เข้าสู่ระบบห้องสมุด
ค้นหา
Is Gloomy Sunday Really Cursed Or Just An Urban Legend?
2025-08-28 08:48:58
258
4 คำตอบ
Zane
2025-08-30 14:19:56
I’d heard the legend on a forum late at night, which probably makes me suspect right away, but the story around 'Gloomy Sunday' is too juicy to ignore. There’s even a film called 'Gloomy Sunday — Ein Lied von Liebe und Tod' that leans into the myth, dramatizing the idea that the song itself brings doom. That cinematic version plays up coincidences (suicides, a cursed melody) because it’s good storytelling — and that’s a big part of why the myth stuck.
In everyday life, though, I treat it like other spooky music stories: a small factual base blown up into lore. The composer’s tragic life and real suicides in the era gave people something to point at, and cultural fears about depression and contagion fed the rumor mill. Personally I’m fascinated by how a three-minute piece of music can carry a cultural narrative for decades, and I think looking at translations of the lyrics or listening to different versions (Hungarian originals versus Billie Holiday’s interpretation) is more interesting than hunting for curses. Still, if a song ever makes you feel dangerously low, I’d advise switching the playlist and talking to someone — the internet’s love of myths shouldn’t replace care.
In everyday life, though, I treat it like other spooky music stories: a small factual base blown up into lore. The composer’s tragic life and real suicides in the era gave people something to point at, and cultural fears about depression and contagion fed the rumor mill. Personally I’m fascinated by how a three-minute piece of music can carry a cultural narrative for decades, and I think looking at translations of the lyrics or listening to different versions (Hungarian originals versus Billie Holiday’s interpretation) is more interesting than hunting for curses. Still, if a song ever makes you feel dangerously low, I’d advise switching the playlist and talking to someone — the internet’s love of myths shouldn’t replace care.
Zara
2025-08-31 04:48:36
I like digging into myths, so I dove into the timeline: 'Gloomy Sunday' was composed in the early 1930s by Rezső Seress, and the melancholic theme caught on during a bleak era. Over the years, newspapers and radio gossip linked it to a string of suicides and even claimed broadcasting bans in places like Britain. Those reports exist, but they’re often vague and inconsistent — sometimes the same incident gets repeated with different details in later retellings.
From a skeptic’s point of view, the story is an urban legend amplified by human psychology. Sad songs can make people feel worse temporarily, and sensational journalism loves a tidy causal line ('song causes suicides'). But actual causes of suicide are complex: mental illness, life events, access to means, and social support matter far more than whether someone listened to a tune. That said, there’s a real phenomenon called the Werther effect where certain depictions of suicide can increase risk in vulnerable populations, so the caution around 'Gloomy Sunday' wasn’t completely paranoid — it was just overstated into a curse. I’d recommend enjoying the music but also respecting how powerful art can be for people who are struggling.
From a skeptic’s point of view, the story is an urban legend amplified by human psychology. Sad songs can make people feel worse temporarily, and sensational journalism loves a tidy causal line ('song causes suicides'). But actual causes of suicide are complex: mental illness, life events, access to means, and social support matter far more than whether someone listened to a tune. That said, there’s a real phenomenon called the Werther effect where certain depictions of suicide can increase risk in vulnerable populations, so the caution around 'Gloomy Sunday' wasn’t completely paranoid — it was just overstated into a curse. I’d recommend enjoying the music but also respecting how powerful art can be for people who are struggling.
Noah
2025-09-02 15:05:43
On a rainy evening I found myself staring at the window and the first few chords of 'Gloomy Sunday' came up on a playlist — it felt like walking into a ghost story you half-remembered from childhood. There’s a romantic, gothic aura to the whole legend: a melancholy Hungarian tune from the 1930s, stories of listeners reportedly killing themselves, and even tales of radio bans and scandalized newspapers. That mix of sorrowful music plus sensational reporting is the perfect soil for an urban myth to grow.
I lean toward calling the curse a myth with some tragic kernels. The song was written by Rezső Seress in the early 1930s and lyrics commonly credited to László Jávor; it was popularized internationally later, especially by Billie Holiday. Over the decades journalists and storytellers connected unrelated suicides to the song, and anxieties about contagion made the claims louder. There’s no solid scientific proof the song literally causes people to kill themselves — but there is real evidence that media can create imitation effects in vulnerable people. For me, the lesson is twofold: appreciate the haunting beauty of 'Gloomy Sunday' as art, and be careful about romanticizing sorrow, because people really do get hurt when melancholy becomes a performance rather than something we tend to with care.
I lean toward calling the curse a myth with some tragic kernels. The song was written by Rezső Seress in the early 1930s and lyrics commonly credited to László Jávor; it was popularized internationally later, especially by Billie Holiday. Over the decades journalists and storytellers connected unrelated suicides to the song, and anxieties about contagion made the claims louder. There’s no solid scientific proof the song literally causes people to kill themselves — but there is real evidence that media can create imitation effects in vulnerable people. For me, the lesson is twofold: appreciate the haunting beauty of 'Gloomy Sunday' as art, and be careful about romanticizing sorrow, because people really do get hurt when melancholy becomes a performance rather than something we tend to with care.
Ursula
2025-09-03 03:36:53
I’m pretty pragmatic about this: the idea that 'Gloomy Sunday' is literally cursed reads like folklore. There are documented stories and media scares from the mid-20th century that linked the song to suicides, but scholars and journalists who have checked the records don’t find clean, causal evidence that the song itself causes people to take their lives.
That doesn’t mean the legend is harmless. Melancholic art can trigger strong feelings in vulnerable people, and sensational claims about curses can stigmatize real grief. If you’re curious, listen to different versions and read about the historical context of the 1930s — it’s often the social conditions that matter more than a melody. And if the song ever hits you in a way that worries you, reach out to someone you trust or a professional; no myth should stand between you and getting help.
That doesn’t mean the legend is harmless. Melancholic art can trigger strong feelings in vulnerable people, and sensational claims about curses can stigmatize real grief. If you’re curious, listen to different versions and read about the historical context of the 1930s — it’s often the social conditions that matter more than a melody. And if the song ever hits you in a way that worries you, reach out to someone you trust or a professional; no myth should stand between you and getting help.
ดูคำตอบทั้งหมด
สแกนรหัสเพื่อดาวน์โหลดแอป
หนังสือที่เกี่ยวข้อง
Urban Vampire
Kim woke up one morning to find that she was dead ... well UNDEAD. Unfortunately, her Vampire after-life is a big mystery. The ones that know are out to kill her and her allies happen to be her food. In order to survive the Vampire Nation, Kim will have to outsmart and out think her enemies. The last thing Kim wants or needs are the three gorgeous men vying for her attention, one chocolate, one vanilla and the last caramel. How do you choose between the gorgeous protector, the charming and tasty food, and the scary dangerous elder? Warning; adult situations, graphic sex and language.Urban Vampire is created by Pepper Pace, an EGlobal Creative Publishing signed author.
332 บท
Blessed or Cursed
"What do you mean he's your 3rd fated mate? Answer me Arabella!" Ryker screamed in my face as he stared me down waiting for an answer. Looking at his red face and clenched fists I'm not sure if he is going to kill me or my mates. My brother is ridiculously over protective. The only reason he is even here is to watch over me. He know's our father is going to be livid if anything happens to me. I thought finally getting accepted to moonlight academy would give me the freedom I desperately needed. It turns out, I'm not as prepared as I thought I was. My power's keep getting stronger, and mate's keep popping up out of nowhere. The lines between right and wrong are blurring, but I'm determined to prove I can do this on my own. I'm not sure if this mark the moon goddess gave to me is a blessing or a curse, but Im strong enough to figure it out on my own.
54 บท
Legend of the jungle
The novel, "Legend Of The Jungle". Is ani magination story full of love, hope, lost, battleand
war.
The story started with slavery and clash between two states but end with unity and love.
Sir Mallow, Lord of the castle, led his citizens to gather inside the castle to worship their Gods at
night. Not knowing that their enemy was already with them.
Suddenly,the sound of "Boom" was heard and everything began to clash. All the houses
were burnt and everywhere was scattered.
Finally,the Lord of the castle,Sir Mallow was Captured and everyone surrender which Mark's
the beginning of slavery.
Thanks to the legend of the jungle who deliver us from slavery, the novel is dedicated to all story lover's.
12 บท
Should I Really Do It Or Not?
"St.gardens?!"
"Yes, sir cho"
"Come closer, let me see you properly!"
"...umm...that should be enough, sir Cho! Auntie said that, it's just once a week!"
Cho Ja Nathaniel"....."
"Are you done, St.gardens?!!"
"I...I am sorry, sir Cho. I am just st…"
"Mnnn...mnn...stop it, sir Cho!! This is not right!! I signed a contract!"
"What f**king contract is that?!! That is between you and my mother!! I'm signing another one! We need more to make a stamp!!"
"...What?! No!!"
"No?!! I see you are really fierce. Well, you should know that I like your kind!!"
"F**k you!!"
"Haha…! No, little girl! You don't stand the chance! But don't you worry, I'll help you! I'll f**k you instead and quite well too!!"
St.gardens"....."
******
Haneul Ja St.gardens is a gentle, innocent and sweet girl but also covered with taekwondo skills. One thing that is constant in her life, is bad luck. She could not find a better job to make her life more stable.
St.gardens is feeding from hand to mouth, until the day she meets a middle aged woman. She offers her a deal she can not refuse because the benefit is awesome.
St.gardens is to become a surrogate mother for her son Cho Ja Nathaniel. Things might not go well the way St.gardens has planned and she asks herself several times, if she should really do it, or not?
******
A refreshing book, wrapped specially for you! Join them as they search for the right key to the invisible golden door!
Happy Reading!
Please, stay safe.
#For me and for all!
Love from Author Elaami.
38 บท
Really Dirty Business
Hero and Lyra are more than just friends...
In the morning, Lyra Semana is a very strict professor to Hero, her outspoken and handsome student in Business Law and Policy.
In the evenings, Hero Agpalza is a very demanding superior to Lyra, his smart and seductive "Business Consultant".
They never planned their relationship to be like this but it had to happen for both their sakes and sanity.
Lyra needs to help Hero stop a ruthless and unknown killer who intends to take over his family's business. Meanwhile, Hero needs to financially support the hospitalization of Lyra's parents and save her from a very dangerous and obsessive ex.
Will all these issues find a way to make them realize their love for each other or will they end up being alone and apart instead?
Or even worse... dead.
----------
Check out my interview with GoodNovel here: https://tinyurl.com/y23rvs6n
103 บท
He Is Just An Actor In This Show
The sole heiress of a wealthy family, Amanita Wallace, had seven prospective husbands, taken in from childhood to potentially wed her one day.
All of them fulfilled her every wish, except Marcus Channing, who was cold and mean to her.
Due to this, Amanita fell for him and even became his lapdog.
Then, one day, she saw him pin his supposed sister against the wall and confess his feelings to her.
24 บท
คำถามที่เกี่ยวข้อง
What Language Are The Gloomy Sunday Lyrics Originally In?
4 คำตอบ2025-08-28 14:03:03
I still get a little chill thinking about the original version of 'Gloomy Sunday'. The tune actually began life in Hungarian — the song's original title is 'Szomorú vasárnap' and it was composed in 1933 by Rezső Seress, with the Hungarian lyrics usually credited to the poet László Jávor.
Hearing the Hungarian lyrics for the first time hit me differently than the English renditions; there's a kind of raw, cultural melancholy in the phrasing and phrasing cadence that doesn't always survive translation. Sam M. Lewis later wrote the best-known English lyrics, and those are the words most English-speaking listeners know, especially from Billie Holiday's version. But if you want the original emotional colors, try finding a recording or a translation of 'Szomorú vasárnap' — it's like reading a different chapter of the same story.
How Can I Play Gloomy Sunday On Piano As A Beginner?
4 คำตอบ2025-08-28 01:40:29
There’s something almost cinematic about tackling 'Gloomy Sunday' as a beginner — its melody demands mood more than speed. I’d start by breaking the song into tiny, digestible chunks: pick the main vocal melody and learn it with your right hand first, one phrase at a time. Hum it, sing it, and then find those notes slowly on the keyboard. Don’t try to play the whole form at once.
Once the melody feels comfortable, add a very simple left-hand pattern: play single bass notes on beats one and three, or try an easy Alberti-bass (low–high–middle–high) to give it motion. Work hands separately at a slow tempo with a metronome, then gradually bring them together. If you want some harmonic grounding, stick to a small set of chords (the song sits naturally in a minor key) and practice switching between them smoothly.
I also recommend listening to a few different renditions of 'Gloomy Sunday' to catch phrasing and rubato, and using slow-down features on videos or MIDI files so you can copy details. Practice in short daily sessions, and don’t forget to experiment with sustaining pedal and dynamics — the song lives in those tiny expressive choices. After a few weeks of steady, patient work, the haunting vibe will start to come through, and that’s the fun part.
Who Wrote Gloomy Sunday And What Inspired The Lyrics?
4 คำตอบ2025-08-28 13:23:29
There’s a small, tragic legend behind 'Gloomy Sunday' that I find endlessly fascinating. The music was written by Rezső Seress, a Hungarian pianist and composer, in the early 1930s. The original Hungarian lyrics, titled 'Szomorú vasárnap', were penned by poet László Jávor; those words are the ones most tied to the song’s dark reputation. Later, an English set of lyrics was written by Sam M. Lewis, which softened some of the more morbid extremes for international audiences.
People often ask what inspired the lyrics. The short, honest version is heartbreak and despair—Jávor’s poem reads like someone facing unbearable loss. Over the years many stories grew around it: rumors of multiple suicides linked to the tune, a BBC ban in Britain, and a sense that the melody and words fed off each other’s gloom. I like to think of the song as a product of its time—interwar Europe, personal grief, and a composer who was already attuned to melancholy. It’s haunting, yes, but also a powerful example of how music and myth can amplify one another.
Where Has Gloomy Sunday Appeared In Movies Or TV Soundtracks?
4 คำตอบ2025-08-28 17:24:04
On quiet evenings when I fall into rabbit holes of soundtrack trivia, 'Gloomy Sunday' always pulls me down a moodier lane. The most obvious place it shows up is the 1999 film literally called 'Gloomy Sunday' (German title 'Ein Lied von Liebe und Tod – Gloomy Sunday'), which revolves around the song’s history and the mythos surrounding it. That movie uses the tune both as a plot device and as atmospheric music, so if you want a direct cinematic take on the song’s story, that’s the one to watch.
Beyond that, Billie Holiday’s haunting 1941 recording of 'Gloomy Sunday' has been licensed for numerous period pieces, documentaries, and atmospheric crime dramas—especially whenever directors want a smoky, melancholic backdrop. I’ve noticed the track turning up in documentary montages about wartime Europe or in scenes where a character’s loneliness needs to be felt rather than told. If you’re hunting down exact placements, checking soundtrack credits on IMDb or using Tunefind/Discogs usually reveals which version was used and in which episode or scene. It’s one of those songs that filmmakers keep reaching for when they want a very specific, unsettled vibe.
What Books Or Essays Analyze The Gloomy Sunday Mythology?
4 คำตอบ2025-08-28 10:22:42
There’s a weird little thrill I get when I dig into cultural myths, and the 'Gloomy Sunday' story is one of my favorite rabbit holes. If you want a starting place that treats the song as folklore/urban legend rather than pure fact, Jan Harold Brunvand’s collections are incredibly useful: check out 'The Vanishing Hitchhiker' and his 'Encyclopedia of Urban Legends' for good, skeptical overviews that put the suicides stories into the broader context of how urban legends form and spread.
For the music-history angle, I like pairing that folklorist perspective with biographies and cultural studies. Billie Holiday’s autobiography 'Lady Sings the Blues' gives flavor about the song’s place in jazz/popular music circles, while books about censorship, moral panic and media reaction like 'Folk Devils and Moral Panics' are great for understanding why newspapers and authorities amplified the myth. And don’t forget the original title 'Szomorú vasárnap'—searching that term in Hungarian archives or music journals turns up a lot of primary material about Rezső Seress and contemporary press coverage.
What Mood Does The Original Gloomy Sunday Melody Convey?
4 คำตอบ2025-08-28 23:26:19
On slow, grey afternoons I catch myself replaying the original 'Gloomy Sunday' melody and feeling something like a soft, relentless ache. The mood it gives off is not sudden terror or melodrama, but a slow, intimate sorrow — the kind that settles into your chest and makes ordinary sounds feel distant. The sparse piano, the downward-loping phrases, and the hushed vocal line all conspire to create a sense of resigned loneliness, as if the music is telling you a secret that can't be fixed.
It’s elegiac more than theatrical: funeral candles rather than thunder. There’s also an odd tenderness hidden in that sadness, a paradox where the song comforts by mirroring your melancholy. I usually put it on when I want to feel seen rather than cheered up — and somehow that recognition can be quietly consoling.
Did Billie Holiday Ever Record Gloomy Sunday And When?
4 คำตอบ2025-08-28 09:42:39
I still get chills thinking about the stories behind songs, and 'Gloomy Sunday' has always been one of those pieces that draws me in. From what I've dug up and heard on old compilations, Billie Holiday did record 'Gloomy Sunday' during her Columbia-era years — the session is usually dated to 1941, though you'll find slight variations in exact session dates depending on the discography you consult.
I tend to cross-check a few sources (label discographies, Tom Lord's jazz discography, and the big Billie Holiday box sets) because different reissues sometimes use different session notes. If you want to hear her take, look for the tracks collected in comprehensive Columbia/Decca-era compilations; they usually include her rendition of 'Gloomy Sunday'. It’s a haunting performance, fitting the song’s lore, and it always stands out next to her other work like 'Strange Fruit'. If you want precise session data, I can point you to which reissues and session notes tend to be the most reliable — I’ve bookmarked a few.
Where Can I Find Authentic Gloomy Sunday Sheet Music Online?
4 คำตอบ2025-08-28 18:00:24
I get that feeling when I want the "real" treat — the original phrasing, the little tempo marks, the exact voicings — so my first port of call is always libraries and archives. If you want authentic, try searching the major digital sheet collections: IMSLP can sometimes have older songs if they’re in the public domain, and the British Library or Library of Congress digitized catalogs occasionally hold scans of early 20th-century popular sheet music. Also search Hungarian resources under the original title 'Szomorú vasárnap kottája' or by composer Rezső Seress; the National Széchényi Library (Magyar Nemzeti Könyvtár) has a decent digital catalog.
If those don’t pan out, I look for vintage print scans on sites like eBay or Etsy — sellers often post photos of original covers and measures so you can eyeball authenticity. For clean, playable editions, Musicnotes, Sheet Music Plus, and SheetMusicDirect sell licensed piano/vocal/guitar arrangements. When you check a listing, verify composer credit (Rezso Seress) and compare the melody line to recordings — differences in lyrics or surprising reharmonizations are red flags. I’ve spent afternoons cross-referencing a dusty 1930s scan with a modern transcription; it’s oddly satisfying when they line up.
คำถามยอดนิยม
การค้นหายอดนิยม เพิ่มเติม
Born To Be Bound
Romance Fantasy Books Ya
Highschool Dxd Yasaka Is My Wife
Bible Reading Guides
Trolls(dreamworks) Fanfiction
Rise Of The Lustful Evil Monarch
For Dummies Networking
Black Sheep
Man’s Search For Meaning
There Are Rivers In The Sky
Bl Book
Artemis
Pacifying
Cutecore App System ( Girl X Femboy )
A Man In Full Audiobook
Hunterdon Library
Psychic Princess
Romance Novels With Greek Mythology
Evanescence Lost In Paradise Lyrics
Netloanexpress
Books Gay Romance
Book The Canterbury Tales
American Prometheus: The Triumph And Tragedy Of J. Robert Oppenheimer
Romance Webtoons
Reincarnation Wattpad
The Last Solari Ascendant Prince
Grace Johnson
City Of God
Reader Kate Winslet
Murder Of Innocence
สำรวจและอ่านนวนิยายดีๆ ได้ฟรี
เข้าถึงนวนิยายดีๆ จำนวนมากได้ฟรีบนแอป GoodNovel ดาวน์โหลดหนังสือที่คุณชอบและอ่านได้ทุกที่ทุกเวลา
อ่านหนังสือฟรีบนแอป
สแกนรหัสเพื่ออ่านบนแอป
