Who Wrote The Book What Is History

2025-06-10 21:47:19 186

3 answers

Ava
Ava
2025-06-11 19:37:58
I stumbled upon 'What Is History?' during my deep dive into historiography, and it completely reshaped how I view the past. The book was written by Edward Hallett Carr, a British historian who challenged traditional narratives with his provocative ideas. Carr argues that history isn’t just a collection of facts but a dynamic dialogue between the historian and the past. His perspective resonated with me because it highlights how biases and contemporary contexts shape our understanding of history. I especially love how he critiques the illusion of objectivity, urging readers to question who gets to write history and why. This book is a must-read for anyone curious about the philosophy behind historical study.
Orion
Orion
2025-06-12 16:11:11
As someone who nerds out over how history is written, E.H. Carr's 'What Is History?' blew my mind. Carr, a towering figure in 20th-century historiography, dismantles the myth that history is purely objective. Instead, he presents it as an interpretation shaped by the historian’s society and personal biases. His famous analogy comparing historians to fish swimming in the ocean of their time stuck with me—we can’t escape our cultural context.

What’s fascinating is how Carr engages with other thinkers like Leopold von Ranke, pushing back against the idea of history as mere 'facts.' He emphasizes the role of selection and interpretation, which made me rethink everything from school textbooks to documentaries. The book isn’t just theory; it’s a call to critically engage with the past. For anyone tired of dry historical accounts, Carr’s lively prose and bold arguments feel like a breath of fresh air.

I’d pair this with 'The Historian’s Craft' by Marc Bloch for another perspective on how history works. Both books peel back the curtain on what historians actually do, making them perfect for aspiring history buffs.
Owen
Owen
2025-06-11 00:50:07
I first read 'What Is History?' in college, and E.H. Carr’s ideas still haunt my thoughts. The book’s central question—whether history is about facts or interpretations—feels especially relevant today. Carr, a diplomat-turned-historian, writes with a clarity that cuts through academic jargon. His insistence that history is a process, not a static record, helped me understand why the same event can be told in wildly different ways.

One section that stuck with me is his critique of 'great men' history. Carr argues that focusing solely on leaders ignores the broader social forces at play. This idea transformed how I consume biographies or political documentaries. The book also delves into causality, asking whether events like revolutions are inevitable or contingent. It’s heavy stuff, but Carr’s wit keeps it engaging.

If you enjoy meta-discussions about knowledge itself, this book pairs well with Thomas Kuhn’s 'The Structure of Scientific Revolutions.' Both challenge how we define 'truth' in their respective fields.

Related Books

Azzario's History
Azzario's History
Dia terlahir dengan nama Almarine, keturunan raja dan ratu dari suku Edelyn. Ia lahir satu purnama setelah kematian ayahnya--saat perang masih belangsung, sang ibu menyerahkan gadis itu pada orang kepercayaan agar melarikannya ke Bumi Manusia agar musuh mereka tak bisa mengejarnya. Gordhova, wanita kerjam berhati iblis dengan kekuatan sihir maha dahsyat, terobsesi menjadi wanita paling cantik di dunia. Ia sangat membenci Ratu Ava, karena sang ratu lebih cantik dari dirinya. Pada suatu kesempatan, pecahlah perang kerajaan melawan pengkhianat yang dipimpin sang penyihir. Ratu Ava yang masih lemah setelah melahirkan disandera, aura kecantikannya dihisap sehingga wanita itu menjadi tua dan layu. Sementara itu, sang putri dibawa pergi ke Bumi sampai ia siap merebut kembali apa yang menjadi haknya.
10
10 Chapters
GRESMORY : REVEAL THE FALSE HISTORY
GRESMORY : REVEAL THE FALSE HISTORY
Seorang pemuda berusia 20 tahun yang memiliki kemampuan unik. Dia bernama Kenshin saat dia bermimpi, kemungkinan besar mimpinya akan menjadi sebuah kenyataan. Namun suatu ketika dia memimpikan sesuatu yang tak lazim dan tidak masuk akal dan mimpi itu pula yang akan membantunya menguak sebuah sejarah manusia yang terluput
10
74 Chapters
Test Book
Test Book
Test Test Test Test Test Test Test Test Test Test Test Test Test Test Test Test Test Test Test Test
Belum ada penilaian
1 Chapters
Selena (Shirea book 2)
Selena (Shirea book 2)
Awalnya Selena mengira dirinya adalah putri sah Raja dan Ratu kerajaan Axylon, sebelum akhirnya seorang tahanan wanita di penjara bawah tanah menceritakan bahwa ia bukan anak mereka. Jati dirinya perlahan terkuak dan mengakibatkan hubungan Selena dengan Raja dan Ratu merenggang. Ditambah, cincin Blue Saphire yang ia kenakan mulai menunjukkan sebuah misteri baginya. Selain itu, pergolakan antara Axylon dan Vainea membuatnya terjebak dalam pernikahan politik dengan Pangeran Azura, Putra Mahkota Vainea demi terciptanya perjanjian damai setelah berperang selama hampir dua dekade. Namun, keputusan Raja baru Vainea yang menginginkan perdamaian dengan Axylon justru mengakibatkan adanya pemberontakan oleh suatu kelompok dari kerajaan Vainea itu sendiri yang tak menginginkan perjanjian damai tersebut. Keadaan diperparah dengan tewasnya raja Zealda dalam politik adu domba, membuat perdamaian yang baru tercipta kembali retak. Selena berusaha menghadapi polemik antar kerajaan di tengah masalah pribadinya yang belum usai. Sayangnya, situasinya semakin memburuk ketika Raja Radith juga tewas dalam insiden pemberontakan. Di sisi lain, Selena sudah jatuh hati pada suaminya, tapi perang antar dua kerajaan tak dapat dihindari lagi. Kini ia pun terjebak di antara cinta dan politik yang tengah berkecamuk.
10
59 Chapters
Rein (Shirea book 3)
Rein (Shirea book 3)
Kegelapan malam telah menyisakan sebuah penyesalan untuk memejamkan matanya. Rein, mencoba menyelidiki kasus kematian orang tuanya yang masih penuh misteri, meninggalkan trauma dan ketakutan dalam benaknya. Sebagai pewaris tunggal, ia menggantikan posisi ayahnya sebagai raja. Dengan kemampuan yang diwarisi oleh kedua orang tuanya, membuat sosoknya ditakuti. Perjalanan hidup yang diwarnai konflik dan politik licik serta cinta penuh dendam, membangkitkan sosok dirinya yang kejam. Hingga suatu saat ia mengangkat pedang untuk berperang, lagi dan lagi.
10
54 Chapters
Sweet Forgiveness  Book 1 (Bahasa Indonesia)
Sweet Forgiveness Book 1 (Bahasa Indonesia)
Ketika semua rahasia terungkap, mampukah Safiyya mempertahankan pernikahannya bersama Rizky saat Tuhan mula menguji hati mereka? Hanya kekuatan cinta, ketulusan jiwa dan keutuhan rasa percaya mampu mempertahankan ikatan cinta yang tersambung dengan akad nikah. P/s: Jangan lupa follow cerita ini dan terima kasih atas dukungan kalian ^_^ A Lots of love from me, Mr Mocha Latte
10
93 Chapters

Related Questions

Greek Who Wrote History Book

3 answers2025-06-10 06:03:33
I've always been fascinated by ancient Greek historians, especially Herodotus. He's often called the 'Father of History' because he wrote 'The Histories,' which chronicled the Greco-Persian Wars and other events. His approach was unique—he mixed facts with myths and personal observations, making his work lively and engaging. I love how he included cultural details about the peoples he wrote about, like the Egyptians and Scythians. Thucydides is another favorite; his 'History of the Peloponnesian War' is more analytical, focusing on politics and military strategy. His writing feels modern because he prioritized accuracy and cause-and-effect over storytelling. These two set the foundation for how history is written today.

Who Wrote The First History Book

3 answers2025-06-10 13:50:23
I’ve always been fascinated by ancient historians, and the title of 'first history book' is often debated. The earliest known historical work is 'The Histories' by Herodotus, a Greek writer from the 5th century BCE. He’s called the 'Father of History' for a reason—his accounts of the Greco-Persian Wars and various cultures were groundbreaking. Unlike myths or chronicles, he tried to verify facts, though his style was narrative and colorful. Thucydides later refined the approach with 'History of the Peloponnesian War,' focusing on objectivity. But Herodotus set the foundation, blending travelogues, anthropology, and politics into something entirely new for his time.

Who Wrote The Book Living History

5 answers2025-06-10 20:32:31
As someone who’s always fascinated by political memoirs, I’ve spent a lot of time diving into 'Living History'. It’s a gripping read penned by Hillary Rodham Clinton, the former First Lady of the United States and Secretary of State. She offers a deeply personal account of her life, from her early years to her time in the White House and beyond. The book is a mix of political insight and personal reflection, making it a standout in the genre. What I love about 'Living History' is how Clinton balances her public persona with private struggles. She doesn’t shy away from discussing the challenges she faced, like the Monica Lewinsky scandal or her role in healthcare reform. Her writing style is engaging, almost conversational, which makes the heavy political content feel accessible. If you’re into memoirs that blend history with personal growth, this one’s a must-read.

Who Wrote The Book History Of India

3 answers2025-06-10 16:22:21
I've always been fascinated by Indian history, and 'History of India' is one of those books that feels like a treasure trove of knowledge. The author, Romila Thapar, is a legendary historian whose work has shaped how many of us understand India's past. Her writing is detailed yet accessible, making complex historical events easy to follow. I remember picking up her book during a trip to Delhi and being completely absorbed by her narrative style. Thapar doesn't just list facts; she weaves stories that bring ancient India to life. Her perspective on the Mauryas, Guptas, and Mughals is particularly eye-opening. If you're into history, her books are a must-read.

Who Wrote The Book The History Of The Legend?

4 answers2025-06-10 09:45:07
I've been diving deep into fantasy and historical literature for years, and 'The History of the Legend' is one of those books that feels like a hidden gem. From what I’ve gathered, it was written by David Gemmell, a master of heroic fantasy. His works often blend myth, history, and gritty realism, and this book is no exception. It’s part of his Drenai series, which is packed with unforgettable characters like Druss the Legend. Gemmell’s writing has this raw, visceral energy that pulls you into the world he creates. If you’re into epic battles, moral dilemmas, and legends that feel larger than life, this is a must-read. The way he crafts his heroes—flawed yet noble—makes the story resonate long after you’ve turned the last page. For fans of authors like Joe Abercrombie or Brandon Sanderson, Gemmell’s work is a cornerstone of the genre.

Who Wrote A Gospel And A Book Of History

3 answers2025-06-10 08:13:32
I've always been fascinated by biblical literature, and one of the most compelling figures who contributed to both a gospel and a historical account is Luke. He wrote the 'Gospel of Luke,' which delves into the life and teachings of Jesus with a focus on compassion and inclusivity. What’s even more impressive is his sequel, the 'Acts of the Apostles,' a gripping narrative that chronicles the early church’s growth and the spread of Christianity. Luke’s meticulous attention to detail and his ability to weave personal stories into grand historical events make his works stand out. His background as a physician adds a unique layer of empathy to his storytelling, making his gospel and historical book deeply human and relatable.

Who Wrote The History Of The Legend Book?

4 answers2025-06-10 03:30:25
As a longtime fantasy enthusiast, I’ve delved deep into the lore of 'The History of the Legend,' and it’s fascinating how this book has become a cornerstone for many mythos lovers. The author is none other than J.R.R. Tolkien, whose meticulous world-building in works like 'The Silmarillion' and 'The Lord of the Rings' has set the gold standard for legendary histories. Tolkien didn’t just write stories; he crafted entire civilizations, languages, and cosmologies that feel alive. His attention to detail makes 'The History of the Legend' feel less like fiction and more like a rediscovered ancient text. What sets Tolkien apart is his ability to weave grand narratives with intimate character arcs. The book isn’t just a dry recounting of events; it’s filled with tragic heroes, divine interventions, and epic battles that resonate emotionally. If you’re a fan of rich, immersive worlds, this is a must-read. It’s no wonder his work has inspired countless authors, games, and even entire genres of fantasy.

Who Wrote The First American History Book

4 answers2025-06-10 23:04:56
As someone deeply fascinated by historical literature, I’ve always been curious about the origins of American historical writing. The first American history book is widely considered to be 'The History of the Colony and Province of Massachusetts-Bay' by Thomas Hutchinson, published in the mid-18th century. Hutchinson, a colonial governor, meticulously documented early New England life, blending political insight with personal observations. While not a perfect work by modern standards, it laid the foundation for American historiography. Another early contender is 'The History of New England' by John Winthrop, though it’s more of a journal than a formal history. These works capture the raw, unfiltered perspectives of early settlers, offering a glimpse into their struggles and triumphs. For anyone interested in the roots of American historical writing, Hutchinson’s work remains a pivotal starting point.
Jelajahi dan baca novel bagus secara gratis
Akses gratis ke berbagai novel bagus di aplikasi GoodNovel. Unduh buku yang kamu suka dan baca di mana saja & kapan saja.
Baca buku gratis di Aplikasi
Pindai kode untuk membaca di Aplikasi
DMCA.com Protection Status