn’t believe how her fate got twisted this way with the most dangerous and noble man, who until now was resistant to the women. The key thing was that she was not very keen to the change her life like this. Even when she was rotten spoiled by him, she was still not ready to accept her identity as the wife of this ridiculously man.
9.7
62 Chapters
Scars is Also Beautiful
Scars is Also Beautiful
Betrayed, raped, tortured and abandoned to her death, Eve swore that she would find vengeance on the family who had wronged her and her people. This includes the very man she had given her heart to, Adam Sviatoslavich. .... Being a princess of the Ice kingdom Zhatiera, Eve knew she wanted to do more than to soon rule after her beloved parents and, roaming through the forest and finding new adventure was the one thing she can't ever let go. When one of her adventures causes her to encounter the future king of the Lycan empire, Adam, she was smitten and ready to abandoned her throne for the man she calls soulmate. Despite being warned by her parents, she chose to stay with Adam who claimed to love her and swore to do right by her. Unfortunately, his own family do not hold the same sentiments and is determined to make the couple suffer. When their goal was achieved, Eve was left to die by the very person she entrust her life to. Surviving her painful ordeal with no kingdom and family to call her own, Eve swore to do whatever it takes to get her revenge and, if a whole kingdom has to burn because of it, it wouldn't matter. They all deserve it. No matter what it takes. ... I met him when I was a child, I knew he was mine from the moment I met him, I have sworn to never love anyone but him, I was his, but I didn't know that he was never mine, I never expect him to turn his back on me and betray me so cruelly, I would have given my life for him, I just never knew that was what he had wanted from me in the first place...
9.3
134 Chapters
Why Me?
Why Me?
Why Me? Have you ever questioned this yourself? Bullying -> Love -> Hatred -> Romance -> Friendship -> Harassment -> Revenge -> Forgiving -> ... The story is about a girl who is oversized or fat. She rarely has any friends. She goes through lots of hardships in her life, be in her family or school or high school or her love life. The story starts from her school life and it goes on. But with all those hardships, will she give up? Or will she be able to survive and make herself stronger? Will she be able to make friends? Will she get love? <<…So, I was swayed for a moment." His words were like bullets piercing my heart. I still could not believe what he was saying, I grabbed his shirt and asked with tears in my eyes, "What about the time... the time we spent together? What about everything we did together? What about…" He interrupted me as he made his shirt free from my hand looked at the side she was and said, "It was a time pass for me. Just look at her and look at yourself in the mirror. I love her. I missed her. I did not feel anything for you. I just played with you. Do you think a fatty like you deserves me? Ha-ha, did you really think I loved a hippo like you? ">> P.S.> The cover's original does not belong to me.
10
107 Chapters
WHY ME
WHY ME
Eighteen-year-old Ayesha dreams of pursuing her education and building a life on her own terms. But when her traditional family arranges her marriage to Arman, the eldest son of a wealthy and influential family, her world is turned upside down. Stripped of her independence and into a household where she is treated as an outsider, Ayesha quickly learns that her worth is seen only in terms of what she can provide—not who she is. Arman, cold and distant, seems to care little for her struggles, and his family spares no opportunity to remind Ayesha of her "place." Despite their cruelty, she refuses to be crushed. With courage and determination, Ayesha begins to carve out her own identity, even in the face of hostility. As tensions rise and secrets within the household come to light, Ayesha is faced with a choice: remain trapped in a marriage that diminishes her, or fight for the freedom and self-respect she deserves. Along the way, she discovers that strength can be found in the most unexpected places—and that love, even in its most fragile form, can transform and heal. Why Me is a heart-wrenching story of resilience, self-discovery, and the power of standing up for oneself, set against the backdrop of tradition and societal expectations. is a poignant and powerful exploration of resilience, identity, and the battle for autonomy. Set against the backdrop of tradition and societal expectations, it is a moving story of finding hope, strength, and love in the darkest of times.But at the end she will find LOVE.
Not enough ratings
160 Chapters

Related Questions

How To Get Lunala In Pokemon Ultra Sun And Moon?

4 Answers2025-10-22 09:41:30
Catching Lunala in 'Pokemon Ultra Sun and Moon' feels like a truly epic quest! After making your way through the game and getting to the climax, there’s a specific moment where you can encounter this majestic Pokémon. You’ll want to have completed the main story and reached a certain point involving the Ultra Wormholes. At that time, head to the Ruins of Conflict on Melemele Island after obtaining the necessary items. When you're ready, summon it with the Light of the Moon! It’s crucial to have a solid team prepared for battle, as Lunala is a Psychic/Ghost type Pokémon and can be quite challenging to catch. You might want to carry some Ultra Balls or a Master Ball if you’re feeling adventurous. Don’t forget to save your game just before entering, in case things don’t go quite as planned. Once you’re in the encounter, weaken it using your best tactics—status moves like Sleep or Paralysis work wonders. Remember that Lunala has some powerful attacks, so having healing items on hand can save you from a sticky situation. This legendary Pokémon has a stunning design, and it’s super satisfying to have it on your team. Plus, its unique ability, Shadow Shield, is game-changing. Getting Lunala is definitely a high point in 'Pokemon Ultra Sun and Moon'!

What Are The Steps To Catch Lunala In Pokemon Ultra Sun And Moon?

4 Answers2025-10-22 17:30:38
To catch Lunala in 'Pokemon Ultra Sun and Moon', you need to prepare yourself for an epic adventure! First off, make sure you’ve progressed through the game until you reach the Ultra Wormhole after defeating the Elite Four and completing the main storyline. You’ll encounter the Ultra Beast, Nihilego, earlier on, so don’t stress too much about that. Once that’s done, head over to the Ultra Warp Ride where you can navigate to different dimensions via the Ultra Wormholes. The key here is to find one that leads to the Moon Dimension. Now, this may take a few tries. When you enter the wormhole, look for a quirk in the colors – if you see a large hole that looks like a moon, you've found it! After some navigation, you should land right in the battle with Lunala. It’s a Pokémon capable of a variety of powerful moves that can leave your team stunned, so be prepared! Make sure you have a good supply of Ultra Balls or even the Master Ball if you're feeling bold. I tend to weaken Lunala first; using moves that won't knock it out is crucial. Status moves like Sleep Powder or Thunder Wave are super handy here. Just be patient, as catching this majestic Pokémon can take time. It’s worth the effort, trust me! Catching Lunala will enrich your game experience, making your Pokémon team even more solid. Good luck!

How Did The Sun Also Rises Influence Lost Generation Writers?

7 Answers2025-10-22 02:26:55
Reading 'The Sun Also Rises' felt like being handed a map to a city already half‑ruined by time — the prose is spare, but every empty alleyway and paused cigarette says something huge. When I first read it I was struck by how Hemingway's style — the clipped dialogue, the surface calm that hides an ocean of feeling — became almost a template for the rest of the Lost Generation. That economy of language, his 'iceberg' approach where most of the meaning sits under the surface, pushed other writers to trust implication over exposition. It made emotional restraint into an aesthetic choice: silence became as meaningful as a flourish of adjectives. Beyond style, 'The Sun Also Rises' helped crystallize the themes that define that circle: disillusionment after the war, expatriate drift in places like Paris and Pamplona, and a brittle, code‑based masculinity that tries to hold the world steady. Those elements propagated through contemporaries and later writers — you can see the echo in travel narratives, in the way relationships are shown more than explained, and in how modern short fiction borrows that pared-down precision. Even now, when I write dialogue I find myself thinking, less about showing everything and more about what the silence can do — it’s a lesson that stuck with me for life.

Can I Download Midnight Sun Free Online Read Legally?

1 Answers2025-10-23 04:59:15
Discovering 'Midnight Sun' was such a delightful adventure for me, and I can totally relate to the urge to read it without spending a dime. However, finding a legal and free way to dive into it online can be quite tricky. First off, let’s consider the options. Sometimes posts on platforms like Wattpad or fan sites might offer discussions or summaries that can quench your thirst for the story, but they’re not the entire book. Libraries often provide digital lending services that allow you to borrow e-books for free; apps like Libby or OverDrive are fantastic for that. It's like having the whole library right in your pocket! Just make sure to check your local library’s digital offerings. If you're not keen on the library route, some places occasionally offer promotional chapters or excerpts directly from the publisher. I feel like a sneak peek doesn’t truly capture the full essence of 'Midnight Sun,' but it’s definitely better than nothing! It's amazing how a few chapters can pull you in and ignite that familiar nostalgia for the ‘Twilight’ saga. Of course, using pirated sites may be tempting, but it really undermines the hard work of the authors and the industry. It’s like stealing someone's hard-earned creation! Ultimately, while it may not be straightforward to find 'Midnight Sun' for free, exploring these options can lead you to read it while supporting the people behind the story. Plus, knowing that you’re getting your read legally from a reputable source makes the experience all the more enjoyable!

Does Marrying The President:Wedding Crash,Queen Rises Have Subs?

8 Answers2025-10-22 13:48:58
I got curious about this too and did a little hunting: yes, 'Marrying The President:Wedding Crash,Queen Rises' does have subtitles available, but how easy they are to find depends on format and where you look. If you’re watching an official release (streaming platform or licensed YouTube upload), you’ll usually find professional subtitles in English and often other major languages—these show up as selectable CC or subtitle tracks. For episodes posted only on regional platforms, subtitles might be limited or delayed. Meanwhile, enthusiastic fan groups tend to produce English and other language subs very quickly; they’ll post them on fan sites, Discord servers, or subtitle repositories. Timing and quality vary: fansubs are faster but sometimes rough, while official subs are polished but might appear later. Personally I prefer waiting for the official tracks when possible, but I’ll flip to a fansub if I’m too impatient—there’s a special thrill in catching a new twist right away.

Who Are The Main Characters In Moon Embracing The Sun?

5 Answers2025-08-29 12:31:59
There's something about the way 'The Moon Embracing the Sun' mixes palace intrigue with a tragic love that always hooks me, so when someone asks who the main players are I get excited to list them. At the center is Lee Hwon — the crown prince who grows into a tormented king. He's proud and duty-bound but haunted by love and loss; his arc is the emotional spine of the whole story. Opposite him is Yeon-woo, the warm, kind girl from his youth who later returns as the mysterious shaman Wol after a traumatic disappearance. Her memory loss and quiet strength make her one of my favorite tragic heroines. Rounding out the core trio is Yang Myung, Lee Hwon's close friend and rival who also loves Yeon-woo. There's also Heo Yeom, a devoted physician and guardian figure who protects Yeon-woo, and Yoon Bo-kyung, a noblewoman whose jealousy and political ambition push the plot into darker territory. Beyond those five, the court — the Queen Dowager, ministers, and palace schemers — are crucial, but if you want the beating heart of the drama, it's really Lee Hwon, Yeon-woo/Wol, Yang Myung, Heo Yeom, and Yoon Bo-kyung.

Why Did Moon Embracing The Sun Become A Hit Drama?

5 Answers2025-08-29 04:50:12
From the first time I stumbled onto 'Moon Embracing the Sun', I was hooked by how it felt both grand and intimate at once. What sold me immediately was the chemistry between the leads—there's this aching, slow-build longing that isn't just cute shipping fuel, it actually gives the characters weight. The show mixes palace intrigue with personal tragedy so neatly that every scene feels consequential. Visually, the costumes and sets are lush without being gaudy; paired with an emotional score, moments land hard in a way that makes you want to rewatch scenes just to catch all the little acting choices. Beyond aesthetics, the storytelling plays with fate and power in a way that speaks to a wide audience: it's romance for people who also love politics, betrayal, and the occasional heartbreaking twist. Socially, it arrived at a time when everyone wanted a shared water-cooler obsession, so conversations and memes spread it even further. For me, it's the combination of palpable romance, smart plotting, and the music that turned it from a well-made drama into a cultural phenomenon I still recommend to friends.

What Influences Did Kazuo Ishiguro Cite For Klara And The Sun?

4 Answers2025-08-29 06:50:03
I got pulled into this book conversation after reading a few interviews Ishiguro did around the time 'Klara and the Sun' came out, and what stuck with me was how mixed his influences are — part literary, part everyday observation. He talks about being drawn to the long tradition of robot/AI stories (the whole lineage of machines that look human and ask us moral questions), and he explicitly frames 'Klara and the Sun' in that science-fiction orbit while insisting it’s really a human story about devotion and loss. On a more concrete, almost visual level, he mentioned the odd inspiration of window displays and mannequins — that sense of a lifelike figure on a shop floor watching people come and go. He also folded in ideas about childhood consumer culture (how parents choose technology for kids), and religious or worship motifs — hence the sun-as-deity image in the novel. So think: classic robot fiction + street-level observations (mannequins, stores, kids) + themes of belief and love.
Explore and read good novels for free
Free access to a vast number of good novels on GoodNovel app. Download the books you like and read anywhere & anytime.
Read books for free on the app
SCAN CODE TO READ ON APP
DMCA.com Protection Status