What Are The Scientific Errors In 'Journey To The Center Of The Earth'?

2025-06-24 13:08:16 130

3 Answers

Patrick
Patrick
2025-06-27 14:05:12
'Journey to the Center of the Earth' makes me chuckle with its wild liberties. The biggest whopper is the idea of giant caverns near the core—pressure at those depths would crush anything hollow into molten paste. The novel treats temperature like a mild sauna when reality would vaporize humans instantly. Dinosaurs surviving underground? Cute, but biologically impossible without sunlight or ecosystems. The magnetic compass scene is pure fiction too; magnetic fields don’t work that way so deep. Verne’s ocean at the center? Physics says liquid couldn’t exist under that much heat and pressure. Still love the adventure though—just don’t use it as a science textbook.
Violet
Violet
2025-06-28 21:14:16
Here’s the tea on 'Journey to the Center of the Earth'—it’s a masterpiece of imagination that flunks basic science. The characters survive falls that would pancake them into jelly, and breathe air where oxygen molecules would be crushed by pressure. That underground ocean? Water would superheat into plasma at those depths. The ‘luminous gas’ lighting the caves breaks chemistry laws—no gas glows eternally without energy input.

Verne’s dinosaurs are fantasy creatures, not science. Paleontology shows extinction was absolute, and no ecosystem could sustain large predators underground. The novel’s compass navigation ignores how magnetic fields warp near molten iron. Even the famous ‘Sneffels volcano’ entry point is nonsense—Icelandic volcanoes don’t connect to deep mantle tubes. Yet these ‘errors’ created iconic adventure fiction. Want accurate subterranean fiction? Try 'The Hole' by Hiroko Oyamada instead—it nails psychological realism over faux-science.
Zoe
Zoe
2025-06-30 10:15:05
Reading 'Journey to the Center of the Earth' feels like watching a magician ignore physics for spectacle. Let’s break it down layer by layer.

The crust-to-core journey would take months, not days—drilling through rock isn’t a subway ride. Real-world drill projects like Kola Superdeep barely scratched 12 km after years, while Verne’s characters waltz through 6,000 km like it’s a hiking trail. The novel’s ‘hollow Earth’ concept contradicts seismic data showing a solid mantle and liquid outer core. Those volcanic tubes they slide down? They’d be hotter than steel mills, not cool enough for wooden raft rides.

Then there’s the biology. Giant mushrooms need photosynthesis, not geothermal vents. The ‘living fossils’ trope ignores evolution’s pace—species don’t stay unchanged for millennia. Verne’s atmospheric pressure calculations are off by factors of thousands too. Modern geology proves Earth’s interior is denser and hotter than 19th-century sci-fi could’ve imagined. Still, the book’s charm lies in how it inspired real scientists to explore the impossible.
View All Answers
Scan code to download App

Related Books

Scientific Alpha
Scientific Alpha
A lust unable to quench .Stuck in between two males. Unable to select whom to choose. Arenza is a normal billionaire daughter who lost her family during an assassin attack. She is later picked up by the ACCM laboratory to perform a test on her. Long ago, werewolves existed and they still do. This was a discovery found by the ACCM president and although their CEO consistently refused their test approval , they still went behind his back to create it. The Alpha Syrup, The Omega Syrup and the Beta Syrup. Now Arenza who is a fake wolf, feels deep connection between her two mates. One as her human / childhood first love and the other as a Lycan Alpha / her Boss.
10
9 Chapters
Center Land (Book 3 of Kendra's Journey)
Center Land (Book 3 of Kendra's Journey)
Traveling to the center of the earth to retrieve her son from Center Land is intense enough without having to deal with Amazon rogue women, prehistoric animals, and... yes... the aliens and zombies that they thought they'd left on the surface are there too! Is there no escape from the horror? They have a plan to end the aliens and zombies once and for all... but... will it work? The answer is in "Center Land", book three of the apocalyptic romance-thriller series, Kendra's Journey.
Not enough ratings
48 Chapters
Epidemic - A Scientific Mishap
Epidemic - A Scientific Mishap
A Scientific Mishap led to an outbreak of Zombie disease which led to millions of people getting infected. The faith of the others lies on the shoulder of an eighteen-year-old Jason and his friends.
Not enough ratings
5 Chapters
Center of the Iris
Center of the Iris
He wasn't the biggest wolf of them all, far from it. But after his rejection, he had to find a new world. He would make them pay for everything. Terrell was back. A new Alpha, a new pack, and he marched right into that town that had turned his life from horrible to worse. He was back to make the associations needed for his pack, but more importantly, to show them they weren't in charge anymore. Rejected, lost, and now, a hot shot. Gavin would never know what hit him, just like she didn't.
Not enough ratings
20 Chapters
Earth Bound
Earth Bound
Maddison Hart wished upon a star for a life-altering experience. She was a bored college student looking for something to help her heartbreak and one little wish would not hurt anyone, right? She should have been more specific. After a weird encounter with a self-proclaimed Alien Prince named Cy, Maddie is forced into a contract which marks her as his ``Earthling Companion¨. But with unknown enemies and an intergalactic war brewing, how long can the runaway alien prince hide?
Not enough ratings
4 Chapters
Earth Has Fallen
Earth Has Fallen
What is supposed to be a simple escort job turns into a fight for their very survival as Tristan, Rebecca, and Bailey are forced into the smoking ruins of mankind after an alien invasion. Can they survive a wasteland filled with infected, bandits, and aliens? *Inspired by The Last of Us*
Not enough ratings
60 Chapters

Related Questions

What Is The Climax Of 'Journey To The Center Of The Earth'?

3 Answers2025-06-24 19:57:34
The climax of 'Journey to the Center of the Earth' is absolutely jaw-dropping. After months of perilous travel through volcanic tubes and prehistoric landscapes, Professor Lidenbrock, Axel, and Hans reach a massive underground ocean. The real heart-pounding moment comes when they discover a living plesiosaurus battling an ichthyosaur—proof that dinosaurs still exist beneath the Earth's crust. Their raft gets caught in a violent storm, hurling them toward what seems like certain doom, only to be ejected upward through an erupting volcano shaft. The sheer adrenaline of their explosive resurfacing on Stromboli Island, covered in ash but alive, makes this one of literature's most unforgettable finales. It's the perfect payoff for their impossible journey—science fiction becoming science fact in their eyes.

How Does 'Journey To The Center Of The Earth' End?

3 Answers2025-06-24 09:07:41
The ending of 'Journey to the Center of the Earth' is a thrilling mix of discovery and escape. After descending through volcanic tubes and encountering prehistoric creatures, the trio—Professor Lidenbrock, Axel, and Hans—find themselves in a vast underground ocean. They build a raft and sail across this mysterious world, eventually witnessing a battle between sea monsters. Their journey takes a dramatic turn when they get caught in a volcanic eruption that propels them back to the surface through a geyser in Stromboli, Italy. The sudden return to daylight feels surreal after months underground. They bring back incredible knowledge, though Axel notes how little physical evidence remains—just their memories and a few notes. It’s a classic Verne ending: science triumphs, but nature keeps its deepest secrets.

Where Does 'Journey To The Center Of The Earth' Take Place?

3 Answers2025-06-24 09:12:42
In 'Journey to the Center of the Earth,' the adventure kicks off in Hamburg, Germany, where Professor Lidenbrock deciphers an ancient manuscript. The real magic happens when they descend through Iceland's Snaefellsjokull volcano, a spot that feels like the gateway to another world. The underground journey itself is a wild ride through vast caverns, subterranean oceans, and even prehistoric landscapes. The climax takes place when they get spewed out by Mount Etna in Italy, proving the earth's core is full of surprises. The mix of real-world locations and fantastical underground realms makes this setting unforgettable.

How Has 'Journey To The Center Of The Earth' Been Adapted In Film?

5 Answers2025-09-20 13:18:24
The adaptations of 'Journey to the Center of the Earth' have been quite a ride, if I can be honest! Starting with the classic 1959 version, the film really captured the spirit of Jules Verne’s novel. They opted for a more adventure-focused storyline, a hallmark of that era in filmmaking. The visuals, although limited by the technology of the time, still managed to stir the imagination. They really leaned into the fantastical elements found in the book, like prehistoric creatures and bizarre geological formations. Fast forward to 2008, and we hit the modern adaptation starring Brendan Fraser. This one was a wild departure, completely embracing CGI to convey the epic underground world. The action sequences and visual effects were a game changer and made it accessible to a new generation. I loved how it mixed fun family dynamics with over-the-top adventure, making it more of a popcorn flick that could appeal to all ages. So much of the charm in these adaptations lies in how they interpret Verne's original themes. Each version offers a different perspective on exploration and discovery, and that's something worth celebrating. I still enjoy rewatching both versions and noting the contrasts between them, as they add layers to how we perceive classic literature!

Who Are The Main Characters In 'Journey To The Center Of The Earth'?

3 Answers2025-06-24 13:44:09
The main characters in 'Journey to the Center of the Earth' are Professor Otto Lidenbrock, his nephew Axel, and their guide Hans. Professor Lidenbrock is this brilliant but eccentric geologist who finds an old manuscript hinting at a path to Earth's core. His enthusiasm is infectious, and he drags Axel into this crazy adventure. Axel is more cautious, often playing the voice of reason, but he grows a lot during their journey. Hans is this stoic Icelandic guide who’s strong, silent, and utterly reliable—he saves their hides more than once. The trio faces wild challenges, from underground oceans to prehistoric creatures, making their dynamic the heart of the story.

Who Is The Hero In Journey To The Center Of The Earth Book?

1 Answers2025-08-29 19:36:45
I've always had a soft spot for tales where curiosity drags you into danger and somehow makes you better for it, and 'Journey to the Center of the Earth' is one of those classics that hooks you on that exact vibe. If you're asking who the hero is, it depends a lot on how you define 'hero.' Reading it first as a restless teen tucked under a blanket with a flashlight, I naturally rooted for Axel—the narrator and nephew—because the whole story is funneled through his nervous, honest voice. He starts as the relatable everyman: skeptical, frightened, prone to fainting and second-guessing, and that vulnerability makes his gradual courage feel earned. Axel's growth—facing claustrophobia, darkness, and the unknown while learning to trust his own instincts—reads like a classic coming-of-age through peril. The emotional center of the novel lives in his reactions, so in a very immediate sense, Axel is the hero for anyone who loves character development and a nervous-but-brave point of view. On the other hand, if your taste gravitates toward the brilliant, obsessive sort of protagonist who makes things happen, Professor Otto Lidenbrock steals the heroic thunder. He is the driving force: the theorist who deciphers the runes, who insists on action, and who turns a wild hypothesis into a full-blown expedition. Lidenbrock's mania for discovery and absolute confidence push the plot forward, and there's something heroic in that single-minded devotion to knowledge—even when it borders on reckless. I read it later in college while nursing too much coffee, and I found myself admiring his intellectual hubris; without him, Axel and Hans would never descend at all. If heroism for you means leadership, vision, and unflinching resolve, then Lidenbrock is your guy. Then there’s Hans, the quiet Icelandic guide, who feels like a different kind of hero—the practical, steady sort that keeps the others alive. He never seeks praise, hardly speaks, and yet his competence under pressure is what rescues the expedition time and again. I used to joke with friends that Hans is the underrated MVP of this story: while the professor theorizes and Axel narrates his fears, Hans quietly navigates the treacherous paths, preserves supplies, and keeps calm when everything else is melting down. If you prize humility and dependable skill over flash or introspective development, Hans embodies the most grounded heroic traits. So, who is the hero? I like to think the book stages a trio of heroism: Axel as the heart and narrative hero, Lidenbrock as the mind and catalyst, and Hans as the hands that make survival possible. Which one resonates with you will depend on whether you value growth, ambition, or steadiness. Personally, I root for Axel because his fear-to-bravery arc still makes my chest tighten, but I always tip my hat to Hans for keeping them alive. If you reread it, try paying attention to which of the three scenes makes you cheer the loudest—it's a neat little mirror for your own taste in heroes.

How Long Is The Audiobook Of Journey To The Center Of The Earth Book?

5 Answers2025-08-29 05:50:17
If you’re asking about the audiobook length for 'Journey to the Center of the Earth', the short reality is there isn’t a single runtime — it depends on the edition. I usually keep a couple of versions in my library: an unabridged narration that runs several hours and a shorter, dramatized or abridged one for quick re-reads. From my experience, unabridged editions typically land somewhere in the 6–12 hour band, depending on the narrator’s pace and the translation used. Abridged or dramatized productions can shrink that to 2–4 hours, while multi-voice or heavily produced dramatizations may stretch longer. If you want the exact number for the copy you’re eyeing, check the audiobook’s detail page on whatever platform you use — it will list the total running time and whether it’s the complete text. Also remember playback speed: listening at 1.25x or 1.5x makes a long edition feel much more snackable during a commute or late-night reading session.

Who Translated Journey To The Center Of The Earth Book Into English?

1 Answers2025-08-29 00:50:31
I'm the sort of person who gets weirdly excited about translation history — there’s something cozy about tracing the way a book hops between languages — so this question hooked me immediately. Jules Verne’s 'Journey to the Center of the Earth' ('Voyage au centre de la Terre') has been translated into English many, many times, and there isn’t a single translator you can point to forever; the history is a bit messy. The earliest English versions appeared in the 1870s, and one of the most prominent early translators was George Makepeace Towle, whose 19th-century English rendering circulated widely in the U.S. Towle translated a bunch of Verne’s books and his versions helped shape Anglophone readers’ early impressions of Verne’s tone and humor. That said, early translations — including Towle’s and several anonymous or publisher-commissioned ones — were often abridged, altered, or lightly edited for Victorian tastes. I’ve got an old paperback on my shelf where the footnotes and chapter names were rearranged in a way that made me raise an eyebrow. For decades readers of English had to choose between these older, sometimes bowdlerized editions and the newer, scholarship-driven translations. From the mid-20th century onward, scholars and translators began to produce more faithful, annotated versions that try to restore Verne’s voice, scientific asides, and quirky humor. If you’re picking a version to read now, I tend to recommend looking for a modern annotated translation — they’ll usually mention if they used Towle’s text, an earlier anonymous text, or went back to the original French manuscripts. Translators like William Butcher (and some academic editors and translators working through university presses and publishers like Oxford or Penguin) have created editions that aim to be closer to Verne’s intent; those modern editions will point out where older translations cut or changed passages. I’ve had more fun with those, partly because I like the little historical footnotes and the explanations of 19th-century geology and nomenclature. They make the subterranean journey feel both faithful and fresh. So: short practical takeaway from a fellow book nerd — the first widely-disseminated English translation you’ll see historically is George Makepeace Towle’s 19th-century version, but for reading today I’d hunt for a modern scholarly translation or a reputable paperback that specifies its translator and whether it’s abridged. That way you get Jules Verne’s heart and humor intact rather than a Victorianized edit. If you want, I can dig into specific editions (Penguin, Oxford, or older Victorian printings) and point out which ones preserve the most of Verne’s original phrasing — I actually like comparing passages over tea, so it’s an easy excuse to reread the dramatic cliff scenes again.
Explore and read good novels for free
Free access to a vast number of good novels on GoodNovel app. Download the books you like and read anywhere & anytime.
Read books for free on the app
SCAN CODE TO READ ON APP
DMCA.com Protection Status