I always find Ware's books a bit of a mixed bag, and this one is a perfect example. On paper, the plot sounds fantastic—four women, Isa, Fatima, Thea, and Kate, bound by a terrible secret from their boarding school days where they played a game of making people believe their lies. Years later, a body is found, and their past comes crashing back. It's a classic setup.
But honestly, the execution felt slow to me. The present-day tension with the discovery of the bones and the text message 'I need you' is great, but the flashbacks to their schoolgirl 'Lying Game' sometimes drag. The real plot driver is the suspicion that falls on Ambrose, Kate's father, and later, the fear that one of their own might be involved. The ending felt a bit rushed after all that simmering dread, wrapping things up a little too neatly for my taste compared to the messy secrets it promised.
Still, if you love atmospheric, character-driven suspense more than a breakneck thriller, you'll probably enjoy the ride. The setting on the tidal marshes is wonderfully creepy.