When Did The Practice Of Not Thinking Appear In Zen Teachings?

2025-10-17 01:05:03 220

5 Answers

Benjamin
Benjamin
2025-10-18 09:12:29
It's funny how a simple phrase like 'not thinking' can carry centuries of debate and practice — I love that about Zen. If you trace the idea historically, its recognizable form really starts to show up in Chinese Chan around the 6th and 7th centuries. The transmission from Indian meditation traditions (the Dhyana lineage) met Chinese culture and language, and from that fusion terms like 無念 (wu-nian, 'no-thought') and 無心 (wu-xin, 'no-mind') became central. A big milestone is the 'Platform Sutra' attributed to Huineng: he pushed a radical stance of sudden awakening and emphasized ceasing discursive clinging rather than trying to manipulate thoughts. That sutra popularized the shorthand that nonthinking is part of direct, immediate awakening.

I also like to point out that this wasn't invented in a vacuum. Earlier Mahayana sources that were circulating in China, like the 'Lankavatara Sutra', already explored non-conceptual awareness and critiques of conceptual thought. Chan absorbed those currents and turned them into practical, sometimes blunt, instruction: don’t chase thoughts, don’t fabricate a self that watches thoughts. Later developments split into flavors — Linji-style sharp shouts and koans used to shock the intellect out of its patterns, while Caodong teachers cultivated a quieter 'just sitting' approach that Westerners sometimes translate as 'not thinking' but which is more like relaxed alertness.

When I practice, I try to keep that historical texture in mind: 'not thinking' is less a literal banishment of thought and more a trained refusal to get tangled. It’s a stubbornly practical instruction with philosophical roots, and knowing it grew from both Indian meditation and Chinese reinterpretation makes it feel alive, not just a slogan. I still stumble through it, but that's part of the point — the lineage expects stumbling with a laugh and a friendly shove onward.
Gideon
Gideon
2025-10-19 11:44:41
Curious detail: the practice of 'not thinking' in Zen didn't pop into existence overnight — it's the fruit of a long conversation between Indian Buddhist insight and Chinese Chan ingenuity.

If we trace the idea back, Mahayana texts that circulated in the early centuries CE already point toward non-conceptual wisdom. Texts like the 'Lankavatara Sutra' and the 'Vimalakirti Nirdesa' emphasize seeing mind directly and not being trapped by conceptual overlays; they frame liberation as recognizing the emptiness or non-substantiality of thoughts rather than engaging them. By the time Buddhism moved eastward, teachers were carrying not just doctrines but experiential directions: how to relate to thoughts so they don't become obstacles. When those ideas landed in China and met Taoist sensibilities, a more pointed practice language developed.

Chinese Chan, beginning in the 5th–8th centuries and crystallizing with figures such as Bodhidharma and later the Sixth Patriarch, gave us the explicit practice vocabulary. The 'Platform Sutra' (attributed to the Sixth Patriarch, Huineng) uses phrases like 'no-thought' (wu-nian) to describe the attitude toward the mind: not suppression, but non-grasping. That teaching matured into multiple approaches—koan-based methods that break conceptual fixation, and meditative styles like 'silent illumination' and, later, the Soto emphasis of 'shikantaza' (just-sitting) as elaborated by teachers such as Dogen. Each tradition frames 'not thinking' slightly differently: sometimes it's sudden, sometimes it's a steady removal of attachment to thought.

I've sat in both koan work and long stretches of zazen, and I can testify that 'not thinking' is easy to misunderstand. It's not about producing a blank screen; it's more like learning to let thought be a passing weather pattern without chasing it. Reading the 'Platform Sutra' alongside modern guides helped me swap the image of mental erasure for one of spaciousness — and that change made the practice human, humble, and oddly joyful. It still surprises me how an ancient phrase like 'no-thought' can feel so practical in a noisy life.
Paisley
Paisley
2025-10-20 16:10:58
If you ask when 'not thinking' showed up as a named practice in Zen, the clearest historical marker lands in early Chinese Chan, especially around the 6th–7th centuries with figures like Huineng and the text we call the 'Platform Sutra'. But I also pay attention to ancestry: Indian meditation ideas about non-conceptual awareness were already in the air via texts such as the 'Lankavatara Sutra', and Chinese masters translated those ideas into pointed instructions like 無念 and 無心.

What I like about this is the nuance — across the generations it wasn’t a command to brutally silence thought but a pointer to not be entangled in thought, a training toward awake, unobstructed presence. Later teachers and schools refined and argued about it, so the phrase became a living practice rather than a static slogan. Personally, when I try to practice that 'not thinking', I remind myself that the whole lineage expects messiness, and that makes the effort feel friendlier and more human.
Xavier
Xavier
2025-10-22 12:41:21
There’s a lot packed into the phrase 'not thinking,' and I often turn to the debate between the early Chan figures to make sense of when it became doctrine. The flashpoint is the sixth-century split between the more gradual, cultivation-focused approach and Huineng’s sudden enlightenment message. The 'Platform Sutra' promotes the idea that true mind isn't produced by thought, and this is where the explicit teaching of 無念 starts to crystallize as a central practice cue: don’t invent or cling to mental constructions.

Beyond Huineng, the idea draws on Indian-era meditation texts that Chinese translators brought over, where non-conceptual awareness was already discussed. Over the next few centuries Chan teachers reworked those Buddhist philosophical points into method: Linji used paradox and verbal jolts to break conceptual fixation, while the Caodong lineage cultivated a luminous, objectless sitting that later Japanese practitioners like Dogen explored in 'Shobogenzo'. Dogen’s take complicated the matter — he insisted that 'no-thinking' wasn’t mere suppression but a living, active presence. For me, this means 'not thinking' appears historically as both an inherited philosophical concept and a practical, evolving set of meditation instructions: it didn’t spring up fully formed, it was hammered out through debate, scripture, and daily practice.

That layered history keeps the practice from feeling dogmatic; it’s a conversation across centuries, and participating in a short sit connects me to that long thread.
Hudson
Hudson
2025-10-23 05:25:28
Timeline-wise, the idea of not thinking shows up early in Buddhist thought and then becomes a defining feature of Chinese Chan.

Broadly speaking, Mahayana scriptures written in the early centuries CE already teach a kind of non-conceptual seeing; passages in works such as the 'Lankavatara Sutra' and 'Vimalakirti Nirdesa' press toward direct awareness beyond conceptual chatter. When Buddhist practice arrived in China, teachers like Bodhidharma and the Sixth Patriarch framed that heritage into concrete instruction. The 'Platform Sutra' explicitly talks about 'no-thought' and forms a clear anchor for the phrase in Zen literature.

After that, Song dynasty developments split into methods: the sudden, piercing strikes of koan practice and the steady, open 'silent illumination' that later influenced 'shikantaza'. Practically speaking, I treat 'not thinking' as a skill of dis-identifying from thoughts rather than trying to erase them — that shift changed my meditation from a struggle into something I could actually relax into, which still feels rewarding.
View All Answers
Scan code to download App

Related Books

Teaching an Alpha
Teaching an Alpha
Nova Jackson never knew another world existed other than the History she taught at her elementary school. Till she mets billionaire/Alpha Turner Ivy the parent of her favorite student Ella. Turner comes with dangerous secret and past pains that could break Nova’s heart. But Nova comes with a past that she didn’t even know she had till she moved schools to take a new teaching job. Will destiny, romance and danger be their downfall or the beginning of true love.
Not enough ratings
31 Chapters
Teaching their Omega
Teaching their Omega
Being an Omega is the last thing I want, especially since it makes some Alphas think of you as a breeding machine. My luck with Alphas haven't been the best and I know that it's because of my past and the few. . .issues I have. Time is running out though. My heat is drawing closer which means that I only have a few weeks to find an Alpha willing enough to help me through it without bonding me. The Omega Centre tried to help, but they don't understand what I want. However, there might be an Alpha who could help. All I need to do is talk his Beta into agreeing.
9.6
86 Chapters
When the Act Ended, So Did the Marriage
When the Act Ended, So Did the Marriage
My husband, Gavin Chapman, is giving his secretary, Natasha Gardner, exactly what she wants. He's making her his wife. To pull it off, he fakes a lab accident, pretends to have amnesia, and brings her home. In his office, Gavin wraps his arms around Natasha and murmurs indulgently, "Not just Mrs. Chapman. Even if you want to pretend to be the vice president for a week, I'll let you." My eyes dim, but I let the lie go on. The next day, at a press conference, Gavin holds Natasha's hand and tells the world she's his real wife. He even threatens to kick me out of the company and take over all my research data. Dozens of cameras swivel toward me, waiting for my outburst. But I stay silent and simply sign the termination papers. Gavin doesn't know that the pharmaceutical project he believes will be done in seven days isn't quite finished. There's still one final step, and I'm the only one who knows how to do it.
9 Chapters
"He saw me when no one did"
"He saw me when no one did"
Somewhere between staying silent and screaming for help… she existed. Seventeen-year-old Maren has mastered the art of disappearing in plain sight. Haunted by past trauma, locked in a toxic relationship she can't escape, and drowning under the pressure of school and a world that never cared to understand her, she begins to wonder if life is even worth staying for. No one sees her pain—until he does. The new boy, Kade, has his own shadows. He’s blunt, observant, and completely unafraid to call her out—making him an instant enemy. But when he overhears a moment no one was meant to witness, he realizes the truth: the girl everyone overlooks is barely holding on. As Kade steps deeper into her shattered world, their connection becomes a lifeline. But secrets run deeper than he imagined, and when Maren goes missing, no one believes she’s worth finding—except him. Fighting time, silence, and the lies that built her cage, Kade refuses to give up. Because sometimes, saving someone means proving they were never invisible at all. A heartbreaking, haunting, and ultimately hopeful story about survival, truth, and what it really means to be seen.
Not enough ratings
9 Chapters
Teaching her a lesson
Teaching her a lesson
She was moving closer in a suggestive manner, and it was obvious she was flirting. She asked, "What are you doing?" I replied, "Making you uncomfortable." It was clear that I was succeeding. I took a step back and asked, "What's happening? I just told you I hate you." "Yes, you did," she said, her fingers reaching out and grabbing my shirt, stopping me from backing away. "And that you want me, like I said when I arrived, even though you pretended you didn't hear me." "I'm confused," I responded. "It's simple," she replied, as she began unbuttoning my shirt. Her lips approached my ear and I could feel them on my skin as she whispered, "There are two things I want from a man. The first one is to be worshipped like a goddess." I shrugged the shirt off my shoulders and let her get to work on my belt as I went to work on her shorts. Pink panties. Bright pink. As pink as the thing inside them. "And the second one?" *** Read the filthy story between a teacher and his mischievous students as they attempt to entice him.
8.8
200 Chapters
Only When I Died Did He Go Insane
Only When I Died Did He Go Insane
It had been ten years, and Ethan—my mate—and I still didn’t have a pup. One day, he suggested we adopt one from the Werewolf Orphan Charity Agency. “My mate,” he said gently, “pregnancy is too hard for you. You’d have to go through so many checkups and herbs. Your wolf shouldn’t have to suffer like that.” When others heard this, they all said Ethan loved me deeply—that he couldn’t bear to see me in pain. But I saw the truth with my own eyes. He took an infant pup from another she-wolf. “Luckily, Mia isn’t pregnant,” he said. “That way, the excuse of adopting an infant works—and the pup can have a legitimate status in my clan.” I knew that she-wolf well. The same one Ethan used to call a “stupid omega.” Swallowing the bitterness in my heart, I called my mentor at the Werewolf Research Academy. “I want to devote myself to herb research,” I said calmly. Three days from now, during the pup’s first New Moon blessing, I’ll fake my death in a fire. No one will be able to stop me.
10 Chapters

Related Questions

Can The Art Of Thinking Clearly Book Help With Daily Life Challenges?

1 Answers2025-09-17 10:14:39
The insights I’ve gained from reading 'The Art of Thinking Clearly' have honestly shaped the way I approach everyday situations. This book dives deep into cognitive biases and logical fallacies, presenting them in a digestible format that makes the concepts stick. I often find myself reflecting on its lessons during daily challenges like decision-making at work or resolving conflicts with friends. For example, one of the biases discussed is the confirmation bias—our tendency to search for, interpret, and remember information in a way that confirms our preconceptions. I’ve caught myself in this trap when debating movie choices with my buddies; I tend to cling to reviews of films I want to see while disregarding the bad ones! Now, after recognizing this pattern, I make a conscious effort to consider multiple viewpoints, making for much more enriching discussions. Another fantastic section is about the idea of 'loss aversion,' which shows how we tend to prefer avoiding losses to acquiring equivalent gains. This insight has been especially helpful when facing career-related decisions, where the fear of failure can be paralyzing. By framing choices in terms of potential gains instead of losses, I’ve found it easier to take bold steps—whether applying for a new job or trying something totally out of my comfort zone, like attending that sketchy karaoke night! Each chapter of the book seems to have its own kind of magic to address our daily challenges, making me feel more empowered and clear-headed. Ultimately, this book isn’t just about dissecting psychological traps; it’s also about how we can learn to navigate through life more effectively. I think anyone picking it up will find nuggets of wisdom that can be walked into daily conversations and interactions. Reflecting on it often makes me smile, as I realize how much our thinking patterns influence our choices, relationships, and ultimately, our happiness.

How Does The Rich Dad Poor Dad Book Change Financial Thinking?

4 Answers2025-09-18 07:14:17
Reading 'Rich Dad Poor Dad' opened my eyes to the world of finance in a whole new way. I used to think saving money was the key to financial security, but this book flipped that notion right on its head. The contrast between the mindsets of the rich and the poor is laid out so clearly that I found myself reflecting on my own beliefs and habits. The idea of having money work for you rather than you working for money really resonated. It got me thinking about investments—stocks, real estate, and even understanding cash flow. I began to view my job differently, as a means to fuel my investments rather than just a paycheck. It's empowering to realize that financial education can change your entire life perspective. Engaging with the principles from this book has not only changed how I think about money but also how I approach life in general. Now, I'm always searching for opportunities to learn more and grow my financial knowledge, which feels like a whole new adventure. This shift has made me excited about the future and my potential to create wealth.

Which Authors Wrote Influential Books About Thinking?

3 Answers2025-09-13 11:13:13
You know, a few authors really stand out when it comes to influential books about thinking. One that comes to mind immediately is Daniel Kahneman, especially with his work 'Thinking, Fast and Slow'. This book dives deep into the dual processes of thought—System 1, which is quick and instinctive, and System 2, which is more deliberate and logical. It's fascinating how he explores the biases we all have and how they impact our decision-making. I remember reading it and just being blown away by the way our minds can trick us! What I love most about Kahneman’s insights is how applicable they are to everyday life. Whether you’re negotiating a deal, reflecting on a personal situation, or even just choosing where to eat, understanding these thought processes can be a game changer. Another author that really influences how we think is Edward de Bono. His book 'Six Thinking Hats' introduces a unique framework to analyze problems and make decisions. Each hat represents a different style of thinking, and I found this approach to be super refreshing. It encourages a more rounded discussion, especially in group settings, which can often become so polarized. I often use this metaphor in my own discussions to help myself and others look at issues from multiple angles. It’s incredible how merely changing your perspective can lead to innovative solutions. Then there's Malcolm Gladwell with books like 'Outliers' and 'Blink'. Gladwell focuses on the nuances of intuition and social psychology, challenging traditional notions of success and decision-making. What's cool about his writing is that it’s not just academic; he weaves stories that keep you engaged and make complex ideas accessible. You finish one of his books not only enlightened but also with a deeper understanding of the social dynamics around you. It’s like a secret weapon for life! These authors really reshape how we engage with our thoughts on a daily basis, and I can’t recommend them enough!

What Themes Are Explored In A Book About Thinking?

3 Answers2025-09-13 19:37:47
Books that delve into the concept of thinking often unravel a multitude of themes, each intertwining elegantly to give readers a deeper understanding of the mind's intricacies. One prominent theme is the exploration of consciousness and self-awareness. For instance, works like 'Thinking, Fast and Slow' by Daniel Kahneman illuminate the dichotomy between intuitive and rational thinking. Kahneman categorizes our thought processes into two systems, presenting a fascinating dialogue about how often we rely on snap judgments instead of deliberate reasoning. This revelation can be quite eye-opening, especially for those striving to make informed decisions in their lives. Another rich theme present in these texts is the impact of cognitive biases on our daily lives. These biases skew our perceptions and influence our choices in significant ways. As an aspiring psychologist, I find it immensely intriguing that many readers might not be aware of how these biases operate. Delving into such insights can not only encourage critical thinking but also inspire readers to be more mindful of their decisions. Thus, a book like 'The Art of Thinking Clearly' by Rolf Dobelli can provoke deep reflections on personal experiences and decision-making processes, making the reader feel empowered to challenge their thought patterns. Lastly, the theme of the interconnectedness of thoughts and emotions emerges beautifully in these narratives. They emphasize that our emotional states often dictate our thought processes, revealing the profound bond between our mental and emotional selves. This blend of psychology and philosophy enriches our understanding, inviting discussions about how emotional intelligence plays a role in effective thinking. Overall, such books can radically alter one’s perception about the self and the world, making the journey of thinking a profound adventure to embark upon.

What Role Do Good Vibes Quotes Play In Positive Thinking?

4 Answers2025-09-14 17:12:05
Good vibes quotes really serve as little bursts of motivation that can brighten our day, don’t you think? They remind us that positivity is a choice, and sometimes, we just need that nudge to shift our mindset. For instance, reading something like 'Your vibe attracts your tribe' can be such a powerful reminder. It encourages us to surround ourselves with positive people, which makes a massive difference in how we perceive the world around us. When I’m feeling a bit low or overwhelmed, I jot down my favorite quotes and stick them on my wall or on my phone. They become my daily affirmations, almost like little mantras that I reconnect with regularly. 'Believe you can, and you’re halfway there' is another favorite of mine, and I love how it subtly pushes me to strive for my goals. In a fast-paced, sometimes negative world, these quotes provide a grounding moment. They offer wisdom in a simple form, and honestly, sharing them with friends can spark those uplifting conversations we all need. Who doesn’t love spreading a little positivity?

Are There Scientific Benefits To The 5 Am Club Practice?

4 Answers2025-10-17 20:57:02
Getting up at 5 am can actually have measurable effects, and I’ve poked into the science enough to feel comfortable saying it’s not just morning-person bragging. On the biological side, waking early tends to sync you with natural light cycles: exposure to bright morning light helps suppress melatonin and resets your circadian rhythm, which can improve sleep quality and daytime alertness. There’s also the cortisol awakening response — a natural uptick in cortisol after waking — that can give you a short-term boost in alertness and readiness. When you pair that with a consistent routine, the brain starts to anticipate productive activity, which reduces decision fatigue and can make focused work feel easier. From a cognitive and behavioral standpoint, studies link regular morning routines with better planning, more consistent exercise habits, and reduced procrastination. Habit formation research shows that consistent timing (like always starting your day at the same hour) strengthens cues and automaticity. That’s why people who keep a steady wake time often report getting more done without feeling like they’re forcing themselves. But scientific papers also remind us to be careful: many findings show correlations, not strict causation. Some benefits attributed to early rising might come from getting enough sleep, better lifestyle choices, or personality differences rather than the hour itself. Practically I’ve found the sweet spot is making sure bedtime shifts with wake time. If you drag yourself out of bed at 5 am but barely slept, the benefits evaporate. Bright morning light, a short bout of exercise, and a focused 60–90 minute block for creative or deep work tend to compound the gains. Personally, when I respect sleep and craft a calm morning, 5 am feels like reclaimed time rather than punishment — it’s peaceful, productive, and oddly joyful.

How Accurately Does 'This Is Going To Hurt' Portray Medical Practice?

5 Answers2025-10-17 18:12:15
The realism in 'This Is Going to Hurt' lands in a way that made me wince and nod at the same time. Watching it, I felt the grind of clinical life — the never-quite-right sleep, the pager that never stops, the tiny victories that feel huge and the mistakes that echo. The show catches the rhythm of shift work: adrenaline moments (crashes, deliveries, emergency ops) interspersed with the long, boring paperwork stretches. That cadence is something you can’t fake on screen, and here it’s portrayed with a gritty, darkly comic touch that rings true more often than not. What I loved most was how it shows the emotional bookkeeping clinicians carry. There are scenes where the humour is almost a coping mechanism — jokes at 3 a.m., gallows-laugh reactions to the absurdity of protocols — and then it flips, revealing exhaustion, guilt, and grief. That flip is accurate. The series and the source memoir don’t shy away from burnout, the fear of making a catastrophic mistake, or the way personal life collapses around a demanding rota. Procedural accuracy is decent too: basic clinical actions, the language of wards, the shorthand between colleagues, and the awkward humanity of breaking bad news are handled with care. Certain procedures are compressed for drama, but the essence — that patients are people and that clinicians are juggling imperfect knowledge under time pressure — feels honest. Of course, there are areas where storytelling bends reality. Timelines are telescoped to keep drama tight, and rare or extreme cases are sometimes foregrounded to make a point. Team dynamics can be simplified: the messy, multi-disciplinary support network that really exists is occasionally sidelined to focus on a single protagonist’s burden. The NHS backdrop is specific, so viewers in other healthcare systems might not map every frustration directly. Still, the show’s core — the moral compromises, the institutional pressures, the small acts of kindness that matter most — is portrayed with painful accuracy. After watching, I came away with a deeper respect for the quiet endurance of people who work those wards, and a lingering ache that stayed with me into the next day.

Which Techniques Teach The Practice Of Not Thinking Quickly?

2 Answers2025-10-17 16:57:10
Whenever my mind races, I reach for tiny rituals that force me to slow down — they feel like pressing the pause button on a brain that defaults to autopilot. One of the core practices I've kept coming back to is mindfulness meditation, especially breath-counting and noting. I’ll sit for ten minutes, count breaths up to ten and then start over, or silently label passing thoughts as ‘planning,’ ‘worry,’ or ‘memory.’ It sounds simple, but naming a thought pulls it out of the fast lane and gives my head the space to choose whether to follow it. I also practice the STOP technique: Stop, Take a breath, Observe, Proceed. It’s like a compact emergency brake when I'm about to react too quickly. Beyond sitting still, I use movement-based slowdowns — long walks without headphones, tai chi, and casual calligraphy sessions where every stroke forces deliberation. There’s something meditative about doing a repetitive, focused task slowly; it trains patience. For decision-making specifically, I’ve adopted a few habit-level fixes: mandatory cooling-off periods for big purchases (48 hours), a ‘ten-minute rule’ for emailing reactions, and pre-set decision checklists so I don’t leap on the first impulse. I also borrow ideas from psychology: ‘urge surfing’ for cravings, cognitive defusion from Acceptance and Commitment Therapy to watch thoughts as clouds rather than facts, and the pre-mortem technique to deliberately imagine how a decision could fail — that method flips fast intuition into structured, slower forecasting. If you like books, ‘Thinking, Fast and Slow’ really helped me understand why my brain loves quick answers and how to set up systems to favor the slower, more rational path. If I want a gentle mental reset, I do a five-senses grounding: list 5 things I can see, 4 I can touch, 3 I can hear, 2 I can smell, 1 I can taste. It immediately drags me back into the present. Journaling is another slow-thinker’s weapon — free-write for eight minutes about the problem, then step back and annotate it after an hour. Over time I’ve noticed a pattern: slowing down isn’t just about the big, formal practices; it’s the tiny rituals — a breath, a pause, a walk, a written note — that build the muscle of deliberate thinking. On a lazy Sunday, that slow attention feels downright luxurious and oddly victorious.
Explore and read good novels for free
Free access to a vast number of good novels on GoodNovel app. Download the books you like and read anywhere & anytime.
Read books for free on the app
SCAN CODE TO READ ON APP
DMCA.com Protection Status