Honestly, my first reaction was skepticism. How could some algorithm possibly come up with anything that felt genuine? But then I got completely stuck trying to write something for a 'Top Gun' exchange last year, nothing was clicking, so I gave one a shot out of desperation. It spit out 'Character A is a pilot who sees ghosts, Character B is their grounded mechanic who doesn't believe in anything they can't fix.' Something about that friction between the fantastical and the hyper-practical just... unlocked a whole dynamic I wouldn't have considered. It wasn't the prompt itself, but the weird little hook it provided that made my brain start connecting dots in a new way.
I think the real value is in the unexpected juxtaposition. You'd never sit down and consciously think, 'What if I crossed Regency-era manners with alien biology?' but a generator might, and suddenly you're sketching out a 'Bridgerton' AU where the gossip is about pheromone compatibility. It forces you out of your own mental ruts. The stories that come from it are still entirely yours—the generator just gives that initial, bizarre shove off the familiar path.