Ass Judging

Robert radiated a smile and wave to a group of cheerleaders as the garage quickly filled up. Meanwhile Derek had left long ago. He didn't wait for her sister as usual. Despite this, Ella was distinct from anyone else he knew. She wasn't like his sister. Carmen will never play with herself in the sitting room when everyone is at home.

When Carmen got there, he had to keep it cool or else his super-sensitive sister would know he was up to something. He trusted her to keep his secret, and she did, but he didn't want to make her part of his plan. His logical thinking was that the less people who knew, the less likely it was that anyone would find out. Derek needed to know because he would be part of his plan and because he wanted his best friend to be there when he finally achieved his goal. Patty would have to assist him to a point that she will not be able to withdraw from the assist. He had never been so dishonest or deceptive before. He was scared.

"Robbie... You need to settle something for us". Erica said.

“It's Robert not Robbie”. He stated

as he turned around, all of his vexation at having to wait for them vanished. Since the last time he had seen the troubler in those black stretchy pants, a lot had changed.

“Was her mound that thick or was that her bush?”. He could make out the outline of her pussy as her pants curved around.

"No, he doesn't." Carmen argued.

"Yes... he does," She said and abruptly turned Carmen around.

“Who has a better ass? Give your honest opinion, no one will be offended”. She added.

"What!". He said surprisedly as he looked around as if he was searching for someone.

"Robert... Who got the better ass?" Erica said with distress.

"Are you tipsy???". It was like a worst situation but almost a great opportunity for him too.

“How do you expect me to even know?”.

"You're a guy, that's what you guys do. You know which one is the best. Just say it; Jeez”.

“Okay...fine, which one would you like to feel”. Erica added.

“Erica, I'm going to kill you... He's my perv brother and...."

“Doesn't change the truth”. Erica cut in.

“What??... You are for real??”. Carmen said with an attacking tone.

"Yeah, yeah, fine. You two shared your mother's body for nine months... And”.

Robert became the prey in their discussion.Although, they were on their backs, Erica holding his hands. A win-win situation, maybe, except for the fact that his sister was the sovereign ruler of round butt according to Derek.

"This is weird." He exclaimed, tentatively feeling with his hands.

“It's not engaging enough, give them a good squeeze Robert,” Erica said.

Given that he was touching her groin, his sister's resistance had been minimal at best.

“Okay...fine”. he replied, and he took full advantage of the opportunity, confident that they would end it quickly. He was excited to be holding onto what they covered as an image of Carmen's pantyhose came to mind. Carmen's ass had more cushion and a slope that tucked under her thighs and hooked into them. It was meaty, soft, and solid inside. It felt good that she had more than a handful.

In comparison to his sister, Erica's ass was smaller, more muscular, and did not have a deep groove between her cheeks. He dared her to make him stop as his finger moved downward. But she didn't. Under the thin layer of material, that had to be her anus. He carried on until he could have pierced her even if she had been naked. She sighed rather than shoving his hand away because she was humid and hot.

"All right,". Carmen said and he released his grip.

“I believe that's sufficient”. She said.

She must have been aware that he was exploiting the troubler's ass.

“Girls, I'm sorry to say that I'm stuck. To fully evaluate, you may need to wear bikinis and...”

“How about we just pull our pants down?" Erica cut in without allowing Robert to finish.

"Hell no!!." Carmen stared.

"I will do it." Erica said with a grin.

"Undoubtedly, you would. In those pants, you're barely covering anything at all. You are an exhibitor”.

"I'm not showing my ass out here in public even if he wasn't my brother. So, let's go”. She added.

"Yeah, let's go." Robert said with some relieved.

With no gap in time, they arrived at Miss Donald's gymnasium and He went to his meeting with Patty after declaring that he had too much studying to do.

After Robert drove away, Carmen was still thinking about his hand on her butt. She hadn't had a clear view, but based on his expression and the movement of his arm, she was pretty sure he had explored every inch of Erica's ass. Her emotions confused her.

She was fearful that they had opened a door that could harm her friendship with Erica, but she was also jealous. Did she not want Robert touching her best friend ass or she was just slightly jealous?

Erica slapped her behind, and said, “You still thinking about that big hand groping your butt?”

“I wasn't, and it didn't prove anything,” she said.

“It was weird, though, letting my brother feel my butt.” she stated.

“I bet he's still thinking about your gorgeous butt...I know I am.” Erica said.

“Doubt it,” Carmen responded.