LOGINAn hour later, Tony rolled his bike around to the back of the Havley house and cut the engine. Then he just sat there.
Kyle spotted him through the screen door and wandered out with his coffee. "Might as well come in and get it over with, man." He took a sip. "I think she took most of it out on me already."
Tony let out a breath that wasn't quite a laugh. He swung off the bike and ran a hand through his hair. "Dee gonna kill me when I walk in there?"
"Dad hasn't dug up the back forty yet."
Tony stopped at the foot of the porch steps. "You gonna kill me?"
Kyle smirked. "I know how to drive the tractor. And dig a hole."
He pulled the screen door open with the grin of a man throwing someone else to the wolves. "Hey, Mom! Look who I found outside."
Tony stepped in behind him, wiping his palms on his jeans.
Dee turned from the stove. For a second the spatula hung at her side like a verdict. Then she set it down on the counter with a soft clink.
"Tony." Her smile was thin, built on the spot. "Would you like some pancakes? We have plenty."
Don and Kyle looked from Tony to Dee and back. Nobody moved. Kyle's grin faltered.
"Uh, Mom? How come he gets pancakes and I got a spatula thrown at my head?"
"The spatula was for your sister," Dee informed him. "And Tony's not in the clear. He could've called me." She turned back to the stove, almost casual. "Seems he managed to get hold of one of us, didn't he?"
"I'm sorry, Mrs. Havley," Tony said. "I should've called. Or made her call."
"As long as we're clear on that." She slid a stack of pancakes onto a plate and set it on the table. "You kept my baby safe, I suppose." Then she really looked at him, head tilted. "And since when do you call me anything but Dee?"
"Sorry. Dee." He didn't leave the doorway.
"Come on, sit down." She pulled out a chair. It scraped loud across the wood floor. He didn't move, and he didn't say thanks, Dee the way he had since he was twelve.
She left the chair where it was.
Tony shot a look at Kyle, then at Don. Am I safe?
Both of them shrugged.
Then Gemma walked in from the hall, hair still damp, wearing his navy sweatshirt. The same one she'd come home in. Tony watched Dee's eyes go from the sweatshirt to him and back, and saw the moment it landed. She'd noticed it this morning. She'd just been too relieved to let herself think about it.
Dee sat down in the chair she'd pulled out for him. "All of you," she said slowly. "Explaining. Now."
Don set his coffee mug on the table. "Now, Dee—"
"Sit." She didn't raise her voice. She didn't need to.
Don sat.
Kyle let out a cough that was mostly a laugh and started edging toward the back door.
"Don't you go anywhere," Dee said without looking at him. "You're next."
Tony crossed the kitchen like a man walking to his sentencing. He stopped beside Gemma, not touching her, every inch of him announcing we are not together in a way that only made it more obvious that they were.
"Mom," Gemma said, "do we have to do this now?"
"Yes. We have to do this now." Dee folded her arms. "You left here last night and I had no idea where you were."
"I was with Tony."
"I know that now." Dee's voice had gone quiet. "What I didn't know, until he wouldn't sit at my table, until the two of you stood there like—" She stopped and looked at them both. "Would you care to tell me what this is? Do you two realize it's nine hours from here to where you'll be living for the next four years?"
Gemma looked at Tony. He looked back, and he knew she could see it on him: fear, the same as hers.
"No, Mom," she said. "We haven't talked logistics." She turned back to her mother. "I don't know what this is yet. But it's something. And if it's real—" She swallowed. "Then I guess we find out if nine hours matters."
Dee studied her daughter for a long moment. Then she got up, went to the stove and flipped the last pancake onto a plate.
"Sit down," she said. "Both of you. Before your breakfast gets cold."
Tony didn't move until Gemma touched his arm. They sat. Dee set the plate between them and took her own chair again, folding her hands on the table.
"Three hours," she said. "That's what you've got. Three hours until you get in that car and drive nine hours to a place you've never lived."
"Mom—"
"I'm not finished." Dee turned to Tony. "I have known you since you were in diapers, Tony Bennet. I watched you skin your knee on our driveway and cry because you didn't want your mother to see. I've made you four thousand pancakes, and you've called me Dee since you were twelve years old."
Tony's jaw tightened.
"So I'm trying to understand how my daughter ended up walking a county road at one in the morning, and the only person who actually tried to do right by her was you." She swung toward Kyle. "You knew where she was. Tony found her, texted you and trusted you to handle it. And you sat on it all night. You let me think she was dead in a ditch while you played big brother."
Kyle went pale. "Mom, I—"
"You what? You were protecting her? Protecting him?" Dee shook her head. "That's not your job. Your job was to tell me, so I could sleep."
She turned back to Tony, and the anger in her face had shifted into something more complicated. "You found her. You told someone. That's more than anybody else at this table managed."
Under the table, Gemma reached for Tony's hand. Dee noticed. Dee always noticed.
"You're twenty-four," she said to Tony. "She's nineteen. In three hours she leaves, and the two of you haven't even talked about what this is." She let that sit. "So here's what happens. You eat your pancakes. Then you tell me your plan. Not your feelings. Your plan. Because you don't have time for feelings. You have three hours to figure out whether you're starting something you can finish, or saying goodbye in my kitchen."
Don cleared his throat. "Dee—"
"Three hours," she repeated, and pushed the syrup toward Tony. "Eat."
Nobody ate. There was no arguing with Dee when she got like this, but there was no swallowing, either.
Gemma held Tony's hand a second longer under the table, then let go and picked up her fork and pushed a bite of pancake around her plate. Tony didn't touch his fork at all.
"Okay, then," Dee said into the quiet. "Maybe we talk before pancakes."
"Dee," Don said. "Let these two figure some of this out on their own."
"These are our kids, Don."
"Yes. And you know they were raised right."
The next Thursday, at their table under the sagging window, Chase turned his phone around to show her his calendar. Every Thursday from seven to ten was blocked off in blue for the rest of the semester. One letter: G."I cleared these," he said. "Thursdays are ours. I need you to protect them too, okay? This only works if we both take it seriously.""Of course," she said. "Yeah. Of course."Freddy had mentioned a movie night on the second floor next Thursday. Gemma had already said maybe. She'd text her later.Chase smiled and slid her newest draft across the table. Green ink covered the first page. In the margin beside her ending, he'd written: Almost. You're so close to being great.She bent over the pages, already reaching for her pen, already wanting to close the gap.It didn't feel like losing anything. It felt like being chosen.***October came in cold, and the nights got long.Thursdays stopped ending at ten. They closed down the library reading room, and when the librarian fl
The night of that very first dinner at Juniper, she'd called Tony from the window seat, still a little warm from the wine. The bar noise came through the phone, and the jukebox, and Kyle yelling at somebody in the background about a tab."Guess what I had for dinner," she said."Let me guess. Sonic.""Duck." She pulled one leg under herself. "With cherry sauce. And this cheese thing called burrata, it's like mozzarella but it's got cream inside, you'd hate it. And wine. One glass. At a place with tablecloths."There was a pause on the line. Then Tony laughed, warm and low. "Duck? Like from the pond? You used to cry when your daddy went out after the mallards.""It's different. It's French.""Uh-huh. Who took you to the French duck place?""Just a friend from the program." She didn't know why she said it that way. A friend. She didn't say Chase. She didn't say he. "A bunch of us went.""Well." She could hear him smiling. "Next time you're home, I'll take you out to the pond and get you
The fourth favor was dinner."You've been here a month," Chase said at the end of their Thursday session, packing up his tablet. "Where have you eaten?"Gemma counted on her fingers. "The dining hall. The pizza place. The Sonic out on the highway. That burger place across from the bookstore." She thought. "Oh, and the Taco Bell. Twice."Chase stared at her like she'd confessed to a crime. "That's it?""What's wrong with Sonic? Sonic has tots.""Nothing's wrong with Sonic." He was trying not to laugh. "Sonic is fine. Sonic is a national treasure. But Gemma." He leaned across the table. "There's a whole world out there that isn't fried and served in a paper bag. Saturday. I'm taking you to dinner. A real one."He took her to a place called Juniper, on a side street downtown, in an old brick building that had once been a bank. The windows were tall and dark, and the tables were small and close together, with white tablecloths and little candles in glass jars, and every single person in t
The third favor was the sweater.It was the last week of September, and the mornings had started to turn cold in a way Oklahoma mornings never did, the air thin and bright and smelling like pine. Gemma had dug out the sweater her mother had knit her the Christmas she was sixteen. It was a big, soft, mustard-yellow cable-knit, with a slightly lopsided collar where Dee had dropped a stitch and decided she liked it. Gemma had worn it to every football game her junior and senior years. It smelled like her mother's cedar chest. She wore it to the library for their Thursday session.Chase looked up when she sat down. He looked at her for a moment longer than usual. Then he set his stylus down."Can I say something," he said, "and you won't throw your coffee at me?"She laughed. "Depends on what it is.""That color." He tilted his head, studying her the way he studied a paragraph. "It's doing you no favors."Gemma looked down at herself. "My mom made this.""I can tell. It's beautiful. The
On Thursday, at their table under the sagging window, Chase pulled up an email on his tablet and turned it around to show her."Friday night," he said. "Dr. Hale's reading from her new collection at the library. Seven o'clock, in the reading room. Very small, invite-only, mostly faculty and the journal staff. She asked me to bring you specifically." His eyes were bright. "Gem, you're going to love it. She's reading the one about her mother's hands. It's the best thing she's ever written."Gemma looked at the email. Then she looked up."I can't," she said. "I'm going to the bonfire with Freddy."Chase laughed, like she'd made a joke. "The football thing?""The football thing.""Gemma." He said it patiently, the way you'd talk to a kid who wanted cake for dinner. "It's a bunch of drunk freshmen standing around a fire. You can do that any night of the week. This is Hale. This is a room full of people who could change your whole life.""I know." She made herself keep looking at him. "But
She'd come out of Forms of Creative Nonfiction at two in the afternoon, dragging, and there he'd be on the bench outside Hawthorne Hall with a second cup, iced this time, because it had been a warm day. She'd stay up until one rewriting a paragraph for workshop and walk into the library the next morning gray-faced and squinting, and before she'd even set her bag down, the cup would be sliding across the table toward her. On the first truly cold morning, when frost furred the grass on the quad and Gemma came out of the guesthouse in a hoodie because she hadn't unpacked her coat yet, he was waiting on the steps with a hot chocolate. Three pumps of caramel. Extra whipped cream. A crosshatch on top."Too cold for espresso," he said, handing it over. "Even for you."She never once saw him buy them. She never saw him stand in line at Marco's cart. They were just there, warm in her hands, whenever she needed one. Sometimes before she knew she needed one.She didn't think it was weird. Not rea
The following morning, as they gathered their belongings, Dee’s voice cut through the sound of the alarm. “Gemma, if you’re planning to shower before we hit the road, you’d better get to it now.”“No thanks. I’m avoiding the shower as long as possible,” Gemma replied, tugging Tony’s sweatshirt back
When they pulled over for fuel and snacks, the reality of Dee's planning set in; they wouldn't be eating any real food until they reached the hotel. "You know we can't mess with Mom's schedule," Kyle remarked as he climbed back into the U-Haul, tossing a bag of chips to his sister.Gemma held the b
Kyle sat down to drink his coffee giving Gemma another hour's rest before he had to wake her up for the two day trip to Colorado he was about to take. The one where he would be riding with his sister just to be leaving her in a strange place. As he sat drinking his coffee and he could hear his par
The house was full of music, and more than half the town. Gemma Havley’s family had gone all out for her going-away party. She was leaving small-town Florence, Oklahoma, for college in Bronson, Colorado. It was already going to be a big change for her, and she hated change. But her English teacher,







