Fake dating the Captain's step brother
I continued, "you and she got into some kind of argument. Over the swings, I think. Children's things. She pushed you, you fell, scraped your knee. Cole ran over to help you instead of her, and she just stood there. Watched. I remember feeling sorry for her, actually, more than anything else. She looked so alone."
"That's it?" Kayla asked, something careful in her voice, like she was waiting for the rest of it.
"That's it," I said. "I never saw her again after that summer. I didn't think about her again, honestly, not until you showed me that photograph yesterday."
"Then why did you look so afraid?"
I sighed, some of the tension I'd been carrying finally loosening slightly now that the truth