Why Do Fans Consider Madara Uchiha A Tragic Antagonist?

2025-08-30 10:19:51 196

4 Answers

Bella
Bella
2025-09-01 05:57:22
I bring a louder, more impatient take when talking about Madara — he’s painful because he’s both admirable and awful. I mean, who doesn’t get a twinge of respect for someone who dedicates their life to ending the cycle of war? Yet the methods make my teeth grind: stagnation through illusion is not peace, it’s theft of agency. In the comics and anime I follow, characters who choose control over consent feel disturbingly plausible, and Madara nails that uncomfortable realism.

He’s tragic because his intellect and charisma could’ve built bridges, but trauma narrowed his options into a single brutal ideology. I also love how his story echoes with others — Obito’s shadow, Hashirama’s optimism — creating this chorus of loss and different responses to it. Fans pick up on that complexity: Madara isn’t a cardboard villain, he’s a mirror that forces you to ask whether ends ever justify monstrous means. That tension is why debates about him still fire up forums years later.
Kimberly
Kimberly
2025-09-01 17:55:43
Madara Uchiha hits me like a slow burn rather than a sudden twist — watching his story unfold in 'Naruto' and 'Naruto Shippuden' felt almost like reading a tragic novel where the villain gradually becomes understandable. He starts as a passionate kid who wants security for his people, and that human desire for peace is his seed. After loss, betrayal, and the crushing failure of the systems around him, his answers turn extreme: the Infinite Tsukuyomi is horrifying but logically consistent with someone who’s watched war keep taking everything he loves.

What really makes him tragic to me is the intimacy of his fall. It isn’t just power-hungry megalomania — it’s loneliness and grief warped into absolute certainty. He believes in a peaceful world, but he learns to trust force and illusion over messy human connection, and that’s heartbreaking because you can almost forgive the motive while hating the method. Also, his rivalry with Hashirama adds layers; it’s like two friends pulled apart by differing visions of peace, and that personal element keeps me invested.

I still find myself thinking about those late-night rereads where I’d pause on panels of his younger face, imagining how small changes could’ve led him elsewhere. He’s a cautionary tale: brilliant, sincere, and devastatingly human — and that blend is why so many fans feel sympathy even as they condemn his crimes.
Yosef
Yosef
2025-09-02 10:31:08
I’ve always been drawn to villains who feel like victims of circumstance, and Madara fits that profile in such a layered way. Start from his background: clan strife, the desperate need to protect his people, and then personal tragedies that reinforce a belief that the world only answers through power. The tragedy is twofold — the personal emotional loss (family, friends, trust) and the philosophical collapse: his ideal of peace morphs into authoritarian fantasy.

Thinking more structurally, he’s tragic because his arc exposes systemic failure. The shinobi system, the political machinations, and the inability of institutions to heal trauma all funnel him toward radicalization. He’s not just a man gone mad with power; he’s a person whose environment consistently punished empathy and rewarded domination. That’s why even when he’s a monster, fans can’t help but analyze him sympathetically: he’s a warning about how good intentions, unmoored from ethics and humility, can become catastrophic. Sometimes I find myself rewatching his key scenes, trying to map where compassion died and calculation took over.
Nolan
Nolan
2025-09-02 22:32:29
When I chat about Madara with friends at the café, the word that comes up most is 'wasted potential.' He’s brilliant, charismatic, and painfully lonely — a recipe for tragedy when left unchecked. He genuinely wants peace but uses an all-encompassing illusion that erases freedom; that contradiction makes him both compelling and terrifying.

Fans empathize because he’s not purely evil in the cartoonish sense — you can trace his choices back to real human reactions to trauma, betrayal, and disillusionment. That mix of relatability and horror is why his story sticks with me: it sparks sympathy, debate, and a little unease every time I think about what true peace should really cost.
View All Answers
Scan code to download App

Related Books

Against the Tragic Fate
Against the Tragic Fate
Claire Leerstrom, a daughter of a powerful and wealthy duke. The youngest sibling and the only daughter of the Leerstrom family. As being the youngest child and only daughter, Claire is a bit spoiled, no. She really is a spoiled brat. A brat what she wants, she will get. Claire fell in love with the first prince and a lady who is blinded by love she do everything in order for her beloved to be crowned as king. Little she didn’t know that the first prince was only using her in order to succeed the throne. After sitting on the throne, the first prince she loved so dearly found another woman. The first prince reasons out her personality and how her brother was labeled as traitors. He two brothers died as traitors without knowing if they really are. Their social status was slowly going down because of what his two brothers accused of. Her parents dying one after another because of sickness they got for so much pressure and stressful events happening on their family after they loss two of their sons. Her twin brother was imprisoned for some reason and was publicly executed. At that time Claire was divorce by the first prince and thrown her out of the palace. Claire being left out alone and individually sucking up what happening on her family and herself crumbled down. Then decided to end her life once and for all. However, what happened next was unexpected. She saw again the faces she thought she would never see again. The faces who brought her to this world. The faces of her parents and brothers. Is that a dream? Or she was given a second chance to live all over again and change her fate. What will happened to her now?
10
17 Chapters
Tragic Fate Looking So Clear
Tragic Fate Looking So Clear
Fear  Noun 1. a distressing emotion aroused by impending danger, evil, pain, etc., whether the threat is real or imagined; the feeling or condition of being afraid. Synonyms: foreboding, apprehension, consternation, dismay, dread, terror, fright, panic, horror, trepidation, qualm. Until that night, Kinsley never knew true fear, never felt terror. She could taste the fear on her tongue, salty with a hint of copper, her throat felt constricted. She wanted to scream but the terror was too thick in her throat, coating it to the point of near suffocation. She was prey and he was the hunter who never failed. Verendus was powerful, a ruthless and cruel Boss, he did not fail and he did not quit. Kinsley Anderson was a woman he coveted, and he would stop at nothing to claim her. He had the means and the manpower to pursue her to the ends of the earth and he would do it, claiming her once and for all.
10
15 Chapters
Dual Marriage:A Friend's Tragic Farewell
Dual Marriage:A Friend's Tragic Farewell
My best friend and I signed up for the Dual Marriage System so the cancer wouldn't kill me. She and I managed to steal the hearts of the Hopkin brothers. Naturally, we became in-laws. Seven years later, my husband's son told me I was dull and useless. Meanwhile, my best friend's husband slammed her behind bars for the sake of his old flame. When she was released, the last thing she told me was, "Live on." Then, she rushed into the oncoming traffic and was crushed into a pulp by a speeding truck.
9 Chapters
The tragic supporting actress in the Duke's household
The tragic supporting actress in the Duke's household
On the mysterious and vast fantasy continent of Estella, magic and miracles coexist, and ancient families and emerging forces intertwine to create a complex and ever-changing power map. Among them, the ducal family, as one of the oldest aristocracies, not only has a long history and endless wealth, but also controls the key power that can shape the fate of the continent. However, behind this glory, there are also countless unknown secrets and simmering disputes.
Not enough ratings
32 Chapters
THE ANTAGONIST'S PART
THE ANTAGONIST'S PART
Sabria Verone Villin is eighteen years old, who always hated the Protagonist in every drama or movie, or book that she has watched or read. She has, however, has a soft spot for the Villain. She understood their pain. The kind of endless pain that only the living could feel. Alone, helpless, locked in a dark room with no one to rely on. Dash, was a racer. His life had always been in the line each race. But an accident caused him to be in a coma for six months. When he regained consciousness, he couldn't remember anything that happened prior to his accident. All he could remember was his memories with the woman he love, Sabrina. Will the charm of second chance love work? Or will it completely destroy what little love they have for each other?
9.9
21 Chapters
Rejected Fiancée: The Antagonist's Revenge
Rejected Fiancée: The Antagonist's Revenge
Ernesta, the daughter of a wealthy family, had lived like an orphan for over a decade after being separated from her parents as a young child. At sixteen, she was finally found and brought home. Ernesta believed her life was starting anew, that she would finally be surrounded by her family's love. But she had no idea what awaited her: her brother's judgmental gaze, her father's disdain, and her mother's feigned affection. This was because someone had completely usurped her place in the family. Her foster sister, Kiera, though unrelated by blood to the Merediths, had been raised in luxury and had become a true lady. Ernesta, the real daughter raised in a less fortunate environment, wasn't considered noble enough, elegant enough, and was treated like an outsider. On the night of Ernesta's 20th birthday, also the night her engagement to Ryder was announced, he coldly stated, “The only one I've ever loved is Kiera.” Why hadn't he said it sooner? Why did he have to say it today, in front of so many guests, making her look like a fool? To make matters worse, her father, mother, and brother all turned their backs on her to protect the deceitful Kiera. Ernesta turned and walked away. This time, she was determined to let go of the family love she had always craved. She wanted to prove to the Merediths and Ryder that her life would be even better without them. But a serious car accident nearly claimed Ernesta's life. When she awoke, a mechanical voice echoed in her ears, “Ding! Congratulations, master, on successfully installing the Life-Altering System. Your brain is severely damaged, and your body is in a vegetative state. If you want a chance to wake up, you need to complete the mission assigned by the Life-Altering System.”
Not enough ratings
12 Chapters

Related Questions

How Did Madara Uchiha Obtain The Rinnegan?

4 Answers2025-08-30 14:58:39
Watching the Rinnegan reveal in 'Naruto' hit me like a plot twist I wasn't ready for — but once you unpack it, Madara's path is actually pretty methodical. He didn't suddenly sprout the eyes mid-fight; the key was mixing Uchiha and Senju power. During his battle with Hashirama at the Valley of the End, Madara took Hashirama's cells into himself so he could better match Hashirama's chakra and Wood Release. That cellular transplant changed his chakra makeup, giving him a sliver of Senju/Asura-like energy to pair with his natural Indra chakra. Decades passed before the change manifested. In the manga, Madara only awakened the Rinnegan very late in life — it was the slow result of those two lineages combining inside him over time. He then transplanted those eyes into a young Nagato to hide them and continue his long game, which explains why Nagato wielded the Rinnegan despite being from the Uzumaki clan. If you like the deeper lore, it's fascinating to compare Madara's method to how Hagoromo granted powers directly; Madara engineered his own fate rather than receiving a gift. Rewatch that arc and you see the slow-burn of obsession and planning — it feels less like a magic trick and more like cold long-term strategy, which is exactly what made Madara so chilling to me.

Is 'The Witcher – Uchiha Madara!' A Crossover Or Fanfiction?

5 Answers2025-06-16 09:19:46
'The Witcher – Uchiha Madara!' is absolutely a crossover fanfiction, blending two wildly different universes into something fresh. It takes Geralt of Rivia's gritty, monster-slaying world from 'The Witcher' and throws in Uchiha Madara, the legendary shinobi from 'Naruto', with his chakra and Sharingan antics. The story explores how these characters collide—whether through dimensional rifts or reincarnation—and how their powers interact. Madara’s ninjutsu against Geralt’s signs creates fascinating clashes or alliances, depending on the author’s take. What makes it stand out is the fusion of dark fantasy with shonen battle tactics. Geralt’s stoicism contrasts Madara’s god-complex, offering rich character dynamics. Some versions lean into political intrigue, with Madara disrupting the Northern Kingdoms, while others focus on epic fights against mutated beasts or rogue mages. The lore mashups can be hit-or-miss, but when done right, they redefine both worlds creatively. Crossovers like this thrive on 'what if' scenarios, and this one’s no exception.

Why Did Madara Uchiha Betray The Senju Clan?

4 Answers2025-08-30 18:56:35
When I look back at Madara's arc in 'Naruto', I see a mix of personal hurt, political fear, and a tragic misunderstanding between two people who once wanted the same thing. Madara wasn't simply some power-hungry villain who switched sides on a whim; he was an Uchiha born into centuries of blood feuds. The Senju-Uchiha rivalry meant constant suspicion. When clans began discussing a village system, Madara saw something that threatened his people's autonomy and survival, not just his pride. Losing loved ones like Izuna and repeatedly being pitted against an idealistic Hashirama chipped away at his faith in compromise. On top of that, the village idea put Hashirama in a place of symbolic leadership that Madara felt would erase Uchiha influence. That fear mutated into bitterness: if the system would leave his clan powerless or subjugated, then staying and negotiating felt impossible. After their final battle at the Valley of the End, Madara's sense of defeat and isolation pushed him to take darker paths—seeking absolute control through the Infinite Tsukuyomi as a way to achieve peace by force. So his turn against the Senju wasn't only spite; it was a tragic reaction to feeling unheard, endangered, and convinced that only domination could stop endless suffering. Reading the manga and watching the fight made me sad more than angry—it's a classic example of two visions of peace colliding in the worst way.

How Did Madara Uchiha Control The Tailed Beasts?

4 Answers2025-08-30 07:14:40
I got hooked on 'Naruto' as a kid and that big Madara moment still gives me chills. The short of it is: Madara didn’t just whisper to the tailed beasts and they obeyed — he used a mix of brute force sealing and ocular/chaotic chakra techniques. Historically, he (and later Obito acting as him) captured the beasts and sealed them inside the Gedo Statue (the Demonic Statue of the Outer Path). That statue acts like a living prison and a reservoir of tailed-beast chakra, so once a beast is sealed into it, its freedom and will are hugely diminished. When the fighting ramps up, you see black chakra receivers and rods used to physically pull or channel a beast’s chakra into the statue. Those rods are basically extensions of the Gedo Statue and were used to suppress or extract the beasts. Later on, when Madara becomes the Ten-Tails jinchūriki, his control becomes even more absolute — as host to the Ten-Tails he can overwhelm individual beasts’ wills since they’re part of a larger whole. There’s also the Rinnegan and Sharingan angle: Madara’s ocular powers let him dominate opponents mentally and manipulate chakra on a massive scale, so it’s a mix of sealing tech, physical chakra-siphoning tools, and raw jinchūriki authority. Watching those scenes again, I still feel the weight of how brutally practical his methods were.

Where Can I Read 'The Witcher – Uchiha Madara!' Online?

5 Answers2025-06-16 14:55:41
Finding 'The Witcher – Uchiha Madara!' online can be a bit tricky since it’s a crossover fanfiction blending two very different universes. The best place to start is fanfiction platforms like Archive of Our Own (AO3) or FanFiction.net, where writers often upload their creative mashups. These sites have search filters to help narrow down the results. Another option is Wattpad, which hosts a variety of fan-written stories, including crossovers. Some users also share links to Google Docs or personal blogs where they post their work. If you’re lucky, you might stumble upon it on niche forums dedicated to either 'The Witcher' or 'Naruto,' where fans discuss and share rare fics. Always check the author’s notes for permissions—some writers move or delete their stories over time.

Why Did Senju Hashirama And Madara Uchiha Become Enemies?

5 Answers2025-08-28 19:38:41
I've always been drawn to tragic friendships, and the Hashirama–Madara split in 'Naruto' hits that sweet spot of heartbreak and ideology. At first they were comrades — two prodigies who could have ruled the shinobi world together — but their core beliefs pulled them apart. Hashirama wanted a village system where clans could stop fighting and ordinary people could live in peace; he trusted in cooperation and institutions. Madara, beaten down by the Uchiha's suffering and a history of clan bloodshed, grew convinced that power and domination were the only reliable means to ensure safety for his people. Their personal rivalry was aggravated by politics and status: Hashirama became the face of the new village as its leader, and Madara felt sidelined, humiliated, and betrayed. The deeper layers — the Indra–Asura reincarnation lineage, past family trauma, and differing concepts of peace — made their conflict inevitable. When trust erodes between former friends and the world pressures them into opposing roles, their clashes stopped being just personal and became symbolic of two incompatible futures. Watching that fall from friendship into warfare still stings for me, and every rewatch of their duel at the Valley of the End tightens that knot in my chest.

Where Did Madara Uchiha Hide After The Battle With Hashirama?

4 Answers2025-08-30 03:07:35
Man, the whole Madara legend never stops being wild to me. Right after that epic clash at the Valley of the End with Hashirama, Madara didn't actually vanish into some dramatic hero's death — he slipped away and went into deep, secret hiding. The basic beat is: he survived, took steps to secure longevity and power (using Hashirama's cells), and retreated to a secluded underground area where he could work in private. That’s where he developed the White Zetsu clones and cultivated his long game away from prying eyes. While the world assumed he was dead, Madara spent decades scheming. He awakened the Rinnegan late in life, encountered the ever-creepy Black Zetsu, and set up contingency plans that would later involve Obito as his proxy. So in short: after the battle he hid in remote, subterranean lairs and secret compounds, sheltering himself while building the tools and allies he'd need to bring the Moon's Eye Plan into motion — a patient, shadowy existence rather than a single, famous hideout, at least from what 'Naruto' shows me.

Who Are The Main Antagonists In 'The Witcher – Uchiha Madara!'?

5 Answers2025-06-16 02:29:55
In 'The Witcher – Uchiha Madara!', the main antagonists are a terrifying blend of supernatural and political threats. The most prominent is Uchiha Madara himself, a legendary ninja resurrected with god-like powers. His sheer strength and mastery of the Sharingan make him nearly unstoppable, capable of bending reality with illusions or summoning meteors to crush entire armies. His goal is to reshape the world through force, believing only absolute control can bring peace. The second major antagonist is the Nilfgaardian Empire, a ruthless faction exploiting the chaos Madara creates. Their emperor, Emhyr var Emreis, manipulates events from the shadows, using spies and assassins to expand his dominion. Unlike Madara’s overt destruction, Nilfgaard’s threat is subtle—corruption, betrayal, and systemic oppression. Together, they form a dual menace: one wielding raw power, the other wielding deception.
Explore and read good novels for free
Free access to a vast number of good novels on GoodNovel app. Download the books you like and read anywhere & anytime.
Read books for free on the app
SCAN CODE TO READ ON APP
DMCA.com Protection Status