What Criticisms Has 'Inteligencias Multiples' Faced From Psychologists?

2025-06-24 14:07:20 44

2 answers

Wesley
Wesley
2025-06-26 17:46:17
The book 'Inteligencias multiples' has sparked quite a bit of debate among psychologists, and I've seen some strong criticisms floating around. One major issue is the lack of empirical evidence supporting the theory of multiple intelligences. Many psychologists argue that Howard Gardner's ideas are more philosophical than scientific, lacking rigorous testing and measurable data. They point out that traditional IQ tests, while not perfect, have decades of research backing their validity and reliability. The multiple intelligences theory doesn't offer a clear way to measure these supposed separate intelligences, making it hard to validate.

Another common critique is that the theory oversimplifies complex cognitive abilities by labeling them as distinct intelligences. Critics say things like musical or interpersonal skills are better understood as talents or learned abilities rather than separate forms of intelligence. There's also concern that the theory's popularity in education leads to misapplication, with teachers trying to cater to nonexistent 'intelligence types' instead of focusing on proven teaching methods. Some psychologists even argue that the theory's vagueness makes it unfalsifiable - it can't be proven wrong, which is a big red flag in scientific circles. The book's influence is undeniable, but the psychological community remains divided on whether it's actually useful or just an appealing idea without substance.
Gregory
Gregory
2025-06-27 03:09:31
I've noticed psychologists tear into 'Inteligencias multiples' for several reasons. The biggest complaint is that Gardner's theory isn't backed by hard science - it's more like an interesting thought experiment than a proven psychological model. Experts in cognitive psychology particularly dislike how it contradicts established research about general intelligence (the g factor). They argue human cognition doesn't work in these neatly separated categories the book proposes. The educational applications also get flak for being unscientific, with critics saying there's no proof teaching to 'multiple intelligences' actually helps learning. It makes me wonder why this theory caught on so much when the evidence is so thin.
View All Answers
Scan code to download App

Related Books

THE BILLIONAIRE'S TWO-FACED BRIDE
THE BILLIONAIRE'S TWO-FACED BRIDE
Kehlani found out two things in one day; one, her soon to be husband was cheating on her, and second, that there was someone she looked so much like in this world and that same person was meant to get married but somehow, she was mistaken for that person. She ran away from a marriage, but ended up running into another one. Why does she have such a bad luck in choosing marriages?
Not enough ratings
72 Chapters
The Mafia's Two-faced Nurse
The Mafia's Two-faced Nurse
Allizander Jenesis Samson lives behind a carefully crafted alias, hiding secrets that could cost her everything. One night, she finds an unconscious and badly hurt man in an alley. She helps him without knowing he’s Giovanni Lawrence Vitale, a powerful and dangerous mafia boss. Her good deed pulls her into a world she never wanted to be part of. Giovanni’s men kidnap her and force her to become his personal nurse. Living under the same roof, Alli sees a different side of him, someone kind, quiet, and hurting. But there’s one problem, Giovanni has a deep hatred for women, and he doesn’t know that Alli is one. As days pass, Alli starts to fall for him. She knows she’s risking everything by staying close, especially while hiding such a big secret. Can she confess her true identity and feelings to Giovanni? Or will her lies destroy them both before the truth comes out?
Not enough ratings
5 Chapters
The Two-Faced CEO’s Killer Girlfriend
The Two-Faced CEO’s Killer Girlfriend
"Are you the hunter, or the hunted?" Aria Strong, codename Spider, is a killer raised by the Black Dahlia mafia group. When she is tasked with assassinating Cyrrus Lied, the rich billionaire with a perfect image, she infiltrates his company and attempts to seduce him — only to find he is all too eager to comply. But the more she gets to know him, the less she understands. Who is he really? What darkness is he hiding underneath that sunny smile? Aria tightens the net around him, but what she doesn't know is that he has her right in his trap...
Not enough ratings
5 Chapters
Exchanged Marriage:the CEO's two-faced wife
Exchanged Marriage:the CEO's two-faced wife
Dante and I have been married for three years. But he never knew my real name. We’d had countless arguments over the past three years—over the petty details of everyday life. I can no longer tolerate such a ridiculous life like a puppet today. Calliope, that’s what he called me, but it was actually my twin sister’s name. My husband may never know that the woman who married him three years ago was a substitute bride. Three years ago, my sister abandoned us and left before the wedding with her lover. To prevent the anger of the Laurent’s, my family had no choice but to let me marry Dante instead of my sister. My phone rang again and again, I finally picked it up. "Throwing another tantrum, are you? Calliope, tell me what you are capable to do if you can not even be merely a housewife?" I knew Calliope could always get her way through her sweet voice and innocent smiles. She can be an obedient and perfect wife—something I could never manage. "Dante. I’m not joking.” I didn't know if my voice sounded a little sad. "You can’t be serious—" For the first time, I heard a tremor in the man's words. He doesn't love me. He likes to be in control. When he realized that his puppet was losing control, he began to panic. It's time for this farce to end. I clenched my phone and spoke to the man on the other end in the calmest voice of my life. "Dante, let's get a divorce." But what shocked me more than hearing Dante's answer was the person who suddenly appeared in front of me. Calliope, my twin sister, who disappeared for the whole three years. “Are you crazy? Why on earth would you want a divorce? That's Dante Laurent, a billionaire heir, every woman's dream!” “Calliope? Our parents and I all thought you would never show up again. I entered this wrong marriage because of your escape. Dante... he’s not that a husband out of your dreams.” “Seraphina, put away your ridiculous niceness and compassion. I have returned this time to take back what is MINE and my place.” She lifted my hand with a sneer and removed the wedding ring from my finger.
Not enough ratings
33 Chapters
Beyond the Divorce
Beyond the Divorce
Most people often see marriage as a reincarnation for women. So, countless foolish women jump into one without a second thought. Many people see my husband as the perfect husband. He cared for me and loved me in every way. Yet, he still cheated on me right under my nose. Faced with the hypocrisy and ugliness behind his facade as a perfect husband, I've decided to serve him karma on a silver platter!
9.2
1558 Chapters
A Gift from the Goddess
A Gift from the Goddess
Aria was the Luna of the Winter Mist pack, renowned for her achievements in war strategy. Her contribution was crucial in her pack becoming the most powerful in the entire country. Everything in her life should be perfect. ...Except it wasn't. In actuality, Aria's life was anything but successful. She was helpless to the whims of her abusive Alpha mate and his mistress. A mate who never loved her. As she watches their relationship grow, her options are to run away or die trying to keep her Luna position. But this is not the story of how Aria sways his closed-off heart until he finally loves her. No, this is the story of how Aria died. So when she is faced with the opportunity to go back in time and try again... will she take it? ...Or is she fated to relive her mistakes all over again? ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ "...And if I refuse?" I asked hesitantly. "Then you will remain in the Abyss, forever reliving your earthly memories." My mind recalled the images that had just tormented me, showing me my death over and over again. I knew now she must have shown me that strategically so I had a taste of what my refusal would look like. "Then I don't want to be Luna again... and I don't want to be Aleric's mate," I said, surprising even myself that I was bargaining with a Goddess. But I couldn't shake the feeling something seemed off. "That is the fate I have chosen for you." "Then I don't accept," I argued. "I think there is something you're not telling me. A reason why you need me to go back so badly." She was silent, her silver eyes regarding me warily. "...So I am correct," I said, taking her silence as confirmation.
9.2
187 Chapters

Related Questions

What Are The Practical Applications Of 'Inteligencias Multiples' In Education?

2 answers2025-06-24 22:23:40
The concept of 'Inteligencias multiples' has completely reshaped how I view education, especially in creating classrooms where every kid feels like their strengths matter. Howard Gardner’s theory isn’t just some abstract idea—it’s a toolkit for teachers to unlock potential in ways standardized tests never could. Let’s break it down without the jargon. Kids aren’t one-size-fits-all, and this theory nails that. Some thrive through music, others by building things with their hands, and some by debating ideas. The magic happens when lessons cater to these differences. A math problem becomes a rhythm exercise for musical learners, while spatial kids sketch solutions. I’ve seen shy students blossom when history lessons include role-playing (bodily-kinesthetic intelligence) instead of just lectures. It’s not about lowering standards; it’s about widening paths to reach them. Now, the real-world ripple effects are wild. Schools using this approach often ditch rigid seating for flexible spaces—corners for group debates (interpersonal), quiet nooks for reflective writers (intrapersonal). Tech plays nice here too: apps gamify grammar for logical minds, while nature-based projects hook naturalist learners. Critics argue it’s chaotic, but data shows engagement spikes when kids stop hearing 'you’re bad at school' and start hearing 'you learn differently.' The kicker? It prepares them for life. Bosses don’t care if you solved a problem via spreadsheet or a rap battle—they care that you solved it. By validating diverse smarts early, we’re building adults who play to their strengths instead of apologizing for them.

How Does 'Inteligencias Multiples' Compare To Howard Gardner'S Theory?

1 answers2025-06-23 09:43:27
I've spent years diving into theories about human intelligence, and 'Inteligencias multiples' always sparks interesting debates when compared to Howard Gardner's work. While Gardner's theory of multiple intelligences breaks down human smarts into distinct categories like linguistic, logical-mathematical, and musical, 'Inteligencias multiples' feels more like a cultural cousin—similar in spirit but with a different flavor. Gardner’s approach is academic, rooted in psychology, while 'Inteligencias multiples' often feels more applied, like a toolkit for educators in Spanish-speaking classrooms. Both reject the idea of a single IQ score defining a person, but 'Inteligencias multiples' sometimes blurs the lines between Gardner’s categories, emphasizing practical skills over theoretical frameworks. What fascinates me is how 'Inteligencias multiples' adapts Gardner’s ideas to local contexts. In Latin America, for instance, it might frame interpersonal intelligence as 'community wisdom' or tie naturalist intelligence to indigenous ecological knowledge. Gardner’s theory is a map; 'Inteligencias multiples' is the travel guide that shows you how to use it. Critics argue that 'Inteligencias multiples' lacks Gardner’s rigorous research backing, but I’d counter that it fills gaps he left open—like how intelligence manifests in collective cultures versus individualistic ones. The real magic happens when you see teachers using both: Gardner’s theory to diagnose strengths, and 'Inteligencias multiples' to design lessons that resonate with kids’ lived experiences.

Can 'Inteligencias Multiples' Help In Personal Development Strategies?

2 answers2025-06-24 22:47:55
The concept of 'Inteligencias multiples' has been a game-changer for how I approach personal growth. Howard Gardner's theory breaks intelligence into distinct categories like linguistic, logical-mathematical, musical, and interpersonal, which resonates deeply with my own experiences. I've found that recognizing my strengths in spatial and bodily-kinesthetic intelligence helped me tailor my career path toward design and physical training, areas where I naturally excel. The real power lies in identifying which intelligences dominate your personality and leveraging them strategically. Someone with strong interpersonal intelligence might thrive in leadership roles, while a person with high musical intelligence could find fulfillment in creative arts. What makes this framework particularly valuable is its flexibility. Traditional metrics like IQ tests never captured my ability to solve real-world problems through movement and hands-on learning. By focusing on my dominant intelligences, I've developed targeted improvement strategies that feel organic rather than forced. For instance, I use rhythm and music to enhance memory retention—a technique that would likely frustrate someone whose strengths lie in logical analysis. The theory also encourages development in weaker areas by framing them as skills to nurture rather than permanent deficiencies. This mindset shift alone has helped me approach challenges with more patience and less self-judgment.

How Does 'Inteligencias Multiples' Redefine Traditional Intelligence Concepts?

2 answers2025-06-24 05:07:28
The book 'Inteligencias multiples' completely shatters the narrow view of intelligence that most of us grew up with. Instead of treating IQ as the holy grail, it argues that human potential is way more diverse—like a garden with different flowers, each blooming in its own way. I love how it breaks down intelligence into distinct types: linguistic, logical-mathematical, musical, spatial, bodily-kinesthetic, interpersonal, intrapersonal, and naturalistic. It’s not just about solving equations or memorizing facts; someone might be a genius at reading emotions but struggle with algebra, and that’s perfectly valid. The book’s real power lies in showing how these intelligences interact. A dancer isn’t just ‘athletic’—they blend bodily-kinesthetic skill with spatial awareness and rhythmic musicality. It makes you rethink everything from education to career paths. Schools obsess over math and language scores, but what about the kid who builds intricate sandcastles or fixes bikes by instinct? They’re brilliant too, just in ways standardized tests ignore. What’s revolutionary is how it challenges the idea of ‘smart vs. dumb.’ Traditional systems label late bloomers or unconventional thinkers as failures, but 'Inteligencias multiples' flips that script. It highlights cases like musicians who compose symphonies in their heads or mechanics who diagnose engine problems by sound alone—abilities no IQ test measures. The book also digs into cultural biases. Western education glorifies logical reasoning, while other societies might prioritize communal or spiritual intelligences. It’s not about ranking strengths but celebrating how they combine uniquely in each person. I’ve seen teachers use this to design lessons where kids learn math through dance or history through storytelling. Suddenly, ‘struggling’ students thrive because they’re finally engaging their dominant intelligence. The concept isn’t just theoretical; it’s a toolkit for unlocking hidden potential everywhere from classrooms to workplaces.

How Is 'Inteligencias Multiples' Portrayed Differently In Various Cultures?

2 answers2025-06-24 19:59:30
The concept of 'Inteligencias multiples' (Multiple Intelligences) varies wildly across cultures, and it’s fascinating to see how different societies interpret and apply Howard Gardner’s theory. In Western education systems, especially in the U.S. and Europe, there’s a strong emphasis on cultivating logical-mathematical and linguistic intelligences, which align with traditional academic success. Schools often structure curricula around standardized testing, but progressive institutions increasingly incorporate spatial, musical, and interpersonal intelligences through arts and collaborative projects. The focus is on individual potential, with educators tailoring methods to nurture diverse talents. In contrast, East Asian cultures like Japan and China traditionally prioritize linguistic and logical-mathematical intelligences due to rigorous exam systems. However, there’s a growing shift toward valuing kinesthetic and interpersonal skills, especially in extracurricular activities like sports or team-based learning. Confucian values still influence the hierarchy of intelligences, but modernization is slowly diversifying perspectives. Meanwhile, Indigenous cultures, such as those in Latin America or Aboriginal communities, often integrate naturalistic and spiritual intelligences into daily life. Knowledge isn’t compartmentalized—learning is holistic, tied to land, storytelling, and community roles. This cultural lens challenges Western individualism, framing intelligence as collective and situational.
Explore and read good novels for free
Free access to a vast number of good novels on GoodNovel app. Download the books you like and read anywhere & anytime.
Read books for free on the app
SCAN CODE TO READ ON APP
DMCA.com Protection Status