Honestly, I’ve been neck-deep in this pairing for a while, and I think the most popular themes revolve around museum afterlife. There’s a ton of fics where the reader is another museum exhibit waking up at night, maybe a forgotten portrait or a statue from a different wing. That setup automatically creates that shared-secret, against-the-rules intimacy. It’s less about the initial meet-cute and more about the quiet moments between guarding duties, sharing stories from their respective eras. The angst potential is huge too—contrasting his immortal-but-trapped existence with a mortal reader’s limited time, or vice versa if the reader is also magically stuck. I stumbled on one where the reader was a modern night guard, totally unaware of the magic, and Ahkmenrah had to decide between revealing himself or staying hidden. The tension was chef’s kiss.
Beyond that, time-displacement is big. Reader gets zapped back to ancient Egypt, or he gets briefly flung into the modern world outside the museum. Fish-out-of-water tropes mixed with that innate kindness he has. I’ve also seen a surprising number of fics exploring his relationship with his parents through the reader’s eyes—someone who can offer him a contemporary perspective on family duty and guilt. The romance often feels like a slow burn, built on trust and easing his loneliness, rather than instant passion. It fits his character. My personal favorites are the ones where the magic of the tablet gets unstable, and the reader has to help him fix it; the shared mission really bonds them.