When Did The Proverb The Enemy Of My Enemy Is My Enemy Appear?

2025-08-28 04:50:20 304

4 Answers

Theo
Theo
2025-08-29 01:56:30
My take is more of a political-mindset dive: the proverb's authoritative early attestation is often traced to ancient South Asian political theory, namely 'Arthashastra' (classical dates debated, but roughly 4th century BCE). The core strategic logic — that a common adversary can create incentive for cooperation — is what made the phrase portable across Greek, Arabic, and later European diplomatic thought. I find it helpful to separate the proverb's historical origin from its life as a rhetorical device; historians point to Kautilya, while journalists and diplomats kept recycling the phrase during colonial era power plays and 19th-century imperial alignments.

The inverted version you mentioned — where the enemy of an enemy remains an enemy — is interesting sociologically. It shows up in modern commentary about coalition risks: sometimes those shared enemies are temporary, and hostility can persist or even spread. I teach or argue this point in discussions: alliances of convenience can store troubles for the future. If you want a deeper read, compare the original political context in 'Arthashastra' with case studies from 20th-century alliances to see how the proverb gets bent to suit narratives.
Cole
Cole
2025-08-30 22:00:09
I've gotten into debates with friends about this line and the confusion is real: most historical traces point to the idea that teaming up with your enemy's enemy is useful, not that the enemy of my enemy remains my enemy. The pro-friend version is ancient — often credited to Kautilya's 'Arthashastra' from around 300–400 BCE — and shows up as a practical rule for statecraft. Across centuries the idea turns up in different cultures, because alliances are a universal headache.

The flip version, 'the enemy of my enemy is my enemy', reads like a modern contrarian joke or political warning: be careful who you ally with because they might become your foe later. I first heard that twist in a political podcast and it stuck as a neat one-liner about short-term realpolitik failing in the long run.
Nolan
Nolan
2025-08-31 06:35:13
You could think of this proverb as ancient common sense. The more familiar line, 'the enemy of my enemy is my friend', goes back a very long time — people usually point to the Sanskrit political manual 'Arthashastra' from around the fourth century BCE as among the oldest written places the idea appears. That makes sense: early states needed rules for making and breaking alliances.

The version you asked about, where the enemy of my enemy is my enemy, is mostly a modern twist. I first heard it tossed out in a debate as a warning that short-term alliances can backfire; it’s a retort more than a classical proverb. In class we used it to discuss how wartime partners sometimes fight later — it’s a neat, skeptical flip that sparks conversation.
Isaac
Isaac
2025-09-03 12:00:42
History nerd hat on: I get a little giddy about origins like this. The version most people recognize is actually 'the enemy of my enemy is my friend' and its basic logic goes way back. Scholars usually point to ancient India — specifically the treatise known as 'Arthashastra' attributed to Kautilya (also called Chanakya) — as among the earliest textual expressions of that diplomatic idea, roughly around the 4th century BCE. So this kind of pragmatic alliance-making is at least two millennia old.

That said, proverbs and diplomatic maxims have popped up independently in many cultures, so similar formulations show in later Greek, Arabic, and medieval European writings too. The twist you asked about — 'the enemy of my enemy is my enemy' — reads like a modern, cynical inversion used to warn against short-term alliances that breed long-term problems. I’ve seen it in opinion pieces and alt-history novels where alliances backfire; it’s less of an ancient proverb and more of a contemporary rhetorical spin. If you like digging, read a bit of 'Arthashastra' and then scan some 19th–20th century diplomatic histories to see how the saying has been repurposed over time.
View All Answers
Scan code to download App

Related Books

My Fated Enemy
My Fated Enemy
Kaira has always been able to see glimpses of the future, but even her powers couldn't save her from Alpha Jarith's betrayal. She was supposed to become his Luna—his Queen. Little did she know that the love of her life wanted her dead. She managed to escape, but the road to her safe haven led through the lands of her greatest enemies. She thought that death would finally claim her, but the Fates placed an unexpected savior on her path… Alpha Dearon was the Angel of Death and the Demon of Lust combined. The soon-to-be king of the broken kingdom wished for nothing more than to keep Kaira by his side. She tried to resist. She knew how reckless it was, but she couldn't walk away. Finally, she surrendered to her desires, letting him heal her once-broken heart, even knowing their happiness wouldn't last… Now she's running out of time, and every breath brings her closer to her end. The secrets can no longer stay hidden, and her true identity is about to be revealed. This is the game she cannot win, but higher powers force her to risk it all. Will the Fates bond them together or forever taint their hearts with hatred?
10
132 Chapters
My Enemy Is My Lover
My Enemy Is My Lover
Rosa met James in a restaurant that he owned and because she was dressed in a shaggy clothing he thought she was an employee in one of his lowest restaurants. They had an argument and they resented each other after that day. James thought Rosa was a lowlife and also arrogant and Rosa thought James was just a rich jerk. They cross paths again in the most unbelievable way possible. Curious about their story? Find out in My Enemy is My Lover.
10
117 Chapters
My dear enemy
My dear enemy
Asher Thompson and Ryder Blackwood have been sworn enemies for years, engaging in a series of heated battles in the corporate world. But when Ryder becomes the new CEO of Thompson Industries, Asher is forced to work alongside his nemesis. As they clash in the boardroom, Asher and Ryder can't deny the sparks flying between them. But with their families' complicated past and their own pride at stake, they must navigate the treacherous landscape of their feelings. Will they be able to put aside their differences and surrender to their desires, or will their animosity tear them apart?
10
165 Chapters
My Enemy is My Mate
My Enemy is My Mate
"I know,” I cried out. His back was faced towards me as I spoke. “I know how it feels like to love you.” Anger started boiling inside of me as I said, “It hurts to love someone like you.” ---- Samantha Parker is an ordinary female werewolf who wishes to have something good in her life after her parents’ death. That good thing turned out to be her worst nightmare as she found out that Ryder Jackson, her brother’s best friend, was her mate. Not only that but she finds out that there was someone, who was responsible for her parents' death, lurking in the shadows ready to take her away. She would encounter difficult situations which led her to think that her life was a lie and the truth needed to be unraveled.
10
126 Chapters
My mate is my enemy
My mate is my enemy
Zara, the late Alpha's daughter from the Edwood pack, was never loved by her stepbrother because of her mixed race. She was treated as an omega. Accepting her sad reality, she longed to find her mate, hoping her circumstances would change for the better. However, as fate would have it, her world came crashing down when she discovered her mate was Vulvan, the Alpah of the Regan pack and sworn enemies to the Edwood pack, but this new discovery brought a twist to her life because her stepbrother would seize this opportunity to conquer the Regans. Vulvan, on the other hand, had his own evil intentions for Zara. Despite this dilemma, Zara fell in love with Vulvan, determined to end the animosity between the two packs. This is a world full of manipulation, deceit, lies, vengeance, and hatred. Will Zara be able to end their animosity?Will Vulvan accept her love?What will happen when she discovers she's pregnant for vulvan?.
Not enough ratings
30 Chapters
My Alpha, My Enemy
My Alpha, My Enemy
Born as the only wolfless person in her pack, Blake's life had been nothing but misery and humiliation, and she never expected things to change. But one innocent accident would change the course of her life forever when she met an Alpha in the male bathroom of her school. Now that her path had crossed with his, her life as a wolfless hybrid would now become the life of a powerful rogue wolf, and when she thought her fate with Nero couldn't get any more twisted, she is faced with the dilemma of choosing or killing him. *I always knew Blake and I was an impossible force from the moment we met again, and I don't get why fate keeps trying to merge us… Only chaos can blossom from what we are, and I want to shield her from all of it. But after everything that has happened so far, I realized that the universe wouldn't allow that to happen, so I will give in to its intention until everything burned into ash for us.
7.9
116 Chapters

Related Questions

What Makes Love Enemy Relationships Compelling In TV Series?

3 Answers2025-10-13 20:01:03
There's something undeniably captivating about love enemy relationships in TV series. I think it all comes down to the tension and chemistry that sparks between two opposing forces. Watching characters who initially clash due to their differences gradually develop feelings for one another creates this intense anticipation. It’s like a delicious slow burn that makes every glance, argument, and unexpected moment count. Take 'Kaguya-sama: Love Is War,' for instance. You've got two top students who engage in this hilarious battle of wits and pride, while their deeper feelings simmer beneath the surface. The comedy entwined with the emotional stakes keeps viewers glued to the screen, rooting for them to each other, knowing they’re both trying to outsmart the other while being hopelessly in love. Additionally, these relationships often provide rich character growth. Watching enemies evolve into lovers reveals layers to their personalities. Characters might start as one-dimensional villains or rivals, but as they confront their issues, vulnerabilities shine through. This transformation can be incredibly gratifying to witness. Compare it to the dynamic in 'Your Lie in April,' where past traumas and rivalries push characters to new heights, leading to beautiful resolutions that resonate deep within. It’s magical when the friction of animosity shifts into affection, and that transition is thrilling to savor throughout a series. Ultimately, love enemy relationships remind us that opposites can attract in the most unexpected ways. That juxtaposition of hate and love is both compelling and relatable, as many of us have encountered a similar tension in our lives. It’s a blend of excitement, humor, and genuine emotion that creates memorable on-screen moments. As a fan, I can’t get enough of them!

What Merchandise Showcases Iconic Love Enemy Couples?

3 Answers2025-10-13 00:12:17
Merchandise spotlighting iconic love-hate couples is everywhere, and it truly captures the unique dynamic of these relationships! One that immediately springs to mind is the eternal rivalry between Edward Elric and Winry Rockbell from 'Fullmetal Alchemist'. I’ve seen everything from adorable chibi figures to beautifully detailed art prints showcasing moments between them. It's incredible how even their bickering feels endearing. They complement each other perfectly, reflecting the beauty of how enemies can have deep connections! You can also snag some amazing merch from 'Naruto'. The playful tension between Sasuke and Sakura has birthed everything from keychains to plushies. When you see them together on a product, it often sparks conversations about their growth throughout the series, making these collectibles special. In the realm of western comics, 'Harley Quinn and the Joker' merchandise tugs on my heartstrings—from high-quality statues to quirky apparel that embodies their chaotic yet passionate bond. It's fascinating to see how the complexity of their relationship has transcended comic pages. Even fandoms can sometimes blur the lines between love and enmity, sparking endless discussions and fan art on platforms like Instagram and Tumblr. Merch celebrating these couples not only caters to nostalgia but also to the emotional weight these stories carry, making it truly valuable in, not just a collector's sense but also in the vibrant storytelling they represent. To sum it all up, these collectibles represent more than just characters; they evoke memories and discussions, making them a part of a deeper conversation about love and rivalry that resonates with many fans, including myself. It's such a joy to explore this world through these adorable items!

Where Was Sleeping With The Enemy Filmed On Location?

4 Answers2025-08-27 09:40:21
I love geeking out about little film-location details, and 'Sleeping with the Enemy' is one of those movies where the locations do as much storytelling as the actors. The film is famously set in Cedar Falls, Iowa, but most of the on-location shooting actually took place in Massachusetts. The house that becomes Laura’s new life after she fakes her death is in Marblehead, Massachusetts, and a lot of the seaside and neighborhood shots that give the film that chilly New England vibe were filmed around Marblehead and nearby coastal towns. I once wandered the Marblehead waterfront with a friend after rewatching the movie, trying to spot the exact angles—locals were pleasantly amused by my questions. Besides Marblehead, the production used other Massachusetts locations for various scenes, so if you’re tracking it down you’ll see a classic New England mix rather than Iowa streets. It’s a neat reminder of how movies shift places to match mood, and if you’re into location-hunting, Marblehead is worth a stroll (respect private property, though—those houses are lived in).

Where Can I Find 'Know The Enemy' Lyrics Online?

5 Answers2025-09-12 20:34:01
Man, I was obsessed with hunting down the lyrics to 'Know the Enemy' too! It's one of those tracks that just hits different, especially when you wanna scream along. I usually start by checking lyric databases like Genius or AZLyrics—they’re pretty reliable and often include annotations about the song’s meaning. Spotify’s lyrics feature has also gotten way better lately, so that’s another solid option. If you’re into deep dives, sometimes fan forums or subreddits dedicated to the band have threads discussing lyrics, especially if there’s debate about certain lines. I once found a goldmine of interpretations on a niche music forum that totally changed how I heard the song. Oh, and don’t forget YouTube! Fan-made lyric videos are everywhere, though quality varies.

Is There A Music Video For 'Know The Enemy' Lyrics?

5 Answers2025-09-12 00:30:21
Man, 'Know the Enemy' hits different, doesn't it? I spent ages digging into this track because the lyrics felt like they deserved a visual feast. While there isn't an official music video for it, the fan-made edits on YouTube are *wild*. Some pair it with scenes from 'Attack on Titan'—super fitting given the rebellious vibe—while others splice together protest footage. It's crazy how the community fills gaps like this. One of my fav fan videos uses clips from 'Devilman Crybaby', and the chaos matches perfectly. If you're into AMVs, it's worth a deep dive. Honestly, the lack of an official MV makes the fan creations feel even more special, like a collective love letter to the song.

What Inspired The Author To Write Sleeping With The Enemy Novel?

5 Answers2025-04-26 14:54:30
The inspiration behind 'Sleeping with the Enemy' likely stems from the author’s fascination with the darker side of human relationships, particularly the facade of perfection that can hide abuse. I think the author wanted to explore how someone can appear charming and loving to the outside world while being a monster behind closed doors. The novel delves into the psychological manipulation and control that often goes unnoticed, shedding light on the courage it takes to escape such a situation. It’s also possible that the author drew from real-life stories or observations of domestic violence, aiming to give a voice to those who feel trapped. The protagonist’s journey from fear to empowerment resonates deeply, and I believe the author wanted to highlight the strength it takes to reclaim one’s life. The novel’s tension and suspense are crafted to keep readers on edge, making it a gripping tale of survival and resilience.

Where Can I Stream An Enemy To-Lovers Movie Tonight?

3 Answers2025-08-24 04:42:30
If you want something that'll scratch that enemy-to-lovers itch tonight, my top trick is to open JustWatch or Reelgood first — they save you so much scrolling. I usually pick a vibe (sassy rom-com, smart period drama, or something with a little supernatural twist) and then search for specific titles. A few reliable picks I reach for are 'The Hating Game' for pure office-fireworks, '10 Things I Hate About You' for teenage snark and peak '90s energy, and 'Much Ado About Nothing' if I’m in the mood for witty Shakespearean barbs turning into hugs. Those often show up on Netflix, Prime Video, or Hulu depending on region; otherwise, you can usually rent them on Apple TV, Google Play, or YouTube Movies. If you’re trying to avoid paying tonight, check Tubi, Pluto, or Peacock — they sometimes have older rom-coms that fit the trope. Also, don’t forget Kanopy or Hoopla if you have a library card; I’ve borrowed gems through those before. If you want company vibes, use Netflix Party or a watch party feature on Prime to sync up with friends. Pick something light and bring snacks I’d recommend popcorn and something fizzy — the banter lands better that way.

What Are Underrated Indie Enemy To-Lovers Movie Gems?

3 Answers2025-08-24 16:56:23
I get a thrill from finding those little indie movies that start off with snark, distrust, or flat-out deception and then quietly slide into real chemistry. If you like enemies-to-lovers that feel messy and human rather than tropey, try these picks. 'The Handmaiden' is a glorious, twisted example: it begins with con artistry and manipulation, but the emotional arc between the two women becomes heartbreakingly real. Park Chan-wook’s film is lush, erotic, and darkly playful — perfect if you want an intense, slow-burn shift from antagonism to genuine attachment. 'Safety Not Guaranteed' is the opposite vibe, a small, silly indie where a skeptical intern and an oddball man planning time travel trade barbs and ultimately find tenderness; it’s quiet, funny, and oddly sweet. 'My Summer of Love' is raw and a little dangerous — two girls from different backgrounds meet with suspicion and class friction, which morphs into an intoxicating and uneasy romance. For something more cerebral, 'The One I Love' plays with identity and trust; it’s a tiny sci-fi-tinged relationship puzzle where a couple’s fragility turns into surprising tenderness amid bizarre circumstances. 'Saving Face' offers cultural friction and familial expectations along with a lovable slow-burn romance between two women who initially clash over honesty and identity. And if you want erotic, art-house power-play that still carries a thread of adversarial attraction, 'The Duke of Burgundy' explores control, negotiation, and how conflict can be a weird kind of intimacy. These films all scratch that particular itch: initial friction that flares into connection. I often rewatch them when I want something that remembers people are complicated, and I love how each one handles the shift in tone — sometimes violent, sometimes tender, always interesting.
Explore and read good novels for free
Free access to a vast number of good novels on GoodNovel app. Download the books you like and read anywhere & anytime.
Read books for free on the app
SCAN CODE TO READ ON APP
DMCA.com Protection Status