How Does The Iliad War Compare To Other Ancient War Epics?

2025-07-31 22:57:21 306

5 답변

Stella
Stella
2025-08-01 10:51:02
What grips me about the 'Iliad' is its refusal to simplify. Other epics, like 'The Táin Bó Cúailnge,' revel in chaotic battles, but Homer balances chaos with haunting quiet moments—the Greek and Trojan soldiers staring at each other across no-man’s-land, or the shared humanity in Priam and Achilles’ night meeting. Contrast this with 'The Nibelungenlied,' where vengeance dominates every interaction. The 'Iliad’s' complexity—Achilles’ rage coexisting with his tenderness for Patroclus—makes it feel less like a war story and more like a mirror held up to human nature itself.
Delilah
Delilah
2025-08-01 19:37:14
The 'Iliad' is darker than most war epics. While 'The Shahnameh' celebrates Persian heroism with a triumphal tone, Homer’s work lingers on loss. Think of the countless minor characters—like Lycaon—who beg for mercy before being killed. This unflinching gaze at war’s randomness sets it apart from later Roman epics, which often serve as propaganda. Even in structure, the 'Iliad' is bold: it starts mid-conflict and ends before Troy falls, rejecting tidy resolutions. That ambiguity feels startlingly modern compared to the moral clarity of something like 'The Thebaid.'
Kate
Kate
2025-08-02 10:50:05
I’d argue the 'Iliad' feels more immediate than other ancient war narratives. Take 'Beowulf'—it’s thrilling, but the monster-slaying lacks the interpersonal tension of Achilles and Agamemnon’s feud. Even 'The Odyssey,' though part of the same tradition, prioritizes adventure over the visceral battlefield drama of the 'Iliad.' Homer’s attention to grief—like Achilles mourning Patroclus—adds layers you don’t see in, say, 'The Argonautica,' where action overshadows emotion. The gods’ meddling in the 'Iliad' also feels more organic than in Mesopotamian epics, where deities often act arbitrarily. It’s this blend of divine scale and intimate stakes that keeps the 'Iliad' timeless.
Leila
Leila
2025-08-02 13:45:46
The 'Iliad' stands out among ancient war epics for its intense focus on human emotions and the personal struggles of its heroes. Unlike 'The Epic of Gilgamesh,' which delves into existential themes, or 'The Mahabharata,' with its sprawling cast and philosophical depth, Homer’s work zeroes in on the wrath of Achilles and the futility of war. The Trojan War isn’t just a backdrop—it’s a crucible that tests honor, loyalty, and mortality.

What fascinates me is how the 'Iliad' avoids glorifying war. While 'The Aeneid' later paints conflict as a means to empire, Homer shows the brutality and cost. Hector’s farewell to Andromache or Priam’s plea for his son’s body—these moments strip war of its grandeur. Comparatively, 'The Song of Roland' feels more one-dimensional, celebrating heroism without the same psychological weight. The 'Iliad' remains unmatched in its raw, poetic humanity.
Yara
Yara
2025-08-05 02:30:50
Compared to other ancient war epics, the 'Iliad' feels less about national identity and more about individual choices. 'The Aeneid' ties war to Rome’s destiny, and 'The Ramayana' frames its conflict as dharma versus chaos. But Homer’s heroes aren’t symbols—they’re flawed, furious, and deeply relatable. Even the gods in the 'Iliad' are pettier, more human, than the stern deities of 'The Eddas.' That’s why, millennia later, we still debate whether Hector or Achilles was 'right.' Most epics tell us who to root for; the 'Iliad' makes us question why we root at all.
모든 답변 보기
QR 코드를 스캔하여 앱을 다운로드하세요

관련 작품

Hate War
Hate War
"Nina is that you. You look so beautiful" a guy said. "Have some drink" "No, she is leaving," said the harsh voice, and next thing I know champagne was all over my dress. I gasped as it stained it. Before I could react he grabbed me and dragged me to the pool area. I yanked my hand. "What the hell. You ruined my clothes" I half yelled. "What the fuck you are doing in my party looking like a slut" he yelled angrily while pinning me to the wall. Listening to his words my blood boiled. "Let me guess you came here to ruin my mood by showing your ugly face," he said letting me know his hate. "Stop giving so much importance to yourself. I'm here because of your mom. My face must be ugly but ugly souls like you are not even worth wasting my life's a single second" I said angrily pushed him but he didn't move. "I can hide my ugly soul behind this face but ugly ducklings like you carry their ugliness which can't even be hidden by beautiful dress because they stain everything around them with their ugliness," his words were hurting my soul but I won't cry. With all my power I pushed him making him fall in the pool. "Happy Birthday," I said with a smirk on my face but he didn't let me go. Things he did to me after it still send a shiver to my spine. One thing was clear on that day that I don't want to see his face again in this life. But I don't know what the hell I'm doing standing in front of him in Church wearing a wedding gown and looking at his angry victory smirk on his face with my glassy eyes.
9
101 챕터
Alphas war
Alphas war
Death and war, two things that always chased Haley around. The last war tore up her family, forcing her to kill her sister to save the world. Knowing the rogues' plans too well, they won't stop until they find the imperial phoenix pack, a rare pack of shapeshifters who vanished long ago. Haley's sister was just like them, and she guessed her niece was the same. So, to avoid history from repeating itself, Haley gave away her niece to a human couple where she will have a normal life. Ten years went by, filled with peace, or that's what Haley thought. Behind her back, the rogues were plotting the upcoming war after they knew about the young shapeshifter. Haley watched the man who helped her during those ten years die because of her mistakes. The rogues killed him as they did with her parents. And when she needed help, only five alphas stood by her side. With an upcoming war and the destiny of the goddess pack in her hands, Haley had to wait for the alpha's son to take his title, not knowing he was her destined mate.
9
17 챕터
War of freedom.. War is inevitable
War of freedom.. War is inevitable
Synopsis - On the night when the young warrior Raen is born, strange things happen in the Free East: A prince dies and the great oracle of Tulga sends a mysterious prophecy. A long journey begins. Will the young Raen manage to take the fate of his people in hand against the dark power of the priests and councilors? Raen's journey takes him to the legendary city of Borgossa, where he is to be trained at the War Academy. There he meets the funny Manoen, a compatriot, and they become friends. But Manoen also keeps a dark secret. When Raen finds out, the terrible machinations of the priests of his country are revealed to him. Together with his friend he returns to Hy to overthrow the priestly caste. War is inevitable.
평가가 충분하지 않습니다.
102 챕터
War of Threes
War of Threes
This is the sequel to "Trio of Mates" (can be found on here) and is NOT a stand-alone book. I felt as if I had just fallen asleep when flashes and fragments of dreams began to play through my mind. They are disjointed, speeding through my mind almost too fast to catch. There is Charlie holding two pups in her arms, the pack being attacked on the western front, Arya fallen to her knees sobbing in the middle of a battlefield, funeral pyres, me looking down at my pregnant stomach with Gael and Hakeem smiling down at me, whoops of victory, and wails of defeat. As the images flit through my mind, a voice enters the chaos. “A war of threes. Three deaths. Three victories. Three trios. Three losses. Betrayal. Birth. Death. Sorrow. Joy. Warn them, Meredith. Be prepared!”
10
135 챕터
Wives at War
Wives at War
My best friend and I married the Luther brothers. I married the older brother, a legendary specialist in childbirth. My best friend, Autumn, married the younger brother, the CEO of a pharmaceutical company. On my birthday, my husband’s crush, Kirsty, scared me into early labor by sending me the carcass of a rotten, dead cat. Autumn rushed me to the emergency room. The doctors had their hands tied as I went into premature labor with a case of amniotic fluid embolism. With the last of my strength, I turned to my husband for help. Instead, I was berated. “So I missed your birthday. Do you have to make a big deal out of it? Why are you lying to me? Kirsty’s pet dog is having puppies. I need to help with the birth, so stop getting in the way!” Later, Autumn took charge and operated on me. I managed to pull through, while my baby was rushed to the ICU. Autumn tearfully called her husband, pleading for the specific medication produced by his company. “Kirsty’s dog is struggling in labor. I’m making a nutritious meal for it. You sure are good friends with Bella to take turns stirring up a fuss. Don’t you have anything better to do than act out in jealousy?” In the end, I lost my child. My heart shattered into pieces. “I want a divorce, Autumn.” “I’m with you! The cheating bastards don’t deserve wives.” We filed for divorce, and the brothers panicked.
8 챕터
War of Hearts
War of Hearts
"Was there something I could have done, to make your heart long for me?To make you see me as your dream the way I see you as mine?” "Nothing is better than to both say our goodbyes, so let’s just let it go Russe. Goodbye.” she vanished into the eerie night with her bag. Russe continued staring at the spot she vanished from, and with tears welling up in his eyes he fell to his knees. “I love you Adel!” he whispered. Nothing would hurt a powerful werewolf more than being rejected by his mate and that’s what happen to Russe, the Alpha of the Teros Pack. After years of being in love and then rejected on the wedding day, he vowed never to get married to another woman, except that the moon goddess’s prophecy really gave him no way out. The moon goddess gave a prophecy decades ago stating “The Alpha who is rejected by his mate must not be without an offspring for the throne. When he begat a first son with the Xenakis, the hybrid one regardless of her mate must be sacrificed for he whose eyes is as cloudy as the sky. Tribulation awaits the Teros Pack until a new offspring is born.” His mate rejected him for a human she was pregnant for, and now he drunkenly impregnated the Xenakis's only female warrior. Finding out his unborn son would be born disabled wasn't the end of his nightmare, even his mate’s hybrid child had to be sacrificed for his own disabled child. Torn between his lingering feelings for his mate and his fatherly love for this disabled child, Russe has to make the decision or someone else will. But who is the enemy? The cause of this whole misery?
10
6 챕터

연관 질문

How Did Achilles Die In The Iliad War?

4 답변2025-08-01 22:37:01
Achilles' death in the 'Iliad' is one of those epic moments that sticks with you long after you've read it. While Homer doesn’t actually describe it in the poem itself, later traditions and ancient sources like the 'Aethiopis' fill in the gaps. The story goes that Achilles was shot in the heel by Paris, guided by the god Apollo. This was his only vulnerable spot, thanks to his mother Thetis dipping him in the River Styx as a baby but holding him by the heel. What makes this so tragic is that Achilles knew his fate—he was destined to die young if he chose glory over a long life. He chose glory, avenging Patroclus' death by killing Hector, but his own death came soon after. The irony is thick: the greatest warrior of the Greeks, nearly invincible, brought down by a single arrow to his one weak point. It’s a stark reminder of how even the mightiest heroes have their flaws, both literal and metaphorical.

What Was Hector'S Role In The Iliad War?

4 답변2025-08-01 00:30:07
Hector was the greatest warrior of Troy in 'The Iliad,' embodying the ideals of honor, duty, and family. Unlike many heroes driven by personal glory, Hector fought primarily to protect his city and loved ones. His confrontation with Achilles is legendary, showcasing his bravery even in the face of certain death. Hector’s humanity shines through moments like his tender farewell to his wife Andromache and their son Astyanax, making him one of the most relatable figures in the epic. Beyond his martial prowess, Hector was a leader who carried the weight of Troy’s survival. His death marked a turning point in the war, symbolizing the inevitable fall of Troy. What makes Hector compelling is his tragic arc—he’s a hero bound by fate, yet his choices reflect deep moral courage. His legacy endures as a counterpoint to Achilles’ rage, offering a quieter but profound commentary on heroism and sacrifice.

In What Ways Does 'The Iliad' Depict The Consequences Of War?

4 답변2025-03-27 11:29:03
'The Iliad' is a vivid portrayal of the grim reality of war that hits different emotions head-on. As a college student diving into this epic, I’m struck by how Achilles’ rage leads not just to personal tragedy but to widespread devastation. The relentless cycle of revenge, like when Hector kills Patroclus, shows that loss spirals outwards—one person's pain igniting others' fury. The battlefield is brutal, with vivid descriptions of death that feel hauntingly real. It's not just the warriors who suffer; families, cities, and the innocent are left in ruins. The gods meddling in human affairs adds a layer of absurdity to it all, highlighting how often the consequences of war are beyond anyone’s control. This epic serves as a timeless reminder that war brings suffering, a theme echoed in modern conflicts. If you're into deep and philosophical reads about the dark side of humanity, I'd suggest checking out 'All Quiet on the Western Front'.

Which Movies Depict The Iliad War Accurately?

5 답변2025-07-31 11:37:16
As someone deeply fascinated by ancient epics and historical accuracy, I find that 'Troy' (2004) starring Brad Pitt is one of the most visually striking adaptations of the Iliad war. While it takes creative liberties for cinematic appeal, the core themes of honor, love, and fate remain intact. The film captures the grandeur of the Trojan War with its massive battle scenes and emotional depth, especially in Hector's portrayal. For a more traditional take, the 1956 film 'Helen of Troy' stays closer to Homer's narrative, focusing on the tragic romance between Paris and Helen. The black-and-white cinematography adds a timeless quality to the myth. Another notable mention is the miniseries 'The Odyssey' (1997), which, while not solely about the Iliad, provides context for the war's aftermath. Each adaptation offers a unique lens, but 'Troy' stands out for balancing spectacle and substance.

What Caused The Iliad War Between Greeks And Trojans?

4 답변2025-08-01 14:51:14
The Iliad war, famously depicted in Homer's epic 'The Iliad,' was sparked by a complex web of divine intervention, human pride, and love. The immediate cause was the abduction of Helen, the most beautiful woman in the world, by Paris, a prince of Troy. Helen was married to Menelaus, king of Sparta, and her departure with Paris was seen as a grave insult to Greek honor, leading Menelaus and his brother Agamemnon to rally the Greek forces against Troy. The deeper roots of the conflict, however, lie in the judgment of Paris, where the Trojan prince was tasked with choosing the fairest among the goddesses Hera, Athena, and Aphrodite. Aphrodite promised him Helen's love in return for his favor, setting the stage for the war. The Greeks, bound by oaths to defend Helen's marriage, saw the abduction as a violation of xenia, the sacred laws of hospitality. This cultural and religious breach, combined with the Greeks' thirst for glory and the gods' manipulations, turned a personal dispute into a decade-long war that reshaped the ancient world.

How Does The Iliad Setting Influence The Trojan War?

5 답변2025-08-17 04:31:28
The setting of 'The Iliad' plays a crucial role in shaping the Trojan War, not just as a backdrop but as an active participant in the narrative. The rugged terrain of Troy, with its high walls and strategic position near the sea, creates a sense of inevitability about the conflict. The Greeks are trapped by their obsession with honor and glory, unable to retreat even when the war drags on for years. The gods, who intervene frequently, are as much a part of the setting as the physical landscape, their whims and rivalries mirroring the human struggles below. The harsh conditions of the battlefield—dust, heat, and the ever-present threat of death—amplify the brutality of the war. Homer’s descriptions of the Scamander River running red with blood or the funeral pyres lighting up the night sky make the setting visceral and oppressive. The Trojan War isn’t just fought by men; it’s shaped by the land, the weather, and the divine, making the setting inseparable from the story itself.

What Happens To Aeneas In The Iliad After The Trojan War?

2 답변2025-07-03 06:17:21
Aeneas’s journey after the fall of Troy is one of those epic survival stories that just hooks you. Unlike most Trojan heroes who get wiped out, Aeneas becomes this symbol of resilience. The 'Iliad' barely scratches the surface, but you can see the seeds of his destiny—especially when Poseidon casually drops that he’s fated to survive and lead the Trojans’ legacy. Homer leaves him mid-battle, but the real drama unfolds later. Imagine carrying your elderly father on your back while dragging your kid through flaming ruins, all because some goddess mom whispered, 'Run, my son, your story isn’t over.' That’s peak heroic material right there. Post-'Iliad,' Aeneas becomes the ultimate wanderer. Virgil’s 'Aeneid' picks up where Homer leaves off, turning him into a refugee with divine homework: found a new city that’ll eventually birth Rome. The contrast between his 'Iliad' role—a minor noble—and his 'Aeneid' glow-up is wild. He’s no longer just another soldier; he’s the guy who weathers storms, ditches Dido (heartbreaking, by the way), and even journeys to the Underworld. His arc feels like a video game protagonist unlocking his true purpose after the tutorial level (Trojan War). The 'Iliad' sets the stage, but Aeneas’s real trials—loss, love, and legacy—are what make him legendary.

Who Are The Main Heroes In The Iliad War Story?

5 답변2025-07-31 12:50:07
As someone who loves diving into epic tales, 'The Iliad' is a masterpiece that never fails to captivate me. The main heroes are legendary figures, each with their own strengths and flaws. Achilles is the central figure, a nearly invincible warrior whose rage drives much of the story. His conflict with Agamemnon, the leader of the Greek forces, sets the stage for the epic. Then there's Hector, the noble prince of Troy, who fights valiantly to defend his city and family. His humanity and courage make him one of the most relatable characters. Other key heroes include Odysseus, known for his cunning and intelligence, and Patroclus, Achilles' close companion whose death fuels Achilles' return to battle. On the Trojan side, Paris, whose abduction of Helen sparked the war, is a complex figure—more of a lover than a fighter. The interplay between these characters creates a rich tapestry of heroism, honor, and tragedy that has resonated for centuries. The way Homer portrays their struggles and sacrifices is what makes 'The Iliad' timeless.
좋은 소설을 무료로 찾아 읽어보세요
GoodNovel 앱에서 수많은 인기 소설을 무료로 즐기세요! 마음에 드는 책을 다운로드하고, 언제 어디서나 편하게 읽을 수 있습니다
앱에서 책을 무료로 읽어보세요
앱에서 읽으려면 QR 코드를 스캔하세요.
DMCA.com Protection Status