Okay, so I see this pairing pop up every now and then, and honestly, I think a lot of writers miss the mark by just making it about Genya being the 'big strong guy' and Aizetsu being the 'manipulative creep'. It's way more layered than that.
Like, take Genya's whole thing—he can only use his demon powers by eating demons, right? That's inherently chaotic and reactive. Aizetsu's ability, from what we see, is this calm, precise, almost mathematical control over his own body and weapons. One power is about consuming and absorbing; the other is about extending and projecting. That's a built-in dynamic right there. A writer could really dig into the tension between Genya's desperate, consuming hunger for power to protect and Aizetsu's detached, clinical mastery of his own form. It's a clash of philosophies, not just physical strength.
Where it gets really juicy for me is in the emotional aftermath of the Swordsmith Village arc. If you're doing an AU where they both survive or something, Genya's left with this massive trauma and grief, and possibly his own demonic nature still in flux. Aizetsu is... well, he's Upper Rank Four. There's a cold, ancient intelligence there. The power dynamic isn't who can punch harder; it's about who holds the psychological and existential cards. Can Genya's raw, human grief even reach something like Aizetsu? Does Aizetsu see Genya's struggle as a fascinating anomaly or just more fuel? That complexity is where the good stories live, far beyond simple dom/sub stuff.