LOGIN
“How long have you been fucking my friend Michael!?” My husband, Harrison, slapped the birthday cake into my face just as I was wishing him a happy birthday and about to tell him that I was pregnant.
I wiped the frosting from my face and asked, “Honey, what are you talking about?”
“Even now, you’re still playing innocent, huh?” he said as he pulled out a stack of photos and flung them straight at my face. Pain flared across my cheek, hot and stinging, as the photos fluttered to the floor around my feet.
I picked up one of the photos. It showed Michael and me in bed, naked, having sex.
Then I flipped through the rest of the photos with shaking hands. There were more, Michael and I having dinner at a restaurant, walking down the street hand in hand, smiling like lovers.
I had never done any of those things. Besides, the last time I saw Michael was last year.
“That’s not real,” I said. “Harrison, those photos are fake. That never happened.”
“Really?” He laughed. “Because it looks pretty clear to me.”
“It’s fabricated! Someone made this. I don’t know how, but I’ve never—I would never—”
“I trusted you,” he said coldly as I stared wide-eyed at him. “I thought you were different from the other women. Virtuous. Loyal to your vows. Turns out you’re just as fickle and wanton as everyone else. I can’t stand what you’ve done with Michael. I want a divorce.”
Everything had happened so fast. I had been holding back my emotions, keeping them buried deep, until I heard the word divorce.
Tears welled up, threatening to spill like a dam breaking, but I forced them back and managed to say through a trembling voice, “Divorce? Over these photos?”
“Is that hard to understand?” His eyebrows went up. “I can’t divorce my cheating wife? And you know what the worst part is?”
The worst part? Haven’t I done enough all these years? I always took care of him in every little way, always going along with his moods. I didn’t even realize that, in his heart, I was never truly enough.
“We’ve been married for three years now. Three whole years, and you still haven’t managed to give me a child.”
My hand twitched toward my stomach before I could stop it. I’d been about to tell him exactly that. That’s why I’d made the cake in the first place, why I’d been waiting by the door with a smile.
The pregnancy test kit was in my purse right this second, sitting on the kitchen counter just a few feet away.
“Do you still love me?” I croaked.
“No.” He didn’t even blink. “After this? No. I don’t.”
I took a shaky breath, trying to find the courage to speak. “What if we had a child?”
He laughed coldly, and the words cut through me like ice. “A child? You want to use a pregnancy to get out of this? You haven’t managed to get pregnant in these three years, and now, right after I tell you I caught you cheating, you suddenly bring up a pregnancy? I can see through your manipulations. You’re a compulsive liar. I don’t believe you’re even pregnant. Even if you were, how would I ever know it’s mine and not Michael’s?”
After his words hit me, all my strength to argue drained away. This was exactly how he saw me, a woman utterly disgraceful in his eyes. He didn’t love me. He didn’t love our child.
Why should I bother telling him anything now?
He left me sobbing there and disappeared into his office without a backward glance. I heard the sounds of drawers being yanked open, papers rustling as he searched for something.
He called his lawyer. The two of them talked about something I couldn’t make out. Then I heard the fax machine beeping.
Beep. Beep.
After that, he picked up a few sheets of paper and walked over to me. I looked down and saw, at the top of the page, a large, unmistakable title:
DIVORCE AGREEMENT.
I looked at him. He was staring at me too, anger still burning in his eyes, but there was something else there as well, something unsettled, almost lost.
He didn’t explain. Didn’t shout.
He just said, cold and final. “Sign it.”
My hands trembled violently as I wiped my tears. I took the pen he offered and signed.
Harrison signed right after me.
His phone suddenly vibrated against the coffee table between us. The screen lit up and I saw the name displayed there before he could snatch it away. I froze.
Lyndsey.
His ex-girlfriend. The woman he’d dated for five years before he’d ever met me. The one his mother had absolutely adored and talked about constantly even after Harrison and I got engaged.
She was the most important person in his life.
I looked up at him slowly. “This was never really about the photos at all, was it?”
He didn’t deny what I’d said. He didn’t even try.
He just picked up his phone and silenced the call.
“You wanted an excuse to leave,” I rasped. “You needed some kind of justification so you could go back to her without looking like the bad guy.”
“Don’t be so dramatic about everything. She is my friend now.”
“Dramatic?” I scoffed. “You just destroyed our marriage over fake pictures and now she’s calling you within seconds of us finishing the signatures.”
He grabbed his jacket. “I’m leaving now.”
He walked to the door and pulled it open. He stepped halfway through the doorway and then suddenly stopped.
His hand tightened around the doorknob. He stood there frozen for what felt like an eternity, his back still turned toward me so I couldn’t see his face.
“What was it?” he asked without turning around. “That good news you said you wanted to tell me earlier. What was it?”
Estelle’s POVI was standing near the cake table when Claire passed me on her way out of the room.I watched her go. Then I set my glass down on the cake table and went after her, before I had finished giving myself permission.She was at the far end of the corridor, by the cloakroom door, with her hand flat on the wall.She wasn’t crying. She had done the thing she did right before she cried—the swallow, the chin lift—and stopped herself before the line.“Claire.”She turned slowly.“Estelle.”“Are you all right?”“I’m fine, Estelle.”I opened the cloakroom door. I did not look at her. I held it.She went in. I followed. I shut the door behind us. Claire stood with her back to the sink and I leaned against the door.“I was watching the toast that’s coming,” she said quietly. “I was watching Helena. She has not stood for anything yet. She will stand for that one. She wants me to know she will, and she wants me to feel it.”She breathed out.“Estelle.”“Yes?”“I am not going to apologi
Estelle’s POVI was downstairs before the birds.Five forty-seven on the kitchen clock, which I noted because the clock was the first thing I could focus on after the light switch. I filled the kettle and got to the table before I remembered what day it was.I sat with the mug in both hands.Chloe came down at eight twenty-five in the dress.The dress was yellow. Nobody in the store had sold it to her as aggressive. Chloe had made it aggressive by force of will. It was the color of a highway sign. She walked into the kitchen with her hands on her hips.“Well.”“Chloe, you look—”“Don’t.”“—extraordinary.”“Thank you.”Daisy laughed wetly into her coffee.Lucas came down four minutes later in the bowtie and a plastic shark. I raised my brow, pointing at the shark. He shrugged and walked to the couch. He sat down very straight to wait to be useful.I went back upstairs at nine. Harrison was in the bathroom with the shower running.I put on the dress, zipping it myself. I checked the hem
Harrison’s POVThomas came over at one with his own hammer and a fresh bag of nails.He didn’t bring mine. I noted that and didn’t ask.“You’re early.”“I’m on time,” he said mildly, setting the bag on the patio table. “You’re late, because you haven’t started.”“I was going to start at one.”“It’s one-twelve, Harrison.”“Thomas.”“I brought the right nails this time.”Lucas was already on the step with his shark book facedown across his knee. He hadn’t looked up from Thomas in about ten minutes. Inside, Chloe was shouting at Estelle about a sheet of lists. Lucas had excused himself from that situation at nine. He had not been called back.“Hi, Thomas,” Lucas said promptly.“Hi, Lucas.”“Are you fixing Dad’s fence?”“I’m helping your dad fix his fence.”“Dad did it wrong.”“So I understand.”Lucas sank back into the book.We walked down to the corner section I’d put up for his birthday three weekends back. The slats had bowed out by Thursday. Estelle had noticed. She had not commented
Estelle’s POVHelena Donovan called me Thursday evening.I was on the couch with a cooking show playing on mute, my feet tucked under a blanket, a glass of wine at my elbow I had forgotten to drink. Harrison was upstairs. Chloe was at the kitchen table doing her Spanish homework out loud to herself because she said repeating the conjugations helped. Lucas was in his room reading a book about basking sharks.My phone rang, and it said Helena Donovan.I sat up slowly. I paused the television. I let it ring a second time before I picked up.“Hello?”“Estelle. It’s Helena.”“Yes. Hi.”“I was hoping you and I could have coffee tomorrow morning. Somewhere quiet. I won’t keep you long. It’s about Saturday.”Harrison had warned me she had gone to Claire’s. He had told me about the four rows and the don’t-turn-around. He had not warned me she might call.“Of course,” I said.“There is a coffee shop on Blackwell Road near the roundabout. I can be there at nine.”“I’ll be there at nine.”“Thank
Claire’s POVThe bell rang at ten past ten.I was drying a mug that had dried itself ten minutes ago. That was how my Wednesday mornings went now—I would pour a cup of coffee I did not drink, wipe down counters that did not need wiping, fold a dishtowel I had already folded, and wait for the clock to tell me it was an acceptable hour to telephone someone.I set the mug on the drainer. I went to the door.Through the peephole I saw a cream wool coat, pearl studs, and silver hair pinned the way it had been pinned in every society photograph I had ever seen of the woman wearing it. Helena Donovan. On my doorstep. On a Wednesday.My hand went to the collar of my blouse, checked it, and dropped.I opened the door.She stood on the mat the way she stood in those photographs—back straight, handbag at her shoulder, collar flat—and she did not apologize for coming unannounced. She did not smile. She waited.“Helena,” I said again, because my mouth had not yet caught up with my brain.“Good mor
Harrison’s POVKarl brought a Barolo he’d been saving. Thomas brought nothing, because Thomas never brought anything to dinner except himself and the faint smell of sawdust.The restaurant was a small Italian place on the west side that Karl had chosen for the booths in the back where nobody would bother us. The hostess seated us at seven-fifteen.Karl slid into one side of the booth. Thomas sat next to him.I sat across from both of them, which felt strange for about thirty seconds and then didn’t.Karl ordered the risotto. Thomas got a steak, medium, with a baked potato—the kind of plain, straightforward meal you order when you’ve spent years eating whatever was put in front of you and just want to choose something simple.I got pasta.Karl poured the wine without ceremony. Thomas drank carefully, slowly, as if he still wasn’t entirely convinced he was allowed.“So,” Karl said, leaning back and folding his hands behind his head. “Harrison Emerson is getting married. Again.”“Again,”
Estelle’s POVI made it to my office before the anger really hit, slamming the door harder than necessary and crossing to my desk where I dropped into my chair and pressed both hands flat against the surface.Lucas had called her Mom.The word kept echoing in my head, bouncing around, making my jaw
Estelle’s POVI was twenty minutes late by the time I rushed into the Capella Capital conference room, my bag sliding off my shoulder and my hair still damp from the too-quick shower after an emergency consultation.Everyone was already seated around the massive glass table and they all turned to lo
Harrison’s POVMy office was quiet, and all I could think about was Estelle pressed against that bathroom sink, her hands gripping the counter behind her, her eyes wide and furious and something else I didn’t want to name.Does he make you happy?I’d asked her that and she’d lied. I knew she’d lied
Lyndsey’s POVI knocked twice on Lucas’s bedroom door before pushing it open, the chocolate bar already in my hand.He was sitting on his bed with his hearing aids in, his small hand slowly turning the volume dial like the audiologist had taught him. When he saw me, his face went blank.“Hi, sweethe







