In 'If We Were Villains', the first major death is Richard Stirling, a member of the tight-knit group of Shakespearean actors at Dellecher Classical Conservatory. Richard's death sets off the chain of events that unravels the group's dynamics and secrets. His demise occurs early in the story, shocking both the characters and readers alike. Richard's aggressive personality and volatile behavior make him a standout figure, so his sudden absence leaves a palpable void. The circumstances surrounding his death are murky, fueling speculation and tension among his friends. The novel explores how his death impacts each character differently, revealing their hidden loyalties and flaws. Richard's death isn't just a plot point—it’s the catalyst that forces the group to confront their own complicity and guilt.
The aftermath of Richard's death is handled with gripping intensity. The remaining characters grapple with paranoia, suspicion, and grief, all while trying to maintain their performances on and off stage. The Shakespearean themes of tragedy and betrayal mirror their real-life struggles, making his death feel even more poignant. The uncertainty about whether his death was accidental or deliberate adds layers to the mystery. Oliver, the protagonist, carries the weight of this event throughout the story, and it shapes his decisions in profound ways. Richard's death serves as the anchor for the novel’s exploration of morality, art, and the blurred lines between fiction and reality.