6 Answers2025-08-31
I must acknowledge that the P&V marketing machine is very good at what it does. So, you’ll find them on the cover of most classic sections in bookstores, and they are often good. But that doesn’t necessarily mean that they are the best translation of a given work, and therefore, other very good translations are dismissed solely on the basis of-store front hype.
And it creates a fascinating (and totally unfair) situation in which to laud Garnett or another translator one instantly appears to be a snarky, overhyping hipster contrarian challenging the givens of mass marketing. P&V is, for many, often the only good option, for specific books, however, another translator might be offering a far more suitable translation than P&V’s. Ultimately, one serves Dostoevsky, not the translator or publishing brand.
12 Answers2026-04-02
Waiting is perhaps the hardest part of things here. One waits for the publishers (Yen Press, Viz Media, Kodansha, and the smaller ones like One Peace Books) to announce the licenses they have picked up. Every so often a new female Japanese author is announced. But nine times out of ten it isn’t. It’s like standing at a train station looking at the arrival board waiting for your train to arrive. Often it seems that there is no schedule for the particular train you want to catch. After a while one stops checking as much. The hope is there but it is not the front of one’s mind. This is how the fan of non-mainstream international fiction feels.
4 Answers2025-08-01
I personally like to buy physical copies of books that I own, but I know that many people prefer PDF versions of certain books. For example, ‘Esperanza Rising’ by Pam Muñoz Ryan is available from Amazon’s Kindle Store and from Barnes & Noble’s Nook Store. It can also be downloaded from many libraries that have a digital catalog. If you can’t afford to buy the book, a free trial to services such as Scribd could be the answer – just watch out for any dodgy sites that offer the book for download – they’re not worth the risk.
10 Answers2025-07-11
Recently it has become a lot harder for me to download manga, due to an influx of DMCA notices. To combat this, I use RSS feeds from the blogs of many of the translation groups. I add their blogs to an RSS reader (I use Feedly) and they notify me whenever there is an update to a series that I am following. Typically the update will be a direct download link to the cleanest version of the chapter or volume, posted on the group’s blog, allowing me to download it before it is taken down by a DMCA notice. It requires a bit of an initial setup but in the end it is very effective.
12 Answers2026-07-27
For the hard core fan, Rodney Merrill’s translation of the Odyssey is an English dactylic hexameter. What he’s tried to do is rephrase Homer in English to exactly the same rhythmic pattern as the original Greek. It’s an academic/poetic exercise that few people have attempted before, and, indeed, few people would wish to read for pleasure. It’s an amazingly challenging read at first but you soon get used to it.
In total contrast to Rieu’s prose translation, the Rodney Merrill translation of ‘The Odyssey’ is written in English dactylic hexameter, attempting to re-create the unique rhythm and sound of the original Greek poems. This challenging, and at times, even strange read is essentially a specialist item – best left to translation geeks and classics students. However, it so effectively highlights the scope of translation of Homer’s works.
8 Answers2025-07-13
It’s interesting that no one has brought up the Constance Garnett translation of “Crime and Punishment” yet. While her translation is historical and oft-reprinted, reading it after P&V is like watching a movie with the contrast cranked down low. The rough edges of Garnett’s translation have all been smoothed over to make Dostoevsky’s work read like that of a slightly more agitated Jane Austen. But Dostoevsky isn’t Austen. He’s a tough, uncomfortable, and repetitive writer who dives deep into the psychological inner lives of his characters to expose their inner conflicts and psychological fears. The P&V translation has somehow managed to resurrect all of the edgey and uncomfortable aspects of Dostoevsky’s novel for English-speaking readers. While it’s true that some of the translations are a bit awkward, it’s sort of necessary in order to accurately portray the main character, Raskolnikov, as well as the dirty, sick, and oppressive city in which he lives. If you want to read a smooth and pleasant classic, then read something else. But “Crime and Punishment” is not for the faint of heart, and you’ll need a translation that isn’t afraid of the novel’s mess.
7 Answers2025-08-11
In the old days you could borrow a book from a friend. Nowadays most ebooks are released with Digital Rights Management (DRM) to protect the copyright. Only a few platforms like Kindle allow lending, but generally this is restricted to certain titles and is often turned off by the publishers for new releases. So, the only aspect of books that has actually increased in the sharing economy is the cost to the buyer, as they often end up paying for the same book that their friends have bought. It is this loss that may explain why people search online for free copies of books. This is not because they want to steal books but because they want to share them, as they used to. Sharing books online is Sharing books in the digital age and, increasingly, this means using a library app rather than downloading a pirated copy from the net. We need to relearn how to share using the new tools not the old broken ones.
9 Answers2026-07-29
Most 'free' sites with popular novels are content farms that will serve you ads and potentially other evils. Their "download" buttons are often fake and will install junk on your computer. The reading experience on these sites is usually abysmal: too small a font size, random and irregular line wrapping, and sometimes even missing pages. It's a false economy of your time and attention. If cost is really your only barrier to reading something, then for God's sake go to a library and get it for free, or set up a price drop alert for the Kindle edition on ereaderiq.com and wait for it to drop to the price of your choice.
5 Answers2026-03-09
I wasted hours looking for a free alternative to a resource that in the end I bought without regrets. The book “Translation State’s” AI politics are crazy to read and the physical book even has these very useful notes in the appendix. I sometimes just have to splurge…
4 Answers2026-02-04
For English-speaking readers, Willa and Edwin Muir’s translation of Kafka still is the most commonly available and conveys the specific atmosphere of his writings very well. The more recent translation by Breon Mitchell even strives for greater textual accuracy. Readers who are interested in legal and judicial contexts may also like to look at the web novel ‘After I Was Sentished to Death by the Three Men I Loved, Their True Punishment Began’. The situation of wrongful execution at the hands of the heroine’s three former lovers is shocking, but the focus of the story lies rather on the subsequent collapse of the three men and on their psychological aftermath than on the proceedings in court.