What Critics Say About 'Big Magic' By Gilbert?

2025-06-30 06:53:19 28

3 Answers

Owen
Owen
2025-07-05 10:50:57
I've seen critics praise 'Big Magic' for its refreshing take on creativity. Many highlight how Gilbert strips away the romantic suffering artist trope, arguing creativity should be joyful, not tortured. The Washington Post called it 'a permission slip to play,' appreciating how it dismantles creative blocks by treating ideas as living things that choose us. Some academic reviewers critique its lack of structured methodology, but even they admit its emotional resonance is powerful. The Guardian noted how Gilbert’s personal anecdotes—like her haunted short story—make abstract concepts tangible. Critics across the board agree it’s not a how-to manual but a why-to manifesto, perfect for burned-out artists needing reignition.
Yvonne
Yvonne
2025-07-06 02:47:43
Delving into critical responses, 'Big Magic' sparked fascinating debates about modern creativity. Literary analysts commend Gilbert’s 'creative entitlement' philosophy—her claim that art doesn’t require justification shook traditional pedagogy. The New Yorker’s review pointed out how her 'idea-driven' approach mirrors ancient Greek muses, repackaged for the Instagram era. Yet, feminist critics had mixed feelings. While some celebrated her rejection of artistic martyrdom, others wished she’d addressed systemic barriers women face more directly.

Psychologists reviewed the book too, praising its alignment with flow theory but questioning her dismissal of deliberate practice. The Atlantic’s critique noted, 'Gilbert treats fear as a backseat driver, not an enemy,' which therapists found useful for anxious clients. Business sections of papers latched onto her 'follow curiosity, not passion' angle, with Forbes calling it 'a startup antidote to hustle culture.' The book’s cross-genre appeal stunned everyone—from poets to CEOs highlighting different passages.

What’s undeniable is its cultural impact. Even skeptical critics admit it shifted conversations about artistic worth, making 'Big Magic' a rare self-help book quoted in MFA programs and boardrooms alike.
Henry
Henry
2025-07-04 16:15:30
Critics can’t stop comparing 'Big Magic' to other creativity books, and Gilbert wins by being radically practical. Unlike 'The Artist’s Way,' it doesn’t demand daily rituals—just playful engagement. The NPR review loved how she reframes rejection: 'Your idea isn’t failing you; it’s just eloping with someone else.' Memoir-focused critics applaud her vulnerability, especially the story of her failed novel that 'left her like a bad boyfriend.'

Skeptics call it lightweight, but fans argue that’s the point. The Boston Globe wrote, 'It’s not about depth; it’s about spark.' Creativity coaches now use its 'shit sandwich' metaphor (balancing passion with pragmatism) as a teaching staple. The most surprising praise came from science writers—Gilbert’s 'hunt for wonder' aligns with recent neuroscience on curiosity-driven learning. It’s not perfect, but as Slate admitted, 'It makes creating feel less like a chore and more like a treasure hunt.'
View All Answers
Scan code to download App

Related Books

 Never Say Goodbye
Never Say Goodbye
WARNING: MATURE CONTENT "How long will I love you?" "Until my dying breath." From the moment they set their eyes on each other, Ian and Kimberly have been head over heels in love. Their intense love for each other fills their lives with colors and their bellies with butterflies but their happiness is cut short when Kimberly is diagnosed with a life threatening sickness. A sudden death forces the love birds to say goodbye to each other but Ian soon discovers that everything they were made to believe was a lie. How far would he go, to be with the love of his life?
10
48 Chapters
Say I Do
Say I Do
Seeing an omega owning a business is already odd in their society, what more an omega CEO? Klyde Rehan has always been the odd one. Used to defying everything that comes his way, even his parents. Tell him he can’t do something and he’ll prove you wrong. He’s been handling his company well for the past years despite many people’s opposition with him being the CEO. He is capable. He can handle it. Until he can’t. People from his company has been screwing him over, desperate to see his downfall. Because of this, his company suffers. His investors have been pulling out left and right and it’s only a matter of time before his company completely drowns. He has no choice but to ask for help from Wade Ashton, an alpha and a CEO of one of the largest conglomerates in the country. He has never been fond of alphas, having been looked down upon by them his whole life. But he has no choice, it’s either his pride or his company. “Two years. The marriage will last for two years. This will make our companies merge.” “Fine. Two years then. After that we’re done.” Will two years be enough to save his company? Or will two years be enough to awaken feelings that shouldn’t be?
10
27 Chapters
Hidden Magic
Hidden Magic
Fallon Presley is different. She has a little something peculiar about her, but she embraces her oddness. Fallon never feels like she belongs with her family. She knows they love her, but she never fits in with the extended family. When her family suddenly dies in a car accident, she is left to sort through the family estate. With the help of her best friend, Bruce Andrews, they begin the task that opens up the mystery of who Fallon Presley is and where she came from. Fallon and Bruce step into a world of magic, witches, wolves, vampires, and the supernatural. Somewhere between the magic elements and the supernatural, Fallon finds herself, her true love , and maybe a little hidden magic.
8
46 Chapters
Never Say Goodbye
Never Say Goodbye
On the exterior, Gabriel Cruz's life appears to be flawless and dazzling, but on the inside, it is quite the contrary. Forced to marry a family friend after accidentally sleeping with her and getting her pregnant, everything in his life takes a turn for the worse. After fleeing an abusive marriage, Arian Macavinta returns to the only home she has ever known. Desperate for a job, she finds a vacancy online for the position of a nanny and applies for it. Gabriel turns out to be her boss, and over time, they become attracted to each other. However, Gabriel's marriage stands as a huge obstacle in their search for happiness.
10
85 Chapters
Big Bad Alphas
Big Bad Alphas
After an attack on her pack, Isabella has to choose between her newly discovered Alpha mate and her beloved, younger sister.
8.8
48 Chapters
Just say yes
Just say yes
Esmeralda and James: Two opposites that in a normal world, shouldn't meet. James is a rich and famous architect who needs to get married in order to access his father's inheritance. Esmeralda lost her parents when she was very young and has had to fend for herself ever since. Their lives are separated by a whole world, until the day James runs over the girl. That incident was all his mother needed to cut him out of his father's will and that's something he can't risk. To avoid further problems, James and Esmeralda create a contract that benefits both parties. Can the two of them follow through to the end of this contract? Or does life have new surprises for them?
Not enough ratings
8 Chapters

Related Questions

What Is Big Magic Book About

3 Answers2025-06-10 21:34:29
I stumbled upon 'Big Magic' by Elizabeth Gilbert during a phase where I felt creatively stuck, and it was like a breath of fresh air. The book dives deep into the idea that creativity isn't some elusive talent but a force we can all tap into. Gilbert shares personal stories, like her journey writing 'Eat Pray Love,' and mixes them with practical advice. She talks about embracing curiosity over fear, which really resonated with me. The book isn't just for writers or artists—it's for anyone who wants to live a more vibrant, creative life. It's packed with quirky anecdotes, like her theory that ideas are almost alive, floating around waiting for someone to grab them. If you've ever felt blocked or uninspired, this book feels like a pep talk from a wise friend.

What Is The Book Big Magic About

2 Answers2025-06-10 04:36:35
I stumbled upon 'Big Magic' during a phase where I felt completely stuck in my creative pursuits. The book isn’t just about creativity—it’s a lifeline for anyone who’s ever felt paralyzed by fear or self-doubt. Elizabeth Gilbert, the author, treats creativity like this wild, almost mystical force that’s just waiting to collaborate with you. She doesn’t sugarcoat the struggles, but she also doesn’t buy into the tortured artist stereotype. Instead, she frames creativity as a playful, joyful partnership. The way she talks about ideas having consciousness, like they’re floating around looking for the right person to bring them to life, is both whimsical and oddly convincing. It’s not about waiting for inspiration to strike; it’s about showing up consistently, even when the muse seems absent. Gilbert’s personal stories—like her obsession with gardening leading to a novel she never planned to write—make the concepts feel tangible. She also tackles perfectionism and fear head-on, calling them out as creativity’s biggest blockers. Her mantra? Do it for the love of it, not the outcome. That shift in mindset alone was worth the read. What I love most is how practical the book is. It’s not some lofty, abstract pep talk. Gilbert gives actionable advice, like how to carve out time for creativity even with a day job, or why you should ditch the idea of ‘originality’ and embrace influence instead. The section on persistence hit hard—she compares creative work to a love affair, where you have to keep choosing it every day. It’s not about being ‘great’; it’s about being brave enough to keep going. 'Big Magic' feels like a permission slip to create messily, passionately, and without apology.

What Are Elizabeth Gilbert'S Tips In 'Big Magic'?

3 Answers2025-06-30 19:31:34
Elizabeth Gilbert's 'Big Magic' is packed with practical wisdom for creatives. She emphasizes the importance of curiosity over passion, suggesting that following what genuinely interests you often leads to more sustainable creativity than chasing grand passions. Gilbert champions the idea of 'creative living' as a daily practice, not some mythical state reserved for the chosen few. She advises treating fear like a backseat passenger on a road trip—acknowledge its presence but never let it drive. One of her most powerful concepts is the idea that ideas are living entities seeking human partners, which takes the pressure off perfectionism. She encourages creatives to finish things, even imperfectly, because the world needs more completed work, not more abandoned projects. Gilbert also stresses the value of persistence and routine over waiting for inspiration, framing creativity as a relationship requiring regular attention.

Does 'Big Magic' Discuss Collaborative Creativity?

3 Answers2025-06-30 06:21:41
As someone who's read 'Big Magic' multiple times, I can confirm Elizabeth Gilbert absolutely tackles collaborative creativity, though not in the way you might expect. She doesn't focus on team projects but rather how creativity flows between people and the universe itself. The book describes ideas as living entities that choose who to manifest through, sometimes jumping from person to person until someone brings them to life. Gilbert shares wild stories about this, like a novel idea she abandoned finding its way to another writer years later. She emphasizes staying open to these 'shared' inspirations while maintaining personal boundaries - it's less about committees and more about cosmic cooperation with the creative force.

Who Is The Publisher Of The Magic Of Thinking Big Book?

5 Answers2025-06-03 23:29:58
As someone who's always digging into self-help and motivation books, 'The Magic of Thinking Big' by David J. Schwartz has been a game-changer for me. I remember picking it up years ago, and its lessons still stick with me. The publisher is Simon & Schuster, one of the big names in the industry, known for releasing impactful works. Simon & Schuster has a solid reputation for publishing books that challenge and inspire readers. They've been behind many bestsellers, and 'The Magic of Thinking Big' fits right in with their lineup. I love how they consistently put out quality content that pushes people to grow. If you're into personal development, checking out their catalog might lead you to other gems too.

Is 'Big Magic' Suitable For Aspiring Novelists?

3 Answers2025-06-30 23:07:28
As someone who's read 'Big Magic' twice and tried its advice, I can say it's perfect for aspiring novelists who struggle with perfectionism. Gilbert doesn't teach plotting or character development—she tackles the psychological barriers that stop writers from creating. Her concept of 'creative living' shifted my mindset entirely. Instead of waiting for inspiration, I now treat writing like gardening—showing up daily to tend ideas, even when they seem small. The book's strength lies in making creativity feel accessible rather than some elite talent. It won't replace craft books, but it’s the emotional fuel that keeps you writing when self-doubt kicks in. For practical techniques, pair it with 'On Writing' by King, but for pure motivational fire, this is unmatched.

Does The Book Magic Of Thinking Big Have A Workbook?

4 Answers2025-06-03 03:21:04
As someone who loves diving deep into self-help books and applying their lessons, I've explored 'The Magic of Thinking Big' by David Schwartz thoroughly. While the original book doesn’t come with an official workbook, there are plenty of companion resources created by fans and coaches. I’ve seen downloadable PDFs and guided journals online that break down each chapter into actionable steps. These unofficial workbooks often include reflection prompts, goal-setting exercises, and practical challenges to help internalize the book’s principles. For those who prefer structured follow-ups, I recommend checking out platforms like Etsy or Amazon for third-party workbooks. Some even integrate modern productivity techniques like habit tracking or mind mapping. If you’re serious about applying Schwartz’s ideas, pairing the book with a dedicated notebook for journaling can be just as effective. The key is consistency—whether you use a formal workbook or create your own system.

What Kind Of Book Is The Magic Of Thinking Big?

3 Answers2025-06-10 05:27:09
I stumbled upon 'The Magic of Thinking Big' during a phase where I felt stuck in life, and it completely shifted my perspective. This book isn’t just about self-help clichés; it’s a practical guide to rewiring your mindset. The author, David Schwartz, breaks down how limiting beliefs hold us back and offers actionable steps to think bigger. I loved how it blends psychology with real-life examples, like how small changes in language ('I’ll try' vs. 'I will') can alter outcomes. It’s not about vague positivity but concrete strategies—like visualizing success or surrounding yourself with 'big thinkers.' The book feels like a mentor pushing you to ditch excuses and embrace ambition. If you’re tired of playing small, this’ll kick you into gear.
Explore and read good novels for free
Free access to a vast number of good novels on GoodNovel app. Download the books you like and read anywhere & anytime.
Read books for free on the app
SCAN CODE TO READ ON APP
DMCA.com Protection Status