Would Smeagol Harry Potter Become A Death Eater Or Ally?

2025-08-23 05:44:07 151

4 답변

Sabrina

2025-08-25 16:00:59

I'm weirdly delighted imagining this crossover, like when I'm half-awake and scribbling fan ideas in the margins of a notebook. Picture Smeagol — that split, desperate creature from 'The Lord of the Rings' — dropped into the wizarding world: he wouldn't sign up for ideology. He clings to possession, to the thing that whispers to him; the Death Eaters recruit by promise of power, purity, and belonging. Smeagol's allegiance would be transactional and terrified, not ideological. He'd be a tool, a spy, maybe even used for skulking into places wizards think secure, but his loyalty would always tilt toward whatever keeps him and his 'precious' safe.

Harry's case is practically the opposite. He's shaped by choice, by refusing easy dark paths. In my head he’s stubbornly moral — the kind of person who turns down shortcuts even when exhausted. Could he be corrupted? Only under extreme, contrived circumstances: intense trauma combined with isolation and manipulation. Even then, he'd likely resist and seek allies. So as a Death Eater? Almost never in my view. More realistically, Harry would be a staunch ally, the kind who gets muddy and angry defending people, not ideologies.

If you like grimwhat-ifs, the interesting story is how both could be used: Smeagol as a pawn, Harry as the rescuer or the one who tempts Smeagol toward a small, fragile redemption. That dynamic makes for far richer fanfic than a straight conversion to villainy.

Zayn

2025-08-26 08:55:00

I love ridiculous hypothetical mash-ups, and this one makes me grin. Smeagol wouldn't become a true Death Eater in spirit — he isn't about philosophy or purity, he's about compulsion and survival. In the wizarding world he'd be more of a coerced asset: an informant who sneaks into cellars and tunnels, bribed by promises of food or a warm corner. The Dark Lord types might exploit him but they'd never really have his devotion.

Harry, on the other hand, is almost written to resist that temptation. He has fear, anger, and moments of doubt, sure, but joining the Death Eaters requires embracing a worldview he consistently rejects. The only interesting route where Harry flips would involve extreme mental manipulation, isolation, or a magical artifact messing with his sense of self — not impossible in fiction, but unlikely given his character. So I'd slot Harry firmly as ally, and Smeagol as tragic, unreliable tool that both sides try to control.

Kai

2025-08-26 14:19:06

If I step into my more analytical, late-night-thesis brain, the distinction between Smeagol and Harry hinges on motive and susceptibility. Smeagol is motivated by attachment and addiction — the Ring created an obsessive feedback loop. Translate that into 'Harry Potter' terms and he'd be someone vulnerable to objects of power or possession rather than to an ideology like blood purity. That makes him exploitable by Death Eaters, but as a coerced agent rather than a true believer. His moral compass is fractured, not inverted.

Harry's moral architecture is constructed very differently: trauma informs him, but so do mentors, friends, and repeated choices to do right. Even if you put him under an Imperius-like pressure or a Horcrux-style corruption, the narrative weight of his friendships and conscience tends to pull him back. If anything, Harry as a hypothetical ring-bearer is a fascinating scenario: would carrying a corrupting object fracture his choices? Yes, possibly — but the key difference is that Smeagol starts fractured and would be a tool; Harry starts whole and would likely resist and rally allies. So in my view, Smeagol equals coerced asset; Harry equals ally and resistor, with rare dark detours in fanfic land.

On a practical note, the best crossover stories come from their interaction: a desperate, whispering creature meeting a stubborn, loyal boy. That tension is where the drama lives.

Ian

2025-08-27 04:14:44

I get a little wistful picturing a scene: Smeagol slinking through moonlit ruins in the wizarding world, hissing about a stolen trinket, while cloaked Death Eaters argue about whether to enslave him or simply use him. He'd be too small and too selfish to buy into their ideology, so he'd become a pawn — terrified, useful, and unreliable.

Harry would stride in very differently. He wouldn't become one of them unless something catastrophic warped his judgment. I can see him pleading with Smeagol, trying to coax out any better part with stubborn kindness. So no neat conversion for either: Smeagol, a coerced tool tangled by addiction; Harry, an ally who fights and sometimes falters but doesn't embrace what the Death Eaters stand for. That image sticks with me — messy, human, and oddly hopeful.

모든 답변 보기

관련 작품

THE SOUL EATER

10 years earlier, Jason drives down a dark deserted road on his way home from a birthday party, when he sees a red haired woman walking along side the road. Picking her up, he finds out that she is not what he thinks she is. Instead, he ends up losing his soul. Spending the next 10 years of his life looking over his shoulder, he eventually comes to the realization that the only way to get his soul back is to kill her. Does he find and kill her or does she haunt him for eternity. Find out in The Soul Eater.

58 챕터

Ally of the Apocalypse

Orphan Ally was always so different she could never find a forever home. When a dark handsome stranger who had been plaguing her dream shows up in a not so chance meeting, her differences finally make sense. Will she be the one to end the world or could she change the course of her own destiny and save the human race?

10 챕터

LYRA, THE HEIR-EATER

They call me the Heir-Eater. I was meant to be an heir, but everything changed the night I was born. My father, Alpha Cedric, and my pack expected twin heirs. Instead, they found only me. A single child. A girl. A disappointment. They accused me of eating my twin before he could take his first breath. They said I stole his life. The pack that once celebrated my existence turned its back on me. They say I am cursed. My Father stripped me of my name, my status, and my right to belong. Instead of an Alpha’s daughter, He condemned me to a life of slavery. But they were wrong about me. I was never the curse. I am the warning. I am Lyra, the Heir-Eater. And my story is only beginning.

평가가 충분하지 않습니다.

5 챕터

THE MAFIA UNEXPECTED ALLY

Mafia boss Dominic Russo faces chaos and betrayal. He forms an unlikely alliance with Lucia Moretti, a mysterious and cunning partner with her own agenda. As they navigate the treacherous mafia world, loyalty and trust are tested. Alliances shift, rivalries intensify, and Dominic and Lucia must outsmart enemies and confront their demons. Will their unexpected alliance lead to redemption or destruction?

평가가 충분하지 않습니다.

4 챕터

Death Wolf

"You can't reject me!" She pleaded with tears glistening her eyes, while he stands there indifferent. Hatred evident in his grey orbs. "Please!" He moves closer to her , entrapping her body between the wall and his big frame. Looking at her from top to bottom in disgust, he seethes at her. "You should have thought about it before sleeping with the bast***" "You should have thought about it before betraying me mate." ............ She was a havoc created by nature, found wrapped in a blanked at the side of a river. Bullied and shunned by the werewolf society. She was a mere rogue who was surviving. Untill he came , hating her. Cursing her and playing with her like a prey. Doing everything to break her like her betrayal has broken her. If only he knew she has not surrendered her virtue by choice, if only he knew she was an innocent. If only he knew he could never break her for she was not a weak pathetic rogue. She was the girl born with the power to summon the strongest known wolf in the world. She was the very soul referred to in the werewolf books of philosophy. She was none other than the summoner. The summoner of the death wolf.

9.5

185 챕터

Flying Death

Travis "Punch" Mitchell is not just any wolf shifter. He should absolutely be illegal, everything about him is sculpted by the goddess herself. He is the lead enforcer of the Flying Death, one of the most deadly and notorious packs there is. Alpha Axel "Dozer" Dennison adopted him and knew immediately that Punch was no ordinary pup. It takes a killer to know a killer. As fate would have it, Alpha Dozer has a beautiful daughter nobody dares to go near. Punch however, is already closer than anyone else to the female. They are in a constant tit for tat with each other, neither ever winning and always walking away frustrated with the other. He's a lot of bark, but no bite when it comes to her. Hazel Dennison is a girl who knows what she wants but is extremely immature with how she gets it. Punch is not only her ultimate nemesis, he is her crush. Her dream mate who wants nothing to do with her. Little does she know he's the female he loves to hate. When she takes matters into her own hands and dates another Alpha's son, Punch can't just sit back. Unfortunately for him, pack business interferes in his love life and everything goes upside down. Excerpt: I find myself leaning against the wall by his room, grateful my parents’ room is downstairs. "Go to bed,” I hear, barely above a whisper. "No,” I say, defiantly, turning to face his door. Either he sensed my heartbeat out here or he smelled me. Maybe both. I can’t wait to have my wolf. This sucks. He needs to know I’m not backing down. I’m not a dumb pup, I more than know what I want. Him. However I can get him.

63 챕터

연관 질문

What Would A Smeagol Harry Potter Patronus Represent?

4 답변2025-08-23 21:24:50

I've been scribbling marginalia in my copy of 'The Lord of the Rings' for years, and the idea of a Smeagol-shaped Patronus made me smile and wince at once. Imagine the Patronus as a flicker of someone's truest, most defended memory—if Smeagol were your Patronus, it would scream of survival, shame, and a clinging, battered tenderness. That tiny, furtive figure would represent the part of you that has been cornered by obsession and hurt, yet still refuses to disappear. On the bright side, a Smeagol Patronus could also be a strange badge of resilience. It would remind you that even damaged things can protect you; the Patronus doesn't judge the origin of its form, it only reacts to the light within. So this Patronus would carry complicated signals—warning to stay vigilant against your darker compulsions, but also a whisper that the soft, human part can still save you if you feed it with kinder memories. I think about this when I reread scenes where Smeagol dims into Gollum, and I picture someone confronting their own shadows with a trembling, honest charm. It wouldn't be pretty, but it would be truthful—and sometimes truth is exactly the kind of shield you need.

Could Smeagol Harry Potter Survive Hogwarts Duels?

4 답변2025-08-23 22:04:52

Oh, what a hilarious mental image—Smeagol in a Hogwarts dueling ring! I can see him now, hissing and twitching while everyone waves wands. Realistically, if we're talking about formal, wand-to-wand duels the way students practice in the dueling club, Smeagol's survival chances depend almost entirely on context. He isn't a witch or wizard, so he can't cast spells reliably; that alone puts him at a huge disadvantage against anyone who knows basic charms like 'Stupefy' or 'Expelliarmus'. On the other hand, his strengths are the kind no textbook covers: slipperiness, feral cunning, and a knack for hiding. Those let him avoid getting hit rather than trade blows. If he turned up with the Ring from 'The Lord of the Rings', all bets shift—suddenly he's invisible, able to skulk around and ambush or flee. Against first-years or distracted duelists he could slip past and survive, maybe even snatch a wand if someone dropped one. But against trained duelists, Professors, or Aurors? No. A well-aimed Stunning Spell or a simple protective charm would incapacitate him. So I’d say: survivable in chaos and stealthy scenarios, laughably outclassed in a straight-up duel with magic users who know what they're doing. I'd personally love to sketch that scene—Smeagol under an invisibility cloak, hissing at a confused Hufflepuff, and vanishing into the portrait hole.

Why Do Fans Pair Smeagol Harry Potter In Fanfiction?

4 답변2025-08-23 17:48:08

There’s something secretly irresistible about pairing two characters who, on paper, could not be more different. When I think about why people ship Smeagol and Harry, my brain goes straight to thematic mirrors: both stories in 'The Lord of the Rings' and 'Harry Potter' deal with corrupting influence, obsession, and split identities. Gollum is the living embodiment of what a powerful object can do to a person; Harry carries pieces of a dark past in a very different form. That parallel lets writers explore what happens when trauma meets trauma — redemption, manipulation, trust, or a slow, dangerous codependency. On a more personal note, I love how Smeagol’s fractured voice creates instant dialogue-driven scenes. Fans can write long, intimate talks where Harry’s empathy collides with Smeagol’s paranoia: it’s ripe for both tender ‘care’ tropes and dark, twisted control dynamics. Most of the fics that clicked with me either age-up Harry or place them in a post-canon AU where both characters are adults, so the ethical bits get handled. There’s also the joy of novelty — crossovers let people mash up two mythic universes and see fresh chemistry. In short, it’s about contrasts, healing fantasies, and the pure storytelling fun of mixing voice-driven characters, and I keep finding new takes that surprise me every time.

Can Cosplayers Recreate Smeagol Harry Potter Accurately?

4 답변2025-08-23 07:55:51

There's something deliciously odd about picturing 'Smeagol' wearing Hogwarts robes, and yes — cosplayers can absolutely recreate a Smeagol-meets-'Harry Potter' look convincingly, if they lean into both the sculptural makeup and the tiny behavioral details. I’ve pulled off prosthetic-heavy characters before, so I’d start with good reference photos: study the pale, veiny skin and big eyes of 'Smeagol' and the broken charm of Harry’s scarf, glasses, and scar. Silicone or foam-latex prosthetics for the forehead and cheeks, a bald cap, thin pale body paint layered for veins, and the right contact lenses will sell the transformation. On costume, don’t do a pristine robe — distress fabric, add mud and patches, maybe a partially melted wand or a battered Gryffindor patch to sell the story. Movement matters: crouched posture, twitchy hand motions, a mix of childlike wonder and a whispery voice imitate that split personality. Lighting and photos will finish the illusion: cooler, directional light to exaggerate hollows, and post-processing for subtle smoothing or eye glow. It’s a mash-up that’s more theatrical than literal, so embrace the weirdness and tell a little backstory with props — I always enjoy when a photo series shows how the two worlds collided.

Are There Official Smeagol Harry Potter Mashups Or Only Fan Art?

4 답변2025-08-23 17:54:19

I've dug through a lot of corners online and the short, candid truth is: there aren't any official crossovers that mash up Sméagol (or Gollum) with 'Harry Potter' from the rights holders. Both universes are tightly controlled—'The Lord of the Rings' material is handled separately from 'Harry Potter'—so an authorized, canonical blend of those characters just hasn't happened. What you will find everywhere, though, is fan creativity: art, comics, cosplay mashups, memes, and fanfiction where someone gleefully imagines Sméagol in a Hogwarts robe or casting weird little spells. I love hunting through DeviantArt, Tumblr, and Instagram for those quirky takes; sometimes creators even make clever commissions or prints on Etsy and Redbubble. Just be careful: commercial sellers sometimes get notices, and platforms will remove infringing or infringing-appearing items. If you want something durable, support an artist directly and check whether they’re open to commissions instead of buying mass-produced bootlegs. Bottom line—official? No. Delightful, inventive fan stuff? Absolutely yes, and it’s my go-to for a laugh or a new aesthetic. If you like, I can point you toward subreddits or tags where the best mashups bubble up.

Which Actor Would Best Play Smeagol Harry Potter In Film?

4 답변2025-08-23 02:18:44

If I had to pick one actor to pull off a Smeagol-like version of Harry Potter on screen, I’d lean straight toward Andy Serkis. I’m not just leaning because he invented the modern motion-capture performance — though that’s a huge part of it — I’m thinking about the way he blends voice, tiny physical tic, and heartbreaking vulnerability into one moving creature. A corrupted or split-personality Harry who whispers to himself and lashes out in panic would be right in Serkis’s wheelhouse. I can almost see the scenes: close-ups where Serkis’s hands tremble, low-light sequences that rely on body language more than dialogue, and a director leaning on motion-capture to let the inner monster and the boy coexist. That approach preserves the tragedy of Smeagol while giving 'Harry Potter' a uniquely haunting, emotional center. Casting Serkis would also allow for creative collaboration on vocal textures and physical micro-expressions, making the duality feel lived-in rather than gimmicky. If you want someone who can sell both the savage and the sorrow, he’s the one I’d pick.

How Does Magic Interact With Smeagol Harry Potter Ring Corruption?

4 답변2025-08-23 02:50:28

If you mash together the corrupting arc of Smeagol from 'The Lord of the Rings' with the cursed, soul-torn ring from 'Harry Potter', you get two cousins of dark magic that operate on different axes. The One Ring corrupts through personality and desire — it amplifies hunger for power, isolates the bearer’s will, and slowly eats away at identity until someone becomes like Smeagol. It’s an artifact with a kind of embedded will, forged to dominate other wills. By contrast, what we see in the Gaunt ring/Horcrux situation in 'Harry Potter' is soul-splintering and protective enchantment: creating a Horcrux deliberately anchors a piece of a soul to an object, which then radiates malevolent influence and can carry curses. Where Tolkien’s ring tempts and reshapes the self over time, a Horcrux actively anchors a fragment of a wizard’s consciousness and resists ordinary magic. If a One Ring landed in the Potterverse it might act like an extremely stubborn, self-aware Horcrux — detectable by Legilimency or dark-magic wards and maybe susceptible to Horcrux-destroying methods (basilisk venom, fiendfyre) — but it would still push back with its will. You’d have psychological possession layered over metaphysical anchoring: wizards could see the influence with Occlumency/Legilimency, and Healers/Protections might sense corruption, but destruction would likely demand both magical firepower and a moral struggle, maybe needing both the right destructive agents and the inner strength to let go.

How Would Smeagol Harry Potter Use The One Ring At Hogwarts?

4 답변2025-08-23 11:35:15

I’ve always loved imagining mash-ups that shouldn’t work on paper but feel absolutely right in the headcanon lab, and picturing Smeagol skulking through the corridors of Hogwarts with the One Ring is delightfully chaotic. First off, invisibility is the obvious win: slipping past Filch, peeking into dormitories, and eavesdropping on late-night common room gossip would be his daily bread. But the Ring doesn’t just hide—you can feel it bending wills. At Hogwarts that would mean more than just being unseen; Smeagol could whisper and tug at weaker minds, coax house-elves into secret errands, or nudge a naive first-year into sharing treats from the kitchens. There’s also the clash of mythologies that fascinates me. In 'The Lord of the Rings' the Ring draws attention from Sauron; at Hogwarts it would probably radiate like a beacon to curious dark artifacts and the Ministry’s aurors. Imagine portraits whispering rumors of a glinting presence, Dumbledore following threads of strange enchantment, or even Voldemort sniffing out another source of domination. I love to think about small, human moments too: Smeagol hunched in a broom cupboard, murmuring to the Ring about sandwiches, half afraid to leave because of how comfortable its possessiveness feels. It’s messy, a little tragic, and totally compelling—like a crossover fanfic I’d reread for the creepy charm of it all.

Would Smeagol Harry Potter Become A Death Eater Or Ally?

4 답변

관련 작품

연관 질문

What Would A Smeagol Harry Potter Patronus Represent?

Could Smeagol Harry Potter Survive Hogwarts Duels?

Why Do Fans Pair Smeagol Harry Potter In Fanfiction?

Can Cosplayers Recreate Smeagol Harry Potter Accurately?

Are There Official Smeagol Harry Potter Mashups Or Only Fan Art?

Which Actor Would Best Play Smeagol Harry Potter In Film?

How Does Magic Interact With Smeagol Harry Potter Ring Corruption?

How Would Smeagol Harry Potter Use The One Ring At Hogwarts?

인기 질문

What Are The Main Themes In 'An Abundance Of Katherines' By John Green The Author?

Can I Find The Job Bible Book In Digital Format?

What Is Meliodas Power Level

Where Can I Read The Midnight Run Book For Free Online?

How Does Bg3 Dark Urge Impact Companion Relationships?

How Does A Harem Romance Novel Differ From A Regular Romance Novel?

What Is The Significance Of The Top 5 Lists In 'High Fidelity'?

Where Can I Find Online Novels For Free Reading Legally?

Who Is The Author Of 'Ideas Have Consequences'?

How To Download Free Kindle Books From Amazon Prime?

인기 검색어 더 하기