LOGINLibrary
Search
Who Does Plato The Republic Call Philosopher-Kings?
2025-08-29 18:42:48
108
4 Answers
Gavin
2025-08-31 17:15:12
On a late-night read-through I started comparing Plato’s philosopher-kings to modern technocrats and it opened up a useful critique. Plato describes philosopher-kings in 'The Republic' as the select few who, after extensive education and moral training, achieve knowledge of the Forms — especially the Form of the Good — and therefore can rule justly. They’re chosen from the guardians and elevated through rigorous tests of character and reasoning; the ruler at the end is someone who knows what justice truly is, not just its appearances.
But I can’t help being skeptical: Plato’s model assumes such knowledge is attainable and that those who claim it won’t be corrupted. That’s a big assumption. From one angle, his ideal corrects the shortcomings of populist rule by insisting on competence and virtue. From another, it risks concentrating authority in an unelected, supposed elite. Still, as a thought experiment, it forces you to ask what kind of knowledge and character we really want in our leaders — and I find that question still matters.
But I can’t help being skeptical: Plato’s model assumes such knowledge is attainable and that those who claim it won’t be corrupted. That’s a big assumption. From one angle, his ideal corrects the shortcomings of populist rule by insisting on competence and virtue. From another, it risks concentrating authority in an unelected, supposed elite. Still, as a thought experiment, it forces you to ask what kind of knowledge and character we really want in our leaders — and I find that question still matters.
Sabrina
2025-09-01 02:57:09
When I first dug into 'The Republic' as a curious teen, the phrase 'philosopher-kings' felt almost mythic — like a cross between a wizard-king and a fair ruler in a story. Plato calls philosopher-kings those rare people who combine a genuine love of wisdom with the moral training and intellectual mastery to rule. In his ideal city, they’re drawn from the guardian class but elevated by rigorous education: years of music, gymnastics, mathematics, and dialectic until they finally grasp the Form of the Good. That knowledge, for Plato, makes them uniquely fit to decide what’s best for the polis rather than chasing power or money.
Plato stresses moral character as much as intelligence. These rulers are supposed to be temperate, courageous, and just — not ambitious office-seekers but reluctant leaders who rule for the common good. He even argues they shouldn’t hold private property or families the way ordinary citizens do, to prevent conflicts of interest. Reading it now, I find it inspiring and a bit unnerving: it’s a noble ideal, but very demanding on the human side, and it assumes knowledge can be cleanly separated from partial interests. Still, there's something hauntingly attractive about the idea of leaders who truly love wisdom and put the city's welfare above themselves.
Plato stresses moral character as much as intelligence. These rulers are supposed to be temperate, courageous, and just — not ambitious office-seekers but reluctant leaders who rule for the common good. He even argues they shouldn’t hold private property or families the way ordinary citizens do, to prevent conflicts of interest. Reading it now, I find it inspiring and a bit unnerving: it’s a noble ideal, but very demanding on the human side, and it assumes knowledge can be cleanly separated from partial interests. Still, there's something hauntingly attractive about the idea of leaders who truly love wisdom and put the city's welfare above themselves.
Annabelle
2025-09-02 14:59:19
Honestly, I like to explain Plato’s philosopher-kings like this: they’re the thinkers who should rule because they understand what’s truly good. In 'The Republic' Plato imagines a community where the best rulers are picked from trained guardians and then schooled in philosophy until they grasp the Form of the Good. That’s the key — it’s not about cleverness or force, it’s about understanding reality and justice deeply.
Plato wants them to be virtuous, immune to greed (hence no private property for rulers), and focused on the common welfare. It’s a neat ideal if you’re into the idea that knowledge should guide power, though obviously it raises questions about who decides who’s wise enough to rule.
Plato wants them to be virtuous, immune to greed (hence no private property for rulers), and focused on the common welfare. It’s a neat ideal if you’re into the idea that knowledge should guide power, though obviously it raises questions about who decides who’s wise enough to rule.
Theo
2025-09-03 21:54:41
If you squint at 'The Republic' through a modern lens, Plato’s philosopher-kings read like his prescription for the ultimate public servant. I picture someone who’s undergone an almost monastic education — he’s gone through the guardians’ practical training and then advanced into philosophical study, culminating in dialectic and the knowledge of the Good. Plato thinks only those who can apprehend the underlying realities, the Forms, can legislate rightly rather than merely following opinion.
He isn’t talking about rulers as career politicians. These are people who resist private luxury, who are trained to prioritize justice over personal gain. In practice Plato wants rulers who are wise, virtuous, and intellectually equipped to see beyond temporary appearances. It’s easy to critique this as elitist, but I often catch myself wishing our decision-makers had a bit more of that moral seriousness and philosophical grounding.
He isn’t talking about rulers as career politicians. These are people who resist private luxury, who are trained to prioritize justice over personal gain. In practice Plato wants rulers who are wise, virtuous, and intellectually equipped to see beyond temporary appearances. It’s easy to critique this as elitist, but I often catch myself wishing our decision-makers had a bit more of that moral seriousness and philosophical grounding.
View All Answers
Scan code to download App
Related Books
Ravens call
A young girl is forced to face the harsh reality of life when she looses her parents at a young age and is adopted by a kind stranger who she calls grandfather.
However, life is not through with her yet as she get older it throws another challenge for her. She discovers she possesses magical powers, one she has to keep a secret to protect her life in a time were such powers are rare and are only found within the elite rulers of the kingdom.
With her new found powers, a revelation of her past identity and the discovery that she is from a race of powerful magical sorceresses known as the Ravens keepers and a destiny to stand against the tyrant ruler of the kingdom. Past truths will be uncovered and battles will be fought, hearts will be broken and hearts will fall in love.
Will she rise above the tide and fufil her destiny ?
56 Chapters
Kat Call
Katherine Elizabeth Douglas is a young journalist, unhappy with her job, but content in life with her best friends in the big city. At a night out for her birthday, she stumbles upon two very different men: the Prince Charming, and the Mysterious Hottie. They both bring her into a world that she never knew existed, but while one she can't seem to stay away from, the other can't seem to leave her alone.
What happens when her world connects with theirs?
8 Chapters
Call it love,Call it war
Riven Vale is Hollywood’s star boy—talented, handsome, untouchable. But when a late-night scandal with a billionaire’s son explodes across every tabloid, his once-soaring career crashes to dust. To quell the frenzy, his team ships him off to a sleepy coastal town in Maine, ostensibly “to rest and recharge.” Unofficially? He stumbled onto something dark: a clandestine meeting between studio executives and a shadowy investor, planning to traffic stolen military tech.He refused their hush-money,and the threats began.
At the edge of a misty harbor stands Kael Quinn, a rugged carpenter with a haunted gaze and zero patience for movie stars. Riven doesn’t recognize him at first, but Kael remembers the boy who crushed a small-town heart in high school—and walked away without a second glance. This time, he’s not letting Riven leave until he makes amends. Only, Kael doesn't just want an apology; he wants the truth, the whole story, and he’s ready to use every tool in his belt to pry it out.
“Tell me, Hollywood—do you kiss better when you're lying, or when you're scared?”
Tension ignites into obsession as Riven fights to stay alive—and to win back the man he once broke. With every secret laid bare, they’re drawn together by danger, by guilt, by the promise of something more. But the label’s mercenaries are closing in, and in a town too quiet to be safe, love might be the deadliest risk of all.
24 Chapters
Demon Kings Mate
/Completed/His eyes fully turned bright red and lethal, the dark grey fog surrounding him as he rose on his feet. Black pointed sharp claws jutted out of his fingers. His skin appeared paler than usual as he stared right into my soul."W-What are...you?" I questioned, my lips trembling in fear."Daemonuim rex" He hissed, his claws disappearing. I froze in my seat as those words echoed in my ears. I know what he meant. Demon King. ***Talia wanted an adventure. Working two jobs and living in a dump for an apartment does that to you. When her friend drags her to the club, she is excited at the prospect of meeting someone new. That’s how she meets Lukas, the handsome stranger at the bar who beds her and leaves the next morning. Her entire life changes because of that one night.From finding out she's demons mate, who’s pregnant with the first half-demon child to ridiculously dressed fairies showing up at her door, getting abducted by the guy with a spear, her life becomes an adventure she wished she never asked. ***
68 Chapters
Call Me Alpha
After discovering her wolf's abnormality, Ashira went to the strongest pack of the North-The Prime Pack- in awe to find her mate. It turned out that her mate was Alpha Aiden, the youngest Alpha that was ever recorded in history. She thought he will be a better mate for her protection, and to keep her away from the danger that her abnormality implies. Unfortunately, Aiden loathes stealers because of a past tragedy though the mate bond kept pulling them together.
Will Aiden protect Ashira? Or will he shower her with wrath and anger?
Find out, read more…
67 Chapters
Vampire's Call
"As you leave, could you do me a favour and grab those flowers you left in my room?" He sneered, but I refused to comply.
Never again would I venture into that room. I was utterly shattered and wrecked. It would have been preferable if we had never met.
They were lost in each other, oblivious to my presence, and their moans echoed in my mind like a taunting reminder of what I had lost.
The urge to faint or disappear was overwhelming, and I wished more than anything that it was all just a bad dream.
At this moment, I deeply regretted my decision to surprise him with a visit.
Little did I know that the man I loved and had given my whole heart to was already entangled with another woman.
The shock of this realization cut into my soul like a knife.
100 Chapters
Related Questions
How Does Plato The Republic Define Justice?
4 Answers2025-08-29 13:43:12
Diving into 'The Republic' feels like opening a map of a city that is also a mind. Plato, through Socrates, builds an ideal city as a way to explain what justice must be: a kind of harmony where everyone and every part does what suits them best. In the famous formulation, justice is doing one's own work and not meddling in others' tasks. That sounds austere, but Plato isn't just talking about jobs—he's mapping social roles to the parts of the soul.
He argues for a tripartite soul made of reason, spirit, and appetite. When reason rules with wisdom, spirit supports it with courage, and appetite follows with moderation, the soul is ordered and healthy. Justice, for Plato, is the stable relationship between those parts: each fulfilling its function without usurping the others. The city's three classes—rulers, auxiliaries, and producers—mirror that internal arrangement.
I love how practical and weird this is at the same time. He ties ethics, psychology, and political theory into one picture: a just city is a just person magnified. It's also where questions get stubborn—what about freedom, equality, or whether roles are fixed? Reading it on a rainy afternoon, I still find Plato's model a brilliant provocation, not an absolute manual.
How Does Plato The Republic Describe The Tripartite Soul?
4 Answers2025-08-29 23:01:04
When I first dug into Plato's 'Republic' as a restless undergrad, what gripped me wasn’t just the big city metaphors but how he slices the inner life into three distinct voices. He calls them roughly reason, spirit, and appetite. Reason (the rational part) is the thinking, calculating part that loves truth and should rule; spirit (thumos) is the part that craves honor and supports reason, especially in resisting shame or fear; appetite (the many desires) chases bodily needs, pleasures, money, and all the messy cravings.
Plato links this to his ideal city so tightly that it clicked for me: rulers = reason, auxiliaries = spirit, producers = appetites. Justice, for him, is harmony — each part doing its proper work under reason’s guidance. He ties virtues to these parts too: wisdom with rulers, courage with spirit, temperance with appetite, and justice when all three fit together. Reading it now I still like picturing the soul as a small city where the rational mayor keeps things from descending into chaos — it’s a tidy moral map that actually helps when my own impulses argue for pizza at 2 a.m.
Why Does Plato The Republic Ban Poets From His City?
4 Answers2025-08-29 00:06:20
On a muggy evening when I was halfway through a re-read of 'The Republic', Plato's ban on poets hit me with the same jolt it always does. He isn't just grumpy about bad rhymes — he's aiming at the soul's education. For Plato, poets are imitators: they paint copies of copies. A sculptor copies the Form of a horse imperfectly; a poet then copies the sculptor's copy, so the poetic product is two steps removed from Truth. That matters because his whole political project is to shape citizens by guiding them toward knowledge and the Good, not toward seductive illusions.
He also worries about moral influence. Many poets in his day — think 'Iliad' and 'Odyssey' material — depict gods and heroes doing ugly, selfish things. Those stories teach by feeling, not reason, and incite desires that conflict with the rational harmony Plato wants in his guardians. So he proposes censoring or excluding poetry that corrupts virtue, while allowing stories that promote courage, temperance, and reverence. Reading it now, I find it a provocative mix of rigorous metaphysics and social engineering — part urgent moral pedagogy, part rhetorical move to spark debate.
What Political Theory Does Plato The Republic Support?
4 Answers2025-08-29 12:59:02
Plato's 'The Republic' basically champions the rule of the wise — a political vision where knowledge and virtue are the criteria for power. I find it fascinating because Plato builds this whole state as an ethical organism: justice for him isn't majority rule or individual liberty, it's a harmony in which each class performs its function well. He divides people into rulers (the philosopher-kings), auxiliaries (the warriors), and producers (farmers, artisans), and ties that division to his tripartite theory of the soul — reason, spirit, and appetite. When reason rules the soul, justice and order follow in the city.
There's a strong elitist and technocratic streak in there. The philosopher-king is central: someone trained to grasp the Form of the Good and therefore fit to govern. Plato also endorses controversial policies — communal living and no private families for the guardians, censorship of poetry, strict education — all intended to cultivate virtue and prevent corruption. To me, it's equal parts moral idealism and authoritarian design: an aristocracy of merit guided by metaphysical insight, which raises real questions about freedom and practicality in any modern reading of the work.
Are There Any Audiobooks For Plato The Republic Book 10?
3 Answers2025-07-06 17:23:04
I've been diving into audiobooks of classic philosophy lately, and yes, 'The Republic' by Plato is widely available in audio format, including Book 10. I recently listened to the version narrated by Bruce Alexander, which captures the essence of Plato's dialogue beautifully. The pacing and tone make it easier to digest the complex ideas, especially when discussing the myth of Er. Other narrators like Peter Coates also offer solid performances, though some prefer more dramatic readings. If you're into philosophy audiobooks, platforms like Audible, Librivox, and Spotify have multiple versions to choose from. Just make sure to check reviews to find a narrator whose style suits your taste.
How Does Plato The Republic Use The Allegory Of The Cave?
4 Answers2025-08-29 18:03:53
Plato uses the 'Allegory of the Cave' in 'The Republic' like a vivid stage play that makes his philosophy actually feel human. I picture those chained people, only seeing shadows, and it hits me how he’s dramatizing the gap between belief and knowledge. The cave compresses his metaphysics (the world of Forms vs. the world of appearances), his epistemology (opinion vs. true knowledge), and his politics (why philosophers should rule) into a single, memorable image.
He isn't just being poetic — the structure matters. The prisoners represent most people who mistake sensory impressions for reality, the ascent to the sunlight is the philosophical education that reveals the Form of the Good, and the return to the cave shows the brutal social cost of truth-telling. Plato also uses the story pedagogically: myths like this make abstract claims about the Good and dialectic practice accessible, and they warn rulers and citizens about complacency, the resistance to change, and the moral duty of those who see more to help those who don't. Reading it, I always think about how it still nags at our media-saturated lives.
How Does Plato The Republic Address Education And Music?
4 Answers2025-08-29 10:28:59
Growing up on a steady diet of choir practice and philosophy podcasts, I always felt Plato's sense that music is more than background noise. In 'The Republic' he treats education as the soul’s architecture: music trains the inner rhythms, gymnastics the outer frame. For the guardian-class he imagines, childhood is sheltered from bad stories and harmful tunes because imitation molds character. That’s why Plato worries about modes, rhythms, and myths—Dorian-like stability is praised, while certain passionate or irregular modes are suspected of producing disorder.
Later in the book the curriculum unfolds toward maths and dialectic, but music remains crucial: it’s the gentle, early tutor that harmonizes appetite, spirit, and reason. Plato’s censorship and careful storytelling aren’t just authoritarian quirks; he’s trying to engineer civic virtue by shaping emotional habits. Reading it now, I can see the tension between moral formation and creative freedom—and I end up thinking about how playlists, childhood media, and school music programs quietly shape who we become.
How Does Plato The Republic Critique Democracy And Tyranny?
4 Answers2025-08-29 09:38:17
I'm the kind of person who devours Plato on a rainy afternoon and then annoys my friends by quoting him at dinner. In 'Republic' he treats democracy like a fever that starts with too much freedom. He argues that when people prize equality above expertise, the city elects leaders who pander to appetites rather than cultivate the soul. The famous sequence—aristocracy to timocracy to oligarchy to democracy to tyranny—shows how political forms decay: excessive liberty births chaos.
Plato (through Socrates) gives vivid pictures: the democratic man is driven by many wants, treating every pleasure as equal and every claim as valid. That environment makes it easy for a charismatic demagogue to promise radical freedom and equality, then break laws to secure absolute power. The tyrant, ironically, is the most enslaved figure—ruled by the worst appetites rather than reason. Plato’s cure is education and philosopher-rulers who love truth over popularity.
Reading it today, I can’t help but compare his warnings to modern viral demagogues and populist rhetoric. I don’t buy everything Plato says, but his psychological account of how freedom can slide into ungoverned license—then into authoritarianism—still stings.
Popular Question
Popular Searches More
Wallace D Wattles The Science Of Getting Rich
Free To Choose: A Personal Statement
Miside But There Are 720 Security Guards
Mystery Novel Best Sellers
Chakra Naruto
Marazhai Romance Guide
Bosch Novel Order
Hondo
Books For To Read
Onyx Storm Blurb
Penguin Book Of Witches
Annihilation Maker Dxd
Surrender Book
Clark County Library Locations
Pillars Of Fire Book
If I Can't Have You Lyrics
Rich Dad Poor Dad
Read For Book
Best Romance Books Ya
Gaia Quest
Sandel
Book About Burning Books
Reborn As Flatline And I Have The Powers Of Rogue Sun In Dc
Are Ebooks Cheaper
Bakugou X Deku Sex Fanfiction
Gregor The Overlander
Othello Pdf
Kindle Digital Books
Deku And His Lusty Adventure
Milton Air
Explore and read good novels for free
Free access to a vast number of good novels on GoodNovel app. Download the books you like and read anywhere & anytime.
Read books for free on the app
SCAN CODE TO READ ON APP
