LOGINLibrary
Search
Which Quote Dostoevsky Do Philosophers Cite Most?
2025-08-28 11:44:49
135
5 Answers
Ariana
2025-08-30 11:31:25
In my readings and chats with friends, the line people bring up most is the sometimes-heard 'If God does not exist, everything is permitted' from 'The Brothers Karamazov'. It's a neat little slogan that philosophers use as a starting point to argue about metaphysical foundations of morality. Personally I think its power comes from being a provocative claim voiced by a troubled character — that nuance gets lost in quick quotes.
Other frequently cited lines are the hysterical confessional openings of 'Notes from Underground' and the oddly comforting 'Beauty will save the world' from 'The Idiot'. Each of these gets picked up by different philosophical camps: ethics, existentialism, and aesthetics respectively.
Other frequently cited lines are the hysterical confessional openings of 'Notes from Underground' and the oddly comforting 'Beauty will save the world' from 'The Idiot'. Each of these gets picked up by different philosophical camps: ethics, existentialism, and aesthetics respectively.
Finn
2025-08-31 13:31:45
Philosophers most commonly pull out the line usually paraphrased as 'If God does not exist, everything is permitted.' from 'The Brothers Karamazov'. I say "paraphrased" because the line is often simplified and then used as a riffing point in debates about moral foundations: can objective morality survive without a divine lawgiver? That short sentence acts like a lightning rod — you see it in ethics papers, lectures about moral ontology, and heated pub conversations about nihilism.
When I first bumped into it in a rainy bookstore while skimming criticisms of modern moral theory, what struck me was the context: it's Ivan Karamazov speaking, and Dostoevsky stages the idea to be examined and troubled by the story. Philosophers will use that line to open a discussion, not as an automatic endorsement. Existentialists pick up different snippets from Dostoevsky, like the neurotic confession in 'Notes from Underground' or the hopeful claim in 'The Idiot' that 'Beauty will save the world.' Reading the works themselves shows how Dostoevsky dramatizes dilemmas rather than handing out neat answers.
When I first bumped into it in a rainy bookstore while skimming criticisms of modern moral theory, what struck me was the context: it's Ivan Karamazov speaking, and Dostoevsky stages the idea to be examined and troubled by the story. Philosophers will use that line to open a discussion, not as an automatic endorsement. Existentialists pick up different snippets from Dostoevsky, like the neurotic confession in 'Notes from Underground' or the hopeful claim in 'The Idiot' that 'Beauty will save the world.' Reading the works themselves shows how Dostoevsky dramatizes dilemmas rather than handing out neat answers.
Gavin
2025-09-02 05:05:40
When I'm trying to explain which Dostoevsky quote philosophers cite most, I go for practicality: it's the one often rendered as 'If God does not exist, everything is permitted' from 'The Brothers Karamazov'. That little formula is irresistible in debates about whether moral norms need a theological anchor. But the quote is used more as a provocation than a settled claim — people argue with it, refine it, or reject its premises.
If you want other contenders: existentialists love the bitter self-examination in 'Notes from Underground', and aestheticians and moralists will sometimes drop 'Beauty will save the world' from 'The Idiot' into conversations. My tip: whenever you see the line in an article or lecture, try to trace it back to the novel to catch the dramatic context — you learn a lot about what Dostoevsky was wrestling with, and then you can decide whether the fodder is useful for your own philosophical fights.
If you want other contenders: existentialists love the bitter self-examination in 'Notes from Underground', and aestheticians and moralists will sometimes drop 'Beauty will save the world' from 'The Idiot' into conversations. My tip: whenever you see the line in an article or lecture, try to trace it back to the novel to catch the dramatic context — you learn a lot about what Dostoevsky was wrestling with, and then you can decide whether the fodder is useful for your own philosophical fights.
Flynn
2025-09-02 23:17:03
I get pulled into this topic every time someone in a seminar mentions Dostoevsky. The single most-cited line is the one that gets reduced to 'If God does not exist, everything is permitted' from 'The Brothers Karamazov' — philosophers love it because it neatly frames the debate about whether moral obligations require metaphysical grounding. But I like to remind friends that this is a fictional character's claim, not a philosophy textbook theorem.
Beyond that, scholars often quote the raw, self-aware contrarian voice of 'Notes from Underground' — that book is a favorite of existential philosophers because of its exploration of hyper-consciousness and rebellion against rational calculation. And then there's the famous 'Beauty will save the world' from 'The Idiot', which gets dragged into aesthetic and ethical discussions about whether beauty has moral power. If you want a real philosophical workout, read the passages in context and watch how Dostoevsky makes ideas live through people and pain.
Beyond that, scholars often quote the raw, self-aware contrarian voice of 'Notes from Underground' — that book is a favorite of existential philosophers because of its exploration of hyper-consciousness and rebellion against rational calculation. And then there's the famous 'Beauty will save the world' from 'The Idiot', which gets dragged into aesthetic and ethical discussions about whether beauty has moral power. If you want a real philosophical workout, read the passages in context and watch how Dostoevsky makes ideas live through people and pain.
Jade
2025-09-03 11:46:40
I tend to approach Dostoevsky like a patient detective: I collect lines people cite, then go back to the novels to see how they were actually used. The one that shows up most in philosophy syllabi and essays is the truncated form of Ivan Karamazov's claim — 'If God does not exist, everything is permitted' — because it frames a central question about moral authority. But it’s important to keep the narrative context in mind: Dostoevsky stages arguments to be tested by suffering, conscience, and familial drama, not to offer straight doctrine.
Sartre and other existentialists may not quote Dostoevsky word-for-word, but they engage with the same problems: freedom, responsibility, and the costs of radical self-awareness that you see in 'Notes from Underground'. Meanwhile, the line 'Beauty will save the world' from 'The Idiot' gets trotted out in conversations about whether aesthetic experiences can have ethical or redemptive effects. If you care about how ideas inhabit people rather than pages, reading the novels slowly is where the real philosophical juice is.
Sartre and other existentialists may not quote Dostoevsky word-for-word, but they engage with the same problems: freedom, responsibility, and the costs of radical self-awareness that you see in 'Notes from Underground'. Meanwhile, the line 'Beauty will save the world' from 'The Idiot' gets trotted out in conversations about whether aesthetic experiences can have ethical or redemptive effects. If you care about how ideas inhabit people rather than pages, reading the novels slowly is where the real philosophical juice is.
View All Answers
Scan code to download App
Related Books
Most unlikely mate
Mary is an orphan who is on the run from yet another horrific foster home. When fate steps in and she runs into her mate, will she be able to recognize him as such? Will she ever find a happy ever after or will she spend the rest of her life alone and on the run.
24 Chapters
Most Amazing You
We already know life is unfair to most of us, but we still preserve, for our uncertain future.
A story of a man who gave up on life because of a mistake he thought was the right decision and solely immersing himself through games to escape in life.
3 years passed in the blink of an eye. Jc, slowly finding out the meaning of fun in life. When he met the game called 'Glory Legends'.
Then one day, he got scouted by a powerhouse club to be a professional player hoping that this will be the chance to get back on track in life again, Or so he thought until he met again, the source of his hopelessness.
Follow the tale, as they pave their way through life, love, and glory together.
12 Chapters
Korea's Most Eligible
When Jae Hwa is given the opportunity to face her fears, after much thought she takes it and plunges into the harsh world of pretence and deciet in search for who could conquer her heart.
With the constant support of her best friend Min Jun, she toughened up to face her enemies but got more than she had bargained for. Through numerous hiccups she had gotten to know more about herself than her actual goals. But there was something more going on than just an innocent show.
Would she be able to keep her sanity after knowing the harsh truth?
Find out in this thrilling novel KOREA'S MOST ELIGIBLE. Follow me here on Goodnovel for mass updates ^_^
56 Chapters
The Most Wanted Luna
Kayla has always been different from other wolves as a child. So different that everyone seemed to despise her for it, everyone except the family who took her in as their own.
On her eighteenth birthday, an unexpected turn of events causes so much mayhem and disruption to her normal life which causes even worse judgement from members of her pack.
But it is an unpredictable betrayal that strikes the last blow and leaves her heart so broken and wounded that she leaves her pack and nothing is heard of her again.
Just when everyone forgets about her existence, she returns to her pack but she is not the same woman they once knew.
[ THE SEQUEL: UNCLAIMED BY ALPHA RAY-KHAN IS OUT NOW]
109 Chapters
My Most Precious Human
Lilith spent most of her life running away and hiding in various places. It was the price she paid for her freedom. She dared to be born as a lowly human and was immediately cast out by her family. After years of growing up as an abandoned child, those who cast her away suddenly found out that her body had a value. They thought of her as their slave who could be sold for a good price. That was when she decided to run and fight for a glimpse of a normal life. Unexpectedly, somewhere along her way, she found someone who was ready to protect her and grant her a life she had never even dared to dream of. Someone for whom she is the most precious human on Earth…
180 Chapters
The Most Wanted Luna
As he came closer, she became more tempting. Her beautiful smell and blood attracted him so much. "Are you truly my Luna?" Gabriel mumbled curiously. As Gabriel got closer to Eva, her eyelids started to open. Eva was not in her state of consciousness, and she was confused.
"Who are you?" Eva softly moaned under her breath. Gabriel's eyes were getting bigger after hearing her voice.
“I'm your Alpha!" He devoured her and kissed her harshly.
***
After becoming the Alpha of the Black Canis Pack, a secret billionaire, Gabriel has the responsibility of finding a mate. Over a century, he has been unable to imprint one. Therefore, his Beta arranged an agreement with a human businessman, Micheal to arrange a marriage between one of his daughters and Gabriel. Unfortunately, the next bride runs away and the sister must replace her.
Evangeline is then sedated by her father to fulfill the agreement between him and Gabriel. What a fortunate Gabriel found that Eva is his mate. So, he imprints her on the peak of mating season. However, innocent Eva is choosing to run away from Gabriel whilst she has his baby in her womb. Now that Eva has the most precious heir with her, she become the number one most wanted human of The Black Canis Pack. For Alpha Xander, Eva is his Luna whom he's been waiting for a hundred years. Will they see each other again?
141 Chapters
Related Questions
What Quote Dostoevsky Should I Use For A Tattoo?
5 Answers2025-08-28 05:24:10
I've got a soft spot for short, punchy lines that carry weight every time I catch a glimpse of my skin. If you want something iconic and minimal, 'Beauty will save the world.' from 'The Idiot' is a classic — three words that look elegant on a forearm or along a rib. It reads both hopeful and haunting depending on the font. Another line I’d consider is 'To live without hope is to cease to live.' It’s a little longer but still compact, and it wears well on the inner wrist or near the collarbone.
When I was deciding on my own ink, I sat in a coffee shop with a battered copy of 'The Brothers Karamazov' and scribbled placement ideas in the margins. If you like something more introspective, try 'Above all, don't lie to yourself.' It has that private truth-telling vibe that suits a stern, simple typeface. For authenticity, think about having the quote in Russian or a tasteful transliteration if Cyrillic feels too bold.
Finally, consider context: short quotes age better, translations vary, and tattoo artists can suggest script styles that preserve legibility. Pick a line that still lands in ten years — that’s what made mine feel right.
Which Quote Dostoevsky Is Most Misquoted Online?
5 Answers2025-08-28 03:29:06
You ever see a quote plastered across a coffee cup or a Tumblr post and feel that little itch that says, "That can't be the whole story"? For Dostoevsky, the most misquoted line online has to be 'Beauty will save the world.' It's short, punchy, and perfect for Instagram, but taken out of context it turns Prince Myshkin's complicated, almost mystical remark into a motivational poster. The novel it comes from, 'The Idiot', uses that line in a tangled web of irony, faith, suffering, and moral ambiguity — not as a cute slogan.
People slice it off from the scene where it's spoken, strip away the character dynamics and the philosophical tension, and then recycle it as if Dostoevsky were handing out life hacks. I love seeing bits of classic literature pop up in daily life, but with him you really miss the point if you ignore context. If you want the real flavor, read the scene slowly, and notice how beauty is both redemptive and unsettling in the narrative. It kept nagging at me long after I closed the book, in a good way.
Which Quote Dostoevsky Explains Suffering And Faith?
5 Answers2025-08-28 12:15:55
I still get goosebumps when I think about the way Dostoevsky tackles suffering and faith — he never gives a neat sermon, he stages arguments. One of the lines that keeps coming back to me is the blunt, heartbreaking protest from Ivan in 'The Brothers Karamazov': he basically says he won't accept a universe where harmony is bought by the suffering of innocent children, ending with the stark image, 'I return the ticket.' That fragment captures the moral problem of suffering: how can a loving God allow innocent pain?
On the flip side, Elder Zosima in the same book offers the spiritual counterpoint. Zosima's teaching — famously condensed into lines like 'Love all God's creation, the whole and every grain of sand in it' — points toward suffering being met by active love and responsibility. So for me Dostoevsky isn't offering a tidy solution; he's staging a dialogue between rebellion and faith. If you want a single sentence that often floats around in discussions of his views on pain, there's also the line people quote: 'Pain and suffering are always inevitable for a large intelligence and a deep heart.' Read the Ivan–Alyosha exchanges and Zosima's chapters back-to-back and you'll feel how Dostoevsky lets suffering test, break, and sometimes deepen faith — no easy endings, just raw, human wrestling.
What Quote Dostoevsky Best Summarizes The Brothers Karamazov?
5 Answers2025-08-28 23:12:46
There’s a line that keeps echoing in my head whenever I think about 'The Brothers Karamazov': 'If God does not exist, everything is permitted.' It’s blunt, uncomfortable, and somehow concise enough to carry the novel’s huge moral weight. When I first read it on a rainy afternoon, I remember pausing, looking up from the page, and feeling the room tilt a little — that sentence isn’t just theology, it’s a moral challenge aimed squarely at how people justify their choices.
That quote comes from Ivan’s rebellion, and it sums up a central tension in the book: what happens to ethics when metaphysical anchors wobble. But I also find the book resists a single line; Zosima’s compassion and Alyosha’s quiet faith complicate Ivan’s bleak logic. Still, if I had to pick one quote that captures the philosophical spine of 'The Brothers Karamazov', that stark claim about God and permission would be it, because it forces the reader to wrestle with freedom, responsibility, and the cost of belief.
What Short Quote Dostoevsky Suits Instagram Captions?
5 Answers2025-08-28 06:04:54
I get a little thrilled whenever I find a Dostoevsky line that fits a photo — his sentences can be tiny mood bombs. For something short and punchy, I love using 'Beauty will save the world.' It’s from 'The Idiot' and it pairs perfectly with a soft sunrise, a candid street portrait, or an artsy mirror selfie.
If I want something more reflective under a moody shot I’ll go with 'Above all, don't lie to yourself.' That one carries a blunt, honest energy that makes people pause when they're scrolling. For travel shots or when I'm feeling stubbornly hopeful, 'To live without hope is to cease to live.' always sits well.
I usually mix the line with a subtle emoji (a small sun, a book, or a lone star) and maybe one or two hashtags like #quietthoughts or #bookquotes. Try swapping fonts or using a light overlay so the caption stands out without shouting — Dostoevsky captions feel best when they look like a whispered thought rather than a billboard.
What Quote Dostoevsky Reveals His Take On Human Nature?
5 Answers2025-08-28 10:03:26
There’s a sentence from him that keeps echoing in my head: 'If God does not exist, everything is permitted.' I first ran into it in 'The Brothers Karamazov' on a slow Sunday afternoon, curled up on the sofa with rain tapping the window, and it stopped me cold. To me that quote isn’t just theology — it’s Dostoevsky’s blunt way of saying moral order, or at least the belief in absolute moral anchors, shapes how people behave. Without that anchor, our impulses and rationalizations can run wild.
He also says, more quietly, that 'Man is a mystery. It needs to be unraveled, and if you spend your whole life unraveling it, don't say that you've wasted time.' That reflects his faith in the complexity of human nature: contradictory, capable of cruelty and tenderness, often driven by suffering. Reading him feels like being handed a mirror that’s smeared and cracked but somehow shows you things you didn’t want to see. I leave his pages thinking humans are fragile mosaics of belief, fear, and stubborn hope.
Which Quote Dostoevsky Best Captures Raskolnikov'S Guilt?
5 Answers2025-08-28 01:25:52
Sometimes a single sentence from a book sticks to me like a splinter — it pricks every time I think about the character. For Raskolnikov, the line that always cuts deepest is Dostoevsky's observation: 'Pain and suffering are always inevitable for a large intelligence and a deep heart.'
That quote isn't a courtroom confession, it's the philosophical needle that explains why Raskolnikov can't sleep, can't eat, can't feel at ease in the world he tried to master with theories. When I read it, I see him pacing through St. Petersburg, feverish and convinced he'd transcended ordinary morality, only to be devoured by his conscience. It ties his crime to the human cost of overreaching pride and to the heavy, lonely interior life Dostoevsky keeps returning to in 'Crime and Punishment'. It also points toward Sonya's role — her own suffering becomes the quiet counterweight that eventually nudges him toward confession and the possibility of redemption.
On a rainy afternoon, after a long walk with the book in my bag, that sentence made the whole novel click for me: guilt isn't just legal punishment for Raskolnikov, it's the unbearable, constant companion of a heart and mind that cannot rest.
What Quote Dostoevsky Pairs Well With A Book Club Discussion?
5 Answers2025-08-28 17:47:24
If our club is picking a Dostoevsky line to hang over the meeting, I’d pick: "The mystery of human existence lies not in just staying alive, but in finding something to live for." I first scribbled this in the margin of my 'The Brothers Karamazov' paperback during a soggy Sunday commute, and it kept nudging me back to the book every time a character wrestled with purpose.
It’s brilliant for discussion because it’s broad and personal at once. We can start by asking: what do the characters live for, and how does that change across the novel? Does the quote read differently if you’re thinking of faith, family, ideology, or simple survival? I’d suggest splitting into small groups—one argues that Dostoevsky champions spiritual purpose, another that he’s exposing the dangers of ideological certainty. Toss in modern parallels: social media activism, career ambition, and how people find meaning today. I always like to end those sessions by asking everyone to name one small, honest thing that gives them a week’s meaning—turns out those mundane details spark the best, honest conversations.
Popular Question
Popular Searches More
The Book The Lie
The Alpha King Call Boy
Steamy Billionaire Romance Books
Win Quick Lotto Casino Spells Caste
Where To Sell An Ebook
A Dowry Of Blood
Romance Light
Lire Bible En Ligne
Seneca Quotes
Pokémon: Ash's Sinnoh Reset
A Walk Among The Tombstones
Best Standalone Romance Books
Read Novel Online Free
Prospero's Book
Tvd Finn's Rage
Read Free Online Romance
Reading Books Aloud Online
Deep And Dark And Dangerous
Accidentally Becoming The Healer Of The Deranged Archduke
Best E-reader
Pucking Around
Catholic Reads
A Vindication Of The Rights Of Woman
Bibliography Annotation
Book Read Before You Die
Utah Book And Magazine
Pokemon Alternate Universe Adventures
Vagabonding Book
Network Books
John Gray Books
Explore and read good novels for free
Free access to a vast number of good novels on GoodNovel app. Download the books you like and read anywhere & anytime.
Read books for free on the app
SCAN CODE TO READ ON APP
