Are The Letters From Cardan To Jude Considered Canon Within Holly Black’S Universe?
Just finished a Holly Black Cruel Prince reread and saw these heartbreaking letters on fan sites. Are they part of official, canonical Folk of the Air lore?
2026-07-30 03:12:20
172
팔로우14
공유
NoahDixon
Novel Scout
Police Officer
ABO 성격 퀴즈
빠른 퀴즈를 통해 당신이 Alpha, Beta, 아니면 Omega인지 알아보세요.
향기
성격
이상적인 사랑 패턴
비밀스러운 욕망
어두운 면
테스트 시작하기
9 답변
RexRyan
Bibliophile
Police Officer
Canon is a slippery concept these days, isn't it? Authors release bonus content on websites, Patreon, social media... where do you draw the line? For me, if it's not in the published novel or a companion anthology officially sold as such, it's soft canon at best. Those letters fall into that gray area.
They're wonderful for deepening the romance and understanding Cardan's guilt, but Holly Black could absolutely contradict a detail from them in a future book without it being a retcon. I enjoy them as a peek behind the curtain, but I don't consider them part of the immutable story.
2026-08-01 09:21:58
12
HappyBud
Longtime Reader
Doctor
Their canonicity is directly proportional to how much you ship Cardan and Jude. The harder you ship, the more likely you are to clutch those letters to your chest and declare them holy text. They are the ultimate ship-fuel, providing the emotional payoff the books' somewhat abrupt ending left some readers wanting.
So in the shipping community, they are 100% canon, no questions asked. In broader literary discussion, the percentage drops. It's all about perspective.
2026-08-01 20:07:01
2
BellaLane
Spoiler Watcher
Librarian
If we're being strict, canon is a closed set. The trilogy is a closed set. The letters are outside that set. Q.E.D. All this 'soft canon' talk is just fans wanting to have their cake and eat it too. You can love them without needing them to be official. It's okay for something to be a wonderful 'what if' or 'in addition to.'
2026-08-02 02:33:28
12
KylieFan
Novel Fan
Student
Man, I just hope they get printed in a future edition. They deserve to be in a physical book. That would settle the debate overnight. Until then, they live in this digital limbo where link rot is a real threat. I've saved them as a PDF just in case.
Their canonicity feels fragile because of that. If the website goes down and they're lost, does that mean they were never canon? The whole thing highlights how our definitions are tied to old, physical media models. Stories aren't just books anymore.
2026-08-02 06:14:18
2
ZoeyPrice
Bookworm
Student
I just see them as a really, really good piece of fanfiction that happened to be written by the original author. Does that make it canon? Not automatically. But it does make it the most authoritative fanfic ever written. It exists in a delightful grey area where the usual rules don't quite apply.
2026-08-02 21:40:04
9
모든 답변 보기
QR 코드를 스캔하여 앱을 다운로드하세요
관련 작품
Azriel King's Luna
Youfoundtes
5
3.6K
“I, Alpha Gabriel Abbott, banish you, Paige Abbott, from Sky Moon Pack as my daughter and a member of this pack.”
****
“You're a disgrace to this pack. I can't have you as my mate. I, Victor Creek, reject you, Paige Abbott, as my future mate and wife.”
****
From princess to pauper, Paige’s life took a different turn when her father publicly accused her of seducing him, which led to her banishment.
Rejected by her betrothed mate due to the banishment, she moved to the human world, and there she met a stranger at her workplace on an auspicious night, and they had a passionate, unforgettable night together.
As Paige faced her new life, she found out she was pregnant, and the father of the baby was her ex. But that wasn't the beginning; Paige discovered that the stranger she had spent the night with was her true mate. And to her surprise, her true mate was no other than Azriel King, the ruthless Alpha King.
"not all monsters do monstrous things" - Jade Estrada. ° ° °Alpha Adryan Romano, Alpha to one of the largest and strongest pack in the world, The Blood Moon Pack. He was said to be cold and merciless. From childhood, he was taught by his father that mates are a weakness. Beaten by his father to be strong, which he is.Jade Estrada The Alpha's Daughter of The Evergreen Forest Pack, which was recently burned to the ground by a bunch of rogues who for some weird reason are after her. Jade manages to escape. She is also hiding a huge secret, and oh..she also happens to be blind. What happens when their paths cross when Jade accidentally tress-passes into The Blood Moon Pack and finds out that the vicious man just turns out to be her moons gift. ° ° °Mysterious death and kidnapping of werewolves start occurring all around the world all of a sudden. Alerting the supernatural world of a possible threat. Jade and Adryan are pushed into a situation they're never encountered before.Enter Adryan's crazy half brother, Darius Romano. Who is obsessed with Jade and would do anything to make her his. A lot of drama unfolds, new enemies are made so are new friends. A war is declared. Read and find out Jade and Adryan's story in 'Alpha Adryan'.
Having survived the deadly trials of Lyria and uncovered the haunting legacy of her ancestors, Maerwynn now faces a reality far more terrifying—a war brewing beyond the realms. She has transformed into a powerful being, but with her newfound immortality and role as the seventh stone, Maerwynn’s existence holds the key to maintaining Lyria's fragile peace. Alongside Valen, the Elusive High Lord who ignites both fury and passion within her, Maerwynn must wield her powers in ways she never imagined.
Yet as they prepare for war against Kyante, the cruel queen of Hadeon, Maerwynn realizes that victory comes with perilous demands. A prophecy looms over her, foretelling betrayal, sacrifice, and a battle that will reshape everything she has come to cherish. As enemies close in and allies grow suspicious of her power, Maerwynn and Valen embark on a treacherous journey to build alliances, reclaim a weapon of immense strength, and face the horrors of Hadeon’s armies.
Amidst bloodshed and treachery, In this heart-wrenching climax, Maerwynn makes an impossible choice that will forever alter her, the High Lord she loves, and the fate of both worlds.
***
BOOK 2 in the AETHER series. If you haven't read the Book 1- " Court of Fae and ruin", please do so, or nothing in this book would make sense. Xoxo
She hated him: his arrogance, his scandals, his infamous smile.
One reckless night left her with something she never expected to happen.
Aurelia Sinclair is pregnant, and Lucian Blackwood doubts her claim.
She walks away, but Pack Law won’t let her go.
Now trapped in Blackwood Manor with the man she cannot forgive,
Lucian is different; dangerously protective and hellbent on claiming her.
Secrets whisper in every shadow, threats lurk behind every door.
To survive, she may have to trust the wolf who broke her heart.
Eclipsed Hearts: The Chronicle of Shadows and Stars
Sarah Richard
0
1.4K
When kingdoms burn and crowns are shattered, one hidden heiress must rise from the shadows.
Serenya Vale has lived her life in disguise, hiding a truth that could ignite a war. But when destiny collides with Kaelen Draven, a mysterious protector with secrets of his own, their bond sparks a forbidden love that could either heal or destroy their world.
As rival heirs, ruthless dukes, and ancient prophecies weave a web of betrayal, Serenya must decide: will she claim her throne and crown herself in fire, or surrender her heart and lose everything?
In a saga of 100 chapters filled with betrayal, passion, and kingdom-shattering twists, Eclipsed Hearts: The Chronicle of Shadows and Stars is a breathtaking journey of love, sacrifice, and the fight for a destiny written in both shadows and starlight.
My sister and I were chosen by the Blood Ledger on the same night.
In our first life, Lydia chose beauty. I chose genius.
She became the most desired girl in the vampire courts, but the Glamour Gift came with one condition. She had to win true devotion before the deadline.
She failed.
Men wanted her face. They wanted her body. They wanted to show her off like a rare jewel. But none of them loved her.
When the Blood Ledger took her beauty back, Lydia lost everything.
I became the youngest scholar in the Night Academy, solved forbidden blood theories, and caught the eye of Adrian Blackthorne, heir to the oldest vampire house.
So Lydia killed me.
She trapped me beneath the sunrise and smiled as I burned.
When I opened my eyes again, we were sixteen, standing before the Blood Ledger once more.
This time, Lydia stole the Scholar Gift before I could speak.
“Now I’ll be the genius everyone worships,” she said. “You can have beauty this time.”
Poor Lydia.
She thought she had stolen my future.
What she didn’t understand was that every blessing in this world had already been marked with a price.
The concept of 'deserve.' Jude believes she must earn everything, that she deserves nothing by birthright. Cardan, born with everything, feels he deserves nothing because he never earned it. His letters reveal a profound sense of illegitimacy. His attraction to her is partly because she embodies the 'earning' he feels he lacks. Her struggle justifies her existence in a way his privileged birth never could for him.
The letters are woven throughout 'The Queen of Nothing' and 'How the King of Elfhame Learned to Hate Stories.' Honestly, reading them in isolation loses so much impact.
Each one arrives at a crucial emotional beat in Jude's journey. Getting them via a list strips away the context of what she's facing when she receives them.
I'd strongly recommend just rereading the final book and the companion novella. The pacing and reveals are part of the experience. The anticipation between chapters is part of the fun.
You miss the gut-punch of finding one when Jude is at her lowest, or the hope it sparks. They're narrative devices, not just collectibles.
Lurking this thread and taking notes. Some of these interpretations are blowing my mind. I never caught half of that subtext. Time for a re-read, I guess.