Why Is The Giver Banned

2025-08-01 05:48:50 246

4 Answers

Finn
Finn
2025-08-02 08:58:02
'The Giver' gets banned because it tackles tough topics head-on. Some people don’t like that it shows a world where feelings are controlled and life isn’t valued the way we value it. The idea of 'release' being a form of euthanasia upsets a lot of readers, especially parents who think it’s too heavy for kids. But that’s what makes the book stand out—it doesn’t sugarcoat the hard questions. The bans are more about discomfort than anything else.
Helena
Helena
2025-08-03 22:56:56
Having seen countless debates about banned books, 'The Giver' is frequently targeted for its unflinching look at a society that sacrifices individuality for stability. The scenes involving euthanasia and the suppression of emotions are often cited as reasons for its removal from school curriculums. Critics claim it’s too dark for young readers, but that’s precisely why it’s important. It forces readers to confront uncomfortable truths about control and conformity. The bans reflect a reluctance to engage with challenging material, but literature like this is vital for fostering empathy and critical thought.
Noah
Noah
2025-08-04 17:36:36
I remember reading 'The Giver' in middle school and being shocked by its raw honesty. It’s banned in some places because it doesn’t shy away from dark themes like euthanasia and controlled societies. Parents and school boards sometimes argue that kids shouldn’t be exposed to such ideas, but I think that’s missing the point. The book’s power lies in its ability to make readers question the world around them. It’s not just about the disturbing moments; it’s about understanding why those moments matter. The bans often come from a place of wanting to protect kids, but stories like this are what help them grow.
Derek
Derek
2025-08-04 22:42:57
As someone who's spent years discussing controversial books in online forums, 'The Giver' by Lois Lowry is often banned because it challenges traditional societal norms. The novel's depiction of a dystopian world where emotions are suppressed and euthanasia is normalized makes some parents and educators uncomfortable. Schools frequently remove it due to themes of infanticide and the questioning of authority, which they believe are too mature for younger readers.

Another reason is its exploration of complex moral dilemmas, like the ethics of sameness and the cost of a pain-free society. Some argue that children aren't ready to grapple with these heavy topics. Yet, this is exactly why the book is so valuable—it sparks critical thinking and discussions about freedom, choice, and humanity. The bans often stem from fear, but banning it only highlights how necessary these conversations are.
View All Answers
Scan code to download App

Related Books

The Alpha's Caregiver
The Alpha's Caregiver
“Whatever you are, whoever you are, I will find out while you are within my reach, I will find out while I possess you. You do not belong to him anymore, you belong to me.” *** Life for an Omega only meant two things;being the perfect plaything for an Alpha or a breeder to carry his pups. How much worse could it be for Eudora who isn't just an Omega but a plus sized one with weird multi-colored hair that gave her the tag of a freak all her life? Raised by the Alpha and Luna of the BlueCoven pack after she was found as a pup in the middle of a bloody field ridden with corpses of wolves thought to be her family, Eudora lived her life with not a single hope of finding a mate who would accept her with all her imperfections.It gets worse. On her eighteenth birthday, she was brutally rejected by the son of the family that had raised her. To keep the shame of their son being mated to an Omega away from the members of the pack, she is sent off to join the harem of an older Alpha. It was going to be the end of her until HE showed up. The disturbed Alpha who is feared by all and hunted by his past. When he finds out she was the only one who could tame the other beast inside of me, he would do anything to keep her. A man who sees an Omega as a weakness he needed to hide away from the world and she, who sees him as a man who needed to be healed. It wasn’t going to be an easy battle. Not when both their pasts sneak up on them and change everything.
9.9
187 Chapters
The Billionaire's Caregiver
The Billionaire's Caregiver
Leah will do anything to fend for her family, even if it means disguising herself as a man to take a high-paying job as a caregiver. But her new boss, a billionaire, Jeremy Harper, is as broken as he is cold, still pained from betrayal and loss. When Leah's secret is found out, she gets fired, only to be called back, to something more; something larger than her. What began as a convenient, emotionless arrangement turns into a whirlwind of passion, lies and heartbreak. Can two wounded souls find love amid the chaos, or will their pasts destroy everything?
10
176 Chapters
Omega and the vampire prince
Omega and the vampire prince
Rejected by her mate the supreme Alpha of the Lunpa clan Tala Tamaska goes rogue to find a better life. Meanwhile Ray Vladimir was introduced as the prince of vampires but seemed and venture first before taking up responsibilities to the throne. The two met at ah highschool but at first their paths where not seemed to align, and after Tala got traded off to a vampire in order to save a wolf from her brother's clan, she got placed under a curse to go hunt Ray on the full moon. They started liking each other, maybe even admit that its love, but the Lunpa clan, Sean the vampire who cursed Tala, and an evil witch named Elaine had different plans for them. Werewolf and Vampire romance is banned by law but that didn't stop Ray from being with Tala, although he later finds out that Tala is a rare variant of wolf called a Twin venom, the only werewolf that can kill a noble vampire. Will Ray leave the dangers of being with Tala to instead marry a vampire Queen named Lilith to secure the future of two kingdoms? Or will his love for Tala prevail against all odds. Tala being an Omega her whole life, will she one day reach alpha? Will her twin venom heritage make her decide to rather not be with Ray, fearing she might kill him? Opposites attract, the age old rivalry between werewolves and vampires are revealed that wolves love vampire flesh, and vampires can't get enough of wolf blood. Inner conflicts, laws, consequences, all stand in the path of Ray and Tala, and the ultimate threat of Ray's grandfather, the sleeping tyrant Vlad Dracul looms in the future, who hates werewolves and wanted to wipe them out in the past.
6
149 Chapters
Treasured by the Alpha Prince
Treasured by the Alpha Prince
“Don’t let me choose between the two of you, Claire. Because it will definitely not be you.” I gasped at his words and my chocolate brown eyes widened as I stared into his blue one. I whimpered. My throat runs dry. Five years…. Five fucking years Is this how it all ends? “Choose Alan! Choose! Because I am not sharing your fucking ass with a nasty home wrecker. “ my voice shifted coldly. The humming of my heart could be heard miles away but I was not backing down. “Fine! You asked for this. Don’t say I didn’t warn you….I, Alpha Alan Crawley of desert storm pack reject you, Claire Claver, and your pup as my mate and pup. From this day you are banned from entering my pack. “ My heart clenched. Pain rippled through me…. *** Claire Claver had a crush on the future alpha of her pack for most of her teen years. On her 18th birthday, she found out she was mated to Alan Crawley It was a dream come true when he made her his in every way possible. Five years later, when it was around the time for her Luna ceremony, she catches him buried inside a woman, his so-called cousin, Olivia. All hope was lost for Claire, but little did she know that a powerful Lycan was searching for her after he caught a sniff of her scent would Claire find happiness again? Read on to find out.
10
65 Chapters
Dirty Deals With The Devil
Dirty Deals With The Devil
I belonged to the Devil, only it wasn't emblazoned on my forehead. ***Desperate times calls for desperate measures as they always say. When 10-year-old Ruby Davies accidentally kills her mom in a freak accident, she's totally terrified and torn.What was a ten year old to do in such a situation?That was exactly what the Devil banked upon when he swooped in as the hero, the savior, ready to bring back her mother only for a seemingly small price which little Ruby eagerly pays. Giving up her soul seemed like a wise decision at the time.Eight long years later, with a condemned life banned from all holy contacts and soul forever destined to perish in eternal fire and torment, Ruby wants absolutely nothing to do the lying soul thief.Until he comes once again with an irresistible offer only the biggest of fools would refuse...
10
45 Chapters
Rejected And Reclaimed
Rejected And Reclaimed
After being rejected by her fiance, Emma was banned from her kingdom. With a broken heart, she tries to start a new life. But to her surprise, the hunter from her kingdom wanted to kill her. Emma is suspicious about why her ex-fiance is trying to kill her. Hatred begins to fill Emma's heart; she is determined to repay Ryan Underwood treatment by asking for help from the Alpha twins, Callum and Derek Abelard, who are known as the notorious and heartless. Unexpectedly, the Alpha twins accepted Emma's request by asking for a reward for being their slave. Will Emma accepts their offer when Ryan also wants her back? Love, hate, and revenge. Which will Emma choose?
10
56 Chapters

Related Questions

Is The Giver A Banned Book

3 Answers2025-08-01 19:02:27
I’ve always been fascinated by the idea of banned books and what makes them so controversial. 'The Giver' by Lois Lowry is one of those books that sparks debate. Some schools and libraries have challenged it due to its themes of euthanasia and controlled societies, which they argue are too mature for younger readers. Personally, I think the book’s exploration of freedom and choice is incredibly thought-provoking. It’s not just a story; it’s a mirror held up to our own world. The way Lowry crafts this dystopian society feels eerily plausible, which might be why it unsettles some people. But that’s exactly why it’s such an important read—it forces you to question and reflect. The fact that it’s been banned in some places only makes me appreciate it more. It’s a testament to how powerful literature can be when it dares to challenge the status quo.

Why Was The Giver The Book Banned In Some Schools?

3 Answers2025-04-16 10:47:24
The book 'The Giver' was banned in some schools because it deals with themes that some people find controversial. The story includes ideas about euthanasia, controlled societies, and the loss of individuality, which can be unsettling for younger readers. Parents and educators sometimes worry that these topics are too mature or complex for children to handle. They fear that the book might confuse or disturb students rather than educate them. Additionally, the book's portrayal of a dystopian world where emotions are suppressed can be seen as promoting a negative view of authority and societal norms. This has led to its removal from certain school curriculums and libraries.

Why Was Novel The Giver Banned In Some Schools?

4 Answers2025-04-16 12:38:20
The novel 'The Giver' has been banned in some schools primarily due to its themes of euthanasia, infanticide, and sexual awakening, which some parents and educators find inappropriate for younger readers. The story’s depiction of a dystopian society that practices controlled breeding and the elimination of the elderly or imperfect infants has sparked controversy. Additionally, the book’s exploration of complex moral questions and its portrayal of a world without pain or emotional depth can be unsettling for some audiences. Critics argue that these elements are too mature for middle school students, who are often the target readers. However, supporters of the book believe it provides valuable lessons on individuality, freedom, and the importance of memory and emotions in shaping human experience. The debate continues, with some schools opting to include it in their curriculum while others remove it entirely.

Is The Giver Book To Read Online Banned Anywhere?

5 Answers2025-07-10 13:21:48
As someone who frequently discusses literature online, I've noticed that 'The Giver' by Lois Lowry is a book that sparks debates in various regions. While it's widely celebrated for its dystopian themes and thought-provoking narrative, some schools and libraries in the U.S. have challenged or banned it due to its mature content, including themes of euthanasia and controlled societies. Internationally, reactions vary; some conservative regions might restrict access to it in educational settings, but outright bans are rare. The book's exploration of freedom vs. control makes it a target for censorship in places that prioritize strict moral guidelines. However, many platforms offer it for online reading, as digital libraries often have more lenient policies. If you’re concerned about access, checking regional laws or school policies is wise. Despite controversies, 'The Giver' remains a staple in discussions about censorship and youth literature.

How Does 'The Giver' End?

3 Answers2025-06-29 07:25:17
The ending of 'The Giver' leaves us with a powerful but ambiguous moment. Jonas, after escaping the community with baby Gabriel, reaches what seems to be a new place. He sleds down a hill towards lights and music, suggesting he's found a village where people experience emotions and memories freely. The book cuts off there, making us wonder if it's real or a final hallucination from starvation and cold. Some readers think Jonas and Gabriel die, their sacrifice symbolizing hope. Others believe they survive, bringing change to the new society. The open-ended nature makes it haunting—we’re left debating whether it’s a tragedy or a triumph of human spirit.

What Happens In The Giver

3 Answers2025-08-01 14:33:53
I remember reading 'The Giver' and being completely captivated by its dystopian world. The story follows Jonas, a boy living in a seemingly perfect society where everything is controlled—no pain, no war, no suffering. But when he's chosen as the Receiver of Memory, he discovers the dark truth behind this 'utopia.' Through the Giver, he learns about emotions, colors, and the messy beauty of life that's been erased from his community. The climax is heart-wrenching as Jonas realizes the cost of this 'perfection' and makes a daring escape with a baby named Gabriel, hoping to find a place where life is truly lived. The book's exploration of freedom and humanity stuck with me long after I finished it.

How Does The Giver End

4 Answers2025-08-01 03:14:18
I was completely captivated by 'The Giver' by Lois Lowry, especially its ambiguous ending that leaves so much room for interpretation. After Jonas escapes the community with baby Gabriel, they embark on a perilous journey toward Elsewhere, a place of freedom and color. The final scene shows them sledding down a hill toward a warmly lit house, hearing music—symbolizing hope and a new beginning. Some readers believe they survive and find a better life, while others interpret it as a bittersweet, possibly tragic, culmination of their struggle. The beauty of 'The Giver' lies in its open-ended finale, allowing readers to ponder whether Jonas and Gabriel truly reach safety or if their journey ends in sacrifice. Lowry deliberately avoids spelling it out, making the ending a powerful conversation starter about choice, humanity, and the cost of utopia. Personally, I love endings that trust the reader to decide, and this one does it masterfully.

What Is The Climax Of The Giver

3 Answers2025-08-01 14:33:35
The climax of 'The Giver' is the moment Jonas decides to flee the community with Gabriel, the baby he’s grown attached to, to escape the controlled and emotionless society they live in. This decision comes after Jonas learns the dark truth about 'release,' which is actually euthanasia, and realizes the community’s so-called perfection is built on lies and suppression. The tension peaks as Jonas steals his father’s bicycle and some food, then sets off toward Elsewhere, a place he hopes offers freedom and real emotions. The weather turns harsh, and Jonas faces starvation and exhaustion, but he pushes forward, driven by his love for Gabriel and his desire for a better life. The climax is both thrilling and heartbreaking, as Jonas risks everything for a chance at true humanity.
Explore and read good novels for free
Free access to a vast number of good novels on GoodNovel app. Download the books you like and read anywhere & anytime.
Read books for free on the app
SCAN CODE TO READ ON APP
DMCA.com Protection Status