Home / Romance / FAKE DATING MY NEW STEP BROTHER / Chapter 6: Never Play Trivia With Your Stepbrother

Share

Chapter 6: Never Play Trivia With Your Stepbrother

Author: Marvel
last update publish date: 2026-11-19 19:54:38

Mara’s POV

“Hiding something?” I laughed, a high, squeaky sound that made me want to throw myself into the nearest bush. “Me? No! Why would I hide anything? I’m boring. My life is literally just books and bad posture.”

Sienna didn't blink. Her blue eyes stayed locked onto mine, sharp as glass. “Then why can’t I come over tonight? It’s just dinner, Mara. Unless... you’re ashamed of your mom’s new place?”

“It’s not that,” I blurted out, my brain scrambling for a lifeline. “It’s just—Ethan and I already have plans tonight. Big plans. Romantic plans.”

Sienna’s manicured eyebrows shot up past her sunglasses. “Oh, really? On a Monday? Ethan hates going out on Mondays. He usually stays in and plays video games with the guys.”

“Well, he’s changing his habits for me,” I said, lifting my chin. “Because he’s... obsessed with me.”

The second the words left my mouth, I wanted to die. Obsessed with me? Who says that? I sounded like a bad romance novel.

Sienna’s smile turned razor-thin. “Obsessed. Cute. Well, since you two are so madly in love, how about you and Ethan meet me and the girls at Benny’s Diner at seven? Just for milkshakes. You can have your big romantic night right after.”

“Sienna, I really—”

“Unless you’re lying about the date,” she interrupted sweetly, tilting her head. “And you’re actually just trying to keep me away from your house.”

Trapped. Completely, utterly trapped. If I said no, she’d be ringing my doorbell by sunset.

“Fine,” I forced out through clenched teeth. “Seven. At Benny’s.”

“Yay!” She clapped her hands together like a toddler, grabbed her tote bag, and bounced away down the brick path. “See you tonight, bestie!”

The moment she turned the corner, I yanked my phone out of my pocket and dialed Ethan. He answered on the second ring.

“Miss me already, Vale?” his deep voice drawled through the speaker.

“Shut up and listen to me,” I hissed, pacing behind a thick oak tree. “Sienna cornered me outside the library. She tried to invite herself over to our house tonight.”

The lazy amusement vanished from his voice instantly. “What? Why?”

“Because she’s a psycho! I panicked and told her we couldn't host her because you’re obsessed with me and planned a huge romantic date tonight.”

Silence on the line. Then, a slow, dark chuckle rumbled in my ear. “Obsessed with you, huh? Tell me more.”

“Ethan, I am going to murder you with a stapler! She called my bluff. We have to meet her at Benny’s Diner at seven o’clock tonight, or she’s going to show up at the house and see Richard’s golf clubs in the foyer!”

“Benny’s at seven,” Ethan repeated, his tone shifting into pure business. “Got it. Go home, put on something that doesn't look like a potato sack, and let me handle Sienna.”

“I like my sweaters!” I snapped, hanging up before he could laugh at me again.

By 6:55 p.m., I was sitting in a red vinyl booth at Benny’s Diner, sweating through a fitted black long-sleeve top I had stolen from the back of my closet. Ethan sat beside me, wedged way too close, his heavy arm draped lazily across the back of the booth behind my shoulders. Every time he shifted, his thigh pressed hot and solid against mine under the table.

“Stop fidgeting,” Ethan murmured against my temple, his warm breath making the tiny hairs on my neck stand straight up. “You look like you’re about to rob a bank.”

“I feel like I’m sitting next to a ticking bomb,” I whispered back, staring intensely at a laminated menu. “Do not touch me under the table.”

“I’m not touching you. The booth is just small.” He leaned closer, his hand dropping from the seat back to rest squarely on my bare knee beneath the Formica tabletop. His thumb stroked a slow, deliberate circle against my skin, sending a sharp, electric jolt straight up my thigh. “Besides, we’re supposed to be madly in love, remember? Act like you actually want me.”

I bit the inside of my cheek to stop a gasp, glaring sideways at him. “Take your hand off my knee before I stab you with a butter knife.”

“Make me,” he smirked, his dark eyes dropping to my mouth for a fraction of a second before snapping toward the front door. “Heads up. Incoming.”

The bell above the diner door jingled loudly. Sienna walked in, flanked by two of her sorority clones, looking like she had stepped straight off a magazine cover in a tight pink miniskirt.

“There’s the happy couple!” Sienna sang out, sliding into the booth directly across from us. Her friends squeezed in beside her, staring at Ethan like he was a piece of prime steak. “Oh my gosh, look how cozy you two are!”

“Can’t keep my hands off her,” Ethan said smoothly, squeezing my knee under the table so hard my toes curled inside my boots. “Right, babe?”

“Right,” I choked out, plastering a wide, stiff grin onto my face. “Total magnet. Can’t peel him off.”

Sienna rested her chin on her interlocked fingers, her blue eyes narrowing slightly as she studied us. “You know, it’s just so wild seeing you two together. Ethan, when we were dating, you barely even liked holding hands in public. And now you’re all over Mara.”

“Guess I just needed the right girl,” Ethan replied effortlessly, turning his head to press a slow, lingering kiss right below my ear. His lips were hot against my skin, his stubble scraping just enough to make my pulse skyrocket.

I shivered, my fingers gripping the edge of the table. He’s too good at this, I thought frantically. Way too good.

“So sweet,” Sienna purred, though her jaw looked tight enough to crack walnuts. “Actually, since you two are moving so fast, I thought we could play a little game! Just to see how well you really know each other.”

My stomach dropped into my shoes. “A game?”

“Yeah! Couples’ trivia!” Sienna clapped her hands, her eyes gleaming with pure malice. “I’ll ask Mara questions about Ethan, and we’ll see if she actually knows her boyfriend. Ready, Mara?”

Beside me, Ethan’s body went completely rigid. Under the table, his hand froze on my knee. We hadn't practiced a script. We didn't have fake-dating backstories.

“Sure,” I squeaked, my voice cracking. “Hit me.”

“Okay, easy one first,” Sienna smiled sweetly. “What’s Ethan’s go-to late-night food?”

“Leftover pad thai,” I answered smoothly. “Cold, straight out of the carton, with extra peanut sauce. He’s a total thief when it comes to takeout.”

Sienna blinked. Her smile faltered for half a second. “Uh... okay. Lucky guess. When we were together, he only ate pizza.”

“People change,” Ethan said easily, though I felt the rumble of a suppressed laugh in his chest.

“Fine,” Sienna said, leaning forward, her voice sharpening. “What’s Ethan’s biggest irrational fear? And don't say heights, because he tells everyone that to sound normal.”

I opened my mouth, then paused. Two weeks ago, during a massive thunderstorm, I had caught Ethan standing in the upstairs hallway holding a lacrosse stick because a giant spider had crawled out from under the bathroom door.

“Spiders,” I said clearly. “Specifically, big hairy ones. He completely loses his cool and tries to fight them with sports equipment.”

The two sorority girls across from us burst out laughing. Ethan’s head snapped toward me, his ears turning bright red.

“I did not lose my cool,” Ethan hissed under his breath, glaring at me. “It was a tactical defense.”

“You jumped onto a chair, Ethan,” I whispered back, unable to stop a real grin from breaking across my face.

Sienna’s face was turning an ugly shade of blotchy pink. She wasn't smiling anymore. “Okay, whatever. How did you even know that? You’ve only been dating for like, what, a week?”

“We FaceTime a lot,” I lied smoothly, riding the sudden rush of adrenaline. “Like, every night. It’s amazing what you learn when someone refuses to hang up the phone.”

“Says the girl who falls asleep on FaceTime,” Ethan shot back, his dark eyes sparkling with amused challenge as he looked down at me. “Alright, my turn. Ask me something about Mara, Sienna. Let’s see if I know my girl.”

Sienna crossed her arms, glaring at me like I had personally ruined her life. “Fine. What’s Mara’s biggest habit when she’s stressed out about a big exam?”

Ethan didn't even hesitate. He looked straight at me, his gaze dropping heavy and slow over my face, lingering on my bottom lip with an intensity that made the air in the booth vanish entirely.

“She chews on her bottom lip until it turns bright red,” Ethan said, his voice dropping an octave, rough and low. “She drowns herself in black coffee until her hands shake, and she completely forgets to eat unless someone practically forces food into her hands.”

My breath completely stopped. The diner noise—the clattering plates, the jukebox, Sienna’s annoyed huff—faded into dead silence.

He wasn't guessing. He had been paying attention every single day—leaving snacks outside my door during midterms, watching me in the kitchen, memorizing every single detail about me without me ever noticing.

“And,” Ethan added softly, his thumb sliding up the inside of my thigh under the table, brushing dangerously close to the hem of my skirt, “when she finally takes a break from her books, she kisses like she’s trying to set the whole room on fire.”

Heat flooded my face, my neck, my entire chest. My heart hammered so hard against my ribs I thought it might bruise.

Sienna slammed her hands on the table, making the salt shakers jump. “Okay! Gross! We get it, you’re totally obsessed with each other! Come on, girls, I suddenly lost my appetite.”

She grabbed her purse and practically bolted out of the diner, her two friends scrambling behind her without even saying goodbye.

For three long seconds, neither Ethan nor I moved.

I sat frozen, my skin burning everywhere his hand was touching me under the table. Slowly, I turned my head to look at him.

Ethan wasn't smirking anymore. His brown eyes were dark, pupils blown wide, staring at my mouth like he was starving.

“Told you I’d handle her,” he murmured, his voice thick and gravelly.

“Ethan,” I whispered, my hands gripping his wrist under the table, though I didn't push him away. “We’re in a public diner.”

“I know,” he breathed, leaning in until his forehead rested against mine, his thumb still pressing hot and steady against my inner thigh. “And if you don't stop looking at me like that, I’m dragging you straight to my truck.”

Continue to read this book for free
Scan code to download App

Latest chapter

  • FAKE DATING MY NEW STEP BROTHER   Chapter 7: A Very Bad Idea in a Black Truck

    Mara’s POV“You wouldn't dare,” I whispered, though my voice shook so badly it ruined the threat completely.Ethan didn't bother answering with words. He tossed a twenty-dollar bill onto the vinyl tabletop, slid out of the booth, and grabbed my wrist—pulling me right out of Benny’s Diner before I could even grab my purse properly.“Ethan!” I hissed, stumbling slightly in my boots as the cool Monday night air hit my flushed cheeks. “People are watching!”“Let them watch,” he muttered, his jaw tight, marching me straight across the dimly lit asphalt toward the far corner of the parking lot where his black truck was parked. “We’re a couple, remember? Couples leave diners together.”“Couples don’t drag each other across parking lots like cavemen!”He reached the passenger side, yanked the door open, and practically lifted me into the high cab by my waist. Before I could even buckle my seatbelt, he jogged around the hood, climbed into the driver’s seat, and slammed his door shut.Silence d

  • FAKE DATING MY NEW STEP BROTHER   Chapter 6: Never Play Trivia With Your Stepbrother

    Mara’s POV“Hiding something?” I laughed, a high, squeaky sound that made me want to throw myself into the nearest bush. “Me? No! Why would I hide anything? I’m boring. My life is literally just books and bad posture.”Sienna didn't blink. Her blue eyes stayed locked onto mine, sharp as glass. “Then why can’t I come over tonight? It’s just dinner, Mara. Unless... you’re ashamed of your mom’s new place?”“It’s not that,” I blurted out, my brain scrambling for a lifeline. “It’s just—Ethan and I already have plans tonight. Big plans. Romantic plans.”Sienna’s manicured eyebrows shot up past her sunglasses. “Oh, really? On a Monday? Ethan hates going out on Mondays. He usually stays in and plays video games with the guys.”“Well, he’s changing his habits for me,” I said, lifting my chin. “Because he’s... obsessed with me.”The second the words left my mouth, I wanted to die. Obsessed with me? Who says that? I sounded like a bad romance novel.Sienna’s smile turned razor-thin. “Obsessed. C

  • FAKE DATING MY NEW STEP BROTHER   Chapter 5: My Ex-Best friend wants to visit me at home

    Mara’s POVThe campus quad on a Monday morning was usually my sanctuary. Today, it felt like walking into a gladiator arena dressed in meat.Every head turned as Ethan’s black truck pulled into the student lot. By the time he walked around to open my door, half a dozen people were openly staring, holding their phones like they were documenting a rare animal sighting.“Relax,” Ethan muttered under his breath, taking my hand the second my feet hit the asphalt. His fingers slid between mine, warm, heavy, and completely unbothered. “You look like you’re walking toward a firing squad.”“I am walking toward a firing squad,” I hissed, trying to pull my hand back. “Ethan, everyone is looking at us.”“That’s the point, remember?” He tugged me closer until my shoulder bumped his chest, his thumb stroking the back of my hand. “We’re deeply in love. So stop looking like you want to throw up on my shoes.”“I hate Marcus,” I whispered through a fake, plastered-on smile. “I hope his coffee is foreve

  • FAKE DATING MY NEW STEP BROTHER    Chapter 4: Fake dating my step-brother

    Mara’s POVThe morning sun poked through my blinds, burning my eyes.I rolled over and slapped my clock. 7:15 a.m.My body felt completely wrecked, but my brain was running at a hundred miles an hour. Every single second of last night kept flashing behind my eyelids—Ethan’s dark eyes, his hot hands on my hips, the heavy weight of his body on top of mine, and then the terrifying sound of my mother’s heels on the stairs while I squeezed behind a dusty wardrobe like a terrified rat.I groaned, burying my face in my pillow.How did my life become such a mess?It wasn't just the step-sibling rule we broke. It was the whole cover story. The lie we had constructed two days ago to save our skins was already spiraling out of control, and then—boom—we went and slept together.I dragged myself out of bed, put on my baggy grey sweatshirt and leggings, and tiptoed down the hallway toward the kitchen. I needed coffee. Strong, black, lethal coffee.I rounded the kitchen corner and froze.Ethan was a

  • FAKE DATING MY NEW STEP BROTHER   Chapter 3: Rule 1- Step-siblings at home, Strangers outside

    Mara’s POVThe silence in my room was so loud my ears rang.I sat on the edge of my bed, staring at the floorboards, my chest heaving. The faint scent of cedar and mint still clung to my skin. My lower lip stung from where Ethan had bitten it.Six months.Six months of building up walls, setting up boundaries, and drafting ironclad rules—all destroyed in less than twenty minutes on a Tuesday night.I collapsed backward onto my mattress, throwing an arm over my eyes. It wasn't supposed to happen like this. We had a plan. A stupid, carefully negotiated, foolproof plan that had started the exact night our parents announced their engagement at Luigi’s.The wedding had taken place three months later at a stone country club overlooking a lake. My mother looked radiant in ivory silk. Richard looked like the happiest man alive.And Ethan and I had stood on the stone terrace during the reception, looking like two people awaiting execution.“You’re standing too close,” I had muttered under my b

  • FAKE DATING MY NEW STEP BROTHER   Chapter 2: The most Popular guy on campus is my new step-brother

    Mara’s POVThe heavy steps on the stairs sounded like a countdown.Step.Step.Step.“Mara? Ethan? You guys up there?” my mother’s voice called out, breezy and cheerful, entirely ignorant of the fact that her daughter was currently standing naked in her brand-new stepbrother’s bedroom.Ethan moved faster than I’d ever seen him move on a football field. He snatched his dark jeans off the floor, practically throwing my oversized sweater and leggings at my face.“Dresser,” he hissed under his breath, pointing frantically toward the tall wooden mahogany wardrobe in the corner. “Get behind it. Now!”“Are you insane? I won't fit!” I whispered back, my voice squeaking in pure terror as I threw my clothes on with trembling hands.“Just shove yourself into the corner, Mara, unless you want to explain to your mother why your socks are on my ceiling fan!”I didn’t argue. I darted behind the heavy wooden wardrobe just as the brass door handle jingled. The door wasn't locked. Ethan hadn't locked i

More Chapters
Explore and read good novels for free
Free access to a vast number of good novels on GoodNovel app. Download the books you like and read anywhere & anytime.
Read books for free on the app
SCAN CODE TO READ ON APP
DMCA.com Protection Status